Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are some people really heavy or am I kidding myself?

295 replies

Ellessdee · 03/12/2022 13:07

I know I'm a bit overweight. I'm a solid size 12. I weighed myself and did my BMI out of curiosity and it's telling me I'm obese. Is BMI wildly inaccurate or am I in denial re my weight? I used to weight train and do have quite a bit of muscle but also a layer of fat on top! Anyway, trying to pose weight, just wondering if I should be worried!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
OverCCCs · 03/12/2022 13:29

Sadly, I think our perceptions of even what “obese” looks like have shifted. It’s very likely that amongst the current population you don’t see yourself as such an outlier as to earn that negative designator, but if you were to travel back in time to the 1960s or 70s, say, you’d possibly stand out as far larger a person than most people commonly encountered.

Hattie72 · 03/12/2022 13:25

I think it’s a good guide, but also individual. I am very slim and a size 8 at the top of my BMI and no one would say I was overweight. I could not go down to let’s say a BMI of 21 or 22 unless I stopped eating and I would look extremely skinny.

Kabalagala · 03/12/2022 13:24

I'm a size 12/14 and just tipped back over from obese to overweight.
Although bmi is flawed, I think we've all lost touch with what a healthy weight really is unfortunately

EdithWeston · 03/12/2022 13:24

BMI is ridiculously inaccurate. It does not take into account muscle mass, activity levels, genetics, ethnicity, age, fat distribution

Yes it does, that's why it's a range that spans about 40lbs (that's nearly 3 stone)

It's not terribly good for certain categories of elite sportspeople, and those in a few particularly physical occupations (eg some military roles), but most people simply aren't in those groups.

Clothes sizing never recovered from the vanity sizing boom of the 1980s and 90s - that wasn't a revalorisation based on population evidence, it was marketing. And an 80s 12 (which we still think of as 'normal') is about an 8 today. Today's 12 is a 16 or 18 then.

So the issue is with sizing and perceptions of that sizing

Ellessdee · 03/12/2022 13:21

Guitarbar · 03/12/2022 13:15

BMI isn't perfect and doesn't account for natural differences, but generally those who say my bmi says I'm obese but I'm not overweight are in denial. Excess muscle also puts a strain on your body so the it's muscle argument misses the point a bit (albeit it's healthier than having lots of excess fat). As we become bigger on a population level and the idea of what a normal/idea weight has shifted quite considerably so its not surprising some prefer to Bury their heads in the sand

Never said I'm not overweight though. I'm not a bodybuilder or anything and wouldn't say I have enough muscle to put physical strain on my body. I just didn't know you could be obese at size 12. Wake up call maybe.

OP posts:
PeloFondo · 03/12/2022 13:20

I'm heavy (yes I'm overweight, and I know that) but I'm broad. As in my shoulders are wide, big feet/wrists/hands

SheWoreYellow · 03/12/2022 13:16

There’s this but it doesn’t take height into account, which makes no sense to me. The other way of doing it is to say it should be half height. So you’d be ok up to 34.5”.

extras.bhf.org.uk/patientinfo/waist-measurement_v1.0/app/

Guitarbar · 03/12/2022 13:15

BMI isn't perfect and doesn't account for natural differences, but generally those who say my bmi says I'm obese but I'm not overweight are in denial. Excess muscle also puts a strain on your body so the it's muscle argument misses the point a bit (albeit it's healthier than having lots of excess fat). As we become bigger on a population level and the idea of what a normal/idea weight has shifted quite considerably so its not surprising some prefer to Bury their heads in the sand

M0rT · 03/12/2022 13:14

I'm in Ireland and the public health messaging switched to waist circumference and waist to hip ratio about 10 years ago.
Apparently that has more of an impact on health than BMI.
They gave away free measuring tapes for a while which are very handy for online ordering!
Maybe google that and see where you are with it?

NameIsBryceQuinlan · 03/12/2022 13:14

I've always been quite heavy, even when I had a 26 inch waist and size 8-10 which at nearly 5ft 9 I didn't feel big at all, I was top of healthy BMI almost in overweight category. I normally hover around 25/26 BMI. I think your measurements can be helpful as it shows where you store excess fat/weight/muscle

Ellessdee · 03/12/2022 13:13

WhoHasMovedMyBrain · 03/12/2022 13:11

I guess it depends on how tall you are. If you are very short you might wear a size 12 and be obese though it wouldn't be very common. So.you wear a different size lower body clothes? For example I used to wear a size 12 for ages for tops, shirts, etc even though for dresses and trousers I needed a size 16 because of my big bottom and thighs.

I'm 5ft 9 so quite tall. I wear size 12 all over.

OP posts:
SheWoreYellow · 03/12/2022 13:13

Obese at a size 12 does sound surprising. Maybe work out the waist ratio instead.

Ellessdee · 03/12/2022 13:12

SoonToBeSwedeyMummy · 03/12/2022 13:11

BMI is ridiculously inaccurate. It does not take into account muscle mass, activity levels, genetics, ethnicity, age, fat distribution.

It's a very blunt tool for something that's very individual.

It's not unusual for athletes in peak condition to be told they're obese or women with small frames being told they are overweight and need to lose a few pounds which would make them skeletal.

So in short, pay no heed to it.

I'm 31 and black African. Gave me a bit of a shock for sure!

OP posts:
Ellessdee · 03/12/2022 13:11

SheWoreYellow · 03/12/2022 13:10

Your waist to height ratio is more important as a health measure. People will say BMI is useless, but it’s reasonable for the vast majority of people I’m afraid.
I think we just get used to everyone being a bit squishier and also vanity sizing.

I definitely am overweight. I'm trying to lose it and managed 2lbs this week. Just didn't know I was THAT overweight.

OP posts:
Ellessdee · 03/12/2022 13:11

SheWoreYellow · 03/12/2022 13:10

Your waist to height ratio is more important as a health measure. People will say BMI is useless, but it’s reasonable for the vast majority of people I’m afraid.
I think we just get used to everyone being a bit squishier and also vanity sizing.

I definitely am overweight. I'm trying to lose it and managed 2lbs this week. Just didn't know I was THAT overweight.

OP posts:
WhoHasMovedMyBrain · 03/12/2022 13:11

I guess it depends on how tall you are. If you are very short you might wear a size 12 and be obese though it wouldn't be very common. So.you wear a different size lower body clothes? For example I used to wear a size 12 for ages for tops, shirts, etc even though for dresses and trousers I needed a size 16 because of my big bottom and thighs.

SoonToBeSwedeyMummy · 03/12/2022 13:11

BMI is ridiculously inaccurate. It does not take into account muscle mass, activity levels, genetics, ethnicity, age, fat distribution.

It's a very blunt tool for something that's very individual.

It's not unusual for athletes in peak condition to be told they're obese or women with small frames being told they are overweight and need to lose a few pounds which would make them skeletal.

So in short, pay no heed to it.

SheWoreYellow · 03/12/2022 13:10

Your waist to height ratio is more important as a health measure. People will say BMI is useless, but it’s reasonable for the vast majority of people I’m afraid.
I think we just get used to everyone being a bit squishier and also vanity sizing.

SallyLovesCheese · 03/12/2022 13:09

BMI doesn't take into account all manner of differences, including muscle mass, bone density, age, race etc.

Ellessdee · 03/12/2022 13:09

Ellessdee · 03/12/2022 13:07

I know I'm a bit overweight. I'm a solid size 12. I weighed myself and did my BMI out of curiosity and it's telling me I'm obese. Is BMI wildly inaccurate or am I in denial re my weight? I used to weight train and do have quite a bit of muscle but also a layer of fat on top! Anyway, trying to pose weight, just wondering if I should be worried!

*lose

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread