Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Shakespeare is a little intense for Yr 7 English?

278 replies

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 16:59

My daughter is studying Romeo and Juliet for Yr 7 English. Am I being unreasonable that this play may have more impact at A level when pupils have greater critical analysis techniques and possibly a greater appreciation for English literature?

I think Shakepeare is a genius of English literature but the language is so dense and tied to contemporary Elizabethian society that I think a Yr 7 pupil could struggle and in some cases actually put pupils off a more gradual approach to literature appreciation.

I also find it difficult explaining to a 12 year old daughter how Juliet (13) is capable of making so such life changing choices such as marriage and ultimately suicide and with the perspective of 21st century society the play does seem remote in experience.

Is the bard best taught at a slightly older age?

OP posts:
LimeTwists · 03/12/2022 17:40

You’re probably overthinking it a bit because you seem to think the whole play would be taught in close detail at a level which is far too difficult for their age, but a good teacher would know how to adapt it.

You don’t teach the entire play, line for line and word for word, to pupils in year 6 and 7. You just want to get them familiar with Shakespeare, his language, his ideas and show them that the plots are really exciting and still relevant today. So, no need to go into gory detail about suicide or spend ages micro-analysing thorny language of long soliloquies with eleven-year olds.

I’ve done some teaching workshops at the Globe and a lot of the focus was on ways to highlight how his plays are still relevant to modern pupils. Eg gangs hating each other, territory battles on the streets, falling in love with someone your parents won’t approve of, forced marriages etc. I would focus on getting them excited about Shakespeare by introducing them to the plot and then to key scenes - ones which are exciting. For example, Mercutio’s Queen Mab speech or the scene before the ball of Capulet getting the servants ready would be pretty pointless, but the main fight scene with Tybalt and Mercutio would be great, as would the argument with Juliet and her father. I’d then look at those scenes in detail and examine the language, the structure and how the audience might react then and now. So, I might teach the class to look at how Benvolio tries his best to stop the argument and get them to look at ways he does this. I might also ask them to colour code words to do with peace / love in the scene and words to do with fighting / hate in order to show the contrast. It’s going to be simpler stuff than you seem to think. If it’s not and the teacher is genuinely just reading page after page aloud with a class that has no idea what’s going on then the problem is the level it’s pitched at, not the choice of play.

Re suicide and other ‘adult’ themes. No need to go into huge detail about suicide - not many lines are devoted to it after all; I’d guess around 30 in total) but obviously the teacher needs to explain that Juliet’s death is tragic and finally shows her parents how destructive the feud is. In the script, she presses a dagger to herself but I’ve never seen a version with blood - usually there’s some theatrical falling on the floor which makes the pupils laugh more than anything. Certainly no worse than any deaths you see in soap operas etc etc. I can’t imagine it traumatising most 11 year olds unless suicide is an unusually sensitive topic for them.

ShinyMe · 03/12/2022 17:40

I agree that they'd probably get MORE out of it at 14 or whatever, but that doesn't make it not worth doing at 10 or 12. But like others have said, it's meant to be watched, not dissected - that's what fosters the enjoyment and the excitement.

I think my first exposure to Shakespeare was in year 6, when I went to see plays. I saw the Winter's Tale and Taming of the Shrew and Antony and Cleopatra within a few months in year 6, and got varying amounts of enjoyment out of them. Did I fully understand everything? Of course not! Did I get more out of them when I saw them again and read them in my teens? Yes of course. But does that mean I shouldn't have had that experience previously? In my opinion, no! I have vivid memories of the Winter's Tale and A&C (can't remember much about TotS to be honest) from those productions, even though they were 40 years ago, and I'm so glad I had that experience.

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 17:39

@thelobsterquadrille

Good point. It is interesting that we have suggested appropriate age with visual media but not written?

OP posts:
Sirzy · 03/12/2022 17:39

Ds did it in year 7 and in year 8 is currently studying the tempest. He has enjoyed both. He also did Animal Farm last year which he loved, I’m sure many didn’t get the in depth complexities of that either but will have got more than enough to understand and learn.

thelobsterquadrille · 03/12/2022 17:37

riotlady · 03/12/2022 17:35

We did Goodnight Mr Tom in year 6 which features WW2, evacuation, child abuse, the very distressing death of a baby, another child, etc.

Same, I also remember reading "A Child Called It" in Year 7.

gogohmm · 03/12/2022 17:37

My DD's have been going to Stratford to see Shakespeare from 8 years old, the family workshops were great at helping them understand, children understand what they are exposed to

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 17:36

@Onnabugeisha

Wow that is so intersting! I am going to tell my daughter that.

OP posts:
thelobsterquadrille · 03/12/2022 17:36

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 17:34

@thelobsterquadrille

Interesting point. Do you think though that you are taking away the fundamental essence of Shakepeare by using modern langauage? Is not the literary magnificence due to precise wording and the poetry that flows from it? I find Shakepeare denuded of the language leaves quite strange bare plots. I do take the point the language can be intense for a 12 year old to understand.

No, not really. We would read the modern language versions so we could understand the plots, then we'd study the language afterwards - we were doing that from the end of year 6 right through to GCSE.

2bazookas · 03/12/2022 17:35

The fantastic thing about Shakespeare is that 400 years later his plays are still so universally appealing to all ages, cultures etc. They don't look it on the page. But then, the script of your favourite TV series is probably very dull and dry on the page. It's the actors and voices that bring it to life. That comes across most vividly when you see the plays live on stage, but film would be a good second.

Get her the zefirelli verion on DVD for a Christmas stocking filler. £10 in amazon.

riotlady · 03/12/2022 17:35

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 17:31

@Goingtothe
@GoingtotheWinchester

Being slightly goady but if I were to write a contemporary novel or play about two young lovers with inter family murder and suicide would it be delivered to year 6? Does Shakepseare get an exemption simply because of his sheer command of the English language and the beauty of writing?

We did Goodnight Mr Tom in year 6 which features WW2, evacuation, child abuse, the very distressing death of a baby, another child, etc.

thelobsterquadrille · 03/12/2022 17:34

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 17:31

@Goingtothe
@GoingtotheWinchester

Being slightly goady but if I were to write a contemporary novel or play about two young lovers with inter family murder and suicide would it be delivered to year 6? Does Shakepseare get an exemption simply because of his sheer command of the English language and the beauty of writing?

I mean, Harry Potter and the Hunger Games are both read by that age group and they involve children murdering each other.

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 17:34

@thelobsterquadrille

Interesting point. Do you think though that you are taking away the fundamental essence of Shakepeare by using modern langauage? Is not the literary magnificence due to precise wording and the poetry that flows from it? I find Shakepeare denuded of the language leaves quite strange bare plots. I do take the point the language can be intense for a 12 year old to understand.

OP posts:
Onnabugeisha · 03/12/2022 17:34

The problem with reading Shakespeare is that it wasn’t meant to be read but watched. See if you can take her to a production of Romeo and Juliet. The language will not be dense at all once you see it on the stage.

As for Juliet being 13, explain the below:

Juliet was originally 16. Shakespeare changed her age to 13 for two reasons:

  1. to avoid a plagiarism law suit as he got the idea for the play from a narrative poem by Arthur Brooke: THE TRAGICALL HISTORY OF ROMEUS AND JULIET in which Juliet is 16

  2. His elder daughter was 13 at the time he wrote the play and her snotty teenage self was probably real life inspiration for the lines he wrote for the character. Juliet does do a lot of flouncing, moping, and drama. Perhaps he had a bit of an unconscious wish of just marry off his teen daughter for the peace of the household. (Reality was that his daughters didn’t marry until 24 and 31.)

Mirabai · 03/12/2022 17:34

I did MND aged 11 and that was the beginning of a love affair with Shakespeare that’s never dimmed. At 12 we did R&J and MofV. I don’t remember them being particularly difficult.

She should watch the old film with Olivia Hussey and Leonard Whiting and then the Baz Lurhman version.

gegs73 · 03/12/2022 17:33

Romeo and Juliet is taught as part of GCSE English Literature. Seems they are going to know it REALLY well in year 10/11 if they are starting in year 7 (or be very bored of it).

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 17:31

@Goingtothe
@GoingtotheWinchester

Being slightly goady but if I were to write a contemporary novel or play about two young lovers with inter family murder and suicide would it be delivered to year 6? Does Shakepseare get an exemption simply because of his sheer command of the English language and the beauty of writing?

OP posts:
thelobsterquadrille · 03/12/2022 17:30

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 17:24

Interesting points above. I do find it strange that teachers don't recommend that my child reads Dickens or Eliot at home as the books are too 'hard' but are confident that they can appreciate Shakespeare?

The "modern language" versions of Shakespeare are much easier to follow than Dickens, though. It's not the plots that are complex, it's the language that makes it seem difficult and grown-up.

GoingtotheWinchester · 03/12/2022 17:26

I’ve long taught R&J in Y6 - kids love it!

Whalesong · 03/12/2022 17:26

Not educated in the UK (but in English). We studied one Shakespeare play every year from Y7. If I remember correctly, it was A Midsummer Night's Dream, then Romeo and Juliet, then Othello, then Macbeth. After that it depended on your subject choices for IB / 6th Form.

CaronPoivre · 03/12/2022 17:25

My son starred in a school production of The Tempest in year 5 and loved it still.

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 17:24

Interesting points above. I do find it strange that teachers don't recommend that my child reads Dickens or Eliot at home as the books are too 'hard' but are confident that they can appreciate Shakespeare?

OP posts:
Dogsgottabone · 03/12/2022 17:23

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 17:08

I think the play can be followed but I feel it interesting contrasting R and J with contemporary teenage romance which is a little more relatable though obviously from a literary perspective relatively badly written. I think a comedy might be better than a tragedy at that age. Is it being a bit snowflakey to suggest themes such as teen suicide are treated with care?

Yes, very flakey. They talk about this stuff in complementary classes, why not study in literature.

BasiliskStare · 03/12/2022 17:21

If I am honest I don't think R&J is inappropriate for a 10 yr old. It is two families and a love story & yes they die. A good teacher will teach it appropriately. I suspect you can find darkness in any Shakespeare play ( MSND - drugs - just thought of that ) if you look for it. We read this at school & I am not sure the ages really stuck in my mind but that's just me

But the reading of a Shakepeare text I think would benefit all young readers.

Perhaps look for a film based on it which is suitable for a 10 year old to watch whilst the studying is going on .

& I agree I think they could be exposed to much worse on the TV etc,

mids2019 · 03/12/2022 17:20

I take the point that Shakepeare, like any literature, will be read from a new perspective with age. I don't take issue with the beauty of the language but do you think there is a case to suggest that the themes of the bard such as ruthless ambition in Macbeth, fatalistic despair in Hamlet, obsessive love in Romeo and Juliet are maybe more fully appreciated by a slightly older child? I am not for one instant suggesting not teaching Shakepeare but could it wait until slightly later in the schooling?

I suppose you are introducing high art to a child just out of primary school (a bit like discussing old masters in art classes as opposed to drawing techniques) and it does seem quite a step educationally. I guess Shakepeare will always take a prime position in the canon of English literature but are we teaching Shakepeare from a cultural perspective as well as a.literary one?

OP posts:
froomeonthebroom · 03/12/2022 17:19

My school teaches Shakespeare at Y7. They don't read the whole text, just concentrate on sections, look at characters etc. It's a great intro to something they have to study at KS4.