Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Shakespeare is a little intense for Yr 7 English?

278 replies

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 16:59

My daughter is studying Romeo and Juliet for Yr 7 English. Am I being unreasonable that this play may have more impact at A level when pupils have greater critical analysis techniques and possibly a greater appreciation for English literature?

I think Shakepeare is a genius of English literature but the language is so dense and tied to contemporary Elizabethian society that I think a Yr 7 pupil could struggle and in some cases actually put pupils off a more gradual approach to literature appreciation.

I also find it difficult explaining to a 12 year old daughter how Juliet (13) is capable of making so such life changing choices such as marriage and ultimately suicide and with the perspective of 21st century society the play does seem remote in experience.

Is the bard best taught at a slightly older age?

OP posts:
Hbh17 · 03/12/2022 17:17

I recently watched a primary-aged group of children perform a very impressive cut down production of "Romeo & Juliet", deaths and all. They did this in front of an audience of 300+ people in a professional theatre. These weren't stage school kids, just local schoolchildren who had been introduced to various plays via a charitable foundation. If it's well taught, there is no reason why children can't engage with Shakespeare - that is one of the beauties of his work. It would be a shame to infantilise young people by suggesting that they couldn't cope with the best plays ever written.

Ihatethenewlook · 03/12/2022 17:16

Shakespeare ruined my love of English in school

PinkPink1 · 03/12/2022 17:15

My love of Shakespeare began in Y7. We started off with comedies lower down in the school, and then tragedies at GCSE. 11 year olds (and younger) are watching a hell of a lot more upsetting and damaging stuff on YouTube and social media.

StrawberryWater · 03/12/2022 17:14

It’ll be presented and studied in an age appropriate way.

My son is 8 and they’ve started looking at Shakespeare in his school. He also has Shakespeare young reader books which he loves.

The younger they’re exposed to it the better.

IScreamAtMichaelangelos · 03/12/2022 17:13

DS and I watched the 90s version of the film, the one with Di Caprio and Danes. He got all the themes and was quite taken with it tbh!

teezletangler · 03/12/2022 17:13

I think this is young for Shakespeare, but then again I live in Canada! We don't study it until age 13-14. I do think R&J is the ideal introductory play for young teens, because it's about young teens and it's easy to follow. It's also got a "cool" factor in youth culture that others lack. It's probably a decent choice.

Singleandproud · 03/12/2022 17:12

DD loves Shakespeare but I've introduced her slowly and from a young age. I've taken her to a few of the Chamberlain's Mens productions which are fantastic. Prior to each play we read the children's versions first, illustrated by Quentin Blake and then read Spark notes online which has the everyday translation next to the original.

Also you have the likes of Gnomeo and Juliet, I think as long as the children have a general idea of the story the language falls in place afterwards. However, I also know lots of the children I work with find it difficult, especially those with a relatively low reading age.

Clymene · 03/12/2022 17:11

YABU

Fairislefandango · 03/12/2022 17:11

Is it being a bit snowflakey to suggest themes such as teen suicide are treated with care?

Why would you assume it wouldn't be handled with care? All teachers are expected to be able to deal with themes like this sensitively, and are used to dealing with groups of students which might always contain children who have been through all sorts of awful things.

AAT65 · 03/12/2022 17:11

Missing the point but your year 7 is 10 years old???

DuncanBiscuits · 03/12/2022 17:10

Given the diet of harmful bilge our adolescents are subjected to via our internet overlords, I really don’t think being exposed to Shakespeare is going to do the slightest bit of harm.

KittensNotMittens · 03/12/2022 17:10

We did Hamlet at that age.

Dogsgottabone · 03/12/2022 17:10

I did Macbeth in Yr6. Loved it. Our teacher used to wait until a dark and stormy winters day and read it to us with the lights off. I still love Macbeth!

Both DC started in yr7. How do you think they build critical thinking skills unless they start early?

5foot5 · 03/12/2022 17:09

When I was in the equivalent of year 7 back in the early 1970s, I remember we were introduced to Shakespeare using this anthology

Tragical Comical Historical Pastoral

ShinyMe · 03/12/2022 17:09

Why does she need to 'completely comprehend' it? When does anyone completely comprehend anything? Surely we're all always learning and developing, and R&J (or any play, or any work of art come to think of it) hits differently on a 12 year old and a 15 year old and a 25 year old and a 50 year old. Part of the joy of books and literature and art is that you see new things in it every time as you get older.

Fairislefandango · 03/12/2022 17:08

YABU. It's not a particularly difficult story to follow. And it's not as if the teacher's going to chuck a copy of it at them and tell them to get on with it. I'd say R&J is a good introduction to Shakespeare. The dark/romantic/violent story is more likely to hold their attention!

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 17:08

I think the play can be followed but I feel it interesting contrasting R and J with contemporary teenage romance which is a little more relatable though obviously from a literary perspective relatively badly written. I think a comedy might be better than a tragedy at that age. Is it being a bit snowflakey to suggest themes such as teen suicide are treated with care?

OP posts:
thelobsterquadrille · 03/12/2022 17:07

Did you not study Shakespeare in Year 7?

I remember doing A Midsummer Nights' Dream at that age, and then we moved on to Macbeth and Othello in year 8/9. We also studied Chaucer at a similar age - maybe year 10 or so.

I really can't see a problem with it at all.

Oysterbabe · 03/12/2022 17:07

We did this in yr7 30 years ago. Yabu.

Beanbagtrap · 03/12/2022 17:05

My 6yo likes watching the cbeebies Shakespeare shows, my 2 yo likes the smeds and the smoos (Romeo and Juliet via Julia Donaldson). I think they way the stories are taught and analysed will vary by age, just as year 7 students studying rocks wont be going into as much detail as a Masters in Geology.

ByTheGrace · 03/12/2022 17:04

We did a Shakespeare play each year, all through school, Chaucer too (state school)
DD also did Shakespeare in yr7, think it's fairly standard. Dd's school rarely reads whole texts though, they don't have funds for a book for everyone, so they just get photocopied sections.

sst1234 · 03/12/2022 17:04

It’s not brain surgery. I’m sure a 12 year old can follow it.

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 17:03

@IScreamAtMichaelangelos

The language is utterly beautiful but can a 10 year old completely comprehend the themes involved.......It is quite a dark play

OP posts:
DuringDinnerMints · 03/12/2022 17:02

We did A Midsummer Night's Dream in Yr 7 and Macbeth in Yr 9, both felt age appropriate at the time.

thewriteradmitsthat · 03/12/2022 17:02

I think Shakespeare is fine in y7 but that they would better off starting with a comedy rather than a tragedy. A good teacher will make this accessible and engaging for them.

I think R and J works better in y9 and y10. My son's class did a performance of King Lear in y6 which I was Confused at given that it's the most desolate of all the tragedies.