Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are some people really heavy or am I kidding myself?

295 replies

Ellessdee · 03/12/2022 13:07

I know I'm a bit overweight. I'm a solid size 12. I weighed myself and did my BMI out of curiosity and it's telling me I'm obese. Is BMI wildly inaccurate or am I in denial re my weight? I used to weight train and do have quite a bit of muscle but also a layer of fat on top! Anyway, trying to pose weight, just wondering if I should be worried!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
WhoopItUp · 03/12/2022 14:40

NameIsBryceQuinlan · 03/12/2022 14:38

I was briefly obese BMI after I had my son, I was 14.6 st and a large size 16 at 5ft 9. To be a size 12 I weigh 11st 6 ish

Yes, same!

Giraffesandbottoms · 03/12/2022 14:40

BMI is certainly more accurate than clothes sizing, which are meaningless today.

most people are fat. Most people are in denial

WhoopItUp · 03/12/2022 14:39

SheWoreYellow · 03/12/2022 14:33

Using the NHS bmi calculator, to be obese at 5’9” the weight needs to be 14 stone and 7 lbs.
OP does that sound like you’ve typed it all in correctly?

I’m amazed that someone would be a size 12 at that height and weight. I’m 5’9’’ and at 14 st 7lbs I’m a good size 16. I know people are different shapes but even so, that doesn’t sound like a 12.

NameIsBryceQuinlan · 03/12/2022 14:38

I was briefly obese BMI after I had my son, I was 14.6 st and a large size 16 at 5ft 9. To be a size 12 I weigh 11st 6 ish

SheWoreYellow · 03/12/2022 14:33

WhoopItUp · 03/12/2022 14:16

How much do you actually weigh OP?

Using the NHS bmi calculator, to be obese at 5’9” the weight needs to be 14 stone and 7 lbs.
OP does that sound like you’ve typed it all in correctly?

Cheesuswithallama · 03/12/2022 14:32

Agree, dress size is not accurate. A-they vary, b- when i put on weight I was adamant I was still x size. Yeah, I could "fit" it... But... I was size bigger frankly. Some clothes grows with you.

Bmi is one of the tools. Not a single one tool. Usually accurate

onlytea · 03/12/2022 14:31

Nah, it's just my brother.

diamondpony80 · 03/12/2022 14:28

I’m 5’9 and obese at size 16. At size 12 I’m normal weight according to BMI. I have very little muscle though

lljkk · 03/12/2022 14:27

I'm in the camp (feels alone on MN) that thinks BMI is pretty damn starkly honest & mostly correct in what it suggests about whether a body is overweight or obese or too small.

I find MN obsession with clothes sizes meaning something useful, somewhere between bewildering & amusing. You said your height, so tell us your bust-waist-hips. But what really matters is how comfortable you are in your own body to do things you'd like to do. If anything about your size, stamina, strength or energy levels is interfering with your quality of life, then you might want to think about what you want to do to improve that.

rubydoobydoo · 03/12/2022 14:23

OP you are quite tall so I wouldn't think you'd be in the obese category at a size 12. So there could be some muscle at play here!

Ihavedogs · 03/12/2022 14:20

Using BMI for my height there is a 2 stone and 11 lb weight range for a normal weight. Whilst BMI may be a bit of blunt tool, it gives a good indication if weight is within the normal range for the majority of the population.

Height to waist ratio can also be used, but won’t tell you as to how under or overweight you are.

Notimeforaname · 03/12/2022 14:20

Telling people that BMI is useless and its not to be paid attention to at all, is very bad advice.

People will say BMI is useless, but it’s reasonable for the vast majority of people I’m afraid This is the truth

WhoopItUp · 03/12/2022 14:16

How much do you actually weigh OP?

Kanaloa · 03/12/2022 14:14

mamabear715 · 03/12/2022 14:00

Bloodyhell.. I'm size 18 & thought I was fairly normal.. :-0

I mean, what do you mean by normal? Because you are normal - lots of people are very overweight, which means it is normal. Unfortunately though, normal doesn’t mean a healthy weight. So you’re both normal (as in fit in with others) and quite overweight.

I have gained a bit of weight recently - I think if most of us who realise we’re overweight are honest with ourselves we don’t need to check BMI to know we need to lose a bit. But at least (I’ve been comforting myself with this) op has realised it before she is very very overweight and it’s much more of a challenge to lose. I think this is where people can fall - saying oh but I’m only a tiny bit overweight so it’s ok, it’s not like I’m obese etc.

mamabear715 · 03/12/2022 14:00

Bloodyhell.. I'm size 18 & thought I was fairly normal.. :-0

sunnydaytoday0 · 03/12/2022 13:58

Have you done a height to waist ratio measurement?

Some people who have a normal BMI but have lots of fat deposited around the middle will come out with a poor H-W ratio and therefore at higher risk of certain health conditions. Those have a worse BMI but due to having a body composition with much more muscle mass are more likely to have a healthy H-W ratio.

FatimaHatima · 03/12/2022 13:44

SoonToBeSwedeyMummy · 03/12/2022 13:11

BMI is ridiculously inaccurate. It does not take into account muscle mass, activity levels, genetics, ethnicity, age, fat distribution.

It's a very blunt tool for something that's very individual.

It's not unusual for athletes in peak condition to be told they're obese or women with small frames being told they are overweight and need to lose a few pounds which would make them skeletal.

So in short, pay no heed to it.

This is what people say when BMI tells them they''re overweight...ooh, its inaccurate for elite athletes and bodybuilder...yeah well guess what, you're neither, but you are way chonkier than you thought.

BMI is fairly blunt but its pretty accurate for the vast majority of people. If your BMi says you're obese, no way will losing a few pounds will make you skeletal, I don't care how small you think your frame is!

Sarahcoggles · 03/12/2022 13:42

SilverGlitterBaubles · 03/12/2022 13:40

I am not sure dress size is an accurate measure as sizing varies so much from store to store and vanity sizing means that size 12 today is not the same as size 12 10-15 years ago.

I agree.
Dress sizes are so variable.
I have in my wardrobe clothes ranging from size 8 to size 20, all of which fit me!

Octomingo · 03/12/2022 13:41

I've had to go and check my bmi now. I don't actually know my weight, although it tends to be between 68 and 70kg or 10.8 and 11. If I can see my hip bones, I'm near 10.8.
I tried both weights and came out 22 or 22.8. Bang in the healthy range. That was the NHS one.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 03/12/2022 13:40

I am not sure dress size is an accurate measure as sizing varies so much from store to store and vanity sizing means that size 12 today is not the same as size 12 10-15 years ago.

Googlecanthelpme · 03/12/2022 13:37

BMI is kind of outdated a bit shit as others have stated. However it can give an indication of ranges IF your body type is what we’d say is typical / average.
A typical person does not have 20lb extra lbs of lean mass nor extremely high activity levels.

If a typical person says overweight or obese on bmi then the chances are they are outside of their ideal weight.

Obese at a size 12 doesn’t sound right but it really depends - a Topshop size 12 is very different to a m&s size 12.
Size 12 tailored trousers from Zara is different to a size 12 jumper from Asda.

Waist circumference is a good one to measure. A size 12 would expect you to be 29/30 inches on the waist. Perhaps check that one - you might find it’s crept up? So you’re thinking size 12 but actually more like 34?

At the gym last week a lady told me she was weighing in that day and hoping to be at 11 stone. I (currently) weight about half a stone more than her but you definitely wouldn’t think of it to look at us. She is “bigger” than me. I was surprised tbh.

You can absolutely have too
high fat % at a size 12, definitely. Especially visceral fat.

Well done for addressing something you don’t feel happy with OP, even if you ignore the BMI, you will know in yourself whether your fat levels have got too high or not!

Octomingo · 03/12/2022 13:36

You're the same height and dress size as me op. I'm never in the obese category. Usually in the middle. Waist 28 inches. Lower stomach around the size of half a grapefruit.I'm generally seen as slim.

IShouldBeSoLurky · 03/12/2022 13:32

As others have said BMI is a good guide for all but a few real outliers. It always makes me roll my eyes when people go ‘oh but muscle’ etc. I’m quite tall and very broad shouldered with big hands and feet. I lift weights and am carrying a LOT of muscle and my BMI is below 20.

Ansjovis · 03/12/2022 13:32

In June of this year I had a BMI of 27.3, so very firmly in the overweight range. I had the same reaction as you - I'm a size 10/12, how can I possibly be overweight? Fast forward to today, I have now lost 2 stone and feel so much better for it. I have more energy, my hair and skin have both improved and I'm performing much better in the gym. If you'd said all of this to me in June I would have told you it wasn't possible because I was perfectly healthy as I was. From my research BMI is generally a good indicator unless you are literally a professional athlete, in which case a false result is possible.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 03/12/2022 13:30

63% of UK adults are overweight or obese. It's not hard to slip into the next category.

What most people think of when they hear 'obese' is actually 'morbidly obese' which is a further category.

Also BMI isn't a great indicator. I'm a size 8-10 and at the very top end of a healhh the y weight according to BMI.