Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In think that most children don't stop believing in Father Christmas at 5 years old?

168 replies

Bbq1 · 03/12/2022 16:13

On Mumsnet, there seems to be a large contingent of posters who claim that children over the age of 5 don't believe in Santa and if they do believe then they shouldn't. I have never met a 5 year old who didn't wholeheartedly believe in Santa, elves, everything. I think peak believing years are actually age 4 to 8. It's actually sad because if a child doesn't believe in Santa at 5 then they never really have. I wasn't a particularly naive child but I was 10 when I worked it out. My ds was around 9 I think. To me believing up to age 10 or so is entirely the norm -vor am in the minority in thinking that ?

OP posts:
RudsyFarmer · 04/12/2022 11:08

I suspect my nine year old knows but he plays along and I said the magic will exist as long as he believes (or pretends to 🤭). My six year old is on the fence. I suspect he’ll be saying it’s nonsense far sooner that my older child HOWEVER we all enjoys the elves and the activities and the magic and it makes for a lot of fun. So on we go.

Ihaveaskedyouthrice · 04/12/2022 11:06

My 5 year old firmly believes. 7 year old DD still believes but is asking a few questions so I think this year may be the last year for her.

ArcticSkewer · 04/12/2022 11:04

10 is not great. It's not ideal to be that naïve in general - makes life and school harder. But 5 - yeah, they mostly believe anything they are told at that age.

Bestcatmum · 04/12/2022 11:03

I never believed in Santa. Poor street wise kids don't.

DriftwoodOnTheShore · 04/12/2022 11:02

I taught 7/8 year olds and it was a very rare one who still believed. Both DS's knew by age 7 from the playground.

gannett · 04/12/2022 11:00

It's actually sad because if a child doesn't believe in Santa at 5 then they never really have

I don't remember ever believing in Santa. Why is that sad? Working out that Santa is a myth didn't harm me in any way.

Bbq1 · 04/12/2022 10:59

NewToWoo · 04/12/2022 10:52

Mibe appeared to still believe at 10 years old. I got really worried they would head off to secondary still claiming Santa existed. We had a difficult conversation in which it was eventually revealed that they'd known since they were nine but thought I still believed and didn't want to spoil Christmas for me. Not sure of their logic on that (how could I not know it was me filling the stockings Xmas Grin?) but it was very cute.

Aw, that's sweet. I think a lot of kids probably hedge their bets just in case!

OP posts:
Bbq1 · 04/12/2022 10:57

Feef83 · 04/12/2022 10:44

I didn't realise it was a crime to ask questions 😂

but your other threads and indeed this one is underpinned with a very strong whiff of judgement!

Okay👍

OP posts:
NewToWoo · 04/12/2022 10:52

Mibe appeared to still believe at 10 years old. I got really worried they would head off to secondary still claiming Santa existed. We had a difficult conversation in which it was eventually revealed that they'd known since they were nine but thought I still believed and didn't want to spoil Christmas for me. Not sure of their logic on that (how could I not know it was me filling the stockings Xmas Grin?) but it was very cute.

Batcountry8 · 04/12/2022 10:50

Never had the conversation.
Offspring is 20 😁

I love it. It's joyous and fun.

Feef83 · 04/12/2022 10:44

I didn't realise it was a crime to ask questions 😂

but your other threads and indeed this one is underpinned with a very strong whiff of judgement!

Bbq1 · 04/12/2022 10:37

Feef83 · 03/12/2022 16:28

Just read your history Op (quiet weekend with a cold!)

you have started threads ranging from thinking young children go to bed too early through to being baffled that parents don’t think cereal and toast is a good snack for a teen.

Why don’t you just focus on what you do?

I didn't realise it was a crime to ask questions that I am genuinely interested in knowing the answer to by hearing the experiences of other parents. I have never ever checked another person's history (or my own) until now. Most of my threads dating back a few years are asking advice about covid or just general advice. I can't see one about bedtimes. Yours I glanced at and your threads range from being angry at Sainsbury's over a perceived slight through to whether MN thinks it's okay for you to date a guy years younger than you...You really don't have to comment on a thread if you're not interested.

OP posts:
Hesma · 04/12/2022 06:46

My eldest was 10 and cried when she found out. My youngest is 10 and I think this is going to be the last magical year 😢

bellamountain · 04/12/2022 00:15

Hats off to the parents who are supportive of keeping the magic alive. Five is still very young and if a ten year old still believes, so what? They aren't going to tell their friends, they'll just keep the belief to themselves. Santa is no less real than the other very famous Christmas story anyhow.

CoQ10 · 04/12/2022 00:09

My 10 year old said to me today (as we were decorating the tree) that he doesn't want to grow up.

He is starting to realise the magic isn't real. He wants to believe but it makes me sad that the childhood dream is almost over .

At least.it lasted this long, I guess.

TheaBrandt · 03/12/2022 23:57

My mother was a primary school teacher and said the 8/9 year olds had lots of questions then all the questions stopped the following year as they wanted to keep believing (or pretended to their parents that they did anyway!)

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/12/2022 23:40

Of course most 5 yos wholeheartedly believe.

Sometimes there’s a contingent on MN that expects and even wants children to grow up in a flash.

I reckon 8-10 is the usual age to work it out. My 8 yo ds is sort of holding on to some threads of belief but is very questioning of the whole thing.

Think my now 14 yo had worked it out by around that age - I can’t really remember but I remember taking to her about her knowing and ds still believing when she was 10

ethelredonagoodday · 03/12/2022 23:36

x2boys · 03/12/2022 16:17

You will.Get a vast array of answers ,from never believing ,to believing at high school ,I would say most kids start questioning from 8/9.

Yep this.

1982mommaof4 · 03/12/2022 23:32

Also I never had the chat with my eldest now 15.. he just eye rolls at me when I talk about Santa 😂

Hellocatshome · 03/12/2022 23:29

Florenz · 03/12/2022 23:24

It's hard to keep kids believing when different families tell their kids different things, eg only the one "big" present is from Santa/all parentthey ss from mum and dad are "from Santa" and other presents are from the people who bought them for you so you have to thank them/ALL presents from Santa.

It's hard to make kids believe when they see the toys advertised on TV and in the shops and they're made of plastic and say "Made in China" on the box. The whole thing probably worked a lot better in Victorian times when kids might get toys made of wood and it was easier to imagine them being made by Santa and his elves.

I agree, I think its all got too complicated now as well with the Elf on the Shelf and Christmas Eve boxes and a Santa's Grotto at every turn. It was a lot easier when it was mostly all down to your imagination.

1982mommaof4 · 03/12/2022 23:28

My DD is 9 and absolutely still believes

Florenz · 03/12/2022 23:24

It's hard to keep kids believing when different families tell their kids different things, eg only the one "big" present is from Santa/all parentthey ss from mum and dad are "from Santa" and other presents are from the people who bought them for you so you have to thank them/ALL presents from Santa.

It's hard to make kids believe when they see the toys advertised on TV and in the shops and they're made of plastic and say "Made in China" on the box. The whole thing probably worked a lot better in Victorian times when kids might get toys made of wood and it was easier to imagine them being made by Santa and his elves.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 03/12/2022 23:22

I think 8/9 is probably a more accurate age. DD was 7

I never believed, ever. I was a very cynical child though 😂

Gintime74 · 03/12/2022 23:19

Mine have all been around 10 when they start questioning, laying little traps etc! So I think they probably have been unconvinced since age 8. The longer the magic is kept alive the better as far as I’m concerned.

Rollin · 03/12/2022 23:09

Both kids absolutely believed at age 10
then asked and were told before the next Xmas when they’d be 11.
most of DD’s 10 year friends genuinely believe.