Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dd is asking for the most expensive Lego set from Santa

235 replies

Bananastars · 03/12/2022 14:41

Because she's saying we won't have to pay for it. What would you do?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
MrsToothyBitch · 04/12/2022 08:35

I think she's chancing her arm. I was at that age too; I got doubts after Christmas age 7 and they just grew to definite non belief over the next couple of Christmasses. I think I really knew at 8 but was careful before I committed publicly and fully to non believing in case it didn't pay off; I set a couple of "tests"! Definitely open about not believing after my 9th Christmas.

Up to you whether you keep up Santa and go into delivery/contractual T&Cs and specifics to stretch the magic or whether you chance your own arm back. With such a big present at her age, I think I would chance my own arm back and say that "I just know" that Santa WON'T be bringing that and she can draw her on conclusions.

FallingsHowIFeel · 04/12/2022 05:33

Bananastars · 03/12/2022 15:40

She loves being mean to her sister, her hormones kicking off

Wow. I’d be sorting that situation out straight away. She’s nearly 10 and is mean to a 5 year old? My kids have a similar age gap and my oldest wouldn’t have dreamed of spoiling the Santa excitement for his little sister. Any mean behaviour with a biggish age gap is unacceptable.

RobinRobinMouse · 04/12/2022 05:25

I've always been clear that the list for Father Christmas is one of ideas and he will choose. You might put something down that you think is amazing but he's been doing this a long time and knows which toys will and won't get played with. I do agree it might be a test though as she is at the age many realize.

caringcarer · 03/12/2022 21:01

If she deliberately spoils it by telling her 5 year old sister she will be on the naughty list. She can choose a different more reasonable priced gift. If she gets angry and tells her sister she will be getting a very small Lego set.

OverTheHillAndDownTotherSide · 03/12/2022 20:51

RedToothBrush · 03/12/2022 18:36

Maybe. But the difference is I'm not telling everyone to do it my way either.

What I'm doing is I'm pointing out that santa isn't your issue, so it's not about 'lying about santa' at all.

That's about dysfunctionality.

There isn't a problem with encouraging imagination in kids through the concept of santa. There is a problem with abusive relationships though which I do get.

Totally different.

Santa isn't to blame for your issues. Your parents are. Separate the two and let others enjoy the innocence you didn't have.

Doesn’t explain my husband’s experience. He grew up securely hundreds of miles from me. Still feels it’s a lie not worth telling.

Beanbagtrap · 03/12/2022 19:28

We just say it won't fit on the sleigh and she's being a CF

healthadvice123 · 03/12/2022 19:22

I think at 9 nearly 10 she knows
But just Say no santa doesn't spend that sort of money , sorry
We always only did a couple presents from santa and the rest he delivered but they knew they came from people so never had this issue

LBFseBrom · 03/12/2022 19:09

PayPennies · Today 18:02
My eldest is just turned 7. His mind is constantly buzzing with all sorts of questions - from DNA, embryos, spleens to earthquakes and tsunamis. When we don’t know answers we look it up. But I see no conceivable way in which our 7 yo will believe a magic man brings presents through his chimneys which don’t exist. But more importantly I just can’t see him demanding such expensive presents when he’s so aware of the cost of living, the heating bills and all else.
what I can’t grasp is now a (nearly) TEN year old still really genuinely believes in magic man and is also apparently so blissfully unaware of expenses. How?
..........
I doubt very much that she does believe in Santa but is probably aware that parents want her too. Plus if they've told her that Santa produces the gifts that's an added incentive to carry on the pretence!

It all sounds so complicated from this thread, eg 'Santa bills us for the presents', etc. It would surely be easier not to do Santa in the first place!

You can still have Christmas stockings (I did and still do them!), and stories, you don't need to make a mythical fantasy into reality for that, especially as doing that seems to cause so much stress for adults.

Staryflight445 · 03/12/2022 19:08

JingsMahBucket · 03/12/2022 14:48

How old is she? It might be time to disabuse her of the concept of Santa.

Yeah this came to my mind first too.

ChristmasCwtch · 03/12/2022 18:58

Bikes, iPads, big Lego sets are always be a mummy/daddy gift in our house. “It’s not kind to ask for very expensive items from Santa as there are millions and millions of children for him to visit, so let’s keep any requests more reasonable”

Mamai90 · 03/12/2022 18:57

I think an almost 10 year old know there is no Santa. My nephew knew from he was 8 as did I. He has a younger sibling who still believes and goes along with it all. Your daughter knows there is no Santa, she's chancing her arm!

Mummyoflittledragon · 03/12/2022 18:53

RedToothBrush · 03/12/2022 18:36

Maybe. But the difference is I'm not telling everyone to do it my way either.

What I'm doing is I'm pointing out that santa isn't your issue, so it's not about 'lying about santa' at all.

That's about dysfunctionality.

There isn't a problem with encouraging imagination in kids through the concept of santa. There is a problem with abusive relationships though which I do get.

Totally different.

Santa isn't to blame for your issues. Your parents are. Separate the two and let others enjoy the innocence you didn't have.

As someone, who felt stupid and betrayed when the golden child told me Santa didn’t exist, I agree with this comment. Children in secure attachment relationships with their families seem to not react like this.

Hellsmovie · 03/12/2022 18:48

Bananastars · 03/12/2022 15:04

She's 9, nearly 10. She wants one of those star wars Lego that cost £600+ which is definitely a big no. We could look for cheaper options or look on eBay but you can never tell whether it's complete until you finish itConfused

Take a look on aliexpress. They sell copys of lego models . Check reviews and youtube videos before you buy incase the set isnt any good

For example lego bowser is around £230

The copy is £71+ tax

£46.63
30%OFF | 2807pcs Super The Mighty Bowser Compatible 71411 Building Blocks Kit MOC Bricks Toys Children Birthday Gift Christmas gifts
a.aliexpress.com/_mOCosvA

Inserthiliarioususernamehere · 03/12/2022 18:45

I had bought some Santa presents which I didn’t realise my son had seen one year. After opening his stocking he said “but I saw these. Did you buy them?” Since then, I’ve always told him I buy the presents that Santa can’t get in Lapland and pay for them. As others have said, say you pay for them, and there’s a budget. I definitely wouldn’t buy her the expensive set.

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 03/12/2022 18:43

Because she's saying we won't have to pay for it

Well presumably that's because you have led her to believe that Santa brings all her presents.

It's time to tell the truth isn't it?

Perhaps you could tell her that you can give her some Christmas money and then she can use some other Christmas money or save up pocket money to get it herself afterwards. Or organise to get it in advance as a joint present with another person but put a label on it saying who it is from. But still explain to her that Santa is a story for small children that society thinks is a nice thing to do but that as she's so grown up now it's time for her to know that presents come from parents, family and friends and it costs money and that everyone has a budget.

RedToothBrush · 03/12/2022 18:36

OverTheHillAndDownTotherSide · 03/12/2022 18:32

Yes. Early childhood trauma is horrendous and this is one of my earliest memories. I feel like an outcast every December because I can’t enjoy the things others seem to demand I do (because they are like you and have no respect for difference).

Your approach is very alien to me and surely pretty far off the other end of the scale?!

Maybe. But the difference is I'm not telling everyone to do it my way either.

What I'm doing is I'm pointing out that santa isn't your issue, so it's not about 'lying about santa' at all.

That's about dysfunctionality.

There isn't a problem with encouraging imagination in kids through the concept of santa. There is a problem with abusive relationships though which I do get.

Totally different.

Santa isn't to blame for your issues. Your parents are. Separate the two and let others enjoy the innocence you didn't have.

LSSG · 03/12/2022 18:32

Stravaig · 03/12/2022 16:44

Tell DD that children who are mean to their little sister don't get any presents at all. She's too old for Santa, and you need to be addressing her nasty and manipulative tendencies, not rewarding them with lavish presents.

'Nasty and manipulative tendencies' hmm pot, kettle, black...

OverTheHillAndDownTotherSide · 03/12/2022 18:32

RedToothBrush · 03/12/2022 18:26

This isnt about santa.

Its about your disfunctional family and your fixated it on santa.

You massively project your issues on others.

As an older child, I loved santa even when I found out and still got a stocking from santa to the day I moved out for the final time. I was 27.

Once I moved out, santa still delivered every year to our house before DS was born.

Cos santa rocks and I still believe in his magic.

I'm 44.

Yes. Early childhood trauma is horrendous and this is one of my earliest memories. I feel like an outcast every December because I can’t enjoy the things others seem to demand I do (because they are like you and have no respect for difference).

Your approach is very alien to me and surely pretty far off the other end of the scale?!

BreatheAndFocus · 03/12/2022 18:27

I’ve always told my children that Santa brings the presents but the parent(s) has/have to pay for them. They’ve never questioned this and have never asked for anything expensive.

Oh, and there’s no need to spoil the fun about Santa. Children grow up quickly and realisation comes of its own accord. I always think the people who spoil it for others are mean-souled little people. If you have younger DC then ask her to keep the magic going and promise an extra treat. Although hopefully she’ll do it out of kindness anyway.

RedToothBrush · 03/12/2022 18:26

OverTheHillAndDownTotherSide · 03/12/2022 18:21

Yes, really. Spent thousands of £s on therapy over the years.(There were other dynamics at play but this really really drove a wedge. I remember my mother hissing that I better not dare spoil it for my (golden child) sister and that was that. I didn’t like lying and I didn’t trust her/them anymore for lying to me.)

We have just the one child and no. Presents arrive but we’ve never said where they came from. Left it up to her to decide what she believes (as with all religions). Weirdly DH felt he had been lied to when he found out as a child and he probably felt stronger than me that we shouldn’t do it with DD.

I don’t think she ever really believed in it despite peer pressure etc. She worked out age 7 that Santa would have to travel faster than the speed of light to do it and that determined it definitely wasn’t real from then.

She’s never “spoiled the magic” (whatever the fuck that means) for others either.

This isnt about santa.

Its about your disfunctional family and your fixated it on santa.

You massively project your issues on others.

As an older child, I loved santa even when I found out and still got a stocking from santa to the day I moved out for the final time. I was 27.

Once I moved out, santa still delivered every year to our house before DS was born.

Cos santa rocks and I still believe in his magic.

I'm 44.

RedToothBrush · 03/12/2022 18:23

PayPennies · 03/12/2022 18:02

My eldest is just turned 7. His mind is constantly buzzing with all sorts of questions - from DNA, embryos, spleens to earthquakes and tsunamis. When we don’t know answers we look it up. But I see no conceivable way in which our 7 yo will believe a magic man brings presents through his chimneys which don’t exist. But more importantly I just can’t see him demanding such expensive presents when he’s so aware of the cost of living, the heating bills and all else.

what I can’t grasp is now a (nearly) TEN year old still really genuinely believes in magic man and is also apparently so blissfully unaware of expenses. How?

7 year olds still have imaginations.

My 8 year old is smart and into all sorts of science stuff. Yet he still believes in santa.

Given that grown adults believe in religion, despite all the science stuff what's the difference?

AnyOldThings · 03/12/2022 18:23

RandomMess · 03/12/2022 14:44

Tell her that you have to send the money to Santa he delivers and that is why down children get very little indeed.

This is what we always did. So that DD knew we had limits.

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 03/12/2022 18:22

We were lucky in choosing to do the Santa only brings stocking presents.
I'd take no prisoners I reckon. Tell her that it's a bit greedy to ask for something so expensive, so that request will not be passed. Choose again my darling child.
How much do you usually spend?

OverTheHillAndDownTotherSide · 03/12/2022 18:21

user1496146479 · 03/12/2022 17:06

@OverTheHillAndDownTotherSide
Really?? Hmm
Dramatic much!! Do you continue 'the lie' for any dc you have??

Yes, really. Spent thousands of £s on therapy over the years.(There were other dynamics at play but this really really drove a wedge. I remember my mother hissing that I better not dare spoil it for my (golden child) sister and that was that. I didn’t like lying and I didn’t trust her/them anymore for lying to me.)

We have just the one child and no. Presents arrive but we’ve never said where they came from. Left it up to her to decide what she believes (as with all religions). Weirdly DH felt he had been lied to when he found out as a child and he probably felt stronger than me that we shouldn’t do it with DD.

I don’t think she ever really believed in it despite peer pressure etc. She worked out age 7 that Santa would have to travel faster than the speed of light to do it and that determined it definitely wasn’t real from then.

She’s never “spoiled the magic” (whatever the fuck that means) for others either.

RedToothBrush · 03/12/2022 18:19

pairofrollerskates · 03/12/2022 17:48

The Santa thing is a lie. Why are you perpetuating it? Tell her it's a STORY ... children understand the world of stories, and are perfectly able to suspend their disbelief in order to participate win the Santa myth, while at the same time understanding it for what it is. Age taken into consideration, of course. e never told our children about Santa. They picked it up as a story from tv etc. They were always (and still are some 40years later) happy to"play along" but they always knew the truth.Why would you lie to your children?

Cos I'm not a miserable grinch with a stick up my arse.