Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask whether I can be sacked for this?

133 replies

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 18:25

I have name-changed for obvious reasons. Anyone know whether staff can be sacked for being in contact with past colleagues?

In order not to drip feed, quick details (necessarily vague) I work in the UK (England) in an industry which seems to have a high turnover of staff at every level. Recently several people have been removed, all a bit of a blow up. I have remained in contact with one of the leavers but learned today that anyone in contact with these past employees is in danger of being "immediately sacked". Surely not a sacking offence?

We have no HR, that's outsourced to just a payroll company, so no-one to ask. But AIBU to think a company can't sack someone for contact with a former employee?

OP posts:
CovertImage · 03/12/2022 19:43

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 19:40

Really? Are you sure about that? Because I can easily see a tribunal ruling that an employer disallowing contact with an acquaintance that provides key support for any mental health issue without a good operational reason constitutes discrimination. Anyway, as I keep pointing out, whether or not the case succeeds at tribunal is secondary to the leverage that can be applied by the threat of filing it.

Please stop giving advice on something that you're clearly not legaly equipped to give advice on.

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 19:40

niugboo · 03/12/2022 19:25

@OverExcitedPanda76 that most definitely would not count as discrimination.

Really? Are you sure about that? Because I can easily see a tribunal ruling that an employer disallowing contact with an acquaintance that provides key support for any mental health issue without a good operational reason constitutes discrimination. Anyway, as I keep pointing out, whether or not the case succeeds at tribunal is secondary to the leverage that can be applied by the threat of filing it.

niugboo · 03/12/2022 19:40

So in theory it depends.

If, for example, you were a teacher or worked with children and this person had been fired due to safeguarding concerns staying in contact is going to cause problems.

And as a general side note if someone has been fired it isn’t going to serve you well.

this is all irrelevant though as at this point you’re only rights are afforded to you by the equality act and that wouldn’t apply here even if you are a protected character.

protected characters can be terminated, the only thing they can’t be is terminated because of their protected characteristic.

SueVineer · 03/12/2022 19:36

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 18:37

Of course, if they did try to get rid of you, they would have to show it wasn't related to a protected characteristic. So if you were to argue that your friend (and former colleague) was providing you key support with your mental health, well, that would be a Problem for them. Just saying.

The onus would be on op to prove they had dismissed her due to a protected characteristic. So if op wished to show she was dismissed because she was disabled she would have to prove that (I) she was disabled (as defined by law), (II) that her employer knew that and (iii) that that was the reason they dismissed her.

so the above post is complete rubbish. As others have said if you don’t have two years service there is no recourse for unfair dismissal. Discrimination actions would be possible but you would need to have a genuine case.

niugboo · 03/12/2022 19:25

@OverExcitedPanda76 that most definitely would not count as discrimination.

ProfessorSlocombe · 03/12/2022 19:23

No!!!! You are allowed to do what you want out of work.

Not in the UK you're not.

Canthave2manycats · 03/12/2022 19:23

It's not a fair reason for dismissal but I'd advise you to play your cards close to your chest until you have full employment rights. It's a pretty draconian way for an employer to behave.

Notanotherwindow · 03/12/2022 19:20

How would they know? Just don't mention her/him and don't have anyone from work on your social media. Make sure social media is private obviously. None of their business anyway. Play dumb, plead ignorance if seen together.

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 03/12/2022 19:20

There is no fucking discrimination here! The op is not disabled!

I may have missed a bit but discrimination covers a heck of a lot more than a. just the medical conditions that lay people consider to be "a disability" and b. just disability.

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 03/12/2022 19:17

they can sack you for pretty much any reason (as long as it's not discriminatory etc).

Agree get some advice, from your union or a solicitor if you are really concerned. Join a union if you haven't already.

In the meantime, do you and the friend you have kept up with have any of the protected characteristics in common? Because if you do and this is WHY you are friends, then this could become a discrimination case. Or if an activity you do together serves a population that has one of the protected characteristics, at a stretch.

What would happen if one of the let-go prior employees was in the same religious or volunteering organisation, a housemate, a family member etc. - you wouldn't be able to avoid contact anyway. This rule is unworkable really and probably constitutes an unfair contract. But protect yourself as much as you can as employers can be very sneaky.

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 19:15

I guess I would just ask for a reference and try to bargain it out. I'm not afraid to say what I think, it's more a question of understanding what's possible or not, your comments are very helpful.

Various staff members know things about others, not sure how it gets around. Too much gossip and fabrication, some true, some not. Too much game-playing in the workplace....I'm mindful that I don't want to talk in too much detail, even on an anonymous site, but all sorts of other grievances being brought within the company currently.

OP posts:
OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 19:14

5128gap · 03/12/2022 19:11

And what leverage do you think the OP has to negotiate these things?

The threat of filing a tribunal claim. As I said previously, defending such a claim is expensive, risky and inconvenient. Critically, employers don't usually get their costs back. They'd be daft to pursue this one, however tenuous the claim of discrimination was. The mere suggestion is probably enough to take the claim outside the arena of 'manifestly vexatious' (or whatever technical term they apply to it).

Even if it's an empty threat, it's still probably enough to secure a good reference, if nothing else. Plus, writing a bad reference is a whole other can of worms...

5128gap · 03/12/2022 19:11

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 19:06

Compensation, for starters. Reinstatement, although that's always a terrible idea. A guarantee that they won't give you a shitty reference is another thing you could ask for.

And what leverage do you think the OP has to negotiate these things?

5128gap · 03/12/2022 19:09

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 19:04

I understand. Seems very unfair, but they can. I get it.
If it happened, what would they do about references (which I'd want for a new job).

Apart from being in contact with former employees, I have been a model worker otherwise. I've poured a lot into the job, so much so that after only 8 months I got an award and a promotion. But a sacking wouldn't look very good on my references; if the worst happened, what could I ask for? Anything at all?

You could ask for a reference. They don't have to give one. Unfortunately they hold all the cards here. Do they know about the contact?

NotSonicTheHedgehog · 03/12/2022 19:08

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 19:04

I understand. Seems very unfair, but they can. I get it.
If it happened, what would they do about references (which I'd want for a new job).

Apart from being in contact with former employees, I have been a model worker otherwise. I've poured a lot into the job, so much so that after only 8 months I got an award and a promotion. But a sacking wouldn't look very good on my references; if the worst happened, what could I ask for? Anything at all?

It is unfair but employment law is designed to give the employer an advantage not the employee. If I was your rep say, and you were genuinely facing dismissal and we were out of options I’d try to broker you a settlement which included references.

NotSonicTheHedgehog · 03/12/2022 19:06

Agree with the advice on joining a TU though however they tend to have a 90 day cool off period in that if you join because you’re potentially in hot water they won’t necessarily assist you. (I’m work place rep and I tend to just overlook it though…) However, keep in mind as reps we can only do what we can within the employment law we have available to us. Sometimes though you can call their bluff especially if they have no in-house HR… 👀

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 19:06

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 19:04

I understand. Seems very unfair, but they can. I get it.
If it happened, what would they do about references (which I'd want for a new job).

Apart from being in contact with former employees, I have been a model worker otherwise. I've poured a lot into the job, so much so that after only 8 months I got an award and a promotion. But a sacking wouldn't look very good on my references; if the worst happened, what could I ask for? Anything at all?

Compensation, for starters. Reinstatement, although that's always a terrible idea. A guarantee that they won't give you a shitty reference is another thing you could ask for.

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 19:04

tickticksnooze · 03/12/2022 18:58

There is no fucking discrimination here! The op is not disabled!

Well, that's subjective, isn't it? I know that if I was the employer, I wouldn't be very keen to test it. And anyway, I hope you are aware that disability is just one thing that can be discriminated against. There are plenty of others...

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 19:04

I understand. Seems very unfair, but they can. I get it.
If it happened, what would they do about references (which I'd want for a new job).

Apart from being in contact with former employees, I have been a model worker otherwise. I've poured a lot into the job, so much so that after only 8 months I got an award and a promotion. But a sacking wouldn't look very good on my references; if the worst happened, what could I ask for? Anything at all?

OP posts:
NotSonicTheHedgehog · 03/12/2022 19:03

Two years service as others have said gives you way less protection under employment law. There’s what’s called ‘automatically unfair dismissal’ which covers a list of reasons but not ones that are relevant to what you are describing. Sounds like a god awful place to work though.

ChristmasCwtch · 03/12/2022 19:02

You can’t claim for unfair dismissal under 2 years. They don’t need to follow the statutory process and they’d refute that their decision to dismiss is related to a protected characteristic such a sex, race etc.

Just keep any contact with the ex-employees low key.

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 19:01

tickticksnooze · 03/12/2022 18:57

Sigh.

You have to prove you meet the definition of a disability and that one of the forms of disability discrimination has occurred, which can entail having to prove the impact on you was adverse compared to a non disabled person. That is very difficult even where the person in question actually is disabled and actually has suffered disability discrimination, unlike the op.

Just saying "oh it was for my mental health" doesn't mean you have a disability in law.

Again, kind of. The standard of proof can be pretty low. Yes, it helps if you've already told them about it. But it's not essential. Yes, it helps if you can prove it with a statement from a doctor. But again, not essential. Further, the likelihood of the claimant suffering 'genuine' MH problems because of the company's behaviour will be weighed up against the reasonableness of said behaviour. I've seen cases succeed with literally no proof. And I've seen them fail when there is all of the proof. But the (intended) takeaway message is that most (not all) employers are terrified of having to go to a tribunal. The mere threat can often get you the result you want.

TiptoeThroughTheToadstools · 03/12/2022 18:59

YANBU are you in a union? If not join one. Your employer cannot dictate who you are friendly with outside of work.

TheTartfulLodger · 03/12/2022 18:59

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 18:28

Only worked there about 18 months. And no, I haven't divulged company secrets, I know not to do that as it's in the handbook.
I'm just not happy with the "threat" in the workplace.

So where did the actual "threat" come from? Workplace gossip or an official source?

tickticksnooze · 03/12/2022 18:58

There is no fucking discrimination here! The op is not disabled!