Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Shakespeare is a little intense for Yr 7 English?

278 replies

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 16:59

My daughter is studying Romeo and Juliet for Yr 7 English. Am I being unreasonable that this play may have more impact at A level when pupils have greater critical analysis techniques and possibly a greater appreciation for English literature?

I think Shakepeare is a genius of English literature but the language is so dense and tied to contemporary Elizabethian society that I think a Yr 7 pupil could struggle and in some cases actually put pupils off a more gradual approach to literature appreciation.

I also find it difficult explaining to a 12 year old daughter how Juliet (13) is capable of making so such life changing choices such as marriage and ultimately suicide and with the perspective of 21st century society the play does seem remote in experience.

Is the bard best taught at a slightly older age?

OP posts:
ZenNudist · 03/12/2022 20:55

My 8yo is into Shakespeare. He likes learning soliloquies and watching the famous plays or reading kiddie versions.

My Y7 ds is doing Julius Caesar with a focus on the drama.

It really doesn't matter if a Y7 pupil doesn't 'get' it all. They make a start and that important. R&J is one of the more interesting plays to start with I reckon any of the Henry plays might put you off!!

There's some great adaptations. Hopefully you could take her to see Shakespeare performed. I'm looking into Stratford-on-Avon as my relatives are near there and dc are making a start on Shakespeare.

We she will watch the Baz Luhrman film in school?. Thats great, really enjoyable and accessible. Not sure about age rating.

Also it's not hard to explain to a reasonably intelligent 12yo that people had to grow up a lot quicker in those days because they died a lot younger.

The language is hard at any age. You scratch the surface at a younger age and go deeper as you get older.

Not everyone enjoys English lit but it's my degree subject and I love it.

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 20:54

@ThanksItHasPockets
I am afraid English was my first language. :(

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 03/12/2022 20:54

This is interesting and timely for me as my kids have just finished their term at their music/drama group where they had Shakespeare and adaptations for their theme this term - the little ones did stuff from The Lion King (and talked about Hamlet and where the sorry had come from) , not sure what the middle group did and DS1's group (11-14) did Taming of the Shrew/Kiss me Kate with a bit of & Juliet thrown in. DS1 (who's just 11 loved it and in particular playing with a whole different sort of language; DS2 (7) loved the stories and was fascinated by how the stories were adapted.

They're doing a Midsummer Night's Dream next term, but with disco songs. Demystifying Shakespeare by starting young and focusing on the stories feels like such a good way in.

ThanksItHasPockets · 03/12/2022 20:51

Were you educated outside of the UK, OP? I wonder if English isn’t your first language. Fewer than 40,000 students take English Lit A Level. If we saved Shakespeare until then the vast majority of people would leave school having never read him.

RoachTheHorse · 03/12/2022 20:47

Shakespeare is amazing for all ages because there is so much you can take from it. It can be fun, dramatic, gory, rude, hilarious, and everything else.

I know I did it at that age, if not younger, and Romeo and Juliet is so accessible compared to some of the history plays.

LeFeu · 03/12/2022 20:45

Odds on you did it in y7. If you think your child isn’t comprehending it you can get numerous modern translations/alternatives - I worked in a school library for 2 years and we found graphic novels a great Segway into Shakespeare for reluctant readers. I personally think the stories are timeless and the best way into them is at a young age. The understanding of the language comes later! Although I’d go for a midsummer night’s dream for a newcomer to the bard.

thelobsterquadrille · 03/12/2022 20:41

The question I guess is what are the best authors to teach to a group of multi ethnic children with a variety of cultural influences and backgrounds. Shakespeare is brilliant but how do you prevent him becoming 'a dead white male'?

But this is English Literature. It's not a general course about global literature. That would be a different subject entirely.

And, whether we like it or not, most historically significant authors in this country are dead white males, so that's what the curriculum is going to be dominated by. Yes, there are African authors like Chinua Achebe, or female authors like Jane Austen included, but there is only a certain amount of time to teach a certain number of texts.

It's impossible to teach everything to everyone.

Thriwit · 03/12/2022 20:41

DD did Macbeth in Year 4. It culminated in the school putting on a performance of their interpretation of it at the local theatre with a few other schools. I’ve just asked her and she said she loved it, she said all the kids seemed to, even those who weren’t so sure at the start. She said she loved that they were acting in a “proper play”, one that people have been performing in various forms for hundreds of years.
They did some bits word-for-word Shakespeare, and some bits kind of reworded in their interpretation. She’s looking forward to doing more Shakespeare in future - so if nothing else, it’s at least started them off on a positive footing.

DuncanBiscuits · 03/12/2022 20:40

Dead white male he may be, but he wrote some cracking roles for women. Granted, it would be a good few years before a woman could actually play them, but I’m grateful for the legacy.

He set plays in Italy, Greece, France, Denmark…

His speeches bring up so many moral and philosophical questions. Think about Shylock’s speech in The Merchant of Venice, for example…”if you prick me, do I not bleed?’ It certainly brings into question whether the play is really anti-Semitic. There’s a debate to be had there.

Romeo and Juliet can be made relevant by looking at the relationships between the young people and the adults - where was the guidance? And the mindless gang violence sadly still has relevance today.

That was the genius of the man. He was male, and pale, but 400+ years later and he still isn’t stale.

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 20:33

get

OP posts:
mids2019 · 03/12/2022 20:33

@surreygirl1987

I agree part of the genius of Shakepseare is its appeal at various ages. My slight concern though is that Shakepserare wrote for an adult audience and therefore it is ultimately adult themed. Do children love Macbeth for instances simply because of the witches? Do primary school children 'he'd the massacre of MacDuff's children and if not how is this discussed?

OP posts:
ThanksItHasPockets · 03/12/2022 20:29

www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m000tv2n

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 20:25

@Sure
@surreygirl1987

I think you have a good point but don't we start into conversations about 'cancel culture' here and vexed questions about cultural identity.

The question I guess is what are the best authors to teach to a group of multi ethnic children with a variety of cultural influences and backgrounds. Shakespeare is brilliant but how do you prevent him becoming 'a dead white male'?

OP posts:
surreygirl1987 · 03/12/2022 20:22

Does a primary school child appreciate the misguided ambition of Macbeth or the soul destroying guilt of Lady Macbeth?

But that's just it - there are things children can appreciate and enjoy at different ages, and their understanding will change. A university student will obviously appreciate Shakespeare plays differently to a GCSE student for instance.

surreygirl1987 · 03/12/2022 20:20

*I agree. And British school kids should be taught to take pride in Shakespeare as well. Other nations are proud of their writers and painters, so I don’t see why we shouldn’t be. I’d always steer the young away from nationalism and hatred, but they should take pride in being from the island that produced Chaucer, Shakespeare, John Donne, Milton, Blake, Jane Austen, Wordsworth, Shelley, Keats, Dickens, Hardy, Wilfred Owen, Virginia Woolf, etc, not to mention Newton and Darwin. And that is true no matter what their heritage. If you are born on this island, those writers and thinkers are a part of you. They are woven into the landscape and culture you grow up in. It makes no difference if your dad is Indian or your mum is Polish.

To me, that is a healthy, inclusive kind of patriotism. Very few countries have such a rich cultural and intellectual inheritance. We really should make more of it.*

Absolutely!!

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 20:19

@KingscoteStaff

Is there difference between doing Shakepeare and enjoying Shakespeare? Does a primary school child appreciate the misguided ambition of Macbeth or the soul destroying guilt of Lady Macbeth? I guess it comes down to the plays meaning different things at different ages (I wouldn't want my happy 10 year old child coming home reciting 'Tomorrow, Tomorrow, Tomorrow'' with conviction :)

OP posts:
surreygirl1987 · 03/12/2022 20:19

Seriously? 🤨

JoonT · 03/12/2022 20:18

StrawberryWater · 03/12/2022 17:14

It’ll be presented and studied in an age appropriate way.

My son is 8 and they’ve started looking at Shakespeare in his school. He also has Shakespeare young reader books which he loves.

The younger they’re exposed to it the better.

I agree. And British school kids should be taught to take pride in Shakespeare as well. Other nations are proud of their writers and painters, so I don’t see why we shouldn’t be. I’d always steer the young away from nationalism and hatred, but they should take pride in being from the island that produced Chaucer, Shakespeare, John Donne, Milton, Blake, Jane Austen, Wordsworth, Shelley, Keats, Dickens, Hardy, Wilfred Owen, Virginia Woolf, etc, not to mention Newton and Darwin. And that is true no matter what their heritage. If you are born on this island, those writers and thinkers are a part of you. They are woven into the landscape and culture you grow up in. It makes no difference if your dad is Indian or your mum is Polish.

To me, that is a healthy, inclusive kind of patriotism. Very few countries have such a rich cultural and intellectual inheritance. We really should make more of it.

LeakyTapTap · 03/12/2022 20:17

It's brilliant when it's taught properly.

Sirzy · 03/12/2022 20:16

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 20:07

@JudgeJ

They do! However I guess schools would not actively encourage watching East Enders or playing violent video games. You say that East Enders is relatively poor writing compared to the bard but is that subjective? If some one enjoys the strained family dynamics in East Enders is this worse than enjoying the rather interesting familial relationships in Hamlet?

Does some of that not come down to the difference between written word and TV/film though? Things on screen is much less down to personal interpretation of the topic than written word where we make our own images

KingscoteStaff · 03/12/2022 20:13

We teach (and perform) Macbeth in Year 5 and The Tempest in Year 6. We use the RSC workshop materials and they love it. They leave Primary knowing that they can 'do' Shakespeare and that Shakespeare belongs to them!

thelobsterquadrille · 03/12/2022 20:08

JudgeJ · 03/12/2022 19:58

A lot of older Primary pupils will have watched Eastenders etc., there's really not much difference except the quality of the writing. They also play some pretty gruesome computer games!

The quality of writing is subjective, though.

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 20:07

@JudgeJ

They do! However I guess schools would not actively encourage watching East Enders or playing violent video games. You say that East Enders is relatively poor writing compared to the bard but is that subjective? If some one enjoys the strained family dynamics in East Enders is this worse than enjoying the rather interesting familial relationships in Hamlet?

OP posts:
thelobsterquadrille · 03/12/2022 20:07

JudgeJ · 03/12/2022 20:05

There are also similarities! Children can read the classics at different ages and gradually understand more and more, it's the same with Maths. They learn to count from 0, they later develop this into numbers below 0, they're told there isn't a square root of a negative number but later will learn complex numbers. Their knowledge of both the classics and Mathematics becomes more sophisticated as they get older.

While that's true, you still can't do difficult mathematics without getting through the basics.

But with English, once you have a basic understanding of language, you can read everything.

thelobsterquadrille · 03/12/2022 20:06

Someone raised the point of snobbery in deciding which literature was 'worthy' but are schools essentially doing this?

But schools only have a limited number of hour/days/years to teach children. It's physically impossible to include a wide variety of books from every single genre. There just isn't the time.