Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lived experience re racism on Mumsnet

190 replies

lightlypoached · 03/12/2022 09:17

People on a now suspended/ soon to be deleted thread may know why I'm posting this. I was going to post it there but will start a new (soon to be suspended /deleted I'm sure) thread here instead.

At work we did some 'lived experience' sessions where people openly talked about their everyday experiences of sexism , racism and homophopia. The idea was for everyone to listen to the truth of what was being said, and to learn from it. The 'rules' were that you weren't allowed to challenge someone's story as it is their experienced truth. Questions were welcomed and we all learned a great deal. It was a real eye opener.

It helped me to be more aware and to look out for the more insidious words and actions, so that I would not unwittingly do them, and could call others out if I spotted it.

If ever I see racism on here I'll report but the point is that many (a large majority I suspect) of us are white so we don't always understand or see racism (that's a bit shit, but honest).

I think that some 'lived experience' sharing would help immensely. We could have a one-off special thread that would be allowed to refer to content of old threads as well as real life so we can hear specific types of comment that are problematical, and get under the skin of why. Strict rules on contributions though and no debate - all about listening and learning. We could have that as a pinned thread for people to read and learn from.

Is that a daft idea or could it work?

I'd like to be on a site where everyone feels at home , listened to and respected.

So AIBU to suggest we have a one off lived experience thread about racism ?

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 03/12/2022 11:40

You havent in all your posts been able to set out an argument as to why everyone's lived experience should be validated and whether that is a flawed concept

What do you mean validated?

If I tell you something has happened to me, you can believe me or not.

If I say that I think it was because I am (insert identity here), then that is my opinion.

What happened to me is a fact. It's an opinion that it happened because of my identity.

You don't have to believe my opinion. Would you believe my experience?

bellac11 · 03/12/2022 11:17

Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 11:13

It’s on me, really. I shouldn’t have engaged with pp who say that if we consider the lived experience of PoC then we have to consider the lived experience of the KKK. What a great example of false equivalency. I bit the bait.

That was not what was being suggested, it is the concept that everyone's lived experience is valid and cant be questioned/challenged/explored

You havent in all your posts been able to set out an argument as to why everyone's lived experience should be validated and whether that is a flawed concept. Who do you pick and choose?

Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 11:13

It’s on me, really. I shouldn’t have engaged with pp who say that if we consider the lived experience of PoC then we have to consider the lived experience of the KKK. What a great example of false equivalency. I bit the bait.

greentrees9 · 03/12/2022 11:12

dollymixtured · 03/12/2022 10:47

newsflash - we can all say what we want (within the law). Your hurt feelings/offense/upset are for you to manage they might be reasonable they might not. The idea that everyone who is offended by something is automatically in the right is hugely dangerous.

But hate speech isn’t legal? Racism, homophobia isn’t free speech?

Brightstarowl · 03/12/2022 11:07

GCAcademic · 03/12/2022 11:01

Oh, I complained about it to my boss (who was in the room at this event and saw how upset I was). But he didn’t care because he’s only interested in his own career, which seems to require signalling to the higher ups that he’s Doing Something wrt EDI.

Good on you for raising a complaint, it's a shame it fell on deaf ears.

This patronising belittling attitude needs to get in the bin.

LondonWolf · 03/12/2022 11:02

GCAcademic · 03/12/2022 09:32

No thanks. As a WOC, I’m sick of white people telegraphing their white guilt to make themselves look virtuous. I prefer to go about my life without constantly thinking about my skin colour. But now certain terribly virtuous mildly class white colleagues want me to constantly provide fodder for their activism, and to other me in the process. The kind of event that the OP describes at her work was probably absolutely horrible for those colleagues. Whe. we had a similar thing at my work I ended up in tears and should never have been out in that position. It was utterly othering, with a side order of feeling gawped at. The only people it benefitted was the EDI reps who could make themselves feel like they were doing something.

Thank you for explaining this despite it obviously being a difficult experience. I'm sorry it was like that for you. I think it's really important for people to consider this side. So much of this rhetoric seems to be about white people self importantly declaiming their unwanted support! When many POC say they find it divisive and infantilising.

MilkyYay · 03/12/2022 11:02

Also our (Muslim, pakistani heritage) diversity rep at work once suggested to our team that in his experience of living and working in the uk & us, in the UK the class problem is bigger than race (notwithstanding a degree of these being interlinked). He pointed out our (highly paid) professional team was exceptionally diverse.... but we were all from affluent backgrounds, many from private schools, all from russell group universities etc.

Case in point being kwasi kwarteng. In the UK an upper middle class, eton & oxbridge educated black person, is more likely to appear in the cabinet, as a barrister or in a top law firm/ as a doctor, than a white person from a deprived working class background

GCAcademic · 03/12/2022 11:01

Brightstarowl · 03/12/2022 10:40

You must feel so patronised. You should tell them how patronising they are too!

Oh, I complained about it to my boss (who was in the room at this event and saw how upset I was). But he didn’t care because he’s only interested in his own career, which seems to require signalling to the higher ups that he’s Doing Something wrt EDI.

cakeorwine · 03/12/2022 11:01

medicatedgift · 03/12/2022 10:57

This.

I suspect that some of the experiences are so common that it wouldn't be identifying at all. Probably be a lot of people saying "Yes, I get that. That could have been about me. Or one of my family. Or a friend'"

Of course - the comments would be the worst.

leilani83 · 03/12/2022 11:00

lightlypoached · 03/12/2022 10:12

@AbsoluteYawns

As mentioned in my post it helped me at work to understand a perspective I never usually see and it allowed my colleagues who chose to talk (no one was forced, or forced to attend) about how things are for them, what drives them nuts.

I agree with a PP that 'performative' or forced initiatives can be bloody awful, counter productive and indulgent.

I do think there are challenges with the approach though - what one person finds acceptable, another finds abhorrent but even with that risk I think that open discussion helps to get issues out in the open where we can start address them.

It's just about listening and learning. Not everyone is the same and not everyone wants to participate. That's fine.

I do like the principle that truth has validity too. It may not be a widespread or representative truth, but if someone feels like that then they feel like that, and it matters.

I do remember back in the 70s and 80s where men at work would slyly say 'but I didn't mean to be offensive' . But they were. And I used to point out that intent was not the issue, that they had been offensive. To me. And that mattered. We have made progress on workplace sexism owing to people like me sharing what it's like to be a woman at work (it's just we didn't cal, it shared experience then, we just called it 'speaking up').

I've spent a lifetime as a woman working in a male dominated workplace and have struggled often with both blatant and insidious sexism. I welcome discussions where male colleagues can hear directly about how their attitudes, language and behaviour affect me, my performance and happiness at work. And in some cases some of them have actually listened, learned and changed. That how progress can be made.

I agree with you.

medicatedgift · 03/12/2022 10:57

Itchintobestitchin · 03/12/2022 10:52

I think that sharing very personal experiences on a public forum, where lazy journalists regularly copy and paste posts into articles for popular news websites, is a bad idea.

This.

MilkyYay · 03/12/2022 10:56

I want to listen & hear if people voluntarily choose to share but i don't like situations of forced participation or when its driven by woke (usually white) HR types.

I find it much more enlightening to hear experiences on a personal level eg from friends or neighbours i know well.

lightlypoached · 03/12/2022 10:55

Itchintobestitchin · 03/12/2022 10:52

I think that sharing very personal experiences on a public forum, where lazy journalists regularly copy and paste posts into articles for popular news websites, is a bad idea.

Yes, that's a point. Fecking Daily fecking Mail.

OP posts:
lightlypoached · 03/12/2022 10:55

@DuchessofSandwich

"I agree with you but I never dared to say it because I'm white. I feel that constantly pointing out difference in skin colour makes discrimination worse. Of course any racism should be combated but if there's nothing going on then we shouldn't go on about the difference between people but just go on with our lives"

I see what you are saying and what @GCAcademic says too. As with all things those who want to speak up and be heard should be, and those who want to just get on with it should too. We would be nowhere on sex and pay equality if we'd adopted the approach that we are all equal and so nothing more to expose , do, measure or say. As it is on the feminist front pressure was kept on and equal pay is back on the agenda. If we hadn't talked about the difference between men and women then it would still be festering under the carpet.

There's a balance to be had but I don't think we can ignore differences entirely - mainly because some people are discriminatory bastards.

OP posts:
FrippEnos · 03/12/2022 10:54

Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 10:47

Have a good day and enjoy yourself playing avoidance games

What exactly am I avoiding?

Itchintobestitchin · 03/12/2022 10:52

I think that sharing very personal experiences on a public forum, where lazy journalists regularly copy and paste posts into articles for popular news websites, is a bad idea.

bellac11 · 03/12/2022 10:52

Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 10:42

If people with those characteristics commit a crime, to use your example, they should deal with proportionate consequences.

Eg charging George Floyd with whatever crime corresponds to using fake currency to pay for goods would not have been racist, also as long as it is not the case that only those who are black/a minority (or other protected characteristic) are the only ones who are charged with what is otherwise a ‘petty’ crime.

why are pp bringing paedophiles, the KKK, those who like to role play CSA, etc into a thread about racism? Why do you feel the need to digress so wildly and bring these criminal/immoral elements into the discussion?

A poster made the point that validating someones lived experience is a flawed concept because its not a neutral issue. If you validate and respect and believe someones lived experience that goes across the board and that includes apparent lived experiences of people like those you mention

Therefore it is not a concept that is universally accepted and nor should it be

Someone else has mentioned that people's feelings are valid. Are they? Who says? Feelings are notoriously unreliable.

dollymixtured · 03/12/2022 10:48

Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 10:42

If people with those characteristics commit a crime, to use your example, they should deal with proportionate consequences.

Eg charging George Floyd with whatever crime corresponds to using fake currency to pay for goods would not have been racist, also as long as it is not the case that only those who are black/a minority (or other protected characteristic) are the only ones who are charged with what is otherwise a ‘petty’ crime.

why are pp bringing paedophiles, the KKK, those who like to role play CSA, etc into a thread about racism? Why do you feel the need to digress so wildly and bring these criminal/immoral elements into the discussion?

Because people are making blanket statements about how ‘lived experience’ should just be unquestioningly validated and accepted as correct.

DuchessofSandwich · 03/12/2022 10:48

GCAcademic · 03/12/2022 09:32

No thanks. As a WOC, I’m sick of white people telegraphing their white guilt to make themselves look virtuous. I prefer to go about my life without constantly thinking about my skin colour. But now certain terribly virtuous mildly class white colleagues want me to constantly provide fodder for their activism, and to other me in the process. The kind of event that the OP describes at her work was probably absolutely horrible for those colleagues. Whe. we had a similar thing at my work I ended up in tears and should never have been out in that position. It was utterly othering, with a side order of feeling gawped at. The only people it benefitted was the EDI reps who could make themselves feel like they were doing something.

I agree with you but I never dared to say it because I'm white. I feel that constantly pointing out difference in skin colour makes discrimination worse. Of course any racism should be combated but if there's nothing going on then we shouldn't go on about the difference between people but just go on with our lives together.

lightlypoached · 03/12/2022 10:48

@GCAcademic that's sounds bloody horrible.

I can totally relate to the 'I just want to do my job, be recognised fairly for it, and have the same opportunities as everyone else without having to analyse and think about it all the fecking time'. Or be touted as the diversity woman in the organisation to tick a box. I get it. There are times though where (the sexism (in my case) has just become too much and I've had to expose it. It's all just so exhausting.

OP posts:
Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 10:47

FrippEnos · 03/12/2022 10:42

I said that the term "white people" was used on the thread, So your request for me to reread is somewhat Ironic.

And which definition would you like?
There is the sociology definition and there is the individual definition?

I have noticed a lot of racists like the sociology definition as it absolves them of their racism.

Have a good day and enjoy yourself playing avoidance games

dollymixtured · 03/12/2022 10:47

greentrees9 · 03/12/2022 10:42

but if someone is being subject to comments or behaviour due to a perceived difference the person making the offence doesn't have the right to say it wasn't intended that way....if someone is othering someone, or being racist or insensitive or homophobic - its the person experiencing this whose feelings are valid. Otherwise we can all say what we want, with no consequence for the impact / influence on others.

newsflash - we can all say what we want (within the law). Your hurt feelings/offense/upset are for you to manage they might be reasonable they might not. The idea that everyone who is offended by something is automatically in the right is hugely dangerous.

Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 10:42

bellac11 · 03/12/2022 10:32

The trouble is, whether in good faith or not, the comparison is valid and raises an uncomfortable truth which people dont want to consider. Which is why you're dismissing it out of hand

there is a thread somewhere on the site about a twitter post made by Natwest. It would appear to be validating/respecting another post about adult babies, who role play incest and CSA.

Where is the line that is required to make clear that that being disapproving of that behaviour and not being 'respected' by wider society is not a valid lived experience to relay.

Is someone being treated a certain way because of their identity or is someone being treated a certain way because of something they are doing that society disapproves of.

If someone who is gay/black/disabled etc is behaving anti socially, criminally or whatever it is, is their treatment because of their characteristics or is it because of what they are doing? To question that means I am dismissing (perhaps) someones claimed lived experience if they feel its becuase of their characteristics.

If people with those characteristics commit a crime, to use your example, they should deal with proportionate consequences.

Eg charging George Floyd with whatever crime corresponds to using fake currency to pay for goods would not have been racist, also as long as it is not the case that only those who are black/a minority (or other protected characteristic) are the only ones who are charged with what is otherwise a ‘petty’ crime.

why are pp bringing paedophiles, the KKK, those who like to role play CSA, etc into a thread about racism? Why do you feel the need to digress so wildly and bring these criminal/immoral elements into the discussion?

FrippEnos · 03/12/2022 10:42

Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 10:33

no it isn’t an example of that - re read the post and point out where I say what you mention. And I didn’t use “white people” in my post.
and grab the nearest dictionary and look up the definition of ‘racism’

I said that the term "white people" was used on the thread, So your request for me to reread is somewhat Ironic.

And which definition would you like?
There is the sociology definition and there is the individual definition?

I have noticed a lot of racists like the sociology definition as it absolves them of their racism.

greentrees9 · 03/12/2022 10:42

randomusername02 · 03/12/2022 09:22

It's pointless imo. Its not healthy validating every case of someone being offended as an ism, especially in cases where its not been intended or isn't actually an ism.

but if someone is being subject to comments or behaviour due to a perceived difference the person making the offence doesn't have the right to say it wasn't intended that way....if someone is othering someone, or being racist or insensitive or homophobic - its the person experiencing this whose feelings are valid. Otherwise we can all say what we want, with no consequence for the impact / influence on others.

Swipe left for the next trending thread