Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lived experience re racism on Mumsnet

190 replies

lightlypoached · 03/12/2022 09:17

People on a now suspended/ soon to be deleted thread may know why I'm posting this. I was going to post it there but will start a new (soon to be suspended /deleted I'm sure) thread here instead.

At work we did some 'lived experience' sessions where people openly talked about their everyday experiences of sexism , racism and homophopia. The idea was for everyone to listen to the truth of what was being said, and to learn from it. The 'rules' were that you weren't allowed to challenge someone's story as it is their experienced truth. Questions were welcomed and we all learned a great deal. It was a real eye opener.

It helped me to be more aware and to look out for the more insidious words and actions, so that I would not unwittingly do them, and could call others out if I spotted it.

If ever I see racism on here I'll report but the point is that many (a large majority I suspect) of us are white so we don't always understand or see racism (that's a bit shit, but honest).

I think that some 'lived experience' sharing would help immensely. We could have a one-off special thread that would be allowed to refer to content of old threads as well as real life so we can hear specific types of comment that are problematical, and get under the skin of why. Strict rules on contributions though and no debate - all about listening and learning. We could have that as a pinned thread for people to read and learn from.

Is that a daft idea or could it work?

I'd like to be on a site where everyone feels at home , listened to and respected.

So AIBU to suggest we have a one off lived experience thread about racism ?

OP posts:
dollymixtured · 03/12/2022 19:13

Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 19:09

I would never dispute the fact that Ireland was indeed colonised, exploited and denigrated. Your boss reporting you to the police and referring to you as “it” is horrific.

‘Irish’ however isn’t a race so anti-Irish sentiment/actions/etc isn’t racism. It is discrimination and a specific kind of xenophobia, but not racism. You should be able to share your experience as discrimination.

Ooops there you go again, policing what people can and cannot share as their 'lived experience'. Your hypocrisy is quite impressive. No hint of self awareness.

Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 19:13

dollymixtured · 03/12/2022 16:33

Where has anyone said that?

It’s in the same vein as your “if the lived experience of PoC should be considered then so should that of paedophiles and KKK members”

no?

cakeorwine · 03/12/2022 19:13

dollymixtured · 03/12/2022 19:08

Another one who should never be allowed near jury duty.

Would you enlighten us all then with your opinion then?

Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 19:12

unsureatthispoint · 03/12/2022 18:28

That ship has sailed OP I'm afraid

From the moment a cause is used for justification of toppling statues and getting people fired for 'microagressions' a lot of support will be lost

People have a duty to look out for their own and try to change things that affect them and their family personally. Nobody is owed 'allyship' and the way activism has been conducted in this matter is wrong IMO

I'm also not a fan of 'no debate' in general

“People have a duty to look out for their own”

care to expand, in this context?

Orangepolentacake · 03/12/2022 19:09

SomebodyMcSomebody · 03/12/2022 14:39

@808Kate1 Thanks Kate. I was told by our office manager who was shocked. My boss apparently pointed at her and said ‘Should we tell them (the police) about it?’

I was ‘it’.

She was horrified, but frankly I wish she had not told me. I was so mortified and stunned, I couldn’t tell anyone. I didn’t think my English friends would understand, or worried that they too might judge me.

But now, when we did have workplace racism sharing stories, I feel unable to share mine as being anti-Irish isn’t counted as racism. Even though Ireland was also colonised and exploited and denigrated as inferior. I appreciate others have it worse, but I still consider that was racist, and blatantly so.

I would never dispute the fact that Ireland was indeed colonised, exploited and denigrated. Your boss reporting you to the police and referring to you as “it” is horrific.

‘Irish’ however isn’t a race so anti-Irish sentiment/actions/etc isn’t racism. It is discrimination and a specific kind of xenophobia, but not racism. You should be able to share your experience as discrimination.

dollymixtured · 03/12/2022 19:08

stuntbubbles · 03/12/2022 19:01

I’d love to see the police trying to get a witness statement out of that poster:

Couldn’t tell you if it was a man or a woman, officer, it would be purely opinion.
The weather? Wouldn’t like to say.
What did the offender do? Well, that would be conjecture.
Time of day – not in a position to say it as fact.

Another one who should never be allowed near jury duty.

stuntbubbles · 03/12/2022 19:01

cakeorwine · 03/12/2022 18:28

Can you tell me what you think is fact and opinion in my statement?

I’d love to see the police trying to get a witness statement out of that poster:

Couldn’t tell you if it was a man or a woman, officer, it would be purely opinion.
The weather? Wouldn’t like to say.
What did the offender do? Well, that would be conjecture.
Time of day – not in a position to say it as fact.

unsureatthispoint · 03/12/2022 18:31

If I tell you something happened, it happened.
A man called me 'love' and offered to help me change a car tyre.
That happened. It's a fact

People also have the ability to lie. There's a reason why the word 'lie' exists. The current trend of forcing others to accept things at face value is worrying

unsureatthispoint · 03/12/2022 18:28

That ship has sailed OP I'm afraid

From the moment a cause is used for justification of toppling statues and getting people fired for 'microagressions' a lot of support will be lost

People have a duty to look out for their own and try to change things that affect them and their family personally. Nobody is owed 'allyship' and the way activism has been conducted in this matter is wrong IMO

I'm also not a fan of 'no debate' in general

cakeorwine · 03/12/2022 18:28

dollymixtured · 03/12/2022 18:24

I really hope you are never on jury duty! You have repeatedly demonstrated your difficulty with understanding the difference between facts and opinions so I will leave it there, as I have neither the time nor inclination to explain things to you over and over again.

Can you tell me what you think is fact and opinion in my statement?

dollymixtured · 03/12/2022 18:24

cakeorwine · 03/12/2022 18:16

It's a fact.
He called me love and asked if he could help me change my tyre.

What are you disputing?

If I said it's raining, that's a fact.
I didn't say why it was raining. That's an opinion.

I really hope you are never on jury duty! You have repeatedly demonstrated your difficulty with understanding the difference between facts and opinions so I will leave it there, as I have neither the time nor inclination to explain things to you over and over again.

cakeorwine · 03/12/2022 18:16

dollymixtured · 03/12/2022 12:17

No it’s not a fact! It’s your understanding and interpretation of a series of circumstances and interactions. The facts might be your car tyre burst and there was a man there. The rest is just your recount.

It's a fact.
He called me love and asked if he could help me change my tyre.

What are you disputing?

If I said it's raining, that's a fact.
I didn't say why it was raining. That's an opinion.

dollymixtured · 03/12/2022 16:33

pocketvenuss · 03/12/2022 15:55

So if any woman cries rape we must believe them but if a non white person cries racism we don't? Explain please

Where has anyone said that?

Thelnebriati · 03/12/2022 16:12

I've become suspicious of this kind of exercise in the workplace, because the event becomes the activism, and a replacement for meaningful change.
I'd also like to be on a site where everyone feels at home, listened to and respected; but I don't think that's possible on a forum with open membership, so I consider it a work in progress.

pocketvenuss · 03/12/2022 15:55

So if any woman cries rape we must believe them but if a non white person cries racism we don't? Explain please

Puzzledandpissedoff · 03/12/2022 15:41

The idea that everyone who is offended by something is automatically in the right is hugely dangerous

IME this can also be an issue when conflicting "isms" come into play - something which can send MN into a tailspin

I've mentioned this on here before, but when training I was lucky enough to get a particular, very senior lady in the sector to address the group, only to receive a demand for her removal from one of the men present because he considered that being tutored by a woman was deeply offensive

As it happened he was asian and a muslim - something he emphasised very strongly in an attempt to justify his stance - but between sex and race I've often wondered which protected characteristic some would consider the priority

HRTQueen · 03/12/2022 15:25

MN moderators need to be more aware that would be better

but they are defensive and seem to feel they are doing things correctly

there is always room for improvement

lightlypoached · 03/12/2022 15:18

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Yes bloody awful 😣

OP posts:
lightlypoached · 03/12/2022 15:16

Summary so far re lived experience comments on this thread:

  • some people hate lived experience in the workplace (but not much expressed about how/whether it might work on here?)
  • some are worried that shared stories would be taken by the fecking daily fecking mail
  • some people feel that being asked for their experience is not appropriate, is painful, sometimes upsetting and that data can be got from other sources so please don't ask them to do it (again!)
  • some people think it's perfomative, virtue signalling and an indulgence for the white middle classes
  • and a couple think that it's not a valid approach at all.
  • some people think it's a good idea

Did I miss any themes?

An interesting mix of opinion. Clearly a difficult and divisive subject.

It's given me a bit to think about, especially in a work context (I'm not HR or DandI lead, just care about equality and decent treatment of people). It's also offered up a couple of good sources to read (thanks for those suggestions).

OP posts:
BacklogBritain · 03/12/2022 15:13

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

SomebodyMcSomebody · 03/12/2022 14:39

@808Kate1 Thanks Kate. I was told by our office manager who was shocked. My boss apparently pointed at her and said ‘Should we tell them (the police) about it?’

I was ‘it’.

She was horrified, but frankly I wish she had not told me. I was so mortified and stunned, I couldn’t tell anyone. I didn’t think my English friends would understand, or worried that they too might judge me.

But now, when we did have workplace racism sharing stories, I feel unable to share mine as being anti-Irish isn’t counted as racism. Even though Ireland was also colonised and exploited and denigrated as inferior. I appreciate others have it worse, but I still consider that was racist, and blatantly so.

BacklogBritain · 03/12/2022 14:22

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Cherrysherbet · 03/12/2022 14:13

This is so sad.

snowqu33n · 03/12/2022 14:08

Why can’t people just read the information that people have already put out there?
There’s loads.
I found ”Natives” by Akala very informative.

GCAcademic · 03/12/2022 14:05

C8H10N4O2 · 03/12/2022 13:56

@lightlypoached
As mentioned in my post it helped me at work to understand a perspective I never usually see and it allowed my colleagues who chose to talk (no one was forced, or forced to attend) about how things are for them, what drives them nuts

You are underestimating the extent to which minorities end up feeling obliged to participate, knowing that there will be that slight hesitation, slight pause when you are asked and say 'no'. Because you are not playing the game, after all how can middle class white liberals possibly be expected to understand my experience if I don't spill my guts on a regular basis? Then they expect plaudits for sitting and listening, even though there is rarely any identifiable change in behaviour.

Damned if we do, damned if we don't.

As a woman in heavily male dominated industry I have often shared my experiences with other women in mentoring and women's groups. What you are describing is the equivalent of "the totty" being shared out for the entertainment of men - my life experiences are not available for virtue signalling (usually) white, MC liberals who could get exactly the same information by reading up on the subject.

For sure. My manager was pissed off with me that I wasn’t playing the game. The game is to get him (a mediocre white man already promoted way beyond his abilities) his next promotion.