Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is in the wrong here? Re two car drivers.

116 replies

Chocolatereindeerr · 02/12/2022 19:26

Please tell me who is in the wrong here.. I understand it’s probably both but what would happen if it went to insurance?

I was passenger in car A.

car A- fails to stop behind a parked vehicle and give way to oncoming vehicle but would of made it round in enough time if the oncoming car went appropriate speed.

car B- on coming. Notices car A has not given way and puts his foot down and aggressively speeds up towards car A.

the result of this was both cars clipping wing mirrors but could have been worse.

car A pulls over as wing mirror was pushed in and 30 seconds later Car B has turned round and parked behind car A.

Car B driver gets out his car and aggressively starts shouting that Car A driver has knocked his wing mirror off. car A driver apologies and mentions that car B driver was coming fast and that he should of slowed down. Car B driver agrees to putting his foot down but said that it’s his right of way, he wasn’t stopping.

who is in the wrong?

OP posts:
piedbeauty · 02/12/2022 22:12

Becca's = because

piedbeauty · 02/12/2022 22:07

Hmm. Car B was being an impatient, aggressive twat.

If car A had time to pass the parked car after correctly judging the current speed of car B, then they were in the right. There was only a problem Becca's car B was a dick.

If car A had started their manoeuvre, they are allowed to finish it, and Car B should have waited.

PopGoesTheProsecco · 02/12/2022 21:42

Legally car A.

NalaNana · 02/12/2022 21:41

@WatchoRulo I am sometimes skeptical when I hear it but the OP was the passenger in the car and I don't think anyone on here can claim to have a more accurate version of events. According to the OP the driver also admitted to putting his foot down!

WatchoRulo · 02/12/2022 21:38

Does anyone else take these "the other driver sped up" stories with a pinch of salt?
1.It's very hard to estimate the speed of a car coming the other way.
2.I have been accused of it when I didn't - but also didn't immediately stand on the brakes due to the action of another driver - which made it apparent that their judgement (in pulling out straight in front of me when the road was clear behind) was flawed.

amicissimma · 02/12/2022 21:26

Car A is in the wrong. You are not allowed to drive on the wrong side of the road when someone is coming just because you decide they could be going too fast.

Indeed, sometimes when I'm in Car B's position and see a Car A waiting, I might speed up a little so that A doesn't have to wait so long. Not to be aggressive but as a courtesy to A. Specially if I know there is other traffic coming up behind me and if I get a move on A will be able to nip through after me, but if I take my time A will have to wait for C, D, E and F behind me. I wouldn't be impressed if A decided s/he didn't like my speed and barged through in my path, wacking my mirror.

cleanfreak12345 · 02/12/2022 21:22

Both drivers sound like bad drivers

One driving too fast, speeding up when there's a potential hazard, the other not giving way when there's an obstacle on their side of the road

You are meant to give way if there's an obstacle on your side of the road. What normally happens is that whoever gets there first goes through lol

Frabbits · 02/12/2022 21:17

I mean, yeah it's not great to not give way to an oncoming car in this situation, but what driver b should do is allow car A to finish the maneouver.

Speeding up and causing an accident in response to a mistake or at worst a lapse in judgement is far more of a dick move IMO.

NalaNana · 02/12/2022 21:16

@DownNative from the OP driver A would have had suitable room to complete the manoeuvre had driver B not sped up.

You can only make that judgement in the moment based on what you can see ahead of you.

It's not the case that simply seeing an oncoming vehicle means you can't overtake parked cars, in most cities parked cars litter the sides of the roads and no one would be able to go anywhere.

A reasonable driver wouldn't expect an oncoming vehicle to speed up to such an extent that the manoeuvre can no longer be completed and result in a car accident!

CaptainThe95thRifles · 02/12/2022 21:12

It's theoretically possible that car B was half a kilometer away when A pulled out around the obstruction, and that B floored it so that A didn't have time to pull back in. The concept of a "suitable gap" does rely on the other driver behaving in accordance with the speed limit.

B would be in the wrong in those (admittedly unlikely) circumstances, but it would be a devil to prove it without dashcam / other video footage or independent witnesses.

username8888 · 02/12/2022 21:09

If you are overtaking a long line of parked vehicles with no gap to pull in and you start the manoeuvre before there is a sighting of an oncoming car then they should give way to you.

I think this is what people are trying to use as an excuse for car a. However car a's actions do not fit this scenario.

DownNative · 02/12/2022 21:07

NalaNana · 02/12/2022 20:44

@DownNative surely there's something in the Highway Code about not speeding up to drive into other vehicles, and if there isn't, there really should be! Two wrongs don't make a right, I can't see that being anything other than a knock on.

Obviously if driver B hadn't sped up to ensure that driver A didn't have enough time, and was surprised by their overtaking without time to stop their own vehicle, then I would be siding with driver B.

Yes, sure.

But if you're going to overtake a vehicle or other obstructions on YOUR side of the road, onus is on you to ensure the road ahead is sufficiently clear......i.e., 1m clearance space to pass obstructions safely AND more space to ensure you can pull in without cutting in.

Driver A failed by every possible measure in Highway Code Rule 162 and 163! Therefore, fault is more with A than B.

Lesson for A - don't be so impatient to overtake, leave considerably more room than you think you need and give way in future.

Loics · 02/12/2022 21:04

Car A will be found to be at fault.

username8888 · 02/12/2022 21:04

potchy · 02/12/2022 19:38

Car A was wrong in terms of the Highway Code because B had right of way.

Insurance wise A would be held liable.

What a contradictory post

username8888 · 02/12/2022 21:02

Car a. Should have stopped. End of. Being a dick doesn't put you in the wrong in this situation

DownNative · 02/12/2022 20:53

Wednesdayonline · 02/12/2022 19:41

The highway code doesn't actually say you have to give way if there's an obstruction ie a parked car on your side of the road. It's whoever commits first, so if car A was already passing the obstacle and car B carried on coming, then car B is in the wrong especially if they carried on speeding up when they had a chance to stop and wait.

Really?

Highway Code Rule 162 and 163:

  1. Overtaking (162 to 169)

162

Before overtaking you should make sure:

the road is sufficiently clear ahead

road users are not beginning to overtake you

there is a suitable gap in front of the road user you plan to overtake.

Overtake only when it is safe and legal to do so. You should

• move quickly past the vehicle you are overtaking, once you have started to overtake. Allow plenty of room. Move back to the left as soon as you can but do not cut in

• give way to oncoming vehicles BEFORE passing parked vehicles or other obstructions on your side of the road

Car A didn't ensure the road ahead was sufficiently clear. Didn't leave a suitable gap in front. Didn't allow plenty of room. Clearly thought they could cut back in front of Car B. Didn't give way to the oncoming Car B beforehand.

Toetouchingtitties · 02/12/2022 20:46

Were either cars travelling up an incline / hill? The vehicle coming up the hill has right of way.

NalaNana · 02/12/2022 20:44

@DownNative surely there's something in the Highway Code about not speeding up to drive into other vehicles, and if there isn't, there really should be! Two wrongs don't make a right, I can't see that being anything other than a knock on.

Obviously if driver B hadn't sped up to ensure that driver A didn't have enough time, and was surprised by their overtaking without time to stop their own vehicle, then I would be siding with driver B.

InSummertime · 02/12/2022 20:43

Smarshian · 02/12/2022 19:37

Car A was on wrong side of the road. Their fault every time.

This and you won’t be able to prove the speed of B or that they acted aggressively

CarPoor · 02/12/2022 20:43

startfresh · 02/12/2022 19:51

Car A. I currently see this daily but it's a whole queue of cars passing a hazard and stopping the correct lane from proceeding. It's really pissing me off. The just keep going without understanding how to actually drive. I once had a woman try it to me and I stopped, she was pissed and gesturing for me to go back (as she had others behind her) and I refused as she should not have tried to pass on my lane and should have waited.

This isn't people not knowing how to drive. This is people being cheeky because they don't want to be stuck for ages

Hawkins001 · 02/12/2022 20:40

Both of you for.not having dash cameras

DownNative · 02/12/2022 20:40

WrigglyDonCat · 02/12/2022 20:29

It really isn't whoever commits first - as an ADI for the last ten years I hope I know... It would be if there are obstructions both sides, but if it is only your side, you should give way. That means that unless you can clear the obstruction and get back to your side of the road without making the oncoming vehicle slow, change course etc., you should wait.

I would imagine what has happened here is that car A doesn't really have time to get around, car B has seen them coming and decided to teach them a lesson. Shite driving all round. But from an insurance POV, car B had priority (N.B. is is priority, not right of way - there are no rights involved), so car A would likely be held responsible for any damage. If there happened to be clear dashcam evidence, it's possible insurance companies might settle for a split liability of some kind if it's clear that car B had seriously hoofed it into the space, but I really wouldn't want to bank on it.

Correct. Hence Highway Code Rule 163! Very clear.

DownNative · 02/12/2022 20:38

NalaNana · 02/12/2022 20:33

Car B knowingly sped up towards a car that was in the process of overtaking. Whether car A should have stopped to give way or not, the fact is they didn't, that doesn't give anyone permission to ram into it and say "well you shouldn't have been there anyway"! Very reckless.

No-one is saying that.

But the Highway Code Rule 163 is very clear in regards to Car A as they did NOT have a clear route ahead to facilitate SAFE and LEGAL overtaking.

Car A was chancing getting in JUST before Car B at any rate. Always better to not be an impatient driver and give way.

NalaNana · 02/12/2022 20:33

Car B knowingly sped up towards a car that was in the process of overtaking. Whether car A should have stopped to give way or not, the fact is they didn't, that doesn't give anyone permission to ram into it and say "well you shouldn't have been there anyway"! Very reckless.

WrigglyDonCat · 02/12/2022 20:29

Wednesdayonline · 02/12/2022 19:41

The highway code doesn't actually say you have to give way if there's an obstruction ie a parked car on your side of the road. It's whoever commits first, so if car A was already passing the obstacle and car B carried on coming, then car B is in the wrong especially if they carried on speeding up when they had a chance to stop and wait.

It really isn't whoever commits first - as an ADI for the last ten years I hope I know... It would be if there are obstructions both sides, but if it is only your side, you should give way. That means that unless you can clear the obstruction and get back to your side of the road without making the oncoming vehicle slow, change course etc., you should wait.

I would imagine what has happened here is that car A doesn't really have time to get around, car B has seen them coming and decided to teach them a lesson. Shite driving all round. But from an insurance POV, car B had priority (N.B. is is priority, not right of way - there are no rights involved), so car A would likely be held responsible for any damage. If there happened to be clear dashcam evidence, it's possible insurance companies might settle for a split liability of some kind if it's clear that car B had seriously hoofed it into the space, but I really wouldn't want to bank on it.