Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Advise DD To Get Married

144 replies

TheShellBeach · 03/12/2022 16:45

DD lives with a man and they've been together for two years.
They've been actively TTC for nearly a year.

When she told me they were going to TTC I advised her to get married, as he earns much more than she does. I tried to make her see how financially disadvantaged she would be if they split up, but it fell on deaf ears.

She is adamant that her DP would never abandon her and their (not yet conceived) child. A quick look through these boards shows that this is not always the case. DD believes that her DP would be upset if she suggested that she was "only marrying him for money."

Has anyone got any advice on how to get her to see that getting herself and any children she may have as protected as possible would be a good thing? I did say that there would be no need for a big wedding (unless they wanted one) and that this was essentially to protect her, not a moral judgement in any way.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
vivainsomnia · 30/01/2023 14:55

When she told me they were going to TTC I advised her to get married, as he earns much more than she does
Maybe his mum advised him not to marry her since he earns so much more!

Not a case of her giving up her well paid career to look after the kids then. How about instead of jumping into making babies so early, she focuses on her earning ability rather than encouraging her to become dependent on someone she's already known for 2 years!

I advise my DS not to rush into marrying someone who earns much less and is keen to have children asap and pushing for a ring on her finger.

ICanHideButICantRun · 30/01/2023 14:45

BeeDavis · 03/12/2022 17:08

So she only knew her partner for a year before TTC 😣😣 no wonder there is so many women on here left holding the baby because they’ve rushed into something with someone they barely know!!

I completely agree with this.

All this needs to be taught in schools if the girls aren't listening to what their mums say.

Ofcourseshecan · 30/01/2023 14:42

Onnabugeisha · 03/12/2022 17:51

Have you suggested a civil partnership? It doesn’t have to be marriage if religion is an obstacle.

And a register office wedding has always been a non-religious alternative, very low-cost and simple to arrange.

1HappyTraveller · 06/12/2022 23:35

ReallyTiredAndHungry · 04/12/2022 21:13

Why would she be giving up work to care for the baby?

How some people raise daughters like this is beyond me, where is the ambition and drive.

It is not all about ambition and drive. People have to make sensible decisions after weighing up their own circumstances.

  1. childcare is unaffordable for so many people that in many families it makes sense for one parent to stay at home and care for the children and household.

  2. men make more money than women

1HappyTraveller · 06/12/2022 23:31

Frankenstina · 03/12/2022 16:57

Encourage her to join MN.

@TheShellBeach

this should do it tbf 🤷‍♀️

user1477391263 · 06/12/2022 23:08

Oh hang on….she’s 39?
Too late to find another partner.

Has she really been with him for 5 years, starting at 34? If she wanted kids, shouldn’t she have pulled out the ultimatum big guns several years ago?

Frankly, she sounds a bit naive to be a mother, but if she really wants to go for it, doing IVF with a donor would probably be a better choice than this thinly committed bloke who has strung the relationship along for years.

If she really wants to get pregnant with him, approaching it from a perspective of “I’ll get pregnant with him as biological father, but essentially I’m going to think of myself a single mum from day one and work on making sure I can support myself at all times” would be rational. As a single mother, she will be entitled to help from the state, and the guy can be forced to do a 50% share in the form of custody once the relationship dies (which statistics say it will almost certainly do).

user1477391263 · 06/12/2022 23:00

Peedoffo · 03/12/2022 18:08

There's also the groom who decides whether to get married not just the bride. What if he says no? She will have to start off again looking for someone who will marry her before having DC..

Er, is this supposed to be a “bad” outcome? Telling a useless stringer to fuck off, and going off to find a better partner sounds like a pretty good life choice to me. Are you suggesting she should tie her life prospects to a guy who, when all is said and done, may not be properly committed to her? Christ, no wonder nearly all cohabiting parents have split up (statistics show this) by the time the youngest kid is 16.

user1477391263 · 06/12/2022 22:56

Peedoffo · 03/12/2022 17:56

It depends if DD is in her mid - late 30s or even older she might be prioritising having DC hence TTC now over marriage which is a valid choice. As long as she has a strong career and can afford childcare Many women on MN have infertility struggles or will sadly never have children because they have been waiting to get married perfect set of circumstances before TTC.

Nope, doesn’t follow. If the guy is decent and actually committed, there is nothing to stop the couple doing a quick registry office marriage before TTC, then planning a nice wedding or “marriage party” to take place in a few years’ time. The important thing about marriage is the legal protection, not the bloody confetti and cake.

user1477391263 · 06/12/2022 22:53

”She doesn’t have to give up work” “She can put the baby in a nursery and return to work….”

It’s not a black-and-white decision of working vs not working. Most women don’t become SAHMs, but nearly all women’s careers are impacted by the birth of a child. It affects your career progression, the hours you tend to work, the way your boss sees you.

And there are things that can happen, like a birth of a child with a significant disability or complex medical issues. A guy who is not responsible enough to marry the mother of his child is unlikely to be responsible enough to be an excellent carer, so inevitably Mum will gird her loins and ditch her job to look after the child. Have seen this happen several times.

The OP is absolutely entitled to give her daughter advice about this. How have we become so utterly lacking in resilience as a society, that family members are not even allowed to express opinions to each other? She can give advice if she wants. The daughter is entitled to ignore it, if she chooses. But she’s making some foolish decisions here.

user1477391263 · 06/12/2022 22:49

Such naive posters here. “She doesn’

MarriedinMaui · 06/12/2022 22:41

TheaBrandt · 03/12/2022 17:57

its up to the man. He can either propose and they marry and only them she can be a sahm / traditional set up as she has some protection.

Or they don’t marry child takes mums name not his she keeps her job and goes for it at work and does not compromise her career one iota. utterly 50/50 in childcare / chores / responsibility. She could function alone because she has no guarantees from him.

The man can’t pick and chose which bits of marriage / cohabitation suit him. He is either in or out and the woman needs to plan accordingly. That’s what I will be telling my dds anyway. You pick a model and go with that.

This! 100%. I cant believe how many men will insist the baby has their name but not even think of marrying it's mother.

Ideatcakeforbreakfast · 06/12/2022 20:23

It entirely depends on her finances. If she is struggling financially then marriage is probably better for her. On the other hand, me and my partner are not married and I am uneasy about doing so as I am the higher earner, have a very good credit score and will have a very good pension when I retire. If I married him, and we split, he could take me to the cleaners - no way I'd want that to happen no matter how much I trust him.

SadieContrary · 06/12/2022 12:15

My take on this is, no marriage, no baby. If you can’t commit to something that can be legally dissolved then why would you want to have children with that person when you’ll be tied to them forever to an extent - even if you split. It’s utter madness.
You’re also better legally protected.
It’s your daughter’s life and ultimately her business and decision but I completely see where you come from.

Battyfumworts · 06/12/2022 11:36

LaLuz7 · 06/12/2022 10:53

So you are saying that if unmarried mom dies, father listed on BC doesn't maintain parental responsibility but it passes to someone else? What exactly does happen?

That absolutely 100% can't be right

It is not presumed that the surviving biological parent will automatically become responsible for the child should the mother die. There was quite a big thing made about it a couple of years ago.

Loachworks · 06/12/2022 10:55

Besides the financial implications, I'd be deeply suspicious of any man who wouldn't want to marry me before children.

LaLuz7 · 06/12/2022 10:53

Battyfumworts · 06/12/2022 10:47

I believe this is still the case, even if on the birth certificate.

So you are saying that if unmarried mom dies, father listed on BC doesn't maintain parental responsibility but it passes to someone else? What exactly does happen?

That absolutely 100% can't be right

Mogwire · 06/12/2022 10:49

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Battyfumworts · 06/12/2022 10:47

LaLuz7 · 06/12/2022 07:15

Wait, what? Was he not listed as their father on the birth certificates?

I believe this is still the case, even if on the birth certificate.

Battyfumworts · 06/12/2022 10:46

Now, in an ideal world I would absolutely agree with your DD, it shouldn’t matter if your married or not, a committed relationship is just that, not a piece of paper or a change of surname. But, it’s not an ideal world and despite record numbers of parents not being “married”, times haven’t moved on as they should’ve.

I would be more worried about what could happen in the event of a tragedy. As a child in this situation it’s truly horrendous and losing any financial security your family may have had often ruins your kids future on top of the obvious trauma already experienced.

As an unmarried partner and parent who was very close to experiencing this, it is absolutely not worth risking the lack of security. It only takes and ex or disgruntled family member to make life extremely hard, and from experience, it’s not always people you expect it from.

It may not be the ideal, romantic reason to get married but it should be a consideration

Sashamia · 06/12/2022 10:36

Isn't the stress of TTC at 39 enough to put on hold another life changing decision such as marriage? Let them work it out themselves.

AliceDownTheRabbitHole · 06/12/2022 10:28

I'd encourage her to get married. I'm not married and been with my partner 20 years. We have 2 kids and things are starting to fall apart. He's earns way more than me and if we split, he could manage financially on his own but I couldn't. I work part time to look after kids and wemoved away so he could further his career. I now have a lower paying job than if we'd stayed where we previously lived. I also suspect he is squirreling some money away. If/when we split - I'm pretty much screwed and that's after being with someone 20 years! I don't know if being married would offer me any more protection than not. I'm seeking legal advice 'just in case' though

piesforever · 06/12/2022 08:44

Do not give up your career!!! Ever! Financial independence all the way.

jackstini · 06/12/2022 07:50

How are finances split now?
How will they be split during maternity?
Will she go back full or part time?
Do they earn similar?
Will they afterwards?
Is house in joint names?

Really depends on the set up they have!

Faith77 · 06/12/2022 07:48

My parents put pressure on me to get married when my daughter came along, too. Marrying my ex husband was the biggest mistake I ever made. It trapped me with an abusive man for a decade, and, when I left, financially I still left with nothing. In fact, due to being married to him, I actually got lumbered with some of his debts. Marriage is absolutely no guarantee that your daughter won't be left financially destitute, unfortunately. You would be better off advising her to make a financial plan with her partner that will take into account her loss of earnings from employment and ensure that he knows that this means that whilst his contribution to the household will be financial, her input, though unpaid, is no less valuable, and therefore she will be entitled to a 50/50 split of any money left over after he pays all bills, etc. If he gets narky about her having 50% of "his" money, or insists that she also contributes financially whilst not working, advise her to run. Marriage in itself may not guarantee her financial security, but having a frank conversation about money now & getting an idea of his views might save her from being someone posting what I am now on Mumsnet.

RealBecca · 06/12/2022 07:33

Cordeliathecat · 03/12/2022 19:36

Inheritance tax is the best reason to get married.

She believes that he would never abandon her and she may well be right. But what is guaranteed is that one of them will be taxed 40% of the estate (if over £325k) when the other one dies. Just because they didn’t want to get a marriage certificate. That isn’t being very financially responsible to their child(ren).

That's why we did it.

Coupled with feeling overwhelmed by writing a will explicitly saying X should get Y (which could be changed at any time behind anyones back- not that we would do that but it does happen).

I suspect she wants to get married and is saving face. Perhaps ask if and how he is going to top up her pension when she is a SAHP and/or how his salary will be more shared as a sole provider for the family. Gently. Not as an interrogation.

Swipe left for the next trending thread