Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family member wants presents for all the children

318 replies

Diorama1 · 03/12/2022 09:53

I have a family member that has 6 children. Every year she expects that she will buy for my 3 and I will buy for her 6. We have tried in the last few years to stop this but she is refuses.
We have suggested that we take the kids out for a special day near Christmas and make it a tradition to do this, or else but one larger family present.

The budget is about €10/15 per child. As they are getting older it is much more difficult to buy anything decent for this amount so I end up spending more. Every year we end up receiving and buying plastic tat for the children. Its a waste of money and so bad for the planet.
She is very much into Christmas and birthdays and thinks its very important to buy each child a present. I honestly cant think of a single present for them as they are just into computer games. They dont read, play board games, sports, etc.
I am at a loss, does anyone have any suggestions please?

I dont want to offend her, she is already pi**ed as us for forgetting one of her kids birthdays earlier this year so dont want to rock the boat anymore.

OP posts:
Dotcomma · 05/12/2022 02:01

Buy the kids some smellies for bath & some chocolate.

My sister has 4 kids & I gave them money, token amount prob £5 each, youngest is now early 30s. I have 1 child who is 14 years younger & she gets £10 spent on her by my sister. I'd never thought about the disparity before I read this thread.

Looby57 · 05/12/2022 01:30

Give them family planning advice 😂😂😂

Looby57 · 05/12/2022 01:26

She sounds a nitemare

lornesausage20 · 04/12/2022 23:50

Yeah I was looking into the shady goings on of a charity aged 6.

That's why I said "if not OCC" there will be loads of appeals locally 👍

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 04/12/2022 23:43

lornesausage20 · 04/12/2022 23:31

YANBU ultimately. Something I really used to love doing was Operation Christmas Child shoebox appeals. I used to go with my mum and pick out presents to put in it. This is something you could do as a day out with all of your children and then take them home for hot chocolate, a Christmas film and then fill up the shoeboxes/bags. If not OCC then there will be loads of local appeals. I think giving for givings sake is stupid. At the end of the day, do any of us need any of this?

If ever there were an activity not to be encouraged

have you not seen any of the info about the organisation behind it?

stevec711 · 04/12/2022 23:40

Unless you stop being scared to rock the boat, things will never change.

lornesausage20 · 04/12/2022 23:31

YANBU ultimately. Something I really used to love doing was Operation Christmas Child shoebox appeals. I used to go with my mum and pick out presents to put in it. This is something you could do as a day out with all of your children and then take them home for hot chocolate, a Christmas film and then fill up the shoeboxes/bags. If not OCC then there will be loads of local appeals. I think giving for givings sake is stupid. At the end of the day, do any of us need any of this?

Merlin3189 · 04/12/2022 23:03

Somebody has to have sense and be responsible - seems that's you.

If you really want presents both ways, agree that she buys for her kids and labels it from you, and you buy for your kids and label it from her. After all, you both know your own kids best.

Pinkfluff76 · 04/12/2022 22:40

Why are you scared of offending her when her behaviour is offensive…

T1Dmama · 04/12/2022 22:24

How old are they? Could you buy something useful that won’t be thrown to the side the next day… toiletries… sweets… food?
vouchers

Peachy2005 · 04/12/2022 22:05

@FancyFanny tell all your friends “we are just doing cards not gifts anymore”. There’s no need to be stuck in this trap with friends as well as family!! I bet loads of them will be relieved. At least warn them for next year if you’ve already bought your 16 gifts and can’t return any…

T1Dmama · 04/12/2022 21:59

This drives me mad!! After fertility issues I only have one child, my friends and siblings all have 2…. So while everyone spends a set amount on my daughter, I spend double….
As kids are getting older they’re all harder to buy for… personally I’d buy them a family ticket to the cinema… or Amazon vouchers each. If she isn’t happy with that tell her you will gift what you feel appropriate, and as you’re buying for 6 it’s easier to buy vouchers etc so they can save for something they actually want…
Someone can’t insist you gift for their children then whine about what you chose to spend your money on!
As kids my uncle always got us vouchers… we loved a trip to town to spend them on something we really wanted x

Greenshed · 04/12/2022 21:47

Time to stop, in my opinion. There’s far too much emotional blackmail goes on at Christmas.

Sushi7 · 04/12/2022 21:46

AlexandraPeppernose · 04/12/2022 20:17

I have 3vand their cousin is a only. They spend a tenner on each of mine and I spend 30 on theirs. We feel that is fair

This is how it should be!

LaughingCat · 04/12/2022 21:30

Cash! There’s an age you hit where cash in a card from your aunties and uncles (and maybe a chocolate selection box on the side to unwrap) is literally the best present. If the kids are gaming on Xbox or Playstation, maybe it’s a Store voucher for whichever platform or something similar so they can save up for their own game (or even club together with their vouchers if they want to buy the same one).

Harsh that she has six kids so you spend double but them’s the breaks. If my OH and I do have a kid, it will always be one of ours vs the three my SIL/BIL have…but that won’t bother us. We’ll still buy them something every year. But it will, in the next few years, move to cash in a card!

Learnsometjingeveryday · 04/12/2022 21:29

We have decided this year we aren't buying kids presents and habe told all family not not buy ours , now in our situation we would be the ones getting less as have 4 kids 2 will also be 16 xmas eve and one will be 12 on the 28th ,but i think with that we are spending enough and everything has gone up ,my partner wants to still buy for hes sisters kids( she isnt only family member with kids) and have her over but told her not to buy for our kids ,i said toy DP how id that right they sit opening gifts but your sister gets ours nothing ,even though her and her DP earn more ,have less to pay out but can not budget and are always skint and lending money , its stupid , i could do a post of my own !! . ..but for u i would say lets not buy for each others this year or agree on a set amount regardless of children and let the parent choose something their kids will like they will see its not so easy when its half the amount they spend !

blackpearwhitelilies · 04/12/2022 21:15

Buy each child a book and a bar of chocolate - that’s 10 or 11 quid and a nice present.

MrsWeasley · 04/12/2022 21:10

I think I’d buy a family ticket for the four children to go to cinema or bowling or laser tag (or similar -trampoline park etc) and then a selection box each. I wouldn’t pay for the adult tickets though.

or I’d buy them a good popular book each or a book token. Could it be that they don’t read because they haven’t got any books that interest them.

or a joint gift of a selection of nice colouring pens and pencils

FancyFanny · 04/12/2022 21:10

I feel your pain. We have one child, all our friends/family have at least 2, 3 and even 4 children. So our dd gets around 6 gifts and we have to buy around 16 children gifts. It's not really fair. I wouldn't really mind if families with four children gave dd a better gift- but in general they don't.

BlueMongoose · 04/12/2022 20:54

She can 'refuse' all she likes. I'd do what you thought was right ad fair, she would just have to suck it up. If she won't sit down with you and come to a sensible and fair arrangement you can both afford, she and her kids will just have to get what they're given, like it or not.
We have no kids, and we always get presents for nephews and nieces. For me, gift giving is not really a question of everyone spending the same, or all the kids getting the same. Gifts are voluntary expressions of what you wish to give, within the resources you have. They should not be bargaining counters. Sometimes I give an expensive present because it's just right for the person, sometimes a cheap one for the same reason. To keep it feeling fair to the kids, we try to keep things evened up during the year within each family- if someone gets a more expensive birthday present than a sibling, they get a smaller Christmas one to make up for it. None of their parents have ever been ungrateful in any way either.

AmmarettoSours · 04/12/2022 20:52

A day out or group voucher for something they like sounds like a great idea!
Let her get pissy all she likes

This is why in my family we only buy for our own dc. I'm one of 6, each sibling has 3/4 dc each and now several of the dc have there own dc. If we tried to buy for everyone every year we would go bankrupt!

KTMeetsTheRsUptown · 04/12/2022 20:50

Same as others on M/N I put £10 in each of my neice and nephews cards and wrap in Christmas paper, unless they are very young then I get them a present (under 7) I don't ask the parents what to get them as that leads to more trouble for me and becomes more expensive. The kids like it as they can save it up with other Christmas money they get.

earsup · 04/12/2022 20:48

Large box of nice chocs for all of them.....i only buy for 2 friends.....dont need any more tat or crap gifts in my world....I have a childish rich friend who buys me a mountain of unwanted and unsuitable stuff each year....its a bin bag full of childrens board games etc....all useless....i donate the lot to local food bank...i get her some fresh flowers each year....!!

17caterpillars1mouse · 04/12/2022 20:45

I would just go with a pair of pyjamas each or a character t-shirt at least then you know they will get used

mandlerparr · 04/12/2022 20:34

If you bake, make them cookies or something. If you don't, make a little gift. Fill a mug or cup with chocolates or candy, wrap a tissue around it. Get them a few cheap items that are usable like body sprays or cheap candles. Get them a group gift for Christmas, like 6 months of a streaming service they don't have. Most kids don't have any problem getting gifts they can eat or use. It is not up to you to get that present they really want; it is up to the parents. If the parents hold up their end, the kids should have no problem with small gifts from relatives. And all need to stop worrying about who has to buy more items than someone else. Why do they need to know how much you spent? I think people forget that when gift limits are set it is supposed to be an amount you don't go over, not an amount you have to spend. Just do your best to tailor the gift to each child and keep in mind that most kids would love a bag of goodies to eat.

Swipe left for the next trending thread