Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is in the wrong here? Re two car drivers.

116 replies

Chocolatereindeerr · 02/12/2022 19:26

Please tell me who is in the wrong here.. I understand it’s probably both but what would happen if it went to insurance?

I was passenger in car A.

car A- fails to stop behind a parked vehicle and give way to oncoming vehicle but would of made it round in enough time if the oncoming car went appropriate speed.

car B- on coming. Notices car A has not given way and puts his foot down and aggressively speeds up towards car A.

the result of this was both cars clipping wing mirrors but could have been worse.

car A pulls over as wing mirror was pushed in and 30 seconds later Car B has turned round and parked behind car A.

Car B driver gets out his car and aggressively starts shouting that Car A driver has knocked his wing mirror off. car A driver apologies and mentions that car B driver was coming fast and that he should of slowed down. Car B driver agrees to putting his foot down but said that it’s his right of way, he wasn’t stopping.

who is in the wrong?

OP posts:
NalaNana · 03/12/2022 10:57

@DownNative of course we're taking the OP's word for it. If driver B didn't speed up, there would be no point in this thread as obviously driver A would be at fault.

You can't just pick and choose which parts of the OP are true based on which parts support your view. Oh, I've just decided that the OP wasn't a passenger at all, they were the driver, so they had the best view in the house blah blah blah 🙄

DownNative · 03/12/2022 10:38

Getoff · 03/12/2022 10:06

They claim B did on the basis of A saying so and I'd doubt B actually said anything like that too.

They say B admitted it. Not sure if you are missing a fact that OP has given, or choosing to disbelieve it. You can justify anything you want to say about anything if you are going to make up your own facts rather than work within the limits of the ones you've been given.

On the contrary, you're choosing to accept the views of a passenger who had a poor view of road ahead due to obstruction. And taking their word, to boot. That's the OP.

In cases where there's no video evidence, you fall back on Highway Code Rule 162 and 163. Car A clearly flouted each one they're required to follow BEFORE overtaking. This is all the evidence we have to hand.

You can ignore that if you wish....

littlepeas · 03/12/2022 10:38

B should have stopped and waited, regardless of whether it was his right of way or not. As soon as A pulled out they became a hazard and B should have anticipated it and stopped. Part of being a good driver is anticipating hazards and reacting appropriately - as a PP mentioned, you don't just plough on towards something in the road. If you deliberately drive into someone, regardless of the reason, you are at fault. This obviously assumes that he had time to stop, but it sounds like he did.

TheMadGardener · 03/12/2022 10:25

I was in a similar accident 3 years ago in which I was Car B, except that I didn't speed up but slowed down when I realised that Car A wasn't pulling in to the large space available but was going to try to squeeze between me and a parked car. He didn't make it and caused significant damage to my car (replacement panel needed). He then blamed me and my insurers ended up taking him and his insurers to court, where the judge said it was clearly my right of way, he should have pulled over. His insurance had to pay and I kept my no-claims bonus!

(Incidentally, shout out for LV who are my insurers and were absolutely top class with arranging quick repair, sorting me a courtesy car and chasing him through the courts. They were fab!)

dementedpixie · 03/12/2022 10:20

If CarA was already on their way past the cars then CarB should have waited and not started going past them too.

WeeOrcadian · 03/12/2022 10:13

Car B sounds like they feel as if they own the road (they don't) but from an insurance / legal stance, car A should have stopped, every single time. Speed is irrelevant when it comes to 'right of way' (a term I use loosely) so car A was definitely in the wrong.

Getoff · 03/12/2022 10:06

They claim B did on the basis of A saying so and I'd doubt B actually said anything like that too.

They say B admitted it. Not sure if you are missing a fact that OP has given, or choosing to disbelieve it. You can justify anything you want to say about anything if you are going to make up your own facts rather than work within the limits of the ones you've been given.

DownNative · 03/12/2022 09:34

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/12/2022 00:28

And nobody is saying any driver can plough on at someone! Strawman Argument. Fact is, as the passenger in Car A the OP was not in a good position to see if road ahead was clear enough to proceed or to judge speed of oncoming Car B.

You raise some very valid points, but I still maintain that nobody would call it an acceptable standard of driving to speed up, knowing that there is any obstacle ahead that has nowhere to go to avoid your hitting it (unless it's something like a whole coffee cup or dropped packing air bubble - those are fun to drive over!) and thus 'facilitating' a likely collision.

If both drivers were going at an appropriate speed and paying attention (with the required eyesight standard), at worst, this should have ended in a temporary impasse, with both drivers coming to a stop - stopping almost always being preferable to an anticipable and avoidable collision.

Yet OP could not possibly have had the ability to see Car B speeding up. They claim B did on the basis of A saying so and I'd doubt B actually said anything like that too.

A was in the more dangerous position, manoeuvred into the direction of oncoming traffic and flouted every rule that they are required to follow BEFORE overtaking the obstruction. These are things we know for sure.

These situations is why I have a front and rear dash cam plus warning sign on rear too. This gives me a lot of space and drivers behave themselves. Someone will reverse too if I point to my camera at front when they're in the wrong as well.

Excellent investment!

londonrach · 03/12/2022 07:28

Car a but mistakes happen. Car b should have read the road. Car a wrong re insurance. Both wrong if different ways

CarPoor · 03/12/2022 07:23

startfresh · 03/12/2022 00:14

@CarPoor but in my case I was ONE car, they were multiple and still tried to make me wait.

When I've waited recently it's been 3 cars with ROW and like 10 cars (no exaggeration) or more making the unsafe manoeuvre even when the ROW side is trying to move forward, they're dangerously jumping through.

If the ROW is stopped it's not really dangerous. As I said just more cheeky. It's annoying when people push through like that but it's not because they don't know how to drive. And on the other foot in some situations the ROW does have to stop and allow the other cars to come otherwise you can end up with gridlock situations

TooHotToRamble · 03/12/2022 00:42

DownNative · 02/12/2022 19:40

Car A is more in the wrong as the driver blatantly ignored the fact they didn't have right of way.

If a vehicle is approaching, you CANNOT and SHOULDN'T attempt to overtake an obstruction on your side of the road. Possibly being able to clear the obstruction in time as long as Car B travels at an appropriate speed is a completely unreasonable "excuse"!

Driver of Car A needs to read the Highway Code again....

If I followed that rule I'd never get down my very long road between 7am and 9am and 4.30 and 6 pm at night. The only way you can get down is by weaving in and out of the parked cars and timing it in between the oncoming traffic.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/12/2022 00:28

And nobody is saying any driver can plough on at someone! Strawman Argument. Fact is, as the passenger in Car A the OP was not in a good position to see if road ahead was clear enough to proceed or to judge speed of oncoming Car B.

You raise some very valid points, but I still maintain that nobody would call it an acceptable standard of driving to speed up, knowing that there is any obstacle ahead that has nowhere to go to avoid your hitting it (unless it's something like a whole coffee cup or dropped packing air bubble - those are fun to drive over!) and thus 'facilitating' a likely collision.

If both drivers were going at an appropriate speed and paying attention (with the required eyesight standard), at worst, this should have ended in a temporary impasse, with both drivers coming to a stop - stopping almost always being preferable to an anticipable and avoidable collision.

startfresh · 03/12/2022 00:14

@CarPoor but in my case I was ONE car, they were multiple and still tried to make me wait.

When I've waited recently it's been 3 cars with ROW and like 10 cars (no exaggeration) or more making the unsafe manoeuvre even when the ROW side is trying to move forward, they're dangerously jumping through.

startfresh · 03/12/2022 00:11

@RichardMarxisinnocent I salute her. I'm sick of cars taking the mick. It's why people don't want to let others through, because the whole row of cars will take the opportunity to jump in rather than just a couple then back to ROW.

LakieLady · 02/12/2022 23:42

A, but B was a bit of a twat.

SkylightSkylight · 02/12/2022 23:18

MichelleScarn · 02/12/2022 19:36

This

incorrect.

Read the section on moving around parked cars.

NalaNana · 02/12/2022 23:17

@DownNative OP may have had a worse view than the driver of car A, but that is still a hell of a lot of a better view than you or I had, which is zero. Speculating about what you think may have happened, when someone is available to give a first hand account, is not a strong argument in any case.

If a reasonable driver expects others to not follow the Highway Code (which I agree with hence hazard perception being part of the theory test) isn't that even more of a reason why driver B should have waited for driver A to complete the manoeuvre they were committed to instead of driving into them?

You can't reasonably believe that driver B didn't at least contribute to this accident, regardless of whether it is their fault in full or part.

DownNative · 02/12/2022 23:17

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/12/2022 22:55

I don't think A is necessarily blameless, but B is definitely at fault. You can't just plough on, even if you should have priority, and ignore any visible obstacles. If a child had wandered into the road, or an elderly person was taking a while to cross, do people really think that B could just deliberately smash into them "because it was my right of way"?

I also don't see how B could realistically accuse A of 'knocking his mirror off'. The two mirrors hit each other at exactly the same time - it's not like, say, a fist punching a face, where one is clearly a passive target and the other actively moving in order to meet it violently.

Your scenario of a child in the road is not a like for like comparison!

In the case of a pedestrian, Highway Code Rule 7 states:

D If traffic is coming, let it pass. Look all around again and listen. Do not cross until there is a safe gap in the traffic and you are certain that there is plenty of time. Remember, even if traffic is a long way off, it may be approaching very quickly.

Meaning give way to approaching traffic in favour of giving yourself more space to safely proceed.

Same principle for vehicles. See Rule 162-63 above. Give way, suitable gap AND time.

And nobody is saying any driver can plough on at someone! Strawman Argument. Fact is, as the passenger in Car A the OP was not in a good position to see if road ahead was clear enough to proceed or to judge speed of oncoming Car B.

Tomatopasta · 02/12/2022 23:14

Don’t understand why some drivers become so aggressive and angry on the roads. We have all places to be, I don’t see why you would unnecessarily speed up if you see a car overtaking and coming into your side of the road, ESPECIALLY if there’s enough time for them to do it. Just wait and let them pass, jeez.

Sometimes in this situation (and depending on traffic!) I usually wait until it’s clear but obviously that’s not always possible. It can be difficult to predict speed, and I think we are all guilty of sometimes getting it wrong, and thinking we can get around in enough time and we don’t.

Its difficult to say without actual footage! I can easily see how both cars would be at fault though.

DownNative · 02/12/2022 22:55

NalaNana · 02/12/2022 21:16

@DownNative from the OP driver A would have had suitable room to complete the manoeuvre had driver B not sped up.

You can only make that judgement in the moment based on what you can see ahead of you.

It's not the case that simply seeing an oncoming vehicle means you can't overtake parked cars, in most cities parked cars litter the sides of the roads and no one would be able to go anywhere.

A reasonable driver wouldn't expect an oncoming vehicle to speed up to such an extent that the manoeuvre can no longer be completed and result in a car accident!

No, the OP didn't say Car A would have had suitable room. Just said they believe A would have had enough time to do so.

Yet the passenger has a WORSE view of the road ahead than Driver A! And we're supposed to take OPs word for it when they would NOT have been able to see if B was approaching when A pulled out?!

At any rate, A had a list of fails as previously outlined, so it falls more on them.

It's not just seeing an approaching vehicle, is it? It's ensuring there is clearance ahead to proceed! This includes a gap ahead if there's a line of parked cars, for example. Your argument falls flat in that case.

A reasonable driver knows and expects there will be others on the road ignoring the Highway Code and gives themselves:

  1. extra space around their car
  2. patience
  3. doesn't rush

No, Car A was in the wrong as per Highway Code Rule 162-63.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/12/2022 22:55

I don't think A is necessarily blameless, but B is definitely at fault. You can't just plough on, even if you should have priority, and ignore any visible obstacles. If a child had wandered into the road, or an elderly person was taking a while to cross, do people really think that B could just deliberately smash into them "because it was my right of way"?

I also don't see how B could realistically accuse A of 'knocking his mirror off'. The two mirrors hit each other at exactly the same time - it's not like, say, a fist punching a face, where one is clearly a passive target and the other actively moving in order to meet it violently.

fannyfartlet · 02/12/2022 22:54

Car A is clearly at fault irrespective of car B's speed.

Chocolatereindeerr · 02/12/2022 22:51

Thank you all for your replies. It was only one parked car obstruction, not a line of parked cars and the driver of car B definitely sped up which he admitted to ‘putting his foot down’ he also said ‘ I thought I’d made that until I heard the wing mirrors clip.’ It was lucky that the accident wasn’t worse than it was.

OP posts:
SD1978 · 02/12/2022 22:45

Car A regardless of car B's attitude. They pulled out into oncoming traffic.

Underscore21 · 02/12/2022 22:30

Car A is legally supposed to give way if the obstruction is on their side of the road, however, I think Car B should also have taken pre-emotive action. So it might not be clear cut and unlikely to be 100% Car A's fault insurance-wise.

Swipe left for the next trending thread