Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In think that most children don't stop believing in Father Christmas at 5 years old?

168 replies

Bbq1 · 03/12/2022 16:13

On Mumsnet, there seems to be a large contingent of posters who claim that children over the age of 5 don't believe in Santa and if they do believe then they shouldn't. I have never met a 5 year old who didn't wholeheartedly believe in Santa, elves, everything. I think peak believing years are actually age 4 to 8. It's actually sad because if a child doesn't believe in Santa at 5 then they never really have. I wasn't a particularly naive child but I was 10 when I worked it out. My ds was around 9 I think. To me believing up to age 10 or so is entirely the norm -vor am in the minority in thinking that ?

OP posts:
OhmygodDont · 03/12/2022 17:29

My older two have never questioned it one 13 and one 11 but both clearly don’t believe one sends me elf ideas for the little.

catsonahottinroof · 03/12/2022 17:27

It seems to vary quite a lot but I agree with you that if you stop believing by age 5, you can't have understood the concept at all for much more than a year or so. It always baffles me when well-meaning strangers in shops go up to mute babies and toddlers in pushchairs anytime from November onwards and ask them questions about what 'Santa' is bringing them. The babies have no idea what is going on!
I never made much of the whole thing with mine, but one worked it out for herself at a very young age, the other continued believing until far too late (secondary age) I had to tell her in the end as it was getting ridiculous.

Bbq1 · 03/12/2022 17:26

AdalineStephen · 03/12/2022 16:53

The parents saying they are surprised kids older than 5/6 still believe are basing that on their own efforts to maintain the magic.

This is it really. How does an innocent 4 or 5 year old not believe? It must mostly be down to parents telling them or not making efforts to maintain the magic.

OP posts:
Largethighsbadeyes · 03/12/2022 17:23

I think it's rather sad if children of 5 dont believe 😔

Mine is 11 and while I'm sure he knows it's all bollocks I'm not going to sit him down and have a "just checking you know santa isn't real" chat.

I'm keeping the Christmas traditions and magic alive...mostly for me 😊

BaileySharp · 03/12/2022 17:23

Yeah I reckon most still believe until 8ish? I wasn't 100% sure until I was about 10 though! I had doubts earlier sure but part of me still believed...

Bbq1 · 03/12/2022 17:22

x2boys · 03/12/2022 16:17

You will.Get a vast array of answers ,from never believing ,to believing at high school ,I would say most kids start questioning from 8/9.

Yes, that's were I'm at.

OP posts:
PuttingDownRoots · 03/12/2022 17:21

I know my 9yo WANTS to believe. She wants magic to be real, to get her Hogwarts letter next year, and stuff like that.

And overall, its harmless, so why not let her enjoy it?

11yo... knows its really the parents but likes Christmas Magic.

We minimised the gift giving bit of the Santa myth from when they were toddlers so they don't believe for presents. Its for the fun.

SeenAndNot · 03/12/2022 17:20

My 8 year old was bereft when I explained Paddington on the meeting with the Queen was a computer animation.

BringbackSpringsteen · 03/12/2022 17:20

To clarify - I kept up the "it's magic" thing in the conversation but he concluded "I don't think Santa is real"

BringbackSpringsteen · 03/12/2022 17:18

oviraptor21 · 03/12/2022 17:08

I don't think young kids just 'figure it out'. They get evidence that it's not true. The kids that haven't 'figured it out' just haven't had the evidence.
One could say pretty much the same about people that believe or don't believe in various religious figures.

I think it depends what you mean by evidence. My DS never saw us sneaking around or anything like that but last year when he was 5, he asked a series of questions which I don't think relied on any "evidence":

How can Santa know who celebrates Christmas and who doesn't?
Ok so what about xxx who is Muslim but his parents have a Christmas tree, does Santa go there?
How does he get into our house when our fireplace is blocked up?
If he can get in, how do I know burglars can't?

Etc etc. It was a long evening. There's only so many times you can say "magic" without it being a bit thin.

It's probably fair to say that I didn't go to enormous lengths to make up more things to "keep the magic" or whatever but I don't think it's unreasonable for me to say he figured it out and with the same evidence available to other children.

I'm not trying to say he's cleverer, I think being a sceptic is maybe more of a personality trait.

And maybe he gets it from me, my family was very religious but I remember thinking it through when I was 8 and deciding that on balance I didn't think there was evidence of a God. Still keeping that quiet from my parents and I'm 40 😂

DarkShade · 03/12/2022 17:15

I just googled the question "Is Santa real?" And top hits were Wikipedia and articles on what to tell your kids, so...

DarkShade · 03/12/2022 17:12

I think there's an element of truth to what you're saying. The parents who tell the truth the very first time they're asked will have kids who learn the truth at around 5/6. The parents who give vague answers might get another few years. The parents who go full hog adamantly answering that Santa is real could well have kids who believe still at 9/10.

What I don't understand is - don't they just Google it? Surely even reading a forum page like this would give it away (if he weren't real, which he obviously is....).

PolkaDotMankini · 03/12/2022 17:11

YANBU. My DD has just turned 10. She says she doesn't believe in Santa and knows it's me and DH, but has written a letter to Santa anyway, "just in case".

Glittersparkle76 · 03/12/2022 17:11

My DD is 9 and she still believes,I think this will be the last year she does though 😔.

MrsToothyBitch · 03/12/2022 17:09

I would say most 7 is when most kids at least start to doubt although some believe longer. I know someone who believed until yr7 at nearly 12 and found out badly and a family friend's son who was very imaginative, creative and dreamy believed until hitting his teens I think! Although he had much younger brothers they had to keep up the magic for which maybe helped extend it. My colleague reckons it's her 8yos last year believing.

I believed until 7 I think. I have a summer birthday so yr3 would have been my last year of believing for definite at least in the run up to Christmas. I definitely had doubts but played along for presents and test it out for a couple of years after that!

CheeseIsMyPatronus · 03/12/2022 17:09

ASD eldest absolutely believed (until we intervened and told him at 11) because "NORAD tracks santa, and they are in charge of nuclear weapons. Do you think they'd be wasting time on this is he wasn't real?? "One of the many quirks of rigid black and white thinking.

DS2 believed until we explained it to him at 10, but then, my brother said "if you look top credulous in the dictionary, it's your photo, little dude" and DS2 didn't realise he was being teased. He's a very sweet and naïve kid, got pranked a lot by more world peers.

DD had it sussed at 7.

oviraptor21 · 03/12/2022 17:08

I don't think young kids just 'figure it out'. They get evidence that it's not true. The kids that haven't 'figured it out' just haven't had the evidence.
One could say pretty much the same about people that believe or don't believe in various religious figures.

Velvian · 03/12/2022 17:07

I was 9 DH says he was older. Our 9 and 11yo have certainly questioned the last couple of years.

DontMakeMeShushYou · 03/12/2022 17:04

I figured it out at 5 years old (because Dad didn't realise I was awake). But I didn't tell anyone until my mum sat me down at 11 to tell me. So whilst my parents were blissfully happy thinking their 9 year old still believed, the reality was somewhat different. I was very good at playing along with their game.

Maybe not at 5, but I suspect most 7 year olds have figured it out. If you think your 9 year old still believes because you're so good at 'keeping the magic alive', you might want to consider that those acting skills may have been inherited! The wool is being pulled over someone's eyes and it might not be theirs.

Lilyfrilly · 03/12/2022 17:03

my son was 9 when he worked it out. I bought a book on Amazon called ‘the truth about Santa’ it’s really lovely. He’s 12 now and still keeps the magic going for my
9 year old (I think she knows, or suspects now.) and my 3 year old who is understanding Christmas for the first time. I think age 8 is probably average for at least suspecting. And by 10 they almost definitely know but the willing suspension of disbelief helps them believe a little longer sometimes.

HippyChickMama · 03/12/2022 17:03

DS (15) has ASD and believed until he was 12, he only found out the truth when his religious studies teacher included Santa when giving examples of myths and legends. DD turned 9 in August and still believes but is definitely starting to have her doubts, she has just twigged about the tooth fairy so I think this will be our last Christmas where she believes. She is NT afaik so perhaps more typical of the average

ilovesooty · 03/12/2022 17:01

x2boys · 03/12/2022 16:44

These kind of comments really piss me off,always meant in a slightly sneering way ,is it beyond you to understand ,that children just like adults will.alphabet different experiences and imagination,s .?

Who are you to tell me I meant my comment "in a slightly sneering way"?

I made an observation and stated an opinion - nothing more : nothing less. Quit telling others what they meant.

Atmywitsend29 · 03/12/2022 16:59

DS (almost 10) hadn't mentioned anything about it this year, he asked if we could put the decs up (normally happens by magic) so we did.
And then all of a sudden he wanted to write a letter to Santa and asked this morning why Santa didn't move his Xmas teddy which he then did himself.

I don't think he believes anymore, I think he's humouring us.

However last year, he definitely did still believe and was just starting to question.

Frankenstina · 03/12/2022 16:58

Well mine stopped believing at 5 or 6.

Namechanger965 · 03/12/2022 16:56

When I was in primary most kids believed until around year 5. Now it does seem to be a bit younger, more 7/8ish. But kids on the whole seem older these days. I remember girls in year 5 at school still playing with dolls. That doesn’t seem to happen now either. DD is 5 and whole heartedly believes. I hope she does for a few more years but if she hasn’t figured it out by year 6 I think I’d tell her.