Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suspect that the usual mumsnet attitude to a&e is going to end up dangerous if there’s a strep outbreak

66 replies

Swg · 03/12/2022 12:37

Because we’ve all seen it a million times and know how it goes don’t we? Someone is going to show up anxious about their child who has a high temperature and sore throat and be told “that’s not an emergency don’t go to A&E”.

Call 111 (which will have a wait time of over an hour to get through and then may well insist on sending an ambulance no matter what causing more guilt)

Go to urgent care (if you have one)

Go and see your GP (it might take a month for an appointment but hey)

Lambast the poster for asking on here (because they’re not sure whether they have health anxiety and they’re worried about taking a sick child to sit 12 hours in a&e and don’t have childcare for their other kids)

Tell the poster that if they’re not prepared to sit forever in a&e their kid is clearly not that sick (or in a reverse, say that people who can survive sitting 40 hours in A&E are clearly not sick enough to be there)

Do anything at all other than admit the health service is broken and that is no one individuals fault.

AIBU to suggest mumsnet comes up with a blanket response to these threads now before someone dies of bad advice?

OP posts:
Shortpoet · 03/12/2022 14:15

Sorry wrong thread 😞

Shortpoet · 03/12/2022 14:14

This reply has been deleted

Posted on wrong thread. MNHQ

Prinnny · 03/12/2022 14:12

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 03/12/2022 14:08

Depends on the type of health advice. If it's non-acute, MN can be useful - e.g. advice with gynaecological issues, where women notoriously get fobbed off by GPs, told that severe endo is 'period pains' and so on - women with experience can help other posters ask the right questions to get what they need from the professionals. Also, 'I've got X condition/having Y surgery, what do I need to know' threads where people are sharing experiences; people asking what can help soothe minor ailments - all that is useful stuff.

I

Yes peer to peer support can be helpful but I was referring to children's health advice as per the OP.

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 03/12/2022 14:08

Prinnny · 03/12/2022 14:00

Anyone who takes health advice off MN is a moron, you have no idea who you’re talking to and what their intentions are.

If you have serious concerns for your child who need to speak to a health professional, be that your HV, GP, pharmacist or 111, not Barbara from Shropshire who’s cousins mates neighbour had the same.

Depends on the type of health advice. If it's non-acute, MN can be useful - e.g. advice with gynaecological issues, where women notoriously get fobbed off by GPs, told that severe endo is 'period pains' and so on - women with experience can help other posters ask the right questions to get what they need from the professionals. Also, 'I've got X condition/having Y surgery, what do I need to know' threads where people are sharing experiences; people asking what can help soothe minor ailments - all that is useful stuff.

I

sevenbyseven · 03/12/2022 14:07

lljkk · 03/12/2022 13:07

If every parent with an unwell small feverish child takes child to A&E then A&Es will be overwhelmed. Please don't stir up anxiety on a website already heaving with worriers.

This ^

And what the OP is calling "the usual Mumsnet attitude to A&E" is in most cases literally NHS advice.

Lolacat1234 · 03/12/2022 14:04

Ihatethenewlook · 03/12/2022 12:47

It proper does my head in on here when posters get slagged off for leaving an and e waiting rooms. There’s always a chorus of ‘well you clearly weren’t sick enough to be there if you were well enough to leave’. Sometimes it’s just unbearable sitting for hours on end on a metal chair in a boiling waiting room with those horrible lights that give me migraines. My oh sat waiting for 11 hours (and got told it would be at least another 4) with a big shard of metal stuck in his eyeball, before giving up and coming home. Luckily he managed to get an appointment at an actual eye hospital a few hours later and they saved his eye. Sometimes it gets to the point where you just can’t stand it anymore and you can’t help going home.

Totally agree - the problem is now in my area there is no such thing as urgent care it's just all A&E - 111 send you to "urgent care" but it's nothing more than local A&E no differentiation at all, not even a separate queue for all those kids arriving that just need to see an out of hours GP for some penicillin as opposed to be admitted to A&E. so yes I did leave last week after 6 hours when I was told it would be at least another 3 with my 3 year old with tonsillitis, I had to just dose her up and managed to see the GP for medicine the next day. So I guess what I'm trying to say is there are many people at the moment arriving in A&E that are not sick enough to be there because there's no out of hours service and 111 have sent them there. It's not fair on the people that actually need to be in A&E as well.

ILoveeCakes · 03/12/2022 14:03

Mumsnetters are always telling people to go to A&E, call the police and/or LTB.

Swg · 03/12/2022 14:03

FatimaHatima · 03/12/2022 13:17

No, of course I'm not. But then I wouldn't be doing any of those things. I can get a same day appt with my GP, have an out of hours on call dr service, a minor injuries/ailments unit I can drive to, and a paediatric A&E in the next town.

I also have a brain and can judge for myself when my child needs medical attention. The very last thing I would be doing would be posting on bloody mumsnet if my child was sick enough to need urgent attention!

I’m happy for you - genuinely. You are clearly living in one of the few areas currently where the NHS is still working.

However statistically that’s not currently that majority of people and lived experience is confirming the statistical reports that actually getting seen right now for most people is not that easy. Or do you think the various people reporting back that they can’t get help are making it up?

OP posts:
Prinnny · 03/12/2022 14:00

Anyone who takes health advice off MN is a moron, you have no idea who you’re talking to and what their intentions are.

If you have serious concerns for your child who need to speak to a health professional, be that your HV, GP, pharmacist or 111, not Barbara from Shropshire who’s cousins mates neighbour had the same.

Swg · 03/12/2022 13:59

upfucked · 03/12/2022 13:52

In the stress if the moment it can be much more difficult to decision to make. My Dad has asked me before if she should ring an ambulance for my Mum in a certain situation and it’s very clearly a yes but when I was in that situation I hesitated and was torn.

If the person is asking for themselves you have to remember the more unwell you are the more difficult it is to make a decision especially if you have been fobbed off by doctors. I nearly didn’t seek help for myself when I had developed spesis because I was too ill to think logically.

This indeed. I had friends make me call an ambulance earlier this year (fortunately I have friends who are actual friends and not mumsne trolls) because I was so ill that I could no longer process what to do when ill. And particularly as people posting on mumsnet tend to have kids the exhaustion of “but what do I do with the kids” can be overwhelming.

OP posts:
Swg · 03/12/2022 13:57

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 03/12/2022 12:48

If posted in the health topic MN clearly say at the top of every thread:

'Mumsnet hasn't checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have medical concerns, please seek medical attention; if you think your problem could be acute, do so immediately. Even qualified doctors can't diagnose over the internet, so do bear that in mind when seeking or giving advice.'

And honestly I would be quite happy with a mumsnet policy of “health threads go in the health forum, we will actively move those posted elsewhere”. It would keep it away from the hive that is AIBU which people tend to post to just because it’s easy but is also where the trolls hang out.

Basically what I’m saying is mumsnet need a consistent policy that they stick to because their current policy of pretending that their forum isn’t full of dicks who give the same advice of “you’re still breathing so it isn’t an a&e job” to everyone is dangerous

OP posts:
upfucked · 03/12/2022 13:52

PAFMO · 03/12/2022 12:50

I've seen far more of the opposite in fairness.

And nobody should be asking on MN about whether to call an ambulance or not. Though some posters clearly get off on doing so. There's a current long (and very tedious) thread with someone dragging the aunties along with her "health" dramas.

In the stress if the moment it can be much more difficult to decision to make. My Dad has asked me before if she should ring an ambulance for my Mum in a certain situation and it’s very clearly a yes but when I was in that situation I hesitated and was torn.

If the person is asking for themselves you have to remember the more unwell you are the more difficult it is to make a decision especially if you have been fobbed off by doctors. I nearly didn’t seek help for myself when I had developed spesis because I was too ill to think logically.

ShirleyPhallus · 03/12/2022 13:48

RafaistheKingofClay · 03/12/2022 12:56

It’s not quite that simple though. Anyone whose read MN for years will have heard hundreds of times how A&Ebis only for if you are dead of your leg is hanging on by a thread. That sort of message sinks in. It would be quite easy to look at a sick child, decide it’s not actually an emergency and can wait until tomorrow and be quite wrong.

But this is the problem with people thinking that MN is a tiny, friendly forum where everyone can be trusted, apart from the obvious trolls.

You wouldn’t get medical advice from Reddit, don’t trust it from MN either!

Nat6999 · 03/12/2022 13:31

A & E is a nightmare, my mum was in last weekend after having a cardiac seizure, everyone was coughing & spluttering, no covid tests & separating positive & negative patients. She was there 12 hours before she got moved to a ward, waited 3 days to have a pacemaker fitted & came home with Covid which she has passed on to me.

FatimaHatima · 03/12/2022 13:17

Swg · 03/12/2022 13:03

So your child is sick. You’re scared but trying not to panic. You are a) sitting on hold to 111 as you have been for forty minutes trying to soothe your child with one hand whilst you hang onto the phone, b) waiting for an ambulance which has been two hours so far, c) sitting in an A&E waiting room as you have been for six hours feeling guilty for dragging your sick child out or d) have just been offered a GP appointment in January.

But I mean obviously whilst doing those things the one thing you’re never ever going to do is look for reassurance online.

No, of course I'm not. But then I wouldn't be doing any of those things. I can get a same day appt with my GP, have an out of hours on call dr service, a minor injuries/ailments unit I can drive to, and a paediatric A&E in the next town.

I also have a brain and can judge for myself when my child needs medical attention. The very last thing I would be doing would be posting on bloody mumsnet if my child was sick enough to need urgent attention!

luxxlisbon · 03/12/2022 13:15

So everyone with a temperature and a sore throat should be told to go to A&E?

Stop scaremongering about the GP and 111. If your child is ill waiting to speak to someone on 111 isn’t a hardship. I actually don’t think I’ve ever waited 1hr on hold.

The ONLY advice is that no one is qualified to give actual medical advice on mumsnet, so don’t, whether that’s telling them to go to A&E or to not go.

AbsolutelyNebulous · 03/12/2022 13:14

FatimaHatima · 03/12/2022 12:55

Of course it was quick, its the obvious and sensible response! What the fuck would you be doing asking MN if you should bring your sick child to hospital? A random group of strangers who can't see your kid, have (in the main) no medical knowledge, and half of which can't even tell the difference between bought and brought?

It's like asking a clatter of cats where to invest your life savings, only stupider and with worse possible consequences.

Grin Love this and it’s 100% true. Honestly, exactly what level of responsibility do anonymous strangers on the internet have for your child’s health? And why on earth would somebody make their decision based on Mumsnet as opposed to say, going on the NHS website or any other medical type site? Or god forbid asking someone in RL who can, y’know, actually see the child? Or ringing the NHS advice line?

lljkk · 03/12/2022 13:07

If every parent with an unwell small feverish child takes child to A&E then A&Es will be overwhelmed. Please don't stir up anxiety on a website already heaving with worriers.

Swg · 03/12/2022 13:03

FatimaHatima · 03/12/2022 12:55

Of course it was quick, its the obvious and sensible response! What the fuck would you be doing asking MN if you should bring your sick child to hospital? A random group of strangers who can't see your kid, have (in the main) no medical knowledge, and half of which can't even tell the difference between bought and brought?

It's like asking a clatter of cats where to invest your life savings, only stupider and with worse possible consequences.

So your child is sick. You’re scared but trying not to panic. You are a) sitting on hold to 111 as you have been for forty minutes trying to soothe your child with one hand whilst you hang onto the phone, b) waiting for an ambulance which has been two hours so far, c) sitting in an A&E waiting room as you have been for six hours feeling guilty for dragging your sick child out or d) have just been offered a GP appointment in January.

But I mean obviously whilst doing those things the one thing you’re never ever going to do is look for reassurance online.

OP posts:
Swg · 03/12/2022 12:58

Thedungeondragon · 03/12/2022 12:53

Alternatively people will die because there are hundreds of worried parents clogging up A&E with DC with a standard sore throat. It is always going to cause issues when a normal childhood bug becomes serious. It makes it so much more difficult to know when to really worry.

Unfortunately I suspect what will happen is that people will die, full stop, because A&E is understaffed. And then the government will blame it on people not acting responsibly (without acknowledging that whether someone acted responsibly in hindsight usually depends on the outcome). Meanwhile the people you absolutely want to turn up for help will avoid it because they feel guilty.

Much the same as many cancer sufferers aren’t diagnosed until it gets really bad because they’re scared to be a bother.

OP posts:
Willmafrockfit · 03/12/2022 12:56

i agree,
i would not go near mumsnet if i was that concerned

RafaistheKingofClay · 03/12/2022 12:56

ShirleyPhallus · 03/12/2022 12:46

before someone dies of bad advice?

anyone who takes advice from an anonymous internet forum instead of advice from proper channels should be given a Darwin Award

It’s not quite that simple though. Anyone whose read MN for years will have heard hundreds of times how A&Ebis only for if you are dead of your leg is hanging on by a thread. That sort of message sinks in. It would be quite easy to look at a sick child, decide it’s not actually an emergency and can wait until tomorrow and be quite wrong.

x2boys · 03/12/2022 12:55

Bollocks to what mumsnet thinks if I was concerned enough about my child I would seek urgent medical.attention,and anyone who relys on the collective opinion of mumsnet to deceide wether to take their child to A&E is foo!into say the least.

FatimaHatima · 03/12/2022 12:55

Swg · 03/12/2022 12:49

Oh look we’re onto “lambast the poster for asking on here” already. That was quick.

Of course it was quick, its the obvious and sensible response! What the fuck would you be doing asking MN if you should bring your sick child to hospital? A random group of strangers who can't see your kid, have (in the main) no medical knowledge, and half of which can't even tell the difference between bought and brought?

It's like asking a clatter of cats where to invest your life savings, only stupider and with worse possible consequences.

Swg · 03/12/2022 12:54

ThatGirlInACountrySong · 03/12/2022 12:51

@Swg you post a thread then just slate a few selected replies?

I’m on my phone, and replying gradually (and about to go tromp about in the garden at which point all responses will stop for a good hour). Are you invoking some “must reply to every post” etiquette?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread