Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask whether I can be sacked for this?

133 replies

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 18:25

I have name-changed for obvious reasons. Anyone know whether staff can be sacked for being in contact with past colleagues?

In order not to drip feed, quick details (necessarily vague) I work in the UK (England) in an industry which seems to have a high turnover of staff at every level. Recently several people have been removed, all a bit of a blow up. I have remained in contact with one of the leavers but learned today that anyone in contact with these past employees is in danger of being "immediately sacked". Surely not a sacking offence?

We have no HR, that's outsourced to just a payroll company, so no-one to ask. But AIBU to think a company can't sack someone for contact with a former employee?

OP posts:
SueVineer · 03/12/2022 20:13

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 19:43

I mean, I've done this, more than once. But hey, I'm sure you're right. ;-)

The point I think you are missing is that there is no clear-cut measure of whether a claim will succeed, and the employer has far more to lose by rolling the dice. As for the employer knowing about the disability in advance, well, you'd only have to tell them at the time they dismissed you. That's certainly been sufficient in previous claims.

Again complete crap. How could they have dismissed you on the basis of a disability they didn’t know about? How are you possibly going to prove that’s why they dismissed you?

Tempyname · 03/12/2022 20:13

Unlikely. I work in HR and the only thing I could see as a risk here would be if they were criminal/had defrauded company in which case your association may be seen as high risk and/or reputationally damaging to the business.

SueVineer · 03/12/2022 20:11

Whattodo182 · 03/12/2022 20:07

Companies legally can't give a "bad" reference. Only a factual.if you smell a sacking, quit before they get chance. Therefore your reference reads;
Start date
End date
Role
Reason for leaving.

But no, they can't actually sack you for being in contact with ex employees. I'm laughing as my DH worked for the same company I do, imagine if this situation cropped up. I'd have to leave him as well presumably 🤷🏼‍♀️

Again not true. Companies can give a bad reference if they like. You may be able to sue them for defamation if it isn’t true but that will be difficult and expensive

SueVineer · 03/12/2022 20:08

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 19:50

Hmm. Not really, no. Certainly I don't think an employment tribunal would strike a case out without actually hearing the evidence first. And simply stating that you had an existing MH condition that had persisted for over a year would clear that hurdle. Medical evidence is useful, but not absolutely essential. Or at least not in my experience. As for no prospect of success, that depends on what advice you've had. If you can't afford an actual solicitor (and who can, these days?) then they're a lot more lenient. I've never seen costs awarded at employment tribunal, and I've seen much weaker cases than this would be.

This is complete nonsense. Medical evidence is essential is disability claims- you must prove both that you have a disability and that your employer knew about it.

Tribunals are reluctant to dismiss discrimination claims but if they are clearly so ridiculous as the above it would be struck out on a preliminary basis. Certainly there would be a preliminary hearing to establish disability and knowledge which would fail. If it did get the whole way to a full hearing, there could well be a costs order given the claim is so ridiculous. There is no limit on costs that can be awarded.

It’s awful that there is no reliable legal aid or assistance for employment law. If what you say is true, people are relying on your advice and you clearly have no idea.

Whattodo182 · 03/12/2022 20:07

Companies legally can't give a "bad" reference. Only a factual.if you smell a sacking, quit before they get chance. Therefore your reference reads;
Start date
End date
Role
Reason for leaving.

But no, they can't actually sack you for being in contact with ex employees. I'm laughing as my DH worked for the same company I do, imagine if this situation cropped up. I'd have to leave him as well presumably 🤷🏼‍♀️

niugboo · 03/12/2022 20:06

@OverExcitedPanda76 you do realise the more you post the clearer it is that you don’t actually know what you’re talking about?

ThatGirlInACountrySong · 03/12/2022 20:06

Do you belong to a union?

daisychain01 · 03/12/2022 20:05

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 18:41

... and if you take it to logical conclusion, if you quit because of the threat of having to stop being in touch with your former colleague, well, that's constructive dismissal.

Just to be clear, it would not be constructive dismissal. And why would the OP bother citing CD, for which they would have to immediately resign, due to their contract of employment having been made null and void, just for the sake of keeping in contact with some people who used to work there. How pointless.

niugboo · 03/12/2022 20:03

@5128gap fast typing. A protected characteristic is a thing.

AlwaysLatte · 03/12/2022 20:01

If they no longer work for the company then it's no more a sackable offence than meeting with anyone else, surely?! But keep work talk out of it.

SueVineer · 03/12/2022 19:58

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 19:52

You clearly have no idea. I do. Like I said, I've done this before. Have you? If so, how many times? As for getting somebody into trouble, my suggestion is to make a threat of taking action, if and when the OP is dismissed. How's that going to get someone in trouble?

You don’t have any idea what you’re talking about. Your narcissism could cause real damage.

Theluggage15 · 03/12/2022 19:58

Oh shut up @OverExcitedPanda76 what a twat you sound. Using mental health as a leverage, just making shit up. Trivialising actual mental illness that people struggle with. Fuck off.

niugboo · 03/12/2022 19:57

@OverExcitedPanda76 I'm absolutely sure.

In the first instance this person would have to demonstrate that they have a disability. “I’m depressed” doesn’t qualify. You would need to be able to evidence mental health issues that exceed 6 months.

Secondly you would need to be able to establish that you were fired because of that disability. Not easy as in this case the instruction applies to all staff not just the disabled. So you are relying on the indirect discrimination element.

To rely on that you would need to be able to prove that having contact with an untrained individual is a key part of your ability to access employment. That’s impossible.

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 19:57

ChristmasCwtch · 03/12/2022 19:55

There’s some really poor advice above. Only a few of us seem qualified to guid you (and it’s not those saying “I’ve been to tribunal eleventy times”). But you really need to seek real world advice. Start with Acas. But keep your head down and don’t rock the boat if you want to keep the role, or until you’ve got your next role.

Oh yes? What's your qualification then? Because I'm quite happy with my experience. Although I can't argue with the "getting real advice" part. But the OP would have to do that anyway. They insist you put the issue to ACAS anyway before you can file the claim. But if the employer has any sense, it wouldn't go that far.

SueVineer · 03/12/2022 19:56

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 19:40

Really? Are you sure about that? Because I can easily see a tribunal ruling that an employer disallowing contact with an acquaintance that provides key support for any mental health issue without a good operational reason constitutes discrimination. Anyway, as I keep pointing out, whether or not the case succeeds at tribunal is secondary to the leverage that can be applied by the threat of filing it.

This would absolutely not constitute discrimination. It’s a complete non starter.

as I said frivolous claims such as this could end up on the wrong end of a costs award as well as a lost job and reputation. Stop your narcissistic nonsense

ChristmasCwtch · 03/12/2022 19:55

There’s some really poor advice above. Only a few of us seem qualified to guid you (and it’s not those saying “I’ve been to tribunal eleventy times”). But you really need to seek real world advice. Start with Acas. But keep your head down and don’t rock the boat if you want to keep the role, or until you’ve got your next role.

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 19:52

SueVineer · 03/12/2022 19:49

Please stop - you’re talking total rubbish. You could get someone in real trouble.

You clearly have no idea. I do. Like I said, I've done this before. Have you? If so, how many times? As for getting somebody into trouble, my suggestion is to make a threat of taking action, if and when the OP is dismissed. How's that going to get someone in trouble?

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 19:50

SueVineer · 03/12/2022 19:47

That’s complete rubbish. If op made any such ridiculous claims it would be struck out straight away. In order for it to be an actual disability ops mental health would have to be so poor that she had a significant mental impairment for over a year. She would have to prove this with medical evidence. Keeping in touch with friends is irrelevant in the context.

also costs can and are awarded if people bring cases which have no prospect of success. This would be one of those cases.

Hmm. Not really, no. Certainly I don't think an employment tribunal would strike a case out without actually hearing the evidence first. And simply stating that you had an existing MH condition that had persisted for over a year would clear that hurdle. Medical evidence is useful, but not absolutely essential. Or at least not in my experience. As for no prospect of success, that depends on what advice you've had. If you can't afford an actual solicitor (and who can, these days?) then they're a lot more lenient. I've never seen costs awarded at employment tribunal, and I've seen much weaker cases than this would be.

SueVineer · 03/12/2022 19:49

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 19:45

Well, having been directly involved in... three, I think, employment tribunal claims, and several more claims where the employer backed down before a claim was made, I suspect I'm somewhat more qualified than you. So, unless you want to restrict this thread to advice only from qualified employment solicitors, I'll carry right on...

Please stop - you’re talking total rubbish. You could get someone in real trouble.

5128gap · 03/12/2022 19:49

OP, if I were you I'd seek advice from ACAS. They will confirm the correct advice you've received here and explain why some of the suggestions some people have put forward are inappropriate.

SueVineer · 03/12/2022 19:47

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 18:50

Actually, it's "balance of probabilities" same as in pretty much every civil setting. And it's free to go to tribunal, as an employee, in most cases. Also in most cases you won't end up having to pay for the other side's costs, even if you lose. The employer, on the other hand, will have to pay £1000s to be represented. Or they can do it themselves, in which case they'll likely screw it up. It'll also take them hours to sort out all of the paperwork they have to do.

As for perjury, well, yes, if you get as far as court, it could be seen that way. But then, most of these cases never make it to an actual hearing. In any case, don't we all rely on all of our friends for support, in a mental health context? I know I do...

That’s complete rubbish. If op made any such ridiculous claims it would be struck out straight away. In order for it to be an actual disability ops mental health would have to be so poor that she had a significant mental impairment for over a year. She would have to prove this with medical evidence. Keeping in touch with friends is irrelevant in the context.

also costs can and are awarded if people bring cases which have no prospect of success. This would be one of those cases.

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 19:45

CovertImage · 03/12/2022 19:43

Please stop giving advice on something that you're clearly not legaly equipped to give advice on.

Well, having been directly involved in... three, I think, employment tribunal claims, and several more claims where the employer backed down before a claim was made, I suspect I'm somewhat more qualified than you. So, unless you want to restrict this thread to advice only from qualified employment solicitors, I'll carry right on...

5128gap · 03/12/2022 19:45

niugboo · 03/12/2022 19:40

So in theory it depends.

If, for example, you were a teacher or worked with children and this person had been fired due to safeguarding concerns staying in contact is going to cause problems.

And as a general side note if someone has been fired it isn’t going to serve you well.

this is all irrelevant though as at this point you’re only rights are afforded to you by the equality act and that wouldn’t apply here even if you are a protected character.

protected characters can be terminated, the only thing they can’t be is terminated because of their protected characteristic.

There is no such thing as a 'protected character' as if there were she'd certainly be one, as would we all given we all have a sex and an age at least!

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 19:43

SueVineer · 03/12/2022 19:36

The onus would be on op to prove they had dismissed her due to a protected characteristic. So if op wished to show she was dismissed because she was disabled she would have to prove that (I) she was disabled (as defined by law), (II) that her employer knew that and (iii) that that was the reason they dismissed her.

so the above post is complete rubbish. As others have said if you don’t have two years service there is no recourse for unfair dismissal. Discrimination actions would be possible but you would need to have a genuine case.

I mean, I've done this, more than once. But hey, I'm sure you're right. ;-)

The point I think you are missing is that there is no clear-cut measure of whether a claim will succeed, and the employer has far more to lose by rolling the dice. As for the employer knowing about the disability in advance, well, you'd only have to tell them at the time they dismissed you. That's certainly been sufficient in previous claims.

CovertImage · 03/12/2022 19:43

"legally" FFS

Swipe left for the next trending thread