Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In think that most children don't stop believing in Father Christmas at 5 years old?

168 replies

Bbq1 · 03/12/2022 16:13

On Mumsnet, there seems to be a large contingent of posters who claim that children over the age of 5 don't believe in Santa and if they do believe then they shouldn't. I have never met a 5 year old who didn't wholeheartedly believe in Santa, elves, everything. I think peak believing years are actually age 4 to 8. It's actually sad because if a child doesn't believe in Santa at 5 then they never really have. I wasn't a particularly naive child but I was 10 when I worked it out. My ds was around 9 I think. To me believing up to age 10 or so is entirely the norm -vor am in the minority in thinking that ?

OP posts:
WalkingOnTheCracks · 03/12/2022 23:08

Feef83 · 03/12/2022 16:28

Just read your history Op (quiet weekend with a cold!)

you have started threads ranging from thinking young children go to bed too early through to being baffled that parents don’t think cereal and toast is a good snack for a teen.

Why don’t you just focus on what you do?

….there’s just a teeny-weeny whiff of irony here.

Also, what are you trying to do? Shut down the entire internet?

Beachhuts90 · 03/12/2022 23:03

I'm a primary teacher. When I worked in KS1 pretty much everyone in my classes believed. Now I teach LKS2 and it's about half and half in my class from what I've overheard.

twocatsandtwokids · 03/12/2022 21:35

My 6.5 year old fully believes. My 9.5 year old has just about worked it out but isn’t ready to totally give up the belief!

Androideighteen · 03/12/2022 21:08

When I worked in schools and got asked whether Santa was real, usually because someone in the class had said he wasn't, I always told the askers that is what parents of children who are too naughty to get presents say to save their feelings. It satisfied the believers and shut up the rumour spreaders nicely!

33goingon64 · 03/12/2022 20:52

DS1 was 7 when he worked it out which I thought was quite young. DS2 is currently 7 but doesn't seem to have twigged yet. I think he'll cotton on next year if his brother doesn't do it for him.

PomPomChatton · 03/12/2022 20:47

Last year my DD (then 5) no longer believed in Santa. This year (at 6) she has forgotten that she doesn't believe and seems to have gone back to believing. I can't keep up!

My DD8 has never thought Santa was real but tells me she still 'believes' because pretending is part of the magic.

EconomyClassRockstar · 03/12/2022 20:41

Surely it also depends on where you live. We lived in an area with a high Jewish population when my kids were young so they definitely didn’t believe after about 5 as all their school friends had told them the truth already.

110APiccadilly · 03/12/2022 20:36

I have a distinct memory of being aged about six and my slightly younger friend (he'd have been five, probably) announcing to a room that Santa wasn't real and being hurriedly shushed. What I remember thinking is, "Of course Santa's not real, everyone knows that, why do you think it's news?!" So I'd say plenty of children know by five! I'm amazed at the idea that a ten year old would still think Santa was real, though I believe the posters who say they did.

I don't ever remember really believing it, but I still enjoyed it immensely, loved putting a stocking up, writing letters to Santa, all of that. I find it baffling when people talk as if only children who fully believed in it enjoy it. Children pretend all the time and love it.

pointythings · 03/12/2022 20:35

Mine both worked it out at 7. DD1 was delighted to be sworn to secrecy and kept it from DD2 until she worked it out for herself. I don't think most of their classmates still believed after about 8.

bevelino · 03/12/2022 20:31

My dds stopped believing at around 4-5. I don’t understand how children can seriously still believe at age10-11.

TribeD · 03/12/2022 20:27

DD is definitely in the "believe" stage. She'll be 7 early next year, and I know there aren't many magical years left, but while they last, we're making the most of them.

I'm almost 50, and I don't recall ever being told, and in fact my parents (mid 70's) have become more Christmas bonkers since their grandchildren were born, I'm fairly sure my DDad firmly believes 🎅

Hellocatshome · 03/12/2022 19:21

My DS stopped believing at 5. He just announced that Santa, Easter Bunny and the Tooth Fairy were all made up and to stop lying to him, we told him it wasn't lying it was make believe like fairy tales. We had a chat about keeping the secret for the other boys and girls and his little brother then carried on as we had before. We still act like Santa is real now but no one in the house believes as they are 12 and 15.

I do think people who claim there 11 year olds at Secondary school still believe are a bit naive as I have never ever known this to be the case in NT children.

Chickychoccyegg · 03/12/2022 19:13

If my dc hadn't believed at age 5 , I'd think I'd done a rubbish job of creating the whole Christmas magic thing.
My dd has just turned 10 and has been questioning a little, but has said she doesn't want me to tell her, she loves the whole santa/elves magic and doesn't want it to not be real, I think she'll tell me after Christmas that she knows.

Suzi888 · 03/12/2022 19:11

St Nicholas was real so… 😉
I would say around 10 they may question, if they have siblings much younger.
I send money to Santa- so Santa gets what we’ve paid for, he’s basically fed ex, he just delivers.

mamabear715 · 03/12/2022 19:08

He's not real? OMG... :-(

Boooooot · 03/12/2022 19:07

My 8 year old still believes.

Candlesoftime · 03/12/2022 19:05

9 or 10 sounds a good age to me. 5 would be heartbreaking.

I remember the naughty boys at school telling everyone that Father Christmas isn't real and that their parents told them the presents were from them. I thought, well your parents probably have to buy you the presents instead of Father Christmas because you're so naughty all the time! 😂

ILOVECHEESE79 · 03/12/2022 18:46

I didn't 'do' the Father Christmas tale before my DC started school but, having been in Reception for nigh on 2 terms, I'm having to play along, as they believe in all the magic.
Hopefully, it won't go on for too many years!

Bbq1 · 03/12/2022 18:37

BringbackSpringsteen · 03/12/2022 17:45

I thought it was more a badge of shame for not keeping the magic alive for the parents!

Agree. It should be a badge of shame but the parents with very young non believers sound almost gleeful and bragging about it.

OP posts:
TheGuv1982 · 03/12/2022 18:23

My girl had worked it out by last Christmas, we were horrified she was gonna mention it to her younger brother, as she’d already made some sarcastic comments when opening her stocking presents. We had a chat, told her she won’t miss out but under no circumstances tell her brother until he knows himself.

hes 8 and seemingly has no idea still, though we’ll see - I’ll be glad when I no longer have to sneak their Santa gifts into their rooms while I’m half cut.

mam0918 · 03/12/2022 18:20

CMOTDibbler · 03/12/2022 18:07

My ds never believed from when he could talk about it. It wasn't for lack of trying, but he is just that sort of person and was equally problematic on the subject of god when he started school.

My 14 year old NEVER believed in fairies at all even as a little kid, he was utterly adiment that the tooth fairy was the dumbest bull he had ever heard and refused point blank to take any part in it lol.

Always4Brenner · 03/12/2022 18:18

LT2 · 03/12/2022 18:05

I believed until I was 12ish, and I'm glad I did. The magic of Christmas goes once you know (still special and exciting, but not the same). Never got discussed at school so I wasn't bullied over it.

I was 11 for last year at 12 I played along once at senior next year the magic had gone.

mam0918 · 03/12/2022 18:17

I stopped believing at 5 as did pretty much EVERYONE in my infants school (so approx. 180 kids) because one twat told their kid and then the truth spread like wildfire through us all - don't underestimate the power of a school grapevine.

That said knowing the truth and enjoying the magic are two different things... I love a whimsical xmas and wouldnt shit on anyone else suspending their disbelief, I believe most kids 'know' logically but if they are having fun with the stories let them.

Choconut · 03/12/2022 18:15

Onnabugeisha · 03/12/2022 18:01

I never lied to my children so they never believed.

You sound like my old RE teacher - 'the first lie your parents ever told you was that Father Christmas was real, discuss' my god he was a miserable bastard, had been kicked out the church according to the rumour mill.

IME the last two years of primary school are when kids tend to question and find out, which is perfect I think. A boy in ds's Yr 5 class told them all and I'm glad that's how it happened.

Heatherbell1978 · 03/12/2022 18:12

DD is 5 and I'd say in 'peak believing Santa' mode this year. DS is 8 and very much still believes. I believed until I was 10 and my teacher told us the truth! The longer they believe the better in my opinion and I'm happy to carry on nurturing it. I would feel sorry for kids aged 5 who don't, it feels far too young for the magic to have gone.