Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the GP is wrong about miscarriage

61 replies

Digitalash · 02/12/2022 15:02

Me and DH are TTC, I suffered a missed MC in July and then this month my period was a few days late on as well as having a few minor symptoms such as everything spelling weird/different and being super tired.

I took a test yesterday and it was positive (but faint) and then last night i got horrible cramps and started bleeding. I know it's early so there isn't much anyone can do but I rang the GP explained what had happened, took another test, still positive, he said I needed to come and do a test there.

I did and the test at the GP's was negative so he said its just a late period and he doesn't know why I'm here (he was really insensitive in general) i said but they were positive at home though and I didn't think you could get false positive? And he said that the test he is looking at is negative so maybe I am mistaken(???)

I know it's very early on and very common but we have been try for a year and now after another miscarriage I'm just gutted and for him to dismiss made me think I am going crazy?

I have attached a picture of the test from this morning so people can tell me if I am.losing my mind. If I'm not though AIBU to complain to my surgery about him?

I'm worried now it won't go down on my records as a miscarriage and as me being hysterical instead and may delay help in the future etc. If I need it

To think the GP is wrong about miscarriage
OP posts:
Digitalash · 02/12/2022 17:44

I don't want to turn it in to a competition of what is worse o'r not, I think everyone's feelings are valid and tbh with my other MMC that was discovered on my 12 week scan in some respects that was easier than this as I had had no pregnancy symptoms and always felt something was wrong, (baby stopped growing at 7 weeks and I had a d&c as they weren't sure if it was molar)i think i had prepared myself for bad news subconciously but this one felt different, I had all the "classic symptoms" and felt hopeful this time.

I understand people saying why did you go the GP but equally I didn't have a midwife yet (obviously) I felt like I should be doing something? Maybe I was wrong but regardless so was his attitude.

Thank you for all the positive stories, I don't thunk mine will be one and I don't want to get my hopes up. I'm not a drinker or smoker anyway so not alot changes lifestyle wise.

I am still bleeding but will test again in a week to make sure they are negative and at the very least everything has passed.

Thank you also for all your replies, it's not a nice subject and it's nice to just get different opinions and perspectives.

OP posts:
theydontspeakforus · 02/12/2022 17:37

@realsavagelike sometimes it can be a bit of a grief competition. No one's grief is invalid - especially if you lose a much wanted pregnancy / baby. I am currently 6 weeks pregnant following 2 MMC's and I'm terrified. A loss at this stage would be just as hard as my loss at 12 weeks.

realsavagelike · 02/12/2022 17:19

@theydontspeakforus exactly. I have had at least 5 chemical pregnancies. over the years. I always referred to them as miscarriages because they had positive pregnancy tests and felt like I was losing a baby. Recently though I have started to feel as though according to the rest of the world they weren't 'real' losses and that I have been overstating and exaggerating my situation. I feel like a fraud now for telling people all these years how many miscarriages I had.

Kateluvscats1 · 02/12/2022 17:17

Just for those who are seeking fertility treatment, best to not mention a miscarriage as this confirms you can get pregnant, I would advise you to say that you've been trying and have never got pregnant, you'll receive possibly quicker and more in depth investigation by your gynae team.

CarefreeMe · 02/12/2022 17:06

He sounds very insensitive, especially knowing it’s such a sensitive topic.

Tbh I’m not sure why you even went to the gp though.
There’s nothing they could have done and it probably would have made you feel worse even if he wasn’t such a dick.

I personally would take a photo like you have and write in your diary every time you get a positive test and have a miscarriage.

Then ask to see a fertility specialist and tell them about what you’ve been experiencing.

I’m sorry you’ve had such a horrible experience.

theydontspeakforus · 02/12/2022 16:54

As someone who has had 2 MMC's (12 weeks and 9 weeks), if I had a "chemical" (which is still
A very early miscarriage) I would be incredibly sad. Trauma and grief are still trauma and grief.

contrary13 · 02/12/2022 16:53

I'm another saying that it can be possible to have a miscarriage like bleed - and still be pregnant. When I was 8 or 9 weeks pregnant I started to miscarry, having been told by the GP that the home tests are considered 100pc accurate by doctors, who don't like to do the dip-stick in urine tests any more (for various reasons - cost and time efficiency, I thought at the time), so I was definitely pregnant. Was referred to the early pregnancy unit in the hospital for a scan to check that I'd passed everything, a week later (it was the Easter bank holidays, so there was a bit of a delay). Well, it turned out that I'd been carrying twins, miscarried one, and... the other one celebrated his 18th birthday last month.

Even almost 19 years ago, when I was using over the counter pregnancy tests to determine the pregnancy, GPs considered them 100% reliable. Think how the technology of them has advanced in almost two decades!

So there is every possibility that something similar might have happened in your case, @Digitalash - but if, sadly, not, then yes; a miscarriage should always be recorded in our medical records. However early. It takes a few seconds for a GP to type in the words "patient believes that she may have been pregnant, experienced a heavy period-like bleed, potential miscarriage" for future reference, should intervention be needed. It ought not to be dismissed - because what happens if you have a situation like mine, where a woman loses one embryo but not the second, is told she's no longer pregnant, and goes out and gets drunk as a way of coping with her loss? It happens (I didn't, by the way, as I had a gut feeling that I was still pregnant, but I know women who have lost a pregnancy and tried to drink their pain at that loss away for a few weeks).

Flowers
jamoncrumpets · 02/12/2022 16:45

Nobody is denying the way the NHS handles miscarriages needs a big injection of cash and training. My 12 week one was an absolute car crash. But a chemical pregnancy has little to no risk for the mother, and is too early to be seen even by EPU.

I know somebody who treats her chemical pregnancy and her 9 week loss exactly the same, but I personally found them very very different.

Genevieva · 02/12/2022 16:38

@Nightwithhertrainofstars you may be right, but I was told that it is only a miscarriage once the pregnancy is properly established. Chemical pregnancies end before that point and you essentially have a late period that is slightly heavier than normal.

It doesn't make it less upsetting. And from my point of view, the pregnancy was wanted and the symptoms were unmistakable even before the test was positive. E.g. My boobs had gone up several cup sizes virtually over night and were extremely uncomfortable. Looking back, I think this was evidence that something was wrong.

Lolreally · 02/12/2022 16:35

Tbf I don't think the op actually expected the doctor to do anything, she just wanted it acknowledged and recorded so it was on her records hardly expecting the earth. I mean are we actually at the point we accept unkindness and insensitivity from gps cos they are busy?

ZoeQ90 · 02/12/2022 16:30

the fact there's nothing they can do is neither here nor there. we still deserve caring and humane treatment. the handling of my miscarriage (at 10 weeks) was the awful because of this reasoning and it was horrible.

OneFrenchEgg · 02/12/2022 16:30

Sorry I meant additional support

laalaaleelee · 02/12/2022 16:27

He sounds like an absolute ballsack of a man. I'm so sorry for what you've been through.

potchy · 02/12/2022 16:25

jamoncrumpets · 02/12/2022 16:19

This early in a pregnancy there's nothing a GP or anyone else in the NHS can do really, especially as your HCG levels aren't strong enough to register on certain tests. They can't crack their knuckles and go 'Right, plan of action'. There isn't one. It's just wait and see. If the lines get stronger then that obviously indicates it's ok. Otherwise it's sadly a chemical pregnancy ie a very very early miscarriage.

Any pregnancy that doesn't develop past that point is obviously sad for the parents involved, but for a GP it's taking up resources they desperately need to distribute to others. So I can kind of understand them being a bit brusque tbh.

I was about to say exactly this.

I'm sorry op, but at such an early stage it would probably just be considered a chemical.

Unfortunately there's absolutely nothing any doctor can do.

Nightwithhertrainofstars · 02/12/2022 16:25

Genevieva · 02/12/2022 16:15

A loss this early on it counts as a chemical pregnancy rather than a miscarriage.

I don't think this is accurate. Chemical pregnancy is not really a clinical term, it is an early MC. It does sound likely to be what you have experienced OP. I'm really sorry, I know it is really hard. And the GP sounds very insensitive and patronising and it must have been horrible to have felt as if you weren't being believed. You know your body and the results you saw on the tests you did at home. I would agree with PP in terms of pursuing fertility treatment that you can just report how long you have been trying and how many MCs you have had and don't need to provide proof for this. I wish you all the best in your journey.

thisismylittlebrotherGeorge · 02/12/2022 16:23

Are you still bleeding OP?

Keep testing and see if your tests get darker. Thats all you can do.

In 2020 I fell pregnant quickly after stopping the pill, no period between coming off and getting pregnant. I tested at 9dpo (I had fertile signs), test was positive. The next day I had a horrendous sharp pain in my left side and started bleeding heavily. I thought it was a chemical. Next day the test was darker and again the next day.
My 18 month old is running round my feet as we speak right now and she is perfect.

It might be ok. I hope it all works out for you.

jamoncrumpets · 02/12/2022 16:22

FWIW I have had three chemical pregnancies, which were like bad periods.

And a miscarriage at 12 weeks which was pretty much full labour.

They were very very different beasts in terms of how they affected me physically and emotionally.

Dontaskdontget · 02/12/2022 16:21

If you’ve been TTC for a year without a successful pregnancy I think the NHS are supposed to start fertility investigations if you ask for them. I’d request that asap. However for what it’s worth my experience was that the NHS knows absolutely nothing anout fertility and makes a lot of things worse and delays things wasting time you don’t have, so if money allows, go private somewhere like the Lister or ARGC asap.

I don’t think it makes much difference in terms of next steps whether you have 1 miscarriage on your record or three (or whether there is anything there about anxiety), they’ll do the same blood tests and ultrasounds either way.

Sorry your GP is a dick. If at all possible see a woman next time.

jamoncrumpets · 02/12/2022 16:19

This early in a pregnancy there's nothing a GP or anyone else in the NHS can do really, especially as your HCG levels aren't strong enough to register on certain tests. They can't crack their knuckles and go 'Right, plan of action'. There isn't one. It's just wait and see. If the lines get stronger then that obviously indicates it's ok. Otherwise it's sadly a chemical pregnancy ie a very very early miscarriage.

Any pregnancy that doesn't develop past that point is obviously sad for the parents involved, but for a GP it's taking up resources they desperately need to distribute to others. So I can kind of understand them being a bit brusque tbh.

Genevieva · 02/12/2022 16:15

A loss this early on it counts as a chemical pregnancy rather than a miscarriage.

dampthursday · 02/12/2022 16:11

I’m really sorry for your losses.

When I had my booking in appointment I was asked if this was my first pregnancy. I said I’d had a chemical pregnancy the month before (had a positive test two days in a row, then had a negative test and started bleeding) and she basically said ‘we don’t count those, it’s just your body getting confused’.

I was not hugely impressed.

SF14 · 02/12/2022 15:59

I’m so sorry you are going through this OP. I agree too that the NHS tests are less sensitive. Had a similar experience where the doctor said it was negative from their test but I had 5 positive tests at home to prove otherwise. Is there any chance of insisting of having your blood tested? I had to get mine tested every other day to rule out an ectopic pregnancy. Wish you all the best!

mam0918 · 02/12/2022 15:51

It sounds like a possible chemical pregnancy, Im sorry for your loss.

Doctors dont really take chemical pregnancies seriously but if its been a year of trying ask to be refered for fertility testing.

Sailawaygirl · 02/12/2022 15:27

What test did your gp use? The nhs ones are less sensitive. I sadly had a mc and had to test 2 weeks after to check I was negative. On the stip test ( like you) I was still a faint positive but on the test the nhs gave me I was negative and the nurse explained they do use a less sensitive test. So I would wait a week and test again. You may not be out ?