Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think mil is rude for saying I’m skinny

162 replies

Ihavemyeye · 03/12/2022 13:15

I’m 8 stone and 5’4 which is a healthy weight

OP posts:
Ivyblu · 04/12/2022 05:16

PyongyangKipperbang · 04/12/2022 02:19

Well I stand by the fact that referring to anyone by their physical appearance.....size, weight, height, colour, hair colour, lack of hair, stance, gait etc is rude and shouldnt be done. There is no context that makes it ok.

I find it utterly infuriating that if I was to do that to someone who is overweight I would be "fat shaming" but they are cheerfully allowed a free pass to comment on my size or weight because I am slim. So us "skinnies" (quoting a PP) are not allowed to feel offended because larger people envy us?!

I don't know if I would use the term envy. But look at the cat walk models...... it's a positive it's seen as right.

mamabear715 · 04/12/2022 05:05

And.. it turns into an argument, as always..
We come in all shapes & sizes, can we move on?

PyongyangKipperbang · 04/12/2022 02:19

Well I stand by the fact that referring to anyone by their physical appearance.....size, weight, height, colour, hair colour, lack of hair, stance, gait etc is rude and shouldnt be done. There is no context that makes it ok.

I find it utterly infuriating that if I was to do that to someone who is overweight I would be "fat shaming" but they are cheerfully allowed a free pass to comment on my size or weight because I am slim. So us "skinnies" (quoting a PP) are not allowed to feel offended because larger people envy us?!

Kanaloa · 04/12/2022 02:05

PyongyangKipperbang · 04/12/2022 02:00

I apologise.....she didnt use bitch, that was someone else.

Yeah, all op has said is that her mil said she is skinny, then given her weight and height. In some families this would be normal/acceptable, it may have been said in an affectionate way etc. But op has deliberately given absolutely no context to go on, which makes me think it’s more about whipping up a mumsnet classic (let’s be derogatory to thin people and/or insult oversight people) than getting opinions on the behaviour of her mil.

PyongyangKipperbang · 04/12/2022 02:00

I apologise.....she didnt use bitch, that was someone else.

PyongyangKipperbang · 04/12/2022 02:00

Kanaloa · 04/12/2022 01:57

You’ve given an op with absolutely no context, so it’s impossible to say whether she was unreasonable or not. Did she affectionately say ‘oh I wish I was skinny like x!’ Did she respond to somebody else saying they wanted to lose weight with ‘ooh don’t get too skinny or you’ll look awful like x!’ Did she say ‘I’ve been a bit worried about you, you’ve suddenly lost a lot of weight in a short time and you look ever so skinny at the moment.’ Did she say ‘ooh you look tiny and skinny in those new jeans!’ Did she say ‘yuck look at that horrible skinny bitch?’

Either way it depends. No point just giving the bare bones facts and expecting anyone to be able to tell if she was reasonable or not.

Actually its fine.

She used a negative description of another persons body and bolted it onto "bitch". So no matter in what context she used it, she was VVU.

Kanaloa · 04/12/2022 01:59

Annie232 · 04/12/2022 00:15

Sorry can’t relate. Most people struggle to maintain a healthy weight/ be skinny, have to exercise regularly and watch what they eat. Seriously, can you not just have a few weeks on the sofa and work your way through some chocolate bars, pizza or crisps?

Can those people who struggle not just stop lounging round the couch eating pizza and spend a couple of weeks in intensive exercise classes and eat a few salads? Absolutely ridiculous.

Kanaloa · 04/12/2022 01:57

You’ve given an op with absolutely no context, so it’s impossible to say whether she was unreasonable or not. Did she affectionately say ‘oh I wish I was skinny like x!’ Did she respond to somebody else saying they wanted to lose weight with ‘ooh don’t get too skinny or you’ll look awful like x!’ Did she say ‘I’ve been a bit worried about you, you’ve suddenly lost a lot of weight in a short time and you look ever so skinny at the moment.’ Did she say ‘ooh you look tiny and skinny in those new jeans!’ Did she say ‘yuck look at that horrible skinny bitch?’

Either way it depends. No point just giving the bare bones facts and expecting anyone to be able to tell if she was reasonable or not.

SuperSuperCold · 04/12/2022 01:55

If my mil called me skinny I'd give her a massive hug, love her forever and celebrate with a massive slice of chocolate cake! I dream of being called skinny!! .. maybe one day!

RobertaFirmino · 04/12/2022 01:39

pictish · 04/12/2022 01:31

Stop moaning.

No. In fact, I've only just started.

It is downright rude to comment on anyone's body. Fat, thin, tall, short. Plain bad manners.

I'm a scrawny lanky sod and believe me, there is nothing aspirational about my body. Just as there are issues that are common to those with excess weight, the 'skinny bitches/bastards' have problems too. Suggesting that we should 'stop moaning' suggests that you are a superficial arse, concerned only with how things look and unwilling to look beyond.

Blankets and hot drinks to my fellow bee-yatches!

pictish · 04/12/2022 01:31

Stop moaning.

PyongyangKipperbang · 04/12/2022 01:26

Oh the cold........my partner is very understanding that his gas bill trebles for the week when I stay over for one weekend lol!

Honeyroar · 04/12/2022 01:23

Annie232 · 04/12/2022 00:15

Sorry can’t relate. Most people struggle to maintain a healthy weight/ be skinny, have to exercise regularly and watch what they eat. Seriously, can you not just have a few weeks on the sofa and work your way through some chocolate bars, pizza or crisps?

Open your mind a bit! Some people struggle to put on. My husband was very ill and had emergency operations. The hospital said he could go home when he gained 3 stones. He still hasn’t a decade later! They gave up and sent him home after 1.5 stones. And it’s not as wonderful as us portly folk imagine being underweight. He gets cold easily and will probably struggle more when older.

Mamaneedsadrink · 04/12/2022 01:23

Could she mean it in a concerned way? My Dad says that to me meaning he's worried I'm not eating enough. Also when I've put on weight he tells me I'm fat. Can't win. Some people have no tact (or are completely unaware they're being rude). I'd just ignore if you can or else maybe say I'm actually in a healthy weight range thank you and leave it at that.

Spoodee · 04/12/2022 01:19

PyongyangKipperbang · 04/12/2022 01:05

I also have anorexia, if you want my skinny you need to take the anorexia as well.....its a BOGOF.

I don't think people stop to think. Comments on weight can be so upsetting. My sister is naturally very slim and she is trying to gain weight via the gym. Someone calling her skinny would devastate her.

Berlinlover · 04/12/2022 01:18

I miss being called skinny 😭

PyongyangKipperbang · 04/12/2022 01:17

Fraaahnces · 04/12/2022 01:11

I would love to say “You’re just morbidly obese”… but I don’t when I keep hearing about my supposed “Anorexia” from the MIL I haven’t seen or spoken to for over six years. (Other very valid reasons.) I have lost about 65kgs sticking to a strict keto diet and she’s not impressed that I have managed this.

Because you have proved that her obesity is not because she cant but because she cant be arsed.

She has probably spent years convincing herself that her weight is down to her genes, her "thyroid problems" (imagined), lack of time.....when it reality its down to the biscuititis. Then you went and made an effort and lost weight. "Call me out without telling me you are calling me out" Grin

Fraaahnces · 04/12/2022 01:11

I would love to say “You’re just morbidly obese”… but I don’t when I keep hearing about my supposed “Anorexia” from the MIL I haven’t seen or spoken to for over six years. (Other very valid reasons.) I have lost about 65kgs sticking to a strict keto diet and she’s not impressed that I have managed this.

PyongyangKipperbang · 04/12/2022 01:06

Spoodee · 04/12/2022 01:05

What a bizarre view.

You can stick your tiny violin where the sun don't shine. I spent my whole adult life being obese and I was just as beautiful then as I am now. And not wanting people to comment on my body is completely valid.

❤

monsteramunch · 04/12/2022 01:05

"Can you not call me skinny please, it makes me uncomfortable."

Or if you have kids I would go with what would be an honest statement from me:

"Can you not comment on my weight please, we don't want the kids to pick up on commenting on other people's weight or give them any reason to self conscious about their own."

PyongyangKipperbang · 04/12/2022 01:05

Annie232 · 04/12/2022 01:02

I have, and its usually said by someone who doesnt like or is jealous of said "skinny bitch" who actually isnt skinny at all but slimmer than the person who said it.

you said the term skinny is used by someone who is jealous of ‘skinny person’. To be jealous they must have something desirable… ie skinniness

I also have anorexia, if you want my skinny you need to take the anorexia as well.....its a BOGOF.

Spoodee · 04/12/2022 01:05

Annie232 · 04/12/2022 00:59

At the end of the day, size 4/6 is attractive a desirable in society and for most people. Size 18/20 is considered unattractive. There is your difference. I maintain playing the smallest violin for all those skinnies out there…

What a bizarre view.

You can stick your tiny violin where the sun don't shine. I spent my whole adult life being obese and I was just as beautiful then as I am now. And not wanting people to comment on my body is completely valid.

Annie232 · 04/12/2022 01:03

MarshaMelrose · 04/12/2022 01:02

Slim people don't like to be called skinny or fat.

I'm a fat person and I hate being called fat but I'd give my eye teeth to be called skinny.

The reason people call you skinny is because you look good.
The reason people don't call me fat is because I look bad.
So they're not meaning to be rude, they're complimenting you.

Exactly this

poefaced · 04/12/2022 01:03

Yanbu, skinny is rude (i say this as a size 14).

Call her fat, see how she likes it.

Annie232 · 04/12/2022 01:02

PyongyangKipperbang · 04/12/2022 01:00

How? Explain to me please exactly how I have proved your point?

Especially as, the vast majority of the times I have heard it said, was by bigger women to me when I was also very overweight, under the assumption I would also hate said "skinny bitch" based purely on the fact that I was fat.

I have, and its usually said by someone who doesnt like or is jealous of said "skinny bitch" who actually isnt skinny at all but slimmer than the person who said it.

you said the term skinny is used by someone who is jealous of ‘skinny person’. To be jealous they must have something desirable… ie skinniness