Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP won't help with nursery bills

409 replies

Sarahlll · 03/12/2022 12:51

I'm due to go back to work in the new year after maternity leave and my DP of 4 years has just told me that he doesn't see why he should help pay the nursery fees as it's my decision to return to work. AIBU in thinking that this is incredibly unfair?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Soothsayer1 · 04/12/2022 16:29

After a year of trying to negotiate, I gave up, went back to work, found a flat, moved out, found a lovely childminder and took ds with me. Ex was enraged, not because he couldn't see DS every evening but because I had left him without a housekeeper
Nice work!
the more women refuse to accept this treatment the more men will see it's not going to work for them and they wont go down those routes. Your ex may not be able to get past his fury but some of his friends will see what's really happening here, gradually word will spread that women are not to be messed with

Dixiechickonhols · 04/12/2022 08:16

lalala1234 · 04/12/2022 07:29

I think this is the best solution.

This is what I do with my partner (although not because he refuses to pay for nursery). But it just comes straight out of my account and then I transfer whatever is left of my share if the bills/whatever is affordable.

The house is in her name though. If he starts paying mortgage he may be able to claim a beneficial interest. It’s complex but at the minute she’s fine house in her name and she’s paid mortgage from her account so he can’t claim he’s just a lodger and she can throw him out today.
If he starts paying mortgage it muddies water and he could threaten a claim or possibly try to claim. Also if he doesn’t pay mortgage it’s her responsibility to pay and her credit etc ruined.

lalala1234 · 04/12/2022 07:29

honeylulu · 03/12/2022 12:58

Reduce your contribution to the bills and mortgage by the cost of nursery (and make sure the proportion is in line with your respective earnings).The effect will still be the same - proportionately shared joint expenses. He can gripe about it but tough. If he's going to be an arse about the expenses associated with your JOINT child, then he deserves a taste of his own medicine.

I think this is the best solution.

This is what I do with my partner (although not because he refuses to pay for nursery). But it just comes straight out of my account and then I transfer whatever is left of my share if the bills/whatever is affordable.

DontSpeakLatinInFrontOfTheBooks · 04/12/2022 06:39

Honestly? He’s not willing to parent equally and fairly or be a team player with you then I’d be ending this relationship. But that’s probably because I have the benefit of hindsight and wish I’d dumped my ex for a having a similar attitude years before I actually left him.

If you do stay (no judgment from me; it’s practically not easy to just up and leave just like that for most) watch out for warning signs of coercive control.

SuspiciousHedgehog · 04/12/2022 06:38

OP
You haven't really gone into how the rest of the relationship is, or how you feel about your partner generally. So I'm going to assume you were relatively happy at this point.

I would, as coldly and business-like as possible, do the sums on your finances without him, including the child maintenance he will be obligated to pay.

Show him these figures. Explain that he would have the option of being a weekend or 50/50 parent but would be obliged to cover all the child's expenses during this time.

Make it clear that you 100% expected to return to your FT job, he agreed. Be clear that if he sabotages that goal, you have no choice but to evict him, as this is a very important agreement to you, a deal breaker. You expect him to be a fully invested parent, otherwise you may as well do it alone.

I realise the above is a big risk, but I think it's in your interests.

His response to this move will tell you all you need to know. He will either roll over, explain him position better in an attempt to negotiate, but still roll over, or leave, with or without extended arguments.

Sceptre86 · 04/12/2022 06:33

This should have been discussed prior to having a child. To me it is a red flag and says a lot about what he thinks of you. My dh paid the nursery bill whenever I went back to work, he was full time and I part time so it made sense. He also applied for flexible working so he could wfh and do nursery pick ups and drop offs more easily. With our 3rd child he has compressed his hours to have a weekday off so he can have baby and be here for our two primary school aged kids. He recognises we are a team though and does whatever he can to support us as a family. We each play our part.

StClare101 · 04/12/2022 03:39

The house is in your name? Kick him out and mean it. He doesn’t want to pay for his kid and he doesn’t want to look after his kid. Easy decision to make.

Billybear1 · 04/12/2022 03:18

Looke like OP is not comming back.

MintJulia · 04/12/2022 02:59

My ex started out refusing to pay half. His argument was that I didn't need to return to work, he paid the bills and 'my job was to keep house and look after ds'.

After a year of trying to negotiate, I gave up, went back to work, found a flat, moved out, found a lovely childminder and took ds with me. Ex was enraged, not because he couldn't see DS every evening but because I had left him without a housekeeper.

He tried to starve us back until I suggested going via CMS instead (he's a high earner). He finally paid up but with as much ill will as possible.

Some men are bizarre. They secretly think it's still 1950.

Slv199 · 04/12/2022 01:41

@deeperthanallroses aw thanks. Currently attempting to get divorced. Though he’s refusing to move out. DD just told me he said it’s better for her and DS if we all live together.

Heavyraindropsarefallingonmyhead · 04/12/2022 00:22

Why do men do this sort of thing?

I think the vast majority of them who do shit like this are fully prepared to risk losing their children and are gambling on the fact the vast majority of women are not

The OP could call her partners bluff by saying that if he doesn't pay half for childcare she will walk out and let him sort out the entirety of childcare and she will have their child one night a week and every other weekend. But understandably she probably won't because she doesn't want to risk going through with it

But men like this, are fully prepared to risk having no/low contact with their children on the offchance it works and they can get what they want, which usually ends up being a full time parent to their child, housekeeper, someone they berate if they don't get sex when they want it, and someone they can financially control.

They know full well if they lose all contact with the child they will just use the 'my ex is a psycho bitch who took my children away from me and I can't afford to fight her' line, whilst doing their best to avoid paying child support

I'm pretty sure there would be a cross over in a Venn diagram with the other delightful subsection of men we hear about regularly on here who have unprotected sex and then if the woman gets pregnant 100% blame it on her as if she can somehow eject their sperm and actively chose not to

Soothsayer1 · 04/12/2022 00:12

Why do men do this sort of thing?
I think it's driven by resentment, that she is spending time investing in herself rather than doing his bidding, and he cant bring himself to support anything which might reduce his power over her, her career/earning capacity is a significant threat to that.
Obviously most men are decent and there are [a minority of] women who also behave in these ways, but a significant amount of men seem easily triggered into predatory/controlling behaviour...or so it seems to me

deeperthanallroses · 03/12/2022 23:43

Slv199 · 03/12/2022 18:14

Tell him that’s fine but you’ll expect him to quit his job to look after the baby as it’s his baby too.

Why do men do this sort of thing? I’ve got nothing but grief for going back to work. I do pretty much every drop off and pick up. It’s me that goes to all school events and me who takes time off when they are ill.

I think I only know one family who share everything equally. Both parents only work 4 days a week.

@Slv199 I hope you are planning to force changes or leave as well. You deserve an equal relationship.

Roundandnour · 03/12/2022 23:10

roarfeckingroarr · 03/12/2022 20:39

If he is suggesting you share equally his salary and any top up benefits, that's not so bad. I mean it's still bat shit, but at least he isn't a total wanker.

If he expects you to live off top up benefits while being a SAHM without equal access to what would then be family money, he can jog the fuck on.

So her pension is worth loosing?
When/if she finally returns to work unless she’s fucking lucky she won’t be able to walk back into her current role.

depending on her current job she may have professional fees to pay yearly.
In work training to keep up with whatever changes.

On a lesser income it would be possible for him to make a claim on her house.

Just a couple of reasons why it’s a bad idea for anyone to give up their financial independence, earning potential and future retirement fund

All because some wanker thinks he shouldn’t be contributing to expenses.

Catlady2021 · 03/12/2022 22:46

So apart from anything else, he’d rather you gave up work and went on benefits, just so he doesn’t have to pay nursery bills, which is only for a few short years.?? .. right…
Does he realise that you may not even qualify for benefits and also that as a couple you’d be financially worse off?..
What absolute fuckwittery..

MzHz · 03/12/2022 22:45

Venetiaparties · 03/12/2022 14:40

Never ever ever marry this man. Under any circumstances.

Yes this in spades

you tell him it’s a joint expense or he leaves. Go big and go first. You’re not trapping him, this was a joint decision and is a joint responsibility

if he’s not going to support you in this, he can leave.

HoppingPavlova · 03/12/2022 22:42

I'm due to go back to work in the new year after maternity leave and my DP of 4 years has just told me that he doesn't see why he should help pay the nursery fees as it's my decision to return to work.

This is easily dealt with. if he doesn’t want to pay half nursery cost then he stays home half the time and has baby instead. It’s his decision whether to do this or not as the baby is his as well as yours to look after. If not happy going part time after he has had a baby, he needs to fork out in lieu. Problem solved.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/12/2022 22:42

What the hell kind of madness is this?

Your child is your join child! So obviously childcare is a joint expense as you’re equally responsible for caring for them.

You can’t rely on him to support you as you aren’t married, end of.

So you both have to work, and both have to pay for childcare to enable this.

lionsandwhales · 03/12/2022 22:34

100% bell end. Run

OhIdoLike2bBesideTheSeaside · 03/12/2022 22:10

@Sarahlll
I mean didn't you discuss this with him before getting pregnant even???

My view is he's selfish and unrealistic and id LTB if it was me and send him a request for child maintenance

Do not give up your job and become reliant on him

Soothsayer1 · 03/12/2022 22:08

I’m not berating, I just cannot fathom how women sleepwalk into these grossly unfair financial situations
@PorpoiseWithPurpose I know, sorry, it's just I can see both sides, I've been the naïve person who just didnt see the red flags for what they were
predators select victims whom they sense will be easy marks for them, the victim cant see it when they are in the midst of it....imo

unsync · 03/12/2022 21:59

Well I call that a lucky escape. Another awful man.

Keep your independence and tell him to go.

SunshineLoving · 03/12/2022 21:54

He is awful OP. I would not be sticking around for a man who thinks it's okay to treat me and my child like this. You are a unit and everything should be shared. He clearly does not see a future with you if he is happy for your to be financially disadvantaged and he refuses to have a joint account. Also, him not looking after his own child on his days off is shocking IMO. I couldn't move past this.

PinkPrettyAndPointed · 03/12/2022 21:41

Wow. I can't believe he actually said this.

Explain why it's his responsibility too, and that you'd never give up your independence to rely on him.

If he still insists then it's LTB time.

TheNinny · 03/12/2022 21:40

tell him fine but he pays the days he is off and he could watch his child, but chooses not to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread