Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Give up seat on the train

132 replies

ItsTheSmallThings · 02/12/2022 19:00

AIBU to give up a seat on a busy train for a mum carrying a young toddler?

OP posts:
CaronPoivre · 03/12/2022 09:56

Plumbear2 · 03/12/2022 09:28

No you carnt. I have a condition which prevents me from standing for long periods and effects my balance. You would never know this by looking at me.

Oh yes you can. We don’t like to admit it, but oh yes you can.

Fibromyalgia is written all over someone’s face and posture.

Plumbear2 · 03/12/2022 09:44

ChillysWaterBottle · 03/12/2022 09:32

I would, but then I'm not an asshole

I don't like to see people struggle on public transport

This is very unfair. Should other people have to struggle just as much, if not more to give up their seat? Refusing to give up a seat does not make them assholes.

ChillysWaterBottle · 03/12/2022 09:32

I would, but then I'm not an asshole

I don't like to see people struggle on public transport

Plumbear2 · 03/12/2022 09:28

CaronPoivre · 03/12/2022 08:59

You can tell whether someone is young and healthy enough to stand. I would continue to prompt the healthy young man having already stood myself. You only have to look at someone to know they have fibromyalgia.

No you carnt. I have a condition which prevents me from standing for long periods and effects my balance. You would never know this by looking at me.

CaronPoivre · 03/12/2022 08:59

Covidandapartridgeinapeartree · 02/12/2022 23:32

Can you explain how you can tell they're healthy? Is MS, cancer, fibromyalgia etc visible? You should never "prompt" anyone else to do this. By all means, do it yourself but you have no idea what hidden disabilities/issues those others have and you've then put them in a situation where they stand out of embarrassment . I had someone "helpfully" tell me to get up for someone elderly and out of embarrassment, I did but I'd just had extensive surgery and could barely stand. You have no idea how healthy someone is by looking at them.

You can tell whether someone is young and healthy enough to stand. I would continue to prompt the healthy young man having already stood myself. You only have to look at someone to know they have fibromyalgia.

Oxterguff · 03/12/2022 00:38

Covidandapartridgeinapeartree · 02/12/2022 23:32

Can you explain how you can tell they're healthy? Is MS, cancer, fibromyalgia etc visible? You should never "prompt" anyone else to do this. By all means, do it yourself but you have no idea what hidden disabilities/issues those others have and you've then put them in a situation where they stand out of embarrassment . I had someone "helpfully" tell me to get up for someone elderly and out of embarrassment, I did but I'd just had extensive surgery and could barely stand. You have no idea how healthy someone is by looking at them.

This!

Oxterguff · 03/12/2022 00:34

Plumbear2 · 02/12/2022 20:56

I wouldn't, I have a hidden disability but you carnt tell by just looking. Best not to judge.

Exactly! As if you can tell just by looking whether somebody who is sat down has mobility issues? 🙄
I get this all the time when I pull into a disabled parking bay. Just because I am relatively young and can drive does not mean that I don’t have a disability!

Hawkins001 · 03/12/2022 00:27

If I can stand and I saw they needed a seat, I would, I was in the bank today and gave up the seat when an elderly customer wanted to sit down.

WhiteFire · 03/12/2022 00:10

I'd stand, and have done. I was going on a mainline train journey shortly after a major derailment and the trains were all to pot. I had a reserved seat, but the train was packed from cancelled trains. Of course I got up. I do what I think is the right course of action in my circumstances. It is up to others what they do.

MoreSleepPleasee · 03/12/2022 00:02

CaronPoivre · 02/12/2022 21:47

I’ve always thought those most able to stand should offer seats to those less able. People with obvious mobility problems and the very elderly top the list. Heavily pregnant women next. Usually a baby would be in a pushchair or pram so less of a problem but if in a carrier, I’d offer. I’ve been known to prompt healthy young people to stand on crowded trains and can’t bear the pretence they haven’t noticed someone struggling. I’d expect children from about 7 to stand for older adults.

That's awful. Surely you cannot be proud of that? How judgemental and rude.

MoreSleepPleasee · 02/12/2022 23:59

I think you never know what hidden disabilities someone might have. My teen son is disabled and has problems with his joints that cause him pain. I wouldn't expect him to give up his seat but to everyone else he's a rude teen not giving up his seat to a mother and toddler. I don't think you can expect a seat on a packed train you can only hope an able bodied person might offer you theirs. But you can never tell who that is so I wouldn't say anything.

CatJumperTwat · 02/12/2022 23:54

CaronPoivre · 02/12/2022 21:47

I’ve always thought those most able to stand should offer seats to those less able. People with obvious mobility problems and the very elderly top the list. Heavily pregnant women next. Usually a baby would be in a pushchair or pram so less of a problem but if in a carrier, I’d offer. I’ve been known to prompt healthy young people to stand on crowded trains and can’t bear the pretence they haven’t noticed someone struggling. I’d expect children from about 7 to stand for older adults.

Yeah, I've been shamed by people like you, because I look "young and healthy." Most disabilities are invisible. Stop it.

Covidandapartridgeinapeartree · 02/12/2022 23:36

Or the time I was on my way home from hospital having been treated for hyperemesis and was very unwell and was told to stand by someone helpful like yourself, for someone visibly pregnant who then argued with me...hopefully you'll think in future. Angry

Covidandapartridgeinapeartree · 02/12/2022 23:32

CaronPoivre · 02/12/2022 21:47

I’ve always thought those most able to stand should offer seats to those less able. People with obvious mobility problems and the very elderly top the list. Heavily pregnant women next. Usually a baby would be in a pushchair or pram so less of a problem but if in a carrier, I’d offer. I’ve been known to prompt healthy young people to stand on crowded trains and can’t bear the pretence they haven’t noticed someone struggling. I’d expect children from about 7 to stand for older adults.

Can you explain how you can tell they're healthy? Is MS, cancer, fibromyalgia etc visible? You should never "prompt" anyone else to do this. By all means, do it yourself but you have no idea what hidden disabilities/issues those others have and you've then put them in a situation where they stand out of embarrassment . I had someone "helpfully" tell me to get up for someone elderly and out of embarrassment, I did but I'd just had extensive surgery and could barely stand. You have no idea how healthy someone is by looking at them.

Chouetted · 02/12/2022 23:21

Abraxan · 02/12/2022 20:50

I'm not sure most small toddlers will come stood up, holding on, on a busy train tbh.

They can sit down though, and in much smaller spaces. They'd be perfectly safe in some luggage racks, for instance provided they're not sharing it with the luggage, obviously), sat next to Mum, or in a wheelchair/cycle area by her legs (. Depends on what type of train they run near you, how long this journey is for, and what a packed train actually looks like.

Did the guard not offer assistance?

I wouldn't offer them a seat myself, because I'm unstable when standing on trains, and I can assure you holding a toddler is going to be much less inconvenient than having a 6 foot woman flying about the train.

HollaHolla · 02/12/2022 22:21

I have a mobility issue, which would not necessarily be noticeable at first look. However, it means I can’t stand for long, as my balance is rubbish. It’s also pretty painful to stand.
i sometimes use a stick, when I know it will be crowded, so as to ‘show’ people that I might need some allowances made. It’s helpful in being able to show why I need to get a seat, or in the accessible area. Otherwise I look like a perfectly healthy 40-something.

Bur, yes, I often find it’s teenagers who will automatically give up a seat. I’m always very thankful, and stop short of saying that I’m sure their parents would be proud; but definitely think it!!

BogRollBOGOF · 02/12/2022 22:13

It's kind to offer a seat to someone who has a greater need, and that can include young children with poor balance and poor access to hold on to supports.

I've been grateful when people have offered a seat which allowed me to put a young child on each knee. Not terribly comfortable for me, but it was a more space efficient arrangement for crowded spaces and it turns out that both children have hypermobility and one has dyspraxia. He's older now and if there's limited seating, I'll prioritise him because he finds it awkward to get himself arranged into a stable standing position and still can't reach an adult range of grips. He's at higher risk than average of injuring himself.

Asking is awkward because a person may not be offering as they have invisible needs, and can put them in an awkward position.

CaronPoivre · 02/12/2022 21:47

I’ve always thought those most able to stand should offer seats to those less able. People with obvious mobility problems and the very elderly top the list. Heavily pregnant women next. Usually a baby would be in a pushchair or pram so less of a problem but if in a carrier, I’d offer. I’ve been known to prompt healthy young people to stand on crowded trains and can’t bear the pretence they haven’t noticed someone struggling. I’d expect children from about 7 to stand for older adults.

OneFrenchEgg · 02/12/2022 21:39

Should I really have to give up my seat to someone who didn't bother booking just because they have a toddler?

You do know you can't always book a seat? Like it's not an option, not just all booked. Some routes don't offer it so if you are stop x people before you will have taken all the seats.

CatJumperTwat · 02/12/2022 21:38

Disabled not disbanded 😳

CatJumperTwat · 02/12/2022 21:38

No. I'm disbanded and need it as much or more. I've had glares from mothers with young children for taking a seat instead of offering it to them.

Mariposista · 02/12/2022 21:36

Pregnant, elderly, disabled or injured, I would.

Isitsixoclockalready · 02/12/2022 21:30

Some lovely, polite responses on here.

Crazycrazylady · 02/12/2022 21:25

I don't know.. I'm writing this on the train as we speak . It's a 2.5 journey home from a day in meetings and I'm tired so I prebooked my seat to make sure I had one.
Should I really have to give up my seat to someone who didn't bother booking just because they have a toddler?
It's been a really long work week for me too..
Seems unfair.?
I do have 3 kids and always book ahead if we travel by public transport as opposed expect people to simply move for me??

magicalorange · 02/12/2022 21:24

Rogue1001MNer · 02/12/2022 20:32

Mnhq have started deleting reverses. Just saying

I bloody wish they would. So tedious.