Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lived experience re racism on Mumsnet

190 replies

lightlypoached · 03/12/2022 09:17

People on a now suspended/ soon to be deleted thread may know why I'm posting this. I was going to post it there but will start a new (soon to be suspended /deleted I'm sure) thread here instead.

At work we did some 'lived experience' sessions where people openly talked about their everyday experiences of sexism , racism and homophopia. The idea was for everyone to listen to the truth of what was being said, and to learn from it. The 'rules' were that you weren't allowed to challenge someone's story as it is their experienced truth. Questions were welcomed and we all learned a great deal. It was a real eye opener.

It helped me to be more aware and to look out for the more insidious words and actions, so that I would not unwittingly do them, and could call others out if I spotted it.

If ever I see racism on here I'll report but the point is that many (a large majority I suspect) of us are white so we don't always understand or see racism (that's a bit shit, but honest).

I think that some 'lived experience' sharing would help immensely. We could have a one-off special thread that would be allowed to refer to content of old threads as well as real life so we can hear specific types of comment that are problematical, and get under the skin of why. Strict rules on contributions though and no debate - all about listening and learning. We could have that as a pinned thread for people to read and learn from.

Is that a daft idea or could it work?

I'd like to be on a site where everyone feels at home , listened to and respected.

So AIBU to suggest we have a one off lived experience thread about racism ?

OP posts:
lightlypoached · 03/12/2022 10:41

@BacklogBritain why wow?

I had always thought that my examples were obvious and accepted racist, offensive behaviours. Seems not always. 🤷‍♀️🤷🏾‍♀️.

OP posts:
Brightstarowl · 03/12/2022 10:40

GCAcademic · 03/12/2022 09:32

No thanks. As a WOC, I’m sick of white people telegraphing their white guilt to make themselves look virtuous. I prefer to go about my life without constantly thinking about my skin colour. But now certain terribly virtuous mildly class white colleagues want me to constantly provide fodder for their activism, and to other me in the process. The kind of event that the OP describes at her work was probably absolutely horrible for those colleagues. Whe. we had a similar thing at my work I ended up in tears and should never have been out in that position. It was utterly othering, with a side order of feeling gawped at. The only people it benefitted was the EDI reps who could make themselves feel like they were doing something.

You must feel so patronised. You should tell them how patronising they are too!

BacklogBritain · 03/12/2022 10:39

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

lightlypoached · 03/12/2022 10:36

@dollymixtured And there you go. I've learned something and challenged my assumptions.

Helpful. (And that's not sarcasm).

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 03/12/2022 10:35

I am sure that some men have changed their behaviour and have called out other men's behaviour after hearing the experiences of women talking about the experiences they have faced.

I can imagine that some people have read threads on MN and on conversations that have appeared in the media and reflected on their behaviours and those of colleagues towards other people whose experiences they have read about.

lightlypoached · 03/12/2022 10:34

Bringing this thread back on topic.

This is a thread about a suggested approach for racism on Mumsnet.

OP posts:
dollymixtured · 03/12/2022 10:34

lightlypoached · 03/12/2022 10:27

Yep, all that corporate virtual signalling is truly shite. I hate it.

BUT the issue we have is that the people being racist don't think about what they are doing/saying and that often comes from ignorance of facts or how it feels to be someone else.

The obvious stuff is easy and everyone should know it (name calling , 'where are you from?' , 'can I touch your hair?' Etc). It's the more subtle stuff and the institutional things that need drawing out. I do think that this approach can help with that.

Take the 'Asian taxi driver' example from another thread. It was in my opinion an entirely spurious addition to the post. Totally irrelevant and the poster apologised. It was good that it was called out. She won't do that again, and other readers will have learned from it (I hope).

My suggestion is to get these types of examples in one place so we can stop this happening.

Even this is riddled with assumptions. I am not clear if you are a WOC or white @lightlypoached but as a woc I can tell you that I person don’t have an issue with ‘can I touch your hair’ or ‘where are you from’. I know that many other woc do find that offensive. But the fact that you refer to it as ‘the obvious stuff’ as if it is a universally agreed fact is half the issue.

Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 10:33

FrippEnos · 03/12/2022 10:27

Except your post is an example of not being a racist isn't enough you have to be 'anti-racist' or you will offend.

I am also loving the term "white people" on a thread about racism.

no it isn’t an example of that - re read the post and point out where I say what you mention. And I didn’t use “white people” in my post.
and grab the nearest dictionary and look up the definition of ‘racism’

bellac11 · 03/12/2022 10:32

Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 10:26

As disingenuous as your comments about listening to the lived experience of the KKK and paedophiles - you’re not engaging in good faith

The trouble is, whether in good faith or not, the comparison is valid and raises an uncomfortable truth which people dont want to consider. Which is why you're dismissing it out of hand

there is a thread somewhere on the site about a twitter post made by Natwest. It would appear to be validating/respecting another post about adult babies, who role play incest and CSA.

Where is the line that is required to make clear that that being disapproving of that behaviour and not being 'respected' by wider society is not a valid lived experience to relay.

Is someone being treated a certain way because of their identity or is someone being treated a certain way because of something they are doing that society disapproves of.

If someone who is gay/black/disabled etc is behaving anti socially, criminally or whatever it is, is their treatment because of their characteristics or is it because of what they are doing? To question that means I am dismissing (perhaps) someones claimed lived experience if they feel its becuase of their characteristics.

PearlclutchersInc · 03/12/2022 10:31

cakeorwine · 03/12/2022 09:37

Would it be different if people were asked to share their experiences of sexism? That happens a lot - there is a whole website devoted to it.

Or their experiences of ageism? Homophobia? Being treated differently because they were disabled?

Sometimes it feels like "my ism trumps your ism" when the reality is that every minority group experiences the same negative behaviour - and sometimes from each other.

dollymixtured · 03/12/2022 10:30

Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 10:26

As disingenuous as your comments about listening to the lived experience of the KKK and paedophiles - you’re not engaging in good faith

No, I very much am. I am just pointing out your hypocrisy. So why don’t you address that.

lightlypoached · 03/12/2022 10:30

stuntbubbles · 03/12/2022 10:16

@lightlypoached One resource that might be helpful is The Other Box – excellent diversity and bias training for the workplace that’s more about making people confront their own experiences and biases rather than making other people relive theirs.

That's helpful. I'll look it up. Thanks.

OP posts:
dollymixtured · 03/12/2022 10:28

wincarwoo · 03/12/2022 10:25

@dollymixtured then we will agree to disagree.

Genuinely not trying to start a fight, but how do you justify which ‘lived experiences’ you validate and which you dismiss? And do you not think that by doing this you are merely reinforcing whatever views/prejudices you already have?

cakeorwine · 03/12/2022 10:27

cakeorwine · 03/12/2022 10:25

If someone says something happened to them / this is how they were treated, I believe them.

I can't say if it happened to them because of their identity.

But if more people share similar experiences. patterns build.

And I don't believe that all people are treated the same regardless of their identity by all people, institutions etc.

FrippEnos · 03/12/2022 10:27

Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 10:19

No, the rules of what constitutes being non discriminatory and respectful towards others haven’t changed, it’s just that those who still have the levers of power in society are now being challenged about their discrimination and disrespect. Then people who don’t like being challenged or who don’t like to think before they speak say things like “the rules change by the hour so I’ll keep my mouth shut lest I offend someone” (implied: “those” people are over sensitive and don’t know what they want)

Except your post is an example of not being a racist isn't enough you have to be 'anti-racist' or you will offend.

I am also loving the term "white people" on a thread about racism.

lightlypoached · 03/12/2022 10:27

CountessOfNetflix · 03/12/2022 10:01

I can’t stand all this disappearing up one’s own arsehole ‘lived experience’ shit, mostly peddled by white middle/upper class E&D managers.

If a black person says they have experienced racism, believe them.
If they want to talk to you about it, listen to them.

No to forced sharing at work in order for an organisation to tick some boxes.

Yep, all that corporate virtual signalling is truly shite. I hate it.

BUT the issue we have is that the people being racist don't think about what they are doing/saying and that often comes from ignorance of facts or how it feels to be someone else.

The obvious stuff is easy and everyone should know it (name calling , 'where are you from?' , 'can I touch your hair?' Etc). It's the more subtle stuff and the institutional things that need drawing out. I do think that this approach can help with that.

Take the 'Asian taxi driver' example from another thread. It was in my opinion an entirely spurious addition to the post. Totally irrelevant and the poster apologised. It was good that it was called out. She won't do that again, and other readers will have learned from it (I hope).

My suggestion is to get these types of examples in one place so we can stop this happening.

OP posts:
Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 10:26

dollymixtured · 03/12/2022 10:20

Sorry, this seems very much like you are challenging the PPs ‘lived experience’ because you don’t agree. Tut tut, that’s not allowed.

As disingenuous as your comments about listening to the lived experience of the KKK and paedophiles - you’re not engaging in good faith

cakeorwine · 03/12/2022 10:25

If someone says something happened to them / this is how they were treated, I believe them.

I can't say if it happened to them because of their identity.

But if more people share similar experiences. patterns build.

wincarwoo · 03/12/2022 10:25

@dollymixtured then we will agree to disagree.

dollymixtured · 03/12/2022 10:22

wincarwoo · 03/12/2022 10:20

@dollymixtured it's disingenuous false equivalence. So no it's not worth engaging with.

No it’s really not. Either ‘lived experience’ is to be validated or it isn’t. You can’t just choose whose ‘lived experience’ you believe
in.

dollymixtured · 03/12/2022 10:20

Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 10:19

No, the rules of what constitutes being non discriminatory and respectful towards others haven’t changed, it’s just that those who still have the levers of power in society are now being challenged about their discrimination and disrespect. Then people who don’t like being challenged or who don’t like to think before they speak say things like “the rules change by the hour so I’ll keep my mouth shut lest I offend someone” (implied: “those” people are over sensitive and don’t know what they want)

Sorry, this seems very much like you are challenging the PPs ‘lived experience’ because you don’t agree. Tut tut, that’s not allowed.

KnickerlessParsons · 03/12/2022 10:20

If ever I see racism on here I'll report but the point is that many (a large majority I suspect) of us are white so we don't always understand or see racism (that's a bit shit, but honest)

White people can experience racism too. I'm Welsh. During my time at work I've reported three people for racism: for continuing with their racist remarks even after I'd pointed out that they were racist, not funny, and very wearing when repeated ad infinitum.

wincarwoo · 03/12/2022 10:20

@dollymixtured it's disingenuous false equivalence. So no it's not worth engaging with.

lightlypoached · 03/12/2022 10:19

category12 · 03/12/2022 09:53

Isn't this just asking people of colour to educate white people?

If you want to think of it like that, then yes.

And if you are sick of educating people then don't participate.

The previous thread discussion was all about the rise of racism in Mumsnet but because of the TAAT rule people couldn't be specific. I think (and I would find it useful) to be specific.

In my experience on sexism it's often the insidious less overt stuff that makes me angry and grind my teeth. And it may help to expose that so we can see it for what it is and how it feels to people affected by it.

OP posts:
Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 10:19

Georgeskitchen · 03/12/2022 10:10

Given that the rules on what is/isn't acceptable seem.to change by the hour, its probably not a good idea.
Keeping ones mouth firmly shut is the best way to avoid offending anyone, either intentionally or not

No, the rules of what constitutes being non discriminatory and respectful towards others haven’t changed, it’s just that those who still have the levers of power in society are now being challenged about their discrimination and disrespect. Then people who don’t like being challenged or who don’t like to think before they speak say things like “the rules change by the hour so I’ll keep my mouth shut lest I offend someone” (implied: “those” people are over sensitive and don’t know what they want)