Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lived experience re racism on Mumsnet

190 replies

lightlypoached · 03/12/2022 09:17

People on a now suspended/ soon to be deleted thread may know why I'm posting this. I was going to post it there but will start a new (soon to be suspended /deleted I'm sure) thread here instead.

At work we did some 'lived experience' sessions where people openly talked about their everyday experiences of sexism , racism and homophopia. The idea was for everyone to listen to the truth of what was being said, and to learn from it. The 'rules' were that you weren't allowed to challenge someone's story as it is their experienced truth. Questions were welcomed and we all learned a great deal. It was a real eye opener.

It helped me to be more aware and to look out for the more insidious words and actions, so that I would not unwittingly do them, and could call others out if I spotted it.

If ever I see racism on here I'll report but the point is that many (a large majority I suspect) of us are white so we don't always understand or see racism (that's a bit shit, but honest).

I think that some 'lived experience' sharing would help immensely. We could have a one-off special thread that would be allowed to refer to content of old threads as well as real life so we can hear specific types of comment that are problematical, and get under the skin of why. Strict rules on contributions though and no debate - all about listening and learning. We could have that as a pinned thread for people to read and learn from.

Is that a daft idea or could it work?

I'd like to be on a site where everyone feels at home , listened to and respected.

So AIBU to suggest we have a one off lived experience thread about racism ?

OP posts:
dollymixtured · 03/12/2022 10:18

wincarwoo · 03/12/2022 10:17

@dollymixtured whataboutery.

Nice try. Sorry you aren’t able to engage.

wincarwoo · 03/12/2022 10:17

@dollymixtured whataboutery.

NippyWoowoo · 03/12/2022 10:17

This thread is a shitshow. @MNHQ please, enough

Sparklingbrook · 03/12/2022 10:16

Underanothersky · 03/12/2022 09:47

I feel like the nature of Mumsnet means that it is not a good place to do this. If someone really wants to learn there a
is plenty of writing about it other places online and there are plenty of books.

I would agree with this. Most posters don’t use MN as an educational tool.

stuntbubbles · 03/12/2022 10:16

@lightlypoached One resource that might be helpful is The Other Box – excellent diversity and bias training for the workplace that’s more about making people confront their own experiences and biases rather than making other people relive theirs.

BacklogBritain · 03/12/2022 10:16

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

NippyWoowoo · 03/12/2022 10:15

category12 · 03/12/2022 09:53

Isn't this just asking people of colour to educate white people?

Exactly this

lightlypoached · 03/12/2022 10:15

Underanothersky · 03/12/2022 09:47

I feel like the nature of Mumsnet means that it is not a good place to do this. If someone really wants to learn there a
is plenty of writing about it other places online and there are plenty of books.

I know that there are loads of resources out there in internet land. I was talking about having something in here that people can look at to help stamp out offence and unwitting (sometimes deliberate) racism.

OP posts:
NippyWoowoo · 03/12/2022 10:14

randomusername02 · 03/12/2022 09:22

It's pointless imo. Its not healthy validating every case of someone being offended as an ism, especially in cases where its not been intended or isn't actually an ism.

First post in! OP, they're not interested

stuntbubbles · 03/12/2022 10:13

Tell you what I think would be useful on MN and that’s limiting username changes. Someone can be a racist bellend on a thread, everyone takes note of the name so they know not to be baited in future, but then they get to disappear into the night with a quick name change so you don’t instantly recognise their tomfoolery elsewhere.

lightlypoached · 03/12/2022 10:12

@AbsoluteYawns

As mentioned in my post it helped me at work to understand a perspective I never usually see and it allowed my colleagues who chose to talk (no one was forced, or forced to attend) about how things are for them, what drives them nuts.

I agree with a PP that 'performative' or forced initiatives can be bloody awful, counter productive and indulgent.

I do think there are challenges with the approach though - what one person finds acceptable, another finds abhorrent but even with that risk I think that open discussion helps to get issues out in the open where we can start address them.

It's just about listening and learning. Not everyone is the same and not everyone wants to participate. That's fine.

I do like the principle that truth has validity too. It may not be a widespread or representative truth, but if someone feels like that then they feel like that, and it matters.

I do remember back in the 70s and 80s where men at work would slyly say 'but I didn't mean to be offensive' . But they were. And I used to point out that intent was not the issue, that they had been offensive. To me. And that mattered. We have made progress on workplace sexism owing to people like me sharing what it's like to be a woman at work (it's just we didn't cal, it shared experience then, we just called it 'speaking up').

I've spent a lifetime as a woman working in a male dominated workplace and have struggled often with both blatant and insidious sexism. I welcome discussions where male colleagues can hear directly about how their attitudes, language and behaviour affect me, my performance and happiness at work. And in some cases some of them have actually listened, learned and changed. That how progress can be made.

OP posts:
Georgeskitchen · 03/12/2022 10:10

Given that the rules on what is/isn't acceptable seem.to change by the hour, its probably not a good idea.
Keeping ones mouth firmly shut is the best way to avoid offending anyone, either intentionally or not

Puzzledandpissedoff · 03/12/2022 10:07

Superb post, @GCAcademic

I'm another who believes it's important to learn about the experiences of others, though problems can arise it's done not to support but to burnish the credentials of the "listeners", who too often go on to insult everyone else on the back of their newly acquired "knowledge"

Ceaseless focus on "isms" gets us only so far, but IME plain old fashioned manners can often be more useful and tend to be pleasanter for all

KettrickenSmiled · 03/12/2022 10:06

GCAcademic · 03/12/2022 09:58

Interesting that you’re choosing to ignore / straw man the comments from people on this thread who aren’t white.

No, what's interesting is WE DON'T KNOW people's colour unless they tell us, so PP are responding to actual thoughts, not skin colour.

There will be many WOC posting here who seriously dislike being told they ought to be offended, or it's their job to educate white people, or reduce white guilt, or either celebrate their heritage/minimise it to appear less challenging to the parochially-minded, or who choose not to present as victims.
Just as there will be many who are sick to the back teeth of white people instructing them how they are allowed to feel, & telling them their experience of racism isn't real because "it wasn't intended".

Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 10:06

randomusername02 · 03/12/2022 09:49

I'm not saying people can't be offended, they can be offended as they want. I'm saying it's not healthy to fawn and validate every instance of someone being offended as an ism, especially where it isn't.

Who are you to say it wasn’t an ism, before anything has even been shared

dollymixtured · 03/12/2022 10:05

stuntbubbles · 03/12/2022 10:03

It’s a bit “relive your pain, for free, so I as a white person don’t have to do the true work involved in allyship”.

As a white woman it’s my responsibility to educate myself, and seek out resources – of which there are already many online! – not doomscroll through a thread asking WOC to share their suffering a bit more, again, using their time, energy and resources.

Nice bit of performative ‘allyship’ there.

stuntbubbles · 03/12/2022 10:03

It’s a bit “relive your pain, for free, so I as a white person don’t have to do the true work involved in allyship”.

As a white woman it’s my responsibility to educate myself, and seek out resources – of which there are already many online! – not doomscroll through a thread asking WOC to share their suffering a bit more, again, using their time, energy and resources.

Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 10:02

GCAcademic · 03/12/2022 09:32

No thanks. As a WOC, I’m sick of white people telegraphing their white guilt to make themselves look virtuous. I prefer to go about my life without constantly thinking about my skin colour. But now certain terribly virtuous mildly class white colleagues want me to constantly provide fodder for their activism, and to other me in the process. The kind of event that the OP describes at her work was probably absolutely horrible for those colleagues. Whe. we had a similar thing at my work I ended up in tears and should never have been out in that position. It was utterly othering, with a side order of feeling gawped at. The only people it benefitted was the EDI reps who could make themselves feel like they were doing something.

👏

I’ve felt similar in such exercises at work - I’m white but we were asked to contribute sexism or misogyny or xenophobia too and I found myself feeling triggered and like I was expected to offer traumatic/insulting experiences as case studies for male/British colleagues to learn and so EDI reps can pat themselves on the back.

CountessOfNetflix · 03/12/2022 10:01

I can’t stand all this disappearing up one’s own arsehole ‘lived experience’ shit, mostly peddled by white middle/upper class E&D managers.

If a black person says they have experienced racism, believe them.
If they want to talk to you about it, listen to them.

No to forced sharing at work in order for an organisation to tick some boxes.

randomusername02 · 03/12/2022 10:00

KettrickenSmiled · 03/12/2022 09:55

OP: "listen up white people - other people's experience is valid, let's hear about it & not derail with debate & whataboutery"

PP:* *It's pointless imo. Its not healthy validating every case of someone being offended as an ism, especially in cases where its not been intended or isn't actually an ism.

TRANSLATOR: It doesn't affect ME, I'm Not A Racist But, lived experience isn't real, if people detect racism they are wrong because I say so, insults to other people are just feeding their isms. And they've all got isms - not me of course, I am white a Default Normal Human

Well look at you resorting to use race as an insult. Who's the real racist here?

And again, so presumptious to assume my race, as if women who don't align with your race baiting victimhood must be white. God forbid woc have agency.

dollymixtured · 03/12/2022 10:00

wincarwoo · 03/12/2022 09:54

@randomusername02 no we must keep people in check you're right.

@wincarwoo what about the ‘lived experience’ of members of the klan or paedophiles. Should we simply accept their versions of events? After all who are you to say they are wrong? No group should be unquestioningly validated and listened to, whether it’s #metoo or anything else. There are plenty of POC who would perceive all sorts of racial injustices where I for example would not agree with them (I am a POC for clarity).

bellac11 · 03/12/2022 09:59

cakeorwine · 03/12/2022 09:42

Their experience is a fact that it happened to them.

There are loads of threads on here where people talk about sexism etc. and share their experiences.

A persons 'experience' is only ever their interpretation of something. Its never fact

GCAcademic · 03/12/2022 09:58

KettrickenSmiled · 03/12/2022 09:55

OP: "listen up white people - other people's experience is valid, let's hear about it & not derail with debate & whataboutery"

PP:* *It's pointless imo. Its not healthy validating every case of someone being offended as an ism, especially in cases where its not been intended or isn't actually an ism.

TRANSLATOR: It doesn't affect ME, I'm Not A Racist But, lived experience isn't real, if people detect racism they are wrong because I say so, insults to other people are just feeding their isms. And they've all got isms - not me of course, I am white a Default Normal Human

Interesting that you’re choosing to ignore / straw man the comments from people on this thread who aren’t white.

Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 09:57

randomusername02 · 03/12/2022 09:22

It's pointless imo. Its not healthy validating every case of someone being offended as an ism, especially in cases where its not been intended or isn't actually an ism.

wow the first post, right off the bat!

KettrickenSmiled · 03/12/2022 09:55

randomusername02 · 03/12/2022 09:22

It's pointless imo. Its not healthy validating every case of someone being offended as an ism, especially in cases where its not been intended or isn't actually an ism.

OP: "listen up white people - other people's experience is valid, let's hear about it & not derail with debate & whataboutery"

PP:* *It's pointless imo. Its not healthy validating every case of someone being offended as an ism, especially in cases where its not been intended or isn't actually an ism.

TRANSLATOR: It doesn't affect ME, I'm Not A Racist But, lived experience isn't real, if people detect racism they are wrong because I say so, insults to other people are just feeding their isms. And they've all got isms - not me of course, I am white a Default Normal Human