Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think mil is rude for saying I’m skinny

162 replies

Ihavemyeye · 03/12/2022 13:15

I’m 8 stone and 5’4 which is a healthy weight

OP posts:
PyongyangKipperbang · 04/12/2022 00:34

FrozenGhost · 04/12/2022 00:31

I don't comment on people's bodies and I do think it a bit rude, but are you really, genuinely offended? Really? I'm sure you're very proud of the way you look and would hate to put on weight, let alone be overweight. This comes across as a little disingenuous.

Yeah cos it must only be fat people who dont like how they look.....all the skinnies must be all secretly smug about it....

FWIW I hate the way I look now far more than I did when I was a size 22......have a go at that with your jealousy amatuer psychology.

nokidshere · 04/12/2022 00:33

OP, if MIL comments again I'd ask your DH to take her aside and tell her it's rude

I totally agree that it's rude and there is no need for other people to be commenting on anyones weight, but the above sentence really irritates me. MIL was rude to OP, OP should just tell her to stop doing it, why ask her DH to do it for her?

DuplicateUserName · 04/12/2022 00:32

Annie232 · 04/12/2022 00:16

I’m not being sarcastic, genuinely trying to understand as someone who has to fight to maintain a healthy weight.

Then perhaps you should stop letting your personal issues cloud your intelligence?

Maybe take time out to consider why underweight people aren't advised by their GPs to 'just eat more chocolate'?

Do you tell overweight people to 'just eat less chocolate'?

FrozenGhost · 04/12/2022 00:31

I don't comment on people's bodies and I do think it a bit rude, but are you really, genuinely offended? Really? I'm sure you're very proud of the way you look and would hate to put on weight, let alone be overweight. This comes across as a little disingenuous.

PyongyangKipperbang · 04/12/2022 00:30

Oh and I dont go to the gym anymore as it was part of the worst time in my ED, so swapping that for a Nando's wouldnt work either!

You really cannot understand that some people can struggle to maintain a healthy weight from being underweight but you can understand people struggling to to maintain from being overweight? That some people tend towards overweight due to that just being how they are built and that some people tend towards slimness for the same reason and that it would be so easy for either person to go too far in the wrong direction?

Either you are so thick that I am impressed you managed to connect to the internet all by yourself or you are a GF.

PyongyangKipperbang · 04/12/2022 00:25

Annie232 · 04/12/2022 00:15

Sorry can’t relate. Most people struggle to maintain a healthy weight/ be skinny, have to exercise regularly and watch what they eat. Seriously, can you not just have a few weeks on the sofa and work your way through some chocolate bars, pizza or crisps?

Wow......

Ok well speaking for myself, as someone who has to work very hard to not be unhealthily thin due to an ED, no I cannot just sit on the sofa and binge. Sure I would put on weight if I did that but I simply cannot do that. Physically I couldnt stomach enough food and emotionally I couldnt bring myself to put it into my mouth. "Nice" things are what you would consider to be normal, say a roast dinner without a huge side dish of guilt topped with a rich sauce of self hatred.

My friend has a serious health condition that leaves him struggling to keep weight on, in his 70's now and has found that age slowing him down has actually helped. What should he do? Make it worse by eating nutrient poor crap?!

Also, even without an ED.....why would anyone want to do that when it invites other health issues? Thin people with bad diets can get strokes/heart problems too you know.

The fact that you think that all it needs to get fat is veg out with pizza says that you think of food in the wrong way and thats why you struggle to keep weight off. Food is fuel first and foremost, it can be enjoyed but if the only "nice things" you can think of are pizza, junk and chocolate then it suggests to me that you dont actually view your day to day meals as enjoyable so focus on sweet/high carb stuff.....ie....you have a sugar addiction.

PoppyBlunt · 04/12/2022 00:25

Annie232 · 04/12/2022 00:16

I’m not being sarcastic, genuinely trying to understand as someone who has to fight to maintain a healthy weight.

This doesn't come across in the least bit genuine

PoppyBlunt · 04/12/2022 00:22

The dictionary definition of skinny is "unattractively thin"

It's an insult and one I tired of when I was younger.

Annie232 · 04/12/2022 00:19

Annie232 · 04/12/2022 00:15

Sorry can’t relate. Most people struggle to maintain a healthy weight/ be skinny, have to exercise regularly and watch what they eat. Seriously, can you not just have a few weeks on the sofa and work your way through some chocolate bars, pizza or crisps?

Or swap the gym session for a Nando’s

Coralpop · 04/12/2022 00:18

Hmm, 8 stone at 5 '4" on most people would look pretty thin. I'm 5 '3 and the lightest I've been as an adult was 8 stone 3. At that weight my face looked very gaunt and a few people said I'd lost too much.

Annie232 · 04/12/2022 00:16

I’m not being sarcastic, genuinely trying to understand as someone who has to fight to maintain a healthy weight.

Annie232 · 04/12/2022 00:15

TeapotTitties · 04/12/2022 00:07

And this sort of ignorant bollocks annoys me.

Do you seriously think underweight people 'just need to eat a few chocolate bars and nice things' to gain weight?

Twat.

Sorry can’t relate. Most people struggle to maintain a healthy weight/ be skinny, have to exercise regularly and watch what they eat. Seriously, can you not just have a few weeks on the sofa and work your way through some chocolate bars, pizza or crisps?

Theancetocomein · 04/12/2022 00:11

Annie232 · 03/12/2022 23:50

Ffs this does annoy me, just eat a few chocolate bars and nice things if you are underweight. What an awful problem to have…

Those makes me so mad, bit like saying just stop eating cakes and you won't be so fat 🤬 such ignorance

TeapotTitties · 04/12/2022 00:07

Annie232 · 03/12/2022 23:50

Ffs this does annoy me, just eat a few chocolate bars and nice things if you are underweight. What an awful problem to have…

And this sort of ignorant bollocks annoys me.

Do you seriously think underweight people 'just need to eat a few chocolate bars and nice things' to gain weight?

Twat.

DuplicateUserName · 04/12/2022 00:05

Gwenhwyfar · 03/12/2022 14:02

Slim is healthy and looks good. Skinny means too thin so it definitely is a negative comment.

Exactly.

'Skinny' seems to have become a 'compliment' in recent years for some reason, but it's really not a good thing if meant literally.

Cw112 · 04/12/2022 00:02

Commenting on another person's appearance is always rude and unnecessary so yanbu however I'd probably let it go, put it down to her poor manners and ignore her if you can.

Annie232 · 03/12/2022 23:50

Ffs this does annoy me, just eat a few chocolate bars and nice things if you are underweight. What an awful problem to have…

PyongyangKipperbang · 03/12/2022 23:48

My aunt did this to me just this week. I have lost a lot of weight in the last few years. I actually have an eating disorder so struggle to not lose more as I am trying to beat it but she doesnt know that. My BMI is 19 so at the lower end of normal, but still normal which I am ok with.

She came in to where I work and immediately started saying I was too skinny and had lost too much weight. In her case, she has put on a lot of weight of the same period, and knowing her I would say that she is probably jealous (she has form.....hates anyone who looks better than her (in her opinion), it goes back years). but if I had said "Oh you are getting way too fat" I would have been an asshole, but she can tell me I am "too thin" and its ok?!

Gwenhwyfar · 03/12/2022 22:50

"You can’t be too thin on Mumsnet, you should know that by now!"

You defo can. I don't subscribe to the idea that MN is pro-skinny. I keep hearing of 'competitive undereating' on here, but nobody can point to real examples.

AtleastitsnotMonday · 03/12/2022 17:33

I find the phrase 'Unless I'm standing on your foot, I'd prefer you refrained from commenting on my weight' useful. I've rarely needed to use it more than once.

Sagittarius25 · 03/12/2022 17:29

When I was in my late teens/early twenties and before I started weight training in the gym (hello bigger thighs and a bigger behind) people used to call me skinny and I hated it. I wasn't underweight in any way, ate what I want etc. I was happy with how I looked but wouldn't have called myself skinny, just slim. I did used to call people out on it in the end. It's defo rude.

Billybear1 · 03/12/2022 17:25

LBFseBrom · 03/12/2022 16:43

When I was young everyone wanted to be skinny.

Same here, when was younger it was seen
as a compliment. Maybe this is where MIL is comming from. Did you not ask her what she meant by it at the time?

BreakfastClub80 · 03/12/2022 17:20

I hate it, grew up with it! And I’ve always covered myself up to try and hide it. It’s rude and hurtful but some people assume they’re allowed. Yes, we can choose our battles but it really is just as rude as commenting on larger body shapes if it’s designed to shame. Maybe it depends on the context but I don’t think so.

123boom · 03/12/2022 17:02

Def rude. I had this for a lot of my life. People don’t see how hurtful it can be. It’s totally different from using the word ‘slim’

Musicaltheatremum · 03/12/2022 16:58

I'm 5'4 and 15,stones. 8 would be tiny for me(I'm 59) 11 is better. My mil called me "beefy" recently 😥

Swipe left for the next trending thread