Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask whether I can be sacked for this?

133 replies

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 18:25

I have name-changed for obvious reasons. Anyone know whether staff can be sacked for being in contact with past colleagues?

In order not to drip feed, quick details (necessarily vague) I work in the UK (England) in an industry which seems to have a high turnover of staff at every level. Recently several people have been removed, all a bit of a blow up. I have remained in contact with one of the leavers but learned today that anyone in contact with these past employees is in danger of being "immediately sacked". Surely not a sacking offence?

We have no HR, that's outsourced to just a payroll company, so no-one to ask. But AIBU to think a company can't sack someone for contact with a former employee?

OP posts:
Yogagrandmum · 04/12/2022 12:19

What if you were married to them?

daisychain01 · 04/12/2022 12:18

a tribunal = at tribunal

daisychain01 · 04/12/2022 12:17

SueVineer · 03/12/2022 20:13

Again complete crap. How could they have dismissed you on the basis of a disability they didn’t know about? How are you possibly going to prove that’s why they dismissed you?

I think the term @OverExcitedPanda76 is struggling to find is vexatious.

A vexatious claim can indeed fail to be acceptable to be heard a tribunal if it is determined that the case put forward and reviewed in advance doesn't have sufficient merit to believe it would be worthy of the tribunal's time, There are 'tests' that can be done to determine if a case is vexatious.

ProfessorSlocombe · 04/12/2022 11:50

Because I can easily see a tribunal ruling that an employer disallowing contact with an acquaintance that provides key support for any mental health issue without a good operational reason constitutes discrimination.

People can see Jesus Christ in a slice of toast. Don't make it so.

5128gap · 04/12/2022 10:15

Given that we've established that the law will not be your friend here and that whether they're 'fair' or not is moot, practically your options are:
Accept that if you want to work there this is expected of you, cut contact and hope it doesn't come to light.
As above, but if you think there's a strong chance of it coming to light, pre empt it, go to your manager and offer full transparancy regarding the contact youve had, explain you hadn't realised the policy and hope that your track record and honesty goes in your favour.
Look for another job with less draconian policies, and in the meantime hope it doesn't come to light.
There are many variables that will dictate which option is best for you:
How important keeping contact is in comparison to your job.
The likelihood it will be discovered.
How reasonable your employer is generally
How valued you are by the company.
How easy it is for them to replace you.
How they've treated other employees who've done the same (if they've set a precedent for dismissing they will be taking a risk to make you an exception)
Only you can decide based on your unique knowledge of the company and your status.
Good luck regardless.

MrsPinkCock · 04/12/2022 09:44

@OverExcitedPanda76 I am an employment lawyer and it’s clear to me that you have never worked in law. Perhaps low level HR, or an over zealous TU rep, but almost everything you have said is incorrect.

OP, do you have restrictive covenants in your contract? Usually if so it would only be an issue for the outgoing employee to contact former staff members with a view to poaching them, as that could be a breach of their covenants. In 15 years of practice I’ve never seen a specific contractual restriction on current employees contacting former employees, but I suppose it’s theoretically possible.

It could also be possible that you’ve been specifically told not to contact them, in which case I suppose you could be disciplined for insubordination/failure to follow a reasonable management instruction, but as to whether dismissal would be fair, it would depend on a) how that was communicated, b) the company’s reason for the ban, c) your reason for contacting them (being friends for years would be different to you contacting them out of the blue for juicy gossip, for example) plus the usual principles of fairness such as length of service, fair procedure etc.

But it’s a moot point with less than two years service as they can dismiss for any reason as long as it isn’t linked to any of your statutory rights.

niugboo · 04/12/2022 09:28

@OverExcitedPanda76 theres absolutely no way you’ve worked in this field. You’re literally advising people perjure themselves.

Mamaneedsadrink · 04/12/2022 01:49

How is this even possible? I have heaps of friends from past work places, surely you can be in contact with whoever you want?

Letsjumpthebroomstick · 04/12/2022 01:41

Join a trade union , OP and ask them for advice. Always get a copy of your contract, any wage slips and join a trade union. You never know when you might need them.

YouTarzan · 04/12/2022 00:50

So if you were to argue that your friend (and former colleague) was providing you key support with your mental health

its shit like this that makes me roll my eyes these days when people start talking about mental health.

OverExcitedPanda76 · 04/12/2022 00:39

niugboo · 03/12/2022 20:06

@OverExcitedPanda76 you do realise the more you post the clearer it is that you don’t actually know what you’re talking about?

Like I said, I used to do this for a living. But hey, you clearly know best.

OverExcitedPanda76 · 04/12/2022 00:37

Theluggage15 · 03/12/2022 19:58

Oh shut up @OverExcitedPanda76 what a twat you sound. Using mental health as a leverage, just making shit up. Trivialising actual mental illness that people struggle with. Fuck off.

Lol. How does it trivialise it? Second thoughts, don't bother, I'm not interested.

OverExcitedPanda76 · 04/12/2022 00:34

niugboo · 03/12/2022 19:57

@OverExcitedPanda76 I'm absolutely sure.

In the first instance this person would have to demonstrate that they have a disability. “I’m depressed” doesn’t qualify. You would need to be able to evidence mental health issues that exceed 6 months.

Secondly you would need to be able to establish that you were fired because of that disability. Not easy as in this case the instruction applies to all staff not just the disabled. So you are relying on the indirect discrimination element.

To rely on that you would need to be able to prove that having contact with an untrained individual is a key part of your ability to access employment. That’s impossible.

Yeah, I'm sure you're right. It's not like I've worked in this field or anything...

SnowdaySewday · 03/12/2022 22:00

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 18:34

The ex-staff were disciplined, it was a bit complicated.

This drip feed is probably the key to what is going on.

Whatever happened with these former colleagues, assuming it went though the correct channels (and there is no reason to think not, given that there is HR involvement, albeit outsourced), would have to be investigated fairly. That process may not be complete, especially if it happened recently, if there is the possibility of criminal proceedings or the ex-colleagues might appeal the decision.

This will be why you have been told not to contact these people. Doing so could have implications such as prejudicing the outcome of the investigation and would be considered misconduct or gross misconduct, which employees can be dismissed for.

You need proper advice from your union, if you are in one, or ACAS.

PickyEaters · 03/12/2022 21:16

Companies spout crap like this all the time; IME it's rarely acted upon.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 03/12/2022 21:13

Being in touch with people who have been dismissed could put you at risk on the grounds of 'mud sticking' - they could believe that it meant you were also involved in whatever they were fired for but were better at staying under the radar/covering your tracks.

That's not right and it's not fair, but it's also no consolation if you find yourself unemployed 'because it's not working out' shortly after you've been found to have contact.

In addition, the scale of the threat could be because a criminal investigation is ongoing - they may have had enough evidence to terminate employment on some grounds, but that's still going on in the background as they're still looking into people still employed who haven't been 'caught'/are covering their tracks better. So your contact could affect the investigation and outcome of that. Or get you being interviewed under caution, suspended and unable to get another job because of that taking months.

In short, unless you live with one of the people fired, it's really not worth the risk.

ScotlandEuropa · 03/12/2022 21:11

People who lodge employment tribunal claims with no case to answer, in the hope that their employer will just give them money to get rid of the claim, are grifting chancers.

You only add to the stigma around disabled people trying to enforce their rights.

5128gap · 03/12/2022 20:23

niugboo · 03/12/2022 20:21

@5128gap i think in this thread I’m the last thing to worry about and the reality of what it means to have a protected characteristic was explained.

Fair point.🙂

niugboo · 03/12/2022 20:21

@5128gap i think in this thread I’m the last thing to worry about and the reality of what it means to have a protected characteristic was explained.

5128gap · 03/12/2022 20:18

niugboo · 03/12/2022 20:03

@5128gap fast typing. A protected characteristic is a thing.

Indeed it is. But to refer to individuals as Protected Characters is not a thing, and its misleading as it gives rise to misconceptions such as you can go to tribunal if you're dismissed and you're disabled, but not if you're not, when in fact everybody has the potential to be discriminated against on the grounds of one or more PCs, and if they are can go to tribunal. I know that's not what you said, but there's so much misunderstanding on here.

MoniJitchell · 03/12/2022 20:18

How would they know you’re still in touch anyway. Just don’t mention it?

SueVineer · 03/12/2022 20:15

www.thomasmansfield.com/costs-awards-in-employment-tribunals/

one example of a costs award of £87,000 against an employee who brought a claim which had no merit.

Catmatdat · 03/12/2022 20:15

Whattodo182 · 03/12/2022 20:07

Companies legally can't give a "bad" reference. Only a factual.if you smell a sacking, quit before they get chance. Therefore your reference reads;
Start date
End date
Role
Reason for leaving.

But no, they can't actually sack you for being in contact with ex employees. I'm laughing as my DH worked for the same company I do, imagine if this situation cropped up. I'd have to leave him as well presumably 🤷🏼‍♀️

Yes they can.
they give a reference based on facts.

you are confusing factual with an actual written reference🙃

niugboo · 03/12/2022 20:15

@Whattodo182 thats a myth re bad reference.

Catmatdat · 03/12/2022 20:13

Tali5ker · 03/12/2022 18:27

As long as you aren’t discussing the company or business at all, you’re fine.

but bear in mind with less than 2 years service they can dismiss you anyway.

Unless the probation period is less than 2 years