Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Advise DD To Get Married

144 replies

TheShellBeach · 03/12/2022 16:45

DD lives with a man and they've been together for two years.
They've been actively TTC for nearly a year.

When she told me they were going to TTC I advised her to get married, as he earns much more than she does. I tried to make her see how financially disadvantaged she would be if they split up, but it fell on deaf ears.

She is adamant that her DP would never abandon her and their (not yet conceived) child. A quick look through these boards shows that this is not always the case. DD believes that her DP would be upset if she suggested that she was "only marrying him for money."

Has anyone got any advice on how to get her to see that getting herself and any children she may have as protected as possible would be a good thing? I did say that there would be no need for a big wedding (unless they wanted one) and that this was essentially to protect her, not a moral judgement in any way.

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 03/12/2022 20:01

MolliciousIntent · 03/12/2022 19:56

This thread is hilarious. If it were OP's daughter posting asking for advice, every single person would be telling her to get married. But because gasp a mother wants to offer her daughter advice, everyone's gone straight back to age 15 and is yelling you can't tell me what to do mum and banging the door behind them.

No, I wouldn't.

Because I think it's more nuanced.

Do I think the DD is foolish to have a baby without thinking of the long-term situation regarding her relationship? Yes.

Do I think the idea she might choose to be a SAHP in this situation is ridiculous? Also yes.

Do I think that anyone should get married purely based on finances? Of course not.

If they are in a long-term committed relationship, and having a child, then marriage makes sense.

But if they don't want that, she makes sure she's protected regarding their home, that she can financially support herself & DC, and she goes back to work. She's 39, all of the above should be a given.

MolliciousIntent · 03/12/2022 19:57

Twoshoesnewshoes · 03/12/2022 19:00

I didn’t get married. I stayed at home with each of my 3 until they were at least 2, then worked very part time til the youngest was 7 or 8.
we had the house in joint names, of course.
I was named on DPs pension, no need to be married for that. We have always had a joint account since conceiving the first one.
not much to be gained by being married.
the children have both of our names and there is no way that would ever have been different.

And what would you have done if he'd fucked off?

EarringsandLipstick · 03/12/2022 19:57

Tell her that a married woman has the right to stay in the marital home even if she doesn’t own it,

What do you mean? Do you mean for a period of time? Because of you mean long-term, there's no such right & the court will order a sale if necessary.

MrsClatterbuck · 03/12/2022 19:56

Cordeliathecat · 03/12/2022 19:36

Inheritance tax is the best reason to get married.

She believes that he would never abandon her and she may well be right. But what is guaranteed is that one of them will be taxed 40% of the estate (if over £325k) when the other one dies. Just because they didn’t want to get a marriage certificate. That isn’t being very financially responsible to their child(ren).

If not married and no will then inheritance passes to the next of kin that is the children if any. Then his parents siblings etc

MolliciousIntent · 03/12/2022 19:56

This thread is hilarious. If it were OP's daughter posting asking for advice, every single person would be telling her to get married. But because gasp a mother wants to offer her daughter advice, everyone's gone straight back to age 15 and is yelling you can't tell me what to do mum and banging the door behind them.

frozengoose · 03/12/2022 19:56

kavalkada · 03/12/2022 18:01

If your DD believes that her DP would be upset if she suggested that she was "only marrying him for money, he is not the man she should live with, let alone have children.

I agree with this.
If he isn't in to her enough to be okay with marrying her she absolutely shouldn't be having a baby with him.

LexMitior · 03/12/2022 19:55

If she cannot discuss this with her partner, then is she really ready for a baby? Parenting is hard and children need resources. Ducking a conversation that can benefit the future child is not good.

Dontaskdontget · 03/12/2022 19:54

YANBU. Good luck.

Surprised by how many people on this thread are handing out terrible advice.

Tell her that EVERYONE thinks that their man will stay with them forever, but for many that isn’t the case. What if he meets someone else, or gets a brain tumour/injury and becomes violent (I’ve seen this twice and its awful)?

Tell her that a married woman has the right to stay in the marital home even if she doesn’t own it, but an unmarried woman does not. Tell her she’s throwing away numerous legal protections designed to help her child.

I suspect the issue isn’t her wanting to not get married, its him.

EarringsandLipstick · 03/12/2022 19:52

maybe encourage her to sign up to MN and spent time on the relationship boards?

Indeed and she can also read of those of us who've spent years dealing with exH who frustrate the legal process and make it a nightmare to move on from.

Entitlements that come with marriage go both ways.

TheShellBeach · 03/12/2022 19:51

They could live together a few years longer and see how that goes.

She is already 39.

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 03/12/2022 19:51

nonsense! OP absolutely can and she definitely should.

@LaLuz7

Assuming her DD is an adult, no she cannot!

It is not her place to tell her DD how to live her life, and pushing her into a choice she doesn't want would be wrong.

That's different to advising her of the consequences for her of not being married, or not planning financially. As I said in my post.

TheShellBeach · 03/12/2022 19:50

BeeDavis · 03/12/2022 17:08

So she only knew her partner for a year before TTC 😣😣 no wonder there is so many women on here left holding the baby because they’ve rushed into something with someone they barely know!!

No, they moved in together a year ago. They have known each other for five years.

OP posts:
Rainn21 · 03/12/2022 19:50

LaLuz7 · 03/12/2022 17:43

How old is she? Why is she rushing into TTC only a year in?

Naivety, desperation or money.

CurrentHun · 03/12/2022 19:48

And you don't need to wait for a proposal. "Hey partner, I'm not willing to carry a baby and take the career and financial hit until I have adequate legal protection. Which do you prefer - marriage or civil partnership?"

^This 100%

And actually the partner’s finances aren’t relevant, your DD and potential DGC deserves the security of whatever it is that her partner has whether they are a low or high earner- she’s having their child FFS.
If she can’t think about it maturely she’s probably not in the best situation to go ahead with it tbh. They could live together a few years longer and see how that goes.

Miajk · 03/12/2022 19:40

TheShellBeach · 03/12/2022 16:56

She would be giving up work to look after the baby, though.

She doesn't sound mature enough to have a baby, if she doesn't know how to or isn't willing to protect her own interests and security, and by default protect her future child.

Passthecheeseboard · 03/12/2022 19:38

Cordeliathecat · 03/12/2022 19:36

Inheritance tax is the best reason to get married.

She believes that he would never abandon her and she may well be right. But what is guaranteed is that one of them will be taxed 40% of the estate (if over £325k) when the other one dies. Just because they didn’t want to get a marriage certificate. That isn’t being very financially responsible to their child(ren).

Can they not both just have their names jointly on the deeds/ mortgage of the house though?

Passthecheeseboard · 03/12/2022 19:37

I don’t think marrying for financial reasons is a good reason to marry no, and surely in this day and age women are able to earn their own money and not rely on a man anyway, like it’s not the 1950s 🤨 …

However if she doesn’t feel ready to marry this man then why is she ready for a child with him??🤔

Although that’s another topic entirely

Cordeliathecat · 03/12/2022 19:36

Inheritance tax is the best reason to get married.

She believes that he would never abandon her and she may well be right. But what is guaranteed is that one of them will be taxed 40% of the estate (if over £325k) when the other one dies. Just because they didn’t want to get a marriage certificate. That isn’t being very financially responsible to their child(ren).

soddingspiderseason · 03/12/2022 19:34

Yes, absolutely advise her to get married if they are planning children. My previously completely devoted husband had an affair whilst I was pregnant, and our marriage ended soon after. Thank goodness we were married as it made my situation far far clearer legally and financially. Sometimes sadly, the unthinkable happens, and when children are involved it's better to be married than not.

SirCharlesRainier · 03/12/2022 19:25

Twoshoesnewshoes · 03/12/2022 19:00

I didn’t get married. I stayed at home with each of my 3 until they were at least 2, then worked very part time til the youngest was 7 or 8.
we had the house in joint names, of course.
I was named on DPs pension, no need to be married for that. We have always had a joint account since conceiving the first one.
not much to be gained by being married.
the children have both of our names and there is no way that would ever have been different.

@Twoshoesnewshoes I think the point people are making is about protection in the event that you split up and DP doesn't play ball.
What if he takes your name off his pension? Starts paying his wages into his own account, moves out leaving you to look after DC alone, shacks up with an OW etc? (Or rather, what if he'd done those things when DC were much smaller and you were SAH without a job?)

Freddosforall · 03/12/2022 19:17

I'd work on changing her mind about giving up work rather than marriage. Having the ability to earn your own money is far more of a safety net.

TheaBrandt · 03/12/2022 19:17

If you have a larger estate (above £325k) there’s significant iht penalty for not being married. Lots of couples in later life quietly marry or have civil partnerships later in life for this reason alone.

Ameadowwalk · 03/12/2022 19:09

Pleasecreateausername13 · 03/12/2022 18:47

As someone who has recently split I can assure you there is no such thing as a safety net of marriage. Yea the house is up for 50/50 but marriage or not ex still has to pay CM.

That’s about it. Not sure why you think being married would change much.

Exactly, I am in Scotland and it’s a 50/50 split of the assets from the day of the marriage to the end of the marriage.
it would protect you if there is equity in the marital home - but surely having your name on the deeds would do similar? it would also entitle you to half your partner’s pension accrued for the duration of the marriage. But how the heck would you pay the legal bills to secure this if you don’t have an independent income? you still need to pay for the separation agreement and legal costs to have this sorted.
there is no spousal support.
then, in Scotland, the child arrangements need to be agreed before you can divorce. More ££££s if this is contested in any way.
Far better idea not to give up work, to make sure that house is in joint names and that you have a will. Divorce is expensive.

Twoshoesnewshoes · 03/12/2022 19:00

I didn’t get married. I stayed at home with each of my 3 until they were at least 2, then worked very part time til the youngest was 7 or 8.
we had the house in joint names, of course.
I was named on DPs pension, no need to be married for that. We have always had a joint account since conceiving the first one.
not much to be gained by being married.
the children have both of our names and there is no way that would ever have been different.

OliveWah · 03/12/2022 18:55

I never wanted to get married - I was adamant about it from the age of about 10. Each of my DPs have been married and divorced 3 times, and I had not a single example of a successful marriage to aspire to.

When I met DH, he had been married and divorced, and was keen to marry again - I was not interested, one bit! After a few years, we bought a house and decided to TTC. After finding out we were expecting, an unfamiliar need for security began to creep over me, and after a few weeks I found myself desperate to be married before the baby arrived.

Luckily for me, DH is an intuitive chap, and proposed one morning when I was about 7 weeks pregnant. We got married at 16 weeks and now have 2 teenaged DDs.

For me, it wasn't about financial security or any of the other very sensible protections you see recommended on Mumsnet, but because I wanted to have the same surname as my DC, and I wanted us to feel like a unit, a team.

DH and I have a very happy and successful marriage. We've been married for 18 years now and I'm so very glad I changed my mind! It's entirely possible that your DD too @TheShellBeach, but I don't think you're overstepping by advising her as you have. I wouldn't have listened to the same advice from my DM, as she's definitely no expert on marriage (despite being very experienced)!