Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family member wants presents for all the children

318 replies

Diorama1 · 03/12/2022 09:53

I have a family member that has 6 children. Every year she expects that she will buy for my 3 and I will buy for her 6. We have tried in the last few years to stop this but she is refuses.
We have suggested that we take the kids out for a special day near Christmas and make it a tradition to do this, or else but one larger family present.

The budget is about €10/15 per child. As they are getting older it is much more difficult to buy anything decent for this amount so I end up spending more. Every year we end up receiving and buying plastic tat for the children. Its a waste of money and so bad for the planet.
She is very much into Christmas and birthdays and thinks its very important to buy each child a present. I honestly cant think of a single present for them as they are just into computer games. They dont read, play board games, sports, etc.
I am at a loss, does anyone have any suggestions please?

I dont want to offend her, she is already pi**ed as us for forgetting one of her kids birthdays earlier this year so dont want to rock the boat anymore.

OP posts:
TheWomanTheyCallJayne · 05/12/2022 14:56

kiwigeekmum · 05/12/2022 04:13

Honestly I think you're being a bit mean-spirited, although I can see I'm in the minority.

My brother has 5 kids, I have 2. We still buy for all his kids, no worries. Conversely, my SIL has no kids and still buys for our two. Families come in all shapes and sizes, why should the kids be punished?

I think the key is that YOU end up going over your budget and then feel frustrated about it. Reduce your budget to an amount that you're happy with, and STICK to it. As pp have mentioned, a 10quid voucher in a card is perfectly acceptable - older kids would prefer that anyway. Or buy them something cheaper. You don't need to blow your budget.

I agree.
I have four. My sils each have two and I’m well aware of this so always spend more than the agreed budget per child for theirs. I’m not sure they’ve realised this but it’s always made me feel less guilty.

Sartre · 05/12/2022 14:50

Either give them a tenner each in a card or a voucher maybe or just explain you can’t afford it and she doesn’t have to buy for your DC either. I can’t believe she expects presents though, it’s so rude.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 05/12/2022 14:42

family season ticket for a local attraction.
cinema vouchers
costa card or similar
Roblox or google play gift card

or just say no. We’re doing birthdays only

Kamd21 · 05/12/2022 14:34

Just buy for birthdays (or give money, xbox gift card etc) then for Christmas just give selection boxes.

Pipsquiggle · 05/12/2022 14:23

Chocolate orange each with a tenner tucked in it.

That's what we got from my aunty when we were secondary school age and we loved it

Peggy68 · 05/12/2022 13:50

You could buy multipacks of snacks, chocolate etc and split to do 6 'movie night' hampers - ideas on Pinterest. Or invite to yours for a movie night or games night if they don't live too far away.

Years ago we shifted primarily to experiences. You could make a homemade experience voucher offering to take them all to something like crazy golf, foot golf or soft play if very young, on a date to suit. Do it between lunch and dinner and you won't have to feed them - just make up some snack bags with a drink. She can drop them off and pick them up. They will never forget it. Mine went to my brothers house for den building and learned how to build a fire which they cooked sausages on and still talk about it years later! They don't remember any of the plastic tat they used to make me buy, but do remember ALL the experiences!

Purple52 · 05/12/2022 13:49

I’d write them all a cheque!
you know it has to go in their OWN bank account (I know ultimately the parents will control it - but at least it gets there!). Also means if any get lost in the frenzie of opening presents you can replace it.

& give them a £1/£2 box of chocolate that you can wrap & they can open.

Once children are too old for something that costs £10, they do start to see the value of multiple £10’s to enable them to get something they want. …. If more friends do it they could easily end up with a couple of computer games each!

….. if she’s got 6 kids and wants presents for them all her house must be full of tat!! - or very rapidly gets binned anyway! …. Think of the environmental impact. Immediate in her home and the world!

DangerousAlchemy · 05/12/2022 13:32

amiold · 03/12/2022 09:55

I'd be giving them a tenner each in a card or just telling her it's stopping. Your choice not hers.

100% this! 👏

Geepee71 · 05/12/2022 13:20

Tell her you will buy a gift for your children from her and she can buy a gift for her children from you.

PorridgewithQuark · 05/12/2022 13:18

gaf · 03/12/2022 10:01

If they’re into computer games just buy them a Roblox or x box gift voucher (or whatever they play). Then they can choose how to spend it.

This, or chocolate.

I have more children than my sister so when they were small I spent more on hers than she did on mine. Later we established that I'd buy for mine "from" her and she'd buy for hers "from" me - so we each carry the cost of our own but we live a very long way apart and don't see each other at Christmas, so it also saves postage costs.

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 05/12/2022 13:16

I would get one of your kids to set up a secret santa app, whatsapp all the kids with the set up and then leave them to it. All the kids buy one present each for a set price (say £10 or £20). We have done this for the adults this year and its dead easy.

Shamrock77 · 05/12/2022 13:09

Please do not feel you have to be dictated to by a family member! You DO NOT have to do what she says. You can't afford it, it's as simple as that. You tell her that and that you wish things were different but with the cost of living it really isn't feasible this year. If she sees her arse about it, that's her problem, not yours! It's a stressful enough time as it is, a family member acting like that doesn't help! x

steppemum · 05/12/2022 13:08

I don't think that you should feel that you have to buy, but if you do, then go simple

box of Heroes
cinema voucher
costa coffee voucher
£10 cash
giant bar of chocolate
mile of jaffa cakes box
etc
If I do cash I often wrap it to look fun, so a balloon with £10 of £1 coins inside, santa with £10 stuffed in his hand or something, it makes them laugh and the net result is CASH which they love.

ZED55JAX0 · 05/12/2022 13:02

Surely a selection box and a bath bomb/ something similar that can be used in one go and few pounds or just be firm and
tell her you want to stop or can’t afford it anymore

Mammalamb · 05/12/2022 12:40

I have this problem too. I have one child. DS has 7 plus grandchildren. I’ve been buying gifts for Neice’s and nephews since my mid teens. I’m in my 40s now. So I literally just stopped buying them presents during lockdown. I sometimes feel a bit mean about it, but we never see each other (maybe I’m still a bit bitter that no one came to see my new baby son)

Nothing7 · 05/12/2022 11:04

Why not buy a computer game for them all to share? Higher priced but maybe not as high as 6x£10-15

Tomitma111 · 05/12/2022 10:00

Truthfully I think the kids would love a tenner in a card

Gherkinslice · 05/12/2022 09:44

Yep, I'd be rocking that boat! YOUR money, YOUR choice. Its not like you're saying you aren't buying ANY presents for them this year. Many will have no choice but to do exactly that. Who does she think she is to insist how you spend your budget? Rock that boat!

liarliarshortsonfire · 05/12/2022 08:30

I agreed with my brother and friends this year that we'd opt out of buying presents for the dc due to increasing costs. We agreed to do something, like a cinema trip, or a day trip out instead. This year we've decided to go to a light show at our local park, and treat all the dc to hot chocolate instead. The dc are really excited.

OffToJoinTheCircus · 05/12/2022 08:20

We have 3 nieces (to our one ds). They are now all in their 20's. We never give to receive, but it does feel uneven.
Since their teens we have gone for a voucher of £10/15 and one of those tubes of sweets - smarties, rolos, etc..
As they are given before Christmas, as we don't see them on Christmas day, they love having the tubes of sweets to open and eat as breakfast - they still do!!
I would suggest a card with a voucher or cash and then something little - say a selection box - that they can open.

xmaswiththeinlaws · 05/12/2022 07:39

I feel your pain, we have 2 and my brother has 5, but then we have my husband's family (he has 6 siblings who have 8 kids between them so far). We don't do presents with his side of the family unless we are seeing them as they all live abroad so we all agreed it's a faff.
I have been giving DBs kids a tenner in a card and something small for the past few years as I got fed up with seeing their presents on Ebay within a week or having to witness the meltdown of one of the kids getting something he didn't like and having had to open it in front of us. I struggle with the youngest as he's still quite small and has LDs so I'm not sure he understands the concept of money so I try to get him something instead, trouble is we don't see him much so struggle to know what he'd want.
Invariably they get random stuff for our kids every year. DS usually does ok as they have boys but DD has had some odd things, not always age appropriate or just not her. I'd love to agree not to do presents.

RoachPussy · 05/12/2022 06:27

I have 2 DC, my older brother 1, younger brother 2, BIL 1. Their ages 23, 21, 23, 28, 26, 13. I buy for all my nieces and nephews and have always spent a little extra on the only children as I’m aware their parents were buying for 2. My younger brother stopped buying for his nieces and nephews once they turned 18 which is fine. My personal view in regards to my gift giving is that they’re my nieces and nephews, I love them all like my own and I will always get them a gift for Christmas. OP you want to get them something which is lovely, don’t be dictated to by your SIL regarding the gift.

Kitkatcatflap · 05/12/2022 06:05

kiwigeekmum · 05/12/2022 04:13

Honestly I think you're being a bit mean-spirited, although I can see I'm in the minority.

My brother has 5 kids, I have 2. We still buy for all his kids, no worries. Conversely, my SIL has no kids and still buys for our two. Families come in all shapes and sizes, why should the kids be punished?

I think the key is that YOU end up going over your budget and then feel frustrated about it. Reduce your budget to an amount that you're happy with, and STICK to it. As pp have mentioned, a 10quid voucher in a card is perfectly acceptable - older kids would prefer that anyway. Or buy them something cheaper. You don't need to blow your budget.

Be interesting to what your childless SIL really thinks about the 'acceptable' £10 in a card for the combined 7 kids. But doubtless you and your brother make it up her show your appreciation with a thoughtful well chosen gift.

poefaced · 05/12/2022 05:01

Opting out of presents exchange is not ‘punishing kids’, the kids will receive presents from their parents. It’s not up to other people to ensure your kids have lots of things to open.

kiwigeekmum · 05/12/2022 04:13

Honestly I think you're being a bit mean-spirited, although I can see I'm in the minority.

My brother has 5 kids, I have 2. We still buy for all his kids, no worries. Conversely, my SIL has no kids and still buys for our two. Families come in all shapes and sizes, why should the kids be punished?

I think the key is that YOU end up going over your budget and then feel frustrated about it. Reduce your budget to an amount that you're happy with, and STICK to it. As pp have mentioned, a 10quid voucher in a card is perfectly acceptable - older kids would prefer that anyway. Or buy them something cheaper. You don't need to blow your budget.