Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are some people really heavy or am I kidding myself?

295 replies

Ellessdee · 03/12/2022 13:07

I know I'm a bit overweight. I'm a solid size 12. I weighed myself and did my BMI out of curiosity and it's telling me I'm obese. Is BMI wildly inaccurate or am I in denial re my weight? I used to weight train and do have quite a bit of muscle but also a layer of fat on top! Anyway, trying to pose weight, just wondering if I should be worried!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Pascor · 06/12/2022 12:58

Sartre · 06/12/2022 12:39

I’m shocked you’re 5 ft 9 and obese as a size 12. A size 12 is the max size I can be before I’m tipped over into the overweight category, I’m 2 inches shorter than you. If I’m 14-16 then I’m overweight but to be obese I have to be a size 18+ and I’m shorter than you! Very weird.

It's neither weird nor shocking when you realise that she is not a size 12.

My SIL is a size 10 if you ask her. Although she does buy size 14s, she cuts the labels out and claims that they are either mis sized or she likes them looser. Reader, they are not loose. She's a 14.

Sartre · 06/12/2022 12:39

I’m shocked you’re 5 ft 9 and obese as a size 12. A size 12 is the max size I can be before I’m tipped over into the overweight category, I’m 2 inches shorter than you. If I’m 14-16 then I’m overweight but to be obese I have to be a size 18+ and I’m shorter than you! Very weird.

ReneBumsWombats · 06/12/2022 12:36

Pascor · 06/12/2022 12:23

She isn's a size 10 to 12, is the point.

Why not? Size inflation is a thing (albeit not because of "vanity" and a conspiracy to hide fatness) and obesity isn't defined by dress sizes.

Pascor · 06/12/2022 12:23

She isn's a size 10 to 12, is the point.

ReneBumsWombats · 06/12/2022 12:17

Pascor · 06/12/2022 11:58

I wasn't commenting on ther bra size specifically, but on the size 10 and BMI of 32.....and if she's got that BMI, I'm pretty sure the numbers before the HH are not 30!

This is the problem, so many people are deluded about size. They think BMI is inaccurate because they don't see themselves as overweight or obese, but they are whether they see it or not. They ramble about dress sizes, lie about sizing.....it's all delusion.

If she's a size 10 to 12 with HH boobs, her back is probably not very wide, even with a high BMI. Most women wear bras that are too big in the back.

BrioNotBiro · 06/12/2022 12:14

I've just read a fascinating book by a forensic pathologist, Richard Shepherd:
drrichardshepherd.com/portfolio-item/unnatural-causes

He mentions that over a working lifetime of doing post mortems it is very noticeable how much bigger the average person is now. There is a thicker layer of fat on most people that just wasn't there 40 odd years ago - not muscle or denser bones, just more fat.

PeloFondo · 06/12/2022 12:14

Pascor · 06/12/2022 11:58

I wasn't commenting on ther bra size specifically, but on the size 10 and BMI of 32.....and if she's got that BMI, I'm pretty sure the numbers before the HH are not 30!

This is the problem, so many people are deluded about size. They think BMI is inaccurate because they don't see themselves as overweight or obese, but they are whether they see it or not. They ramble about dress sizes, lie about sizing.....it's all delusion.

They could well be though
I've had a BMI of 35 before, at a 34 back size and size 16 bottom/18 top. At 16 stone I'm a size 16, basically my weight matches my size - so 14 stone I am a 14 and so on

Pascor · 06/12/2022 11:58

I wasn't commenting on ther bra size specifically, but on the size 10 and BMI of 32.....and if she's got that BMI, I'm pretty sure the numbers before the HH are not 30!

This is the problem, so many people are deluded about size. They think BMI is inaccurate because they don't see themselves as overweight or obese, but they are whether they see it or not. They ramble about dress sizes, lie about sizing.....it's all delusion.

LolaSmiles · 06/12/2022 11:36

Pascor
If someone uses the Boob or Bust approach rather than the high street M&S approach, the likelihood is they'll have a better fitting bra with a smaller band size and a bigger cup size. A lot of women are wearing a much too big back size and M&S/high street shops are terrible for fitting women in poorly fitting sister sizes.

Someone who is a size 10 could be a 30HH, but boobs in that size would only be around 4-5lbs (approximately 2lbs I breast I believe) so whilst it might tip the BMI into the obese category, they aren't big enough to argue against BMI as a perfectly reasonable measure for most typical people as even with 4-5lbs taken off a BMI of 32 wouldn't go down substantially enough to be in the healthy range.

Pascor · 06/12/2022 11:22

strivingtosucceed · 06/12/2022 00:05

This is me, i'm a 10/12 and i'm obese since my BMI is 32. I also have a HH bust 😂. There's just no way BMI makes sense if you have reasonable muscle mass or are a bit shorter or bustier than the average woman.

On what planet are you a size 10 to 12?

Sparklfairy · 06/12/2022 08:55

You can plug your numbers in here to get an idea of body fat percentage which I found quite helpful. Interestingly it's your neck measurement as well as your weight which makes the difference, and no one can cheat or argue with that really Grin

www.calculator.net/body-fat-calculator.html?ctype=standard

strivingtosucceed · 06/12/2022 00:05

WhoHasMovedMyBrain · 03/12/2022 13:11

I guess it depends on how tall you are. If you are very short you might wear a size 12 and be obese though it wouldn't be very common. So.you wear a different size lower body clothes? For example I used to wear a size 12 for ages for tops, shirts, etc even though for dresses and trousers I needed a size 16 because of my big bottom and thighs.

This is me, i'm a 10/12 and i'm obese since my BMI is 32. I also have a HH bust 😂. There's just no way BMI makes sense if you have reasonable muscle mass or are a bit shorter or bustier than the average woman.

lljkk · 05/12/2022 19:07

There are special BMI charts proposed for BIPOC. They don't say that BMI >= 30 is fine, though.

Are some people really heavy or am I kidding myself?
Chesneyhawkes1 · 05/12/2022 19:04

For most people BMI is fairly accurate.

But you always get people kidding themselves they've got the muscle mass of an Olympic bodybuilder, so it can't possibly be correct.

FoxtrotOscarFoxtrotOscar · 05/12/2022 18:58

Standing naked in front of a full length mirror will tell you enough.
As said further up, your waist should measure half your height.

LolaSmiles · 05/12/2022 18:50

pocketvenuss
Whereas I was a 6-8 pre children and wear an 8 now. I'm between one and a half and two stone heavier and my body measurements are 2inches bigger on my hips and waist.
My BMI always used to be the higher end of underweight to low end of healthy. Now it's the middle of healthy. Honestly I'm carrying more round my middle than I should for my height and could do with being more intentional with my exercise.

I'd say clothing sizes vary a lot more now and shops craft their sizing charts and their garments to fit their target audience so some shops run small and others are very generous.

pocketvenuss · 05/12/2022 17:27

I was a small size 8, 25 years ago. My teen daughter is a size 8 now. She fits my old clothes. On that basis, the clothes sizes haven't changed

Kanaloa · 05/12/2022 17:25

Buckland123 · 05/12/2022 15:37

I think a lot of us who grew up in the 80s/90s still have in our heads that sizes 8/10/12 are ‘small’ sizes - because they were in the olden days! But now a 12 is definitely not that small.
Im pretty much exactly the same size and weight I was at 20 (& I’m now almost 50) and have gone from wearing a size 12 to an 8/extra small - there is nothing extra small about me. Back in the 90s I always felt quite hefty (I’m 5’10, just over 10 stone) but now I am definitely thinner than most people I know.
everyone has got fatter in the UK basically. And clothes have got massive. Look at old tv programmes (when they show the old top of the pops, everyone was so thin!) Most people these days would look massive if we were transported back to 1985.

Where do you buy your clothes that you wear a size 8 at just over 10 stone? I think this is why quoting clothes sizes is so unhelpful. A size 8 would technically ‘fit’ a range of bodies, but it won’t be the right fit for every body.

I don’t agree that all clothes are ‘massive’ but then at just over 10 stone I wouldn’t be in a size 8, so maybe it’s wherever you are shopping.

UmbrellaLegs · 05/12/2022 16:42

Oakbeam · 05/12/2022 15:01

If you use the NHS website it makes allowances for different ethnicities, although at base level I agree there hasn't been enough research on those ethnicities in the first place.

The NHS website is trying to be all things to all people. If you travel to countries with different predominant ethnicity proportions the BMI ranges will be a shock for the average Briton.

In Singapore, for example, it’s a lot easier to be obese…

www.healthhub.sg/programmes/93/bmi-calculator

I remember looking at the bras in a Singapore department store and they were miniature.

ReneBumsWombats · 05/12/2022 15:41

I still wouldn't want to go back to the 90s. Heroin chic, waif look, Minimiser bras because God forbid you have boobs, eating disorders everywhere...and at the end of the day, it didn't cause us all to get slimmer as time went on, did it?

Buckland123 · 05/12/2022 15:37

I think a lot of us who grew up in the 80s/90s still have in our heads that sizes 8/10/12 are ‘small’ sizes - because they were in the olden days! But now a 12 is definitely not that small.
Im pretty much exactly the same size and weight I was at 20 (& I’m now almost 50) and have gone from wearing a size 12 to an 8/extra small - there is nothing extra small about me. Back in the 90s I always felt quite hefty (I’m 5’10, just over 10 stone) but now I am definitely thinner than most people I know.
everyone has got fatter in the UK basically. And clothes have got massive. Look at old tv programmes (when they show the old top of the pops, everyone was so thin!) Most people these days would look massive if we were transported back to 1985.

Pascor · 05/12/2022 15:16

HouseBuyingNovice2022 · 05/12/2022 13:30

My main point is simply that weight is not a reliable indicator of size and, unless OP uses certain words to describe herself in a particular way, it is not for you to draw unreliable conclusions and present them alongside disparaging and unhelpful (and potentially damaging) commentary. OP is welcome to correct me if I have misunderstood but I do not interpret OP’s starting post as an invitation for that.

Weight plus height is a good indicator of size, hence why BMI does in fact work.

As for OP's invitation, she asked was she kidding herself...she is. Also, that's not how AIBU works. You don't get only the answers you want.

Onegingerhead · 05/12/2022 15:07

BMI is fairly accurate for most of the people. It doesn't work well for certain athletes and definitely not bodybuilders.
I'm size 12 and 5'10''. In the overweight category if you look at BMI and yes, I have fat I shouldn't really have

Oakbeam · 05/12/2022 15:01

If you use the NHS website it makes allowances for different ethnicities, although at base level I agree there hasn't been enough research on those ethnicities in the first place.

The NHS website is trying to be all things to all people. If you travel to countries with different predominant ethnicity proportions the BMI ranges will be a shock for the average Briton.

In Singapore, for example, it’s a lot easier to be obese…

www.healthhub.sg/programmes/93/bmi-calculator

ehb102 · 05/12/2022 14:08

Look at body fat percentage if you want a decent number to work with.