Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What would you do. Buy or rent housing association flat?

58 replies

Cheeseandlobster · 03/12/2022 14:05

I am posting on behalf of one of my best friends who doesn't know what to do.

She is living with her ex dp in his home. He is a difficult character in lots of ways as he never made time for her and was emotionally unavailable. He has however said she can stay as long as she needs to sort herself out.

She has always wanted to buy her own home but is unable to afford anything other than a run down property in a bad area. She has a 10 percent deposit and enough for second hand furniture. At 45 she feels time is running out but is scared of negative equity with the current economic climate. She has also been bidding for local authority/ housing association flats and has been 4th or 5th in line recently so may be successful soon.

She has a job which will give her just enough to get by on but her salary will increase in increments over time.

She is torn between desperately wanting to own her own home but she won't be able to afford anything but bills, food and socialising only once a month. Or the option of an ha flat where she could afford to have a better life than just affording the essentials. I think she would struggle not being able to go out often after her relationship breakdown but am worried advising to go down the ha route might be the wrong thing.

What would you do in this situation?"

OP posts:
Obbydoo · 03/12/2022 20:55

Cheeseandlobster · 03/12/2022 15:16

She has about 30k in savings she says. There is no savings threshold mentioned on the council website but some websites say some areas have a 50k threshold so she would be below that.

Wow! It is no surprise we have so little social housing for those who actually need it if we are letting people with £30k savings have them. Advise her to do the right thing and stand on her own two capable feet rather than taking up much needed social housing.

NewBootsAndRanty · 03/12/2022 20:45

OliveWah · 03/12/2022 20:43

I’m sure a small family (a single parent with a baby for example) would be elated to be offered a one bedroom flat. I just think that if you have £30k in the bank then you’re nowhere near as “in need” of a HA property, than someone (and I’m particularly talking about those who have young DC here) who can’t afford to rent privately and is unlikely to be in a position to buy. It seems selfish to me that when there are so few available, someone would think it’s ok to take a HA property that could go to someone with nothing, when they themselves could afford to either buy their own place, or rent privately.

It's unlikely to happen though if the HA are doing the allocations.
My HA always advertises 1 beds as suitable for a single person or a couple, but not families (even small ones).
2 beds are advertised as suitable for small families/single parents.

Ivyblu · 03/12/2022 20:43

OliveWah · 03/12/2022 20:17

I'm amazed that someone with £30k in the bank would be offered a HA property! There are SO many people, many with young children, with no savings, who would (and should imho) be much more of a priority than a single woman with huge savings.

I don't agree with this view though this is why it's difficult to save if your in HA and buy. OPS friend has not been offered but she's perfectly entitled to. 30k sounds decent but some rents are nearly £1000 per month so based upon this what would OP do after spending all her savings?

Because private houses are a lot more money than Social housing.

OliveWah · 03/12/2022 20:43

NewBootsAndRanty · 03/12/2022 20:36

Single woman = 1 bed property
Family = 2+ bedrooms.

I’m sure a small family (a single parent with a baby for example) would be elated to be offered a one bedroom flat. I just think that if you have £30k in the bank then you’re nowhere near as “in need” of a HA property, than someone (and I’m particularly talking about those who have young DC here) who can’t afford to rent privately and is unlikely to be in a position to buy. It seems selfish to me that when there are so few available, someone would think it’s ok to take a HA property that could go to someone with nothing, when they themselves could afford to either buy their own place, or rent privately.

PickyEaters · 03/12/2022 20:37

Take the HA flat! No question.

NewBootsAndRanty · 03/12/2022 20:36

OliveWah · 03/12/2022 20:17

I'm amazed that someone with £30k in the bank would be offered a HA property! There are SO many people, many with young children, with no savings, who would (and should imho) be much more of a priority than a single woman with huge savings.

Single woman = 1 bed property
Family = 2+ bedrooms.

OliveWah · 03/12/2022 20:17

I'm amazed that someone with £30k in the bank would be offered a HA property! There are SO many people, many with young children, with no savings, who would (and should imho) be much more of a priority than a single woman with huge savings.

Stomacharmeleon · 03/12/2022 18:08

In this climate and on here own I would take the housing association flat.

Yabado · 03/12/2022 16:59

My son is doing a rent to buy
long story but he is renting the property he is going to buy as a SO from a HA just waiting for his mortgage to be finalized .
he rents it at just below what his mortgage / rent & service charge would be so much cheaper than regular renting the same apartment
is this an option for your friend
my son has a years AST but they disregard this as soon as he buys it so he won’t have to pay any extra months rent once he buys and he will get his deposit back as well

Gingerkittykat · 03/12/2022 16:46

Is she applying to the HA as someone who is homeless due to relationship break up?

I ask this because even 4th or 5th in line doesn't necessarily mean she is near the top of the list and she could be bidding for a long time.

Are there any part own schemes with HA where you live?

AssumingDirectControl · 03/12/2022 16:45

SEND2022 · 03/12/2022 16:41

See technically our LA has a 50k threshold too but those with 30k would be so low priority they are unlikely to ever reach the top of the list and because of this our LA more or less force them to privately rent. Published criteria and actual reality are two different things

Indeed, I’d be astonished if she was offered a HA tenancy as there are plenty of people in greater housing need.

SEND2022 · 03/12/2022 16:41

Cheeseandlobster · 03/12/2022 15:16

She has about 30k in savings she says. There is no savings threshold mentioned on the council website but some websites say some areas have a 50k threshold so she would be below that.

See technically our LA has a 50k threshold too but those with 30k would be so low priority they are unlikely to ever reach the top of the list and because of this our LA more or less force them to privately rent. Published criteria and actual reality are two different things

SEND2022 · 03/12/2022 16:39

Fidgety31 · 03/12/2022 15:17

@SEND2022 ok it’s Right to Aquire or something like that with a HA - but same principle as right to buy

A right to aquire is not compulsory for HAs and if they agree they can offer you a different home instead.

RitaFires · 03/12/2022 16:09

Prices for materials are very high at the moment and it can be very hard to find trades that are available to do any work. I would normally say do whatever you can to buy a house but your friend's circumstances sound like she'd be much better off in a HA property. Unless she has great DIY skills and experience that would make her confident to do a lot of renovation work herself.

MelchiorsMistress · 03/12/2022 15:52

If she can get a secure HA tenancy she’d be much better off doing that. She won’t be able to buy on a budget and make a nice home. Relatively, her savings aren’t huge, and she’d be much better off having the money to make a nice home out of a decent property without the responsibility of building maintenance.

BatshitandBonkers · 03/12/2022 15:51

Whatever she does she should avoid buying in a bad area.

There have been a couple of threads recently from people who regret being in a bad area, living in a bad area can seriously damage MH.

Ivyblu · 03/12/2022 15:51

I would rent. Because the house may need repairs and how secure is her job?

UC won't pay your mortgage of she fell on hard times.

GrumpyPanda · 03/12/2022 15:50

Owning is about a) security of tenure and b) building up assets. If she is offered a nice enough flat in a decent area that would take care of a), freeing her to invest in other long-term appreciating assets such as stocks and funds. Seems win-win to me, it's spreading her risk and means she gets to avoid all the unexpected bills connected with home ownership.

ladywithnomanors · 03/12/2022 15:48

Living on her own in a rundown house in a bad area sounds miserable. With no spare cash to renovate or socialise? Depressing.

NewBootsAndRanty · 03/12/2022 15:46

Fidgety31 · 03/12/2022 15:17

@SEND2022 ok it’s Right to Aquire or something like that with a HA - but same principle as right to buy

Is that for every HA property?
I've been in mine for over a decade and have no RTA/RTB or similar.

Cheeseandlobster · 03/12/2022 15:41

2bazookas · 03/12/2022 15:22

She has a job which will give her just enough to get by on

Then she probably won't get a mortgage.
Sounds to me as if she's pretty clueless about the additional costs of buying a home ; legal fees, rising mortgage rates, repairs and maintenance, buildings insurance.

A run down property in a bad area will be more expensive to maintain and insure.

She knows all this. She has enough for legal fees and is aware that repairs etc would be her responsibility hence being reluctant to buy a run down home. She has factored buildings insurance and life assurance ( we went through this together as I used to work in financial services) and has a mortgage offer in principle already. So far from clueless. She just wants to make the right decision.

OP posts:
2bazookas · 03/12/2022 15:22

She has a job which will give her just enough to get by on

Then she probably won't get a mortgage.
Sounds to me as if she's pretty clueless about the additional costs of buying a home ; legal fees, rising mortgage rates, repairs and maintenance, buildings insurance.

A run down property in a bad area will be more expensive to maintain and insure.

Cheeseandlobster · 03/12/2022 15:19

LBFseBrom · 03/12/2022 14:55

It's better to buy of course and belt tightening doesn't last forever. I know a couple who bought a small, one bed ex-council flat a couple of years back and they have felt the pinch but are now in a position to buy a house so it has paid off.

Your friend really has to weigh it all up but there's nothing to compare with owning your own property, be it ever so humble. If it is a bit run down, maybe friends can help with decorating and, as you said, she can buy second hand furniture some of which is really nice (British Heart Foundation for one).

The most important thing for a woman on her own is to live somewhere she feels fairly safe so that factor must be considered.

I wish her well whatever she decides.

I would be able to help decorate and source furniture but many of these homes need more than this

OP posts:
Fidgety31 · 03/12/2022 15:17

@SEND2022 ok it’s Right to Aquire or something like that with a HA - but same principle as right to buy

Cheeseandlobster · 03/12/2022 15:16

SEND2022 · 03/12/2022 15:06

If she can afford to buy she may well not have the option of renting a HA flat.

Also, PP said about right to buy. There isn't a right to buy for HA homes

She has about 30k in savings she says. There is no savings threshold mentioned on the council website but some websites say some areas have a 50k threshold so she would be below that.

OP posts: