Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think mil is rude for saying I’m skinny

162 replies

Ihavemyeye · 03/12/2022 13:15

I’m 8 stone and 5’4 which is a healthy weight

OP posts:
BendingSpoons · 04/12/2022 08:08

PyongyangKipperbang · 04/12/2022 02:19

Well I stand by the fact that referring to anyone by their physical appearance.....size, weight, height, colour, hair colour, lack of hair, stance, gait etc is rude and shouldnt be done. There is no context that makes it ok.

I find it utterly infuriating that if I was to do that to someone who is overweight I would be "fat shaming" but they are cheerfully allowed a free pass to comment on my size or weight because I am slim. So us "skinnies" (quoting a PP) are not allowed to feel offended because larger people envy us?!

I agree. We need to stop focusing on other people's weights. It's not healthy for any of us to hear the message that what you weigh is so important.

EVERY time we see PIL they tell me 'you've lost weight' and it is supposed to be a compliment. I reply 'no I haven't' which is a fact I know about my own body, backed up by scales 🙄 They then argue with me that I have. Eventually they back down and say I look well. So just say that!

They also tell DH he has lost weight (he hasn't either) but in his case it is a criticism because he weighs less. It makes me want to scream!

ChubbyMorticia · 04/12/2022 08:06

SuspiciousHedgehog · 04/12/2022 07:55

@ChubbyMorticia I LIKE it when other people affirm my colour choices 😬

I was offering those as examples of compliments that don’t involve commenting on the person’s shape/size/ weight 🤣

RampantIvy · 04/12/2022 08:01

SuspiciousHedgehog · 04/12/2022 07:55

@ChubbyMorticia I LIKE it when other people affirm my colour choices 😬

So do I.

napody · 04/12/2022 07:57

cofeetablebook · 03/12/2022 13:24

It's insulting OP. Fight fire with fire.
"Thank you for your concern, why don't you pull yourself up a couple of chairs and we'll discuss my weight problem..."

😂

SuspiciousHedgehog · 04/12/2022 07:55

@ChubbyMorticia I LIKE it when other people affirm my colour choices 😬

Kanaloa · 04/12/2022 07:54

PyongyangKipperbang · 04/12/2022 02:19

Well I stand by the fact that referring to anyone by their physical appearance.....size, weight, height, colour, hair colour, lack of hair, stance, gait etc is rude and shouldnt be done. There is no context that makes it ok.

I find it utterly infuriating that if I was to do that to someone who is overweight I would be "fat shaming" but they are cheerfully allowed a free pass to comment on my size or weight because I am slim. So us "skinnies" (quoting a PP) are not allowed to feel offended because larger people envy us?!

Of course it isn’t rude to mention any physical attribute! If that was the case you could never say ‘yes Amy with the brown hair’ or ‘yes he is tall isn’t he!’

There’s no reason why we shouldn’t be able to refer to the physical appearance of any person, that’s just daft.

ChubbyMorticia · 04/12/2022 07:53

I sincerely wish people would stop commenting on other’s bodies.

“You look lovely!”
”Gorgeous top!”
” I love that colour on you!”

There are a multitude of ways to pay someone a compliment without commenting on their body size/shape/weight.

SuspiciousHedgehog · 04/12/2022 07:50

I think if someone called me fat now, it would seem MORE insulting, but I would still laugh it off. Differnce is, nobody says a word about the fact I'm overweight, even if I bring up my weight gain. There is a polite silence around my body that, at bmi 21, was apparently open season.

I have never been obese, so I don't know what that feels like, but I imagine there's a lot said with people's eyes, even if they haven't the bollocks to open their mouths.

Ultimately I think unless you are close to the average in terms of weight, people feel entitled to an opinion on it.

THisbackwithavengeance · 04/12/2022 07:40

RampantIvy · 04/12/2022 07:23

Being told that you are skinny is definitely not a compliment. IME those who think it is tend to be overweight themselves.

I had years of being told I was skinny, and never in a nice way. Being flat chested was the bane of my life. DD has inherited my lack of curves and has put up with some nasty comments from the neanderthals at school.

I am still slim, but not skinny.

Indeed. Try being overweight if you want to know what really being insulted feels like!

These threads come up all the time and they descend into a how shit it is to be thin competition.

And then fat people like me come on and say come on guys everyone aspires to be thin so stop moaning.

I'll bore off now. Got to get up for work and it's raining!

Oblomov22 · 04/12/2022 07:39

Choconut:

"A lot of people would like to be considered skinny themselves and so consider it a compliment."

This is where people's view of weight is out of kilter. Maybe because so many are overweight in the uk we have a distorted view? But we shouldn't be aiming for skinny.

I don't want to be considered skinny. I don't see skinny as a positive thing. I don't think others should see it as positive. How is being underweight positive? We all should be aiming for healthy, slim, the correct weight.

Oblomov22 · 04/12/2022 07:34

For me, Athenen0ctua puts it perfectly:

"Skinny to me means underweight for build and height, a negative thing. Slim is a healthy weight."

Slim is the objective. Healthy.
Skinny is not a positive thing. It's underweight.

SuspiciousHedgehog · 04/12/2022 07:30

@THisbackwithavengeance

I wouldn't say insulted, though it can be insulting, depending who says what and how, can be demeaning, excluding, and downright nasty. Especially for kids and young people. It is a dreaded skit among teen boys.

Just because many want to be skinny doesn't erase that. Envy can drive some fucking disturbing behaviour

Oblomov22 · 04/12/2022 07:26

I don't think it's necessarily rude. She might be concerned, rightly so. Depends. What you might consider slim others might consider skinny or underweight.
I have a friend whose dd is underweight, she doesn't see it as an issue, I do.
Plus we are all different. For some the bmi scale doesn't always quite work, some question its legitimacy. It may say it's a healthy weight but for some it isn't. eg : I was the same weight for years. I lost 1/2 a stone from a busy job, all my family and friends were concerned. I am very small in height. I looked ill. I looked underweight. I thought so too. When I left that job and quickly put that 1/2 stone back on, to my normal weight of 15 years, we all agreed I looked best. But per the bmi it claimed that 1/2 stone less was still in the healthy band, but none of us agreed.

TomTraubertsBlues · 04/12/2022 07:25

Skinny is occasionally used negatively, but it isn't really an insulting term. People will order a "skinny latte", but an "obese latte" wouldn't sell, would it?

ElmoNeedsThePotty · 04/12/2022 07:23

SuspiciousHedgehog · 04/12/2022 07:19

Is your age and weight relevant to the reason for clinical attention at all @ElmoNeedsThePotty

That is weird, but I guess even healthcare professionals are not outside cultural influences. I feel smaller at this weight than I did when I was a chubby 19 year old.

Absolutely nothing to do with it whatsoever.

I've had/got gangrene in both hands (thus typing with voice activation) and all the steriods I am now on make me look far from frail😂

RampantIvy · 04/12/2022 07:23

Being told that you are skinny is definitely not a compliment. IME those who think it is tend to be overweight themselves.

I had years of being told I was skinny, and never in a nice way. Being flat chested was the bane of my life. DD has inherited my lack of curves and has put up with some nasty comments from the neanderthals at school.

I am still slim, but not skinny.

THisbackwithavengeance · 04/12/2022 07:20

Yes it's a big insult and you should go NC and divorce your DH to boot.

Let's stop the faux outrage guys.

You all know in your heart of hearts that skinny/thin/slim women do not get insulted.

SuspiciousHedgehog · 04/12/2022 07:19

Is your age and weight relevant to the reason for clinical attention at all @ElmoNeedsThePotty

That is weird, but I guess even healthcare professionals are not outside cultural influences. I feel smaller at this weight than I did when I was a chubby 19 year old.

ElmoNeedsThePotty · 04/12/2022 07:14

SuspiciousHedgehog · 04/12/2022 07:09

@ElmoNeedsThePotty that is shocking. HCPs should be able to recognise a healthy bmi.

Used to be skinny, before medication. Now middle size, slightly overweight. Absolutely zero comments on my size any more. Not everyone meant ill by it, but most did.

I know right?!

This was only last week and I can't stop thinking about it.

I wonder if it is an indication of just how many more overweight people HCP are seeing?

I'm more offended by the "frail" tbh, i'm only 52 and wear size 10-12 clothes.

Gardenerboo · 04/12/2022 07:14

@2bazookas I’m borrowing this! I get comments on my weight all the time (size 6/8).

This comment is short (easy to remember) and lighthearted. Perfect!

Ivyblu · 04/12/2022 07:14

Kanaloa · 04/12/2022 01:57

You’ve given an op with absolutely no context, so it’s impossible to say whether she was unreasonable or not. Did she affectionately say ‘oh I wish I was skinny like x!’ Did she respond to somebody else saying they wanted to lose weight with ‘ooh don’t get too skinny or you’ll look awful like x!’ Did she say ‘I’ve been a bit worried about you, you’ve suddenly lost a lot of weight in a short time and you look ever so skinny at the moment.’ Did she say ‘ooh you look tiny and skinny in those new jeans!’ Did she say ‘yuck look at that horrible skinny bitch?’

Either way it depends. No point just giving the bare bones facts and expecting anyone to be able to tell if she was reasonable or not.

True. OP knows her MIL and her character some are bolder than others.

But if her MIL was really insulting her I think OP would definitely had more to say. Even if her MIL is outspoken who would just go around slandering someone like that? OP has not stated they don't get along or this comment was said out of malice in an argument.

SuspiciousHedgehog · 04/12/2022 07:09

@ElmoNeedsThePotty that is shocking. HCPs should be able to recognise a healthy bmi.

Used to be skinny, before medication. Now middle size, slightly overweight. Absolutely zero comments on my size any more. Not everyone meant ill by it, but most did.

ElmoNeedsThePotty · 04/12/2022 06:56

I was genuinely shocked recently during a stay in hospital to see written on my notes....

"Thin, frail, lady"

I am 5.1 and 8 stone!

SuspiciousHedgehog · 04/12/2022 06:52

SuperSuperCold · 04/12/2022 01:55

If my mil called me skinny I'd give her a massive hug, love her forever and celebrate with a massive slice of chocolate cake! I dream of being called skinny!! .. maybe one day!

This is why I would ask MIL if it is good or bad. Not everyone uses 'skinny' as an insult. If she does, will be fun to let her dig a deeper hole

urbanbuddha · 04/12/2022 05:33

Skinny’s an insult or at the very least has negative connotations. In my experience it always comes from people who are overweight.