Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP won't help with nursery bills

409 replies

Sarahlll · 03/12/2022 12:51

I'm due to go back to work in the new year after maternity leave and my DP of 4 years has just told me that he doesn't see why he should help pay the nursery fees as it's my decision to return to work. AIBU in thinking that this is incredibly unfair?

OP posts:
PorpoiseWithPurpose · 03/12/2022 18:18

Surely you discussed the finances before deciding to have a child together?

I don’t know how you can decide to have a child with a man without having this discussion first.

It’s infuriating and seems to happen time and time and time and time again on Mumsnet.

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 03/12/2022 18:17

Do not stay at home with a partner with these views

Or depending whether this is just a blind spot with this man and you can get it sorted and changed, or whether it's a pattern, maybe consider this:

Do not stay at home with a THIS partner

If you do stay at home or work reduced hours or work in a less well paid job to accommodate his full time work and career, including backdating this across the maternity leave, he should be levelling it up so that your pension, savings, benefit from property versus notional half contribution, and 'fun money', is commensurate with his. No excuses.

But I agree that it should all be out of theoretically a joint pot, even if 'the pot' lives in number ofseparate bank acocunts. You've got time, protect yourself for if you stay with him so you don't realised you have been shafted later and so you can leave if you want to.

I was at a meeting the other day, and the other thing is to make sure that your partner nominates you as the beneficiary of any pension, or life insurance that comes with his job or is arranged personally. Although you can't know or control if they lie, so always take care of yourself as well.

OhChristmasTreeOhChristmasTreeFaLaLa · 03/12/2022 18:15

Oh look yet another woman on mumsnet having a baby with her boyfriend who acts like the baby is the girlfriend's sole responsibility 🙄. Surely you discussed the finances before deciding to have a child together? The child is as much his child as yours, why on earth would he view childcare costs as yours alone?

I highly doubt this relationship will last, return to work and look after your finances, if he doesn't want to pay dump him and claim child maintenance.

Slv199 · 03/12/2022 18:14

Tell him that’s fine but you’ll expect him to quit his job to look after the baby as it’s his baby too.

Why do men do this sort of thing? I’ve got nothing but grief for going back to work. I do pretty much every drop off and pick up. It’s me that goes to all school events and me who takes time off when they are ill.

I think I only know one family who share everything equally. Both parents only work 4 days a week.

PorpoiseWithPurpose · 03/12/2022 18:14

Why are there so many women in this position and questioning if they’re being unreasonable? Of course you aren’t! I can’t believe it’s even a question!!!

this must be the 10th thread in a week.

Can I ask why you’ve made the ENORMOUs life-altering decision of having a child with this man…. But clearly had zero discussions about how this would work financially?

thankfully, you sound like the one rare occasion where being unmarried may actually work in your favour.

Hellno44 · 03/12/2022 18:11

What a wanker. He isn't acting like a partner or a parent. I would LTB. Save yourself years of financial abuse.

Ponderingwindow · 03/12/2022 18:10

You have been providing free child care and continuing to pay “your share” of the bills. He is stealing from you!! You have been subsidizing his lifestyle since you got pregnant (that is when your child related expenses began).

it’s not surprising he thinks that you will continue to hand over your money to him.

you can not trust this man by being anything less than a full time worker. Don’t agree to find a job that work around his shifts because that will impact your earning power. You need to maximize your lifetime career earnings. If he won’t pay nursery fees directly, withhold his portion from your contribution to other bills.

but really, this should be a dealbreaker. If he won’t change today, he needs to go.

slowquickstep · 03/12/2022 18:10

He see's the baby as your responsibility, so in his eyes you pay for childcare and you do the majority of caring for the child. Before you decided to have this baby did you sit and talk about care and financial costs ?

CurlyhairedAssassin · 03/12/2022 18:07

I'm don't understand. Is he REALLY expecting for you to go back to work, pay all the mortgage AND all the nursery fees? This sounds like it was an unequal relationship from the start. I really wish women would think about what they're doing when they choose to have children with men who don't want to be in a proper partnership with them. And vice versa.

You have a situation where you have a man living in your house which you pay for and own (and he doesn't have any part of), you and he share the other bills yet he doesn't want to contribute towards nursery fees. So he's basically a lodger and sperm donor who does a bit of childcare now and again, like a friendly uncle. Maybe that's what he feels like too. It just doesn't sound like this is a real grown up relationship all round really.

Is there a reason why the house is not jointly owned and paid for jointly? Is there a reason why you are not married? They're both red flags to me, when there is a child in the picture.

Just to compare to my experience. DH and I bought our first property together after we got engaged and were married soon after. He earned a lot more than me and so paid ALL the mortgage, but we BOTH were named as owners of the house. We shared the bills. When we had children, we had just moved to a different area and I was between jobs so we decided TOGETHER that I would stay home for a couple of years and not only would he continue paying all the mortgage but all the bills too. He recognised that I was providing childcare for the children that otherwise we'd have to pay for, and I recognised that he was paying for our housing and bills costs to enable me to stay with the children.

When I went back to work PT (didn't earn a lot), we did discuss childcare and basically saw all our money as part of a family pot. He STILL continued to pay ALL the mortgage and ALL the bills, I paid for childcare (not much, top up after the free 15 hours), and all our "extras", like holidays and days out etc.

As a consequence, when I came into a large inheritance a few years back, I had no qualms about paying the rest of the mortgage off, buying him a car, paying for nice family holidays etc, and he STILL pays nearly all our bills. I pay towards the kids' uni expenses and will also think nothing of supporting us both if he wants to retire a few years early.

I'm just illustrating that there are many ways to organise family finances, but the most important thing is that you agree these things together and you work as a team, have each other's back, providing for each other as circumstances change. You aren't working like that at the moment. Figure out if you both want to, and how you're going to do it fairly. Personally if you really love and value with each other I'd start with figuring out why you aren't married and why you don't own the house JOINTLY as equal partners.

Murdoch1949 · 03/12/2022 18:06

Blimey, that's shocking. It's obviously a joint expense, and if he earns more he should pay more. You need to have a good think about this, as he's being a major prick and it could be a red flag for the future.

OutFortheBirds · 03/12/2022 18:05

@Sarahlll I haven’t had the chance read through the whole lot, but you know yourself this is not equal. Care of the child is 50%. It’s worrying that thinks the way he does tbh.

Let him know you’re time for being a SAHM for free has finished, and he can now be the SAHD, and if not: pay.

Create10 · 03/12/2022 18:05

Is he taking the fucking piss?

What does he say when you say he can give up work?

Soothsayer1 · 03/12/2022 18:00

I think the fair way to handle that is to evaluate how much of her mortgage payment goes towards equity and how much towards interest, insurance, etc (whatever isn't being built up as equity). And then come up with some way to ensure that their mutual financial input is treated fairly
That does seem worth exploring, but is this a man who will have an open and honest conversation about what is fair? Or will he try to keep to his 'I'll do as I please and you'll do as your told' way of doing things?

Quiegal · 03/12/2022 17:59

@Sarahlll

Sounds like he doesn't want you to have your independence back. Seems to be implying you don't need to work.

He is being unfair and is financially abusing you.

He probably thought having that child you be sitting at home while he works. No you need to work too.

Dinosaurpoopy · 03/12/2022 17:52

This has shocked me, I'll be paying nursery fees yes but DH pays every single other household bill so we worked it this way as I'll actually be better off?

What a sorry excuse for a dad, sending hugs OP

aloris · 03/12/2022 17:51

"I wonder if his refusal to parent his own child is actually him sulking because OP has more that he thinks she should, her own house, a good pension etc?"

It's possible that he feels it's unfair that some of her input is going toward her mortgage which builds up as equity for her. I think the fair way to handle that is to evaluate how much of her mortgage payment goes towards equity and how much towards interest, insurance, etc (whatever isn't being built up as equity). And then come up with some way to ensure that their mutual financial input is treated fairly.

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 17:45

If I was in your (or his) position, I would be looking at it (mostly) from a financial perspective. Is you staying at home costing the household more than you going back to work and paying nursery fees? I would have thought that, even after taking the fees out, you'll be seeing more money that way.

Plus, as I'm sure has been pointed out already, it's not just about the money. There's career progression to think of, as well as your sanity...

Soothsayer1 · 03/12/2022 17:37

I wonder if his refusal to parent his own child is actually him sulking because OP has more that he thinks she should, her own house, a good pension etc?

arethereanyleftatall · 03/12/2022 17:35

As a slight tangent, a few posters have assumed the father has a job with a high salary. He has also shown himself to be incredibly short of thinking. If people think it's possible that a man can be both this dumb, and in the higher tax bracket; this really shows what advantages men have in the work place. It infuriates me that I know so many super intelligent women on NMW, and then, this.

JustLyra · 03/12/2022 17:28

Vinylloving · 03/12/2022 17:03

I can't fathom these threads. You have a child together, when you return to work the fees are a household bill - they don't come out of one salary or the other. If he thinks you shouldn't work, you need to discuss with him: will you get married so you're protected, will his salary pay for a private pension for you to make up for lost pension payments, does his work have the potential to look after you both and make up for your lost career progression prospect if you agree you won't work while your baby needs childcare. If he doesn't plan it with you properly, leave him and seek child support formally to cover shared childcare costs while you both work

Marriage is the last thing the OP should be considering right now.

The house and mortgage is hers and he’s shown he’s an arsehole. That’s her protection.

RealBecca · 03/12/2022 17:28

Convenient of him to mention this now rather than at any other point of your maternity. seems like he was planning this the whole time

vdbfamily · 03/12/2022 17:27

Ideally, you could both work compressed hours and manage some of the childcare between you and then share the rest of the bill.

vdbfamily · 03/12/2022 17:26

I have only read your connects so this may have been said but his argument goes both ways.
If he gives up his job to be a SAHD, there will be no nursery fees either. Maybe you should suggest that. The child is both of yours, ideally any income and outgoings should be totally shared. Share finances become very difficult at times like this.

Soothsayer1 · 03/12/2022 17:26

His long term plan may be to maneuver you out of your job, persuade you to have another child then propose, so that he can have a claim on your assets
I say he's a grifter, but luckily not smart enough to cover up those red flags so it shouldn't be hard to out-maneuver him!

arethereanyleftatall · 03/12/2022 17:23

A healthy good relationship between two parents...

  1. As soon as one party goes off to look after a joint baby, all money becomes joint, (either joint account or not but the point is the understanding is that it's now shared). Both understand that you are both contributing - just one is doing an unpaid role, therefore obviously, the paid role needs to divvied up.
  1. When mat leave is up, a joint decision is made by the two of you with regard to how you proceed. If one gives up work to look after the joint baby, then obviously the other one needs to take over all costs, including a pension for the sahp, f they have one, savings if they have savings, disposable income if they have etc alll shared. If no one wants to give up work, that is fine, and Both parties must equally divide chores/childcare and costs become either a joint account or equal % of salaries.
Swipe left for the next trending thread