Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the GP is wrong about miscarriage

61 replies

Digitalash · 02/12/2022 15:02

Me and DH are TTC, I suffered a missed MC in July and then this month my period was a few days late on as well as having a few minor symptoms such as everything spelling weird/different and being super tired.

I took a test yesterday and it was positive (but faint) and then last night i got horrible cramps and started bleeding. I know it's early so there isn't much anyone can do but I rang the GP explained what had happened, took another test, still positive, he said I needed to come and do a test there.

I did and the test at the GP's was negative so he said its just a late period and he doesn't know why I'm here (he was really insensitive in general) i said but they were positive at home though and I didn't think you could get false positive? And he said that the test he is looking at is negative so maybe I am mistaken(???)

I know it's very early on and very common but we have been try for a year and now after another miscarriage I'm just gutted and for him to dismiss made me think I am going crazy?

I have attached a picture of the test from this morning so people can tell me if I am.losing my mind. If I'm not though AIBU to complain to my surgery about him?

I'm worried now it won't go down on my records as a miscarriage and as me being hysterical instead and may delay help in the future etc. If I need it

To think the GP is wrong about miscarriage
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SunAndSea37 · 03/12/2022 11:33

I’m so sorry OP, hope you’re feeling a bit better. I’m also sorry the GP was so dismissive and rude. I don’t think you did the wrong thing going, you need to rule out things like an ectopic and people see their doctors for a lot less.

this happened to me (weirdly my period was early and just knew it wasn’t right) and I didn’t see my GP but same as you wanted it recorded as it was my second loss so I paid for a private blood test the next day. The doctor was just as rude and brusque but at least confirmed I had been pregnant.

Hugs to you OP, I have a 6 week old now as was pregnant again a few months later so all the best.

angstridden2 · 03/12/2022 10:50

I’ve been through infertility clinics and tbh I think expecting them to only staff with non pregnant people is a bit unrealistic.I agree that in an ideal world they would be more sensitive (particularly in private clinics where one assumes they’re less stretched) but I know how upset I was by anyone getting pregnant when I apparently couldn’t. My cousin ‘had’ to get married and my mum dreaded telling me, I howled.it’s rubbish and unless you’ve been through infertility and MCs I don’t think people get it.

mam0918 · 03/12/2022 10:42

NalaNana · 02/12/2022 21:28

I can absolutely echo poor treatment from medical professionals! I went to the EPU for a scan with pain to be told it was ectopic and then put back into a waiting room with pregnant people for hours while I awaited bloods, physical exams etc all while being told not to eat or drink in case I needed emergency surgery, and being asked casually how far along I was by others in the waiting area!

No private room, no sympathy, no asking if I was ok, not even any tissues. I was also seen that day and following days by a very pregnant nurse - obviously she has just as much right to work as anyone else but I found it a bit of a kick in the teeth and felt they could have sent a different member of staff to take repeat bloods, I know they had them!

I was having private uninvasive fertility treatments prepping for my IVF, had been going for about 5 months when my nurse announced proudly and excitedly announced she was 3 months pregnant to me. I didnt go back.

Shes a nice person and I know her life doesnt go on hold but it was just such a kick in the teeth.

I got that nurse because the one I was suppose to have went on maternity leave. So 2 out of 3 of the nurse at the infertility sessions where pregnant, just seems like oblivious planning and forethought when the entire point was infertility.

The clinic the nurses rotated across departments, the nurse I had wasnt originally in infertility she came to cover the one on maternity and they had non infertility related groups too just 1 specific fertility clinic so to put the 2 pregnant nurses in infertility just seemed batshit.

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 02/12/2022 21:41

I think your test at home was probably more sensitive than the one at the doctors surgery as it doesn't sound like there was much time difference between the two tests (either that or urine concentration could have been different). Test again tomorrow.

You are right - there isn't much any one can do if it is a miscarriage, doesn't make it any easier though, and it's good for your GP to have a record of these things. Sending hugs xx

NalaNana · 02/12/2022 21:28

I can absolutely echo poor treatment from medical professionals! I went to the EPU for a scan with pain to be told it was ectopic and then put back into a waiting room with pregnant people for hours while I awaited bloods, physical exams etc all while being told not to eat or drink in case I needed emergency surgery, and being asked casually how far along I was by others in the waiting area!

No private room, no sympathy, no asking if I was ok, not even any tissues. I was also seen that day and following days by a very pregnant nurse - obviously she has just as much right to work as anyone else but I found it a bit of a kick in the teeth and felt they could have sent a different member of staff to take repeat bloods, I know they had them!

Cantbebotheredwithausername · 02/12/2022 20:57

I've suffered two miscarriages, too. In my case nobody doubted me (they were confirmed on several scans and I had a D&C both times), but I would've been desperate, furious and devastated if I'd had the response you're describing from a doctor. Honestly it's just not okay on so many levels. No, they can't do much, really, as it's very early and your body seems to be taking care of it by itself. But he could at the very least have some damn empathy, say something nice, and put it down in your records to make sure you'll be offered adequate help if it happens a third time (God forbids).

On a side note - even needing surgery twice, I never actually had anyone ask me how I was doing or whether I was okay. Despite research showing that fairly large percentages (some studies showing up to around 30%) of women having an early miscarriage will have symptoms of PTSD.

I know this wasn't what you brought up, but I still want to say that I'm generally not impressed with the lack of care for women suffering miscarriages.

If you're asking whether the test in your picture is positive, then definitely yes. And no, you are not likely to have a false positive. If you're asking whether YABU to complain, then NO - YANBU!

babyjellyfish · 02/12/2022 20:47

Derbee · 02/12/2022 20:31

Implying that she’s misread a pregnancy test, or is lying is not on.

They can’t stop a miscarriage from happening clearly, but they can acknowledge that it’s happened and not imply she’s wrong/a liar

This.

I had five losses in a row and only two of them would have "counted" as a miscarriage rather than a chemical pregnancy.

I have no proof of the first one, but luckily after the second one I managed to get seen for recurrent miscarriage, and when the fourth and fifth ones happened I had blood tests prescribed so they are all on my medical records. The whole situation was distressing enough even when I was being taken seriously. I don't know what I'd have done if someone had told me most of my losses didn't count so there wasn't a problem.

Derbee · 02/12/2022 20:31

potchy · 02/12/2022 16:25

I was about to say exactly this.

I'm sorry op, but at such an early stage it would probably just be considered a chemical.

Unfortunately there's absolutely nothing any doctor can do.

Implying that she’s misread a pregnancy test, or is lying is not on.

They can’t stop a miscarriage from happening clearly, but they can acknowledge that it’s happened and not imply she’s wrong/a liar

LaForza101 · 02/12/2022 20:28

@NalaNana Completely agree 🙂

babyjellyfish · 02/12/2022 20:28

LaForza101 · 02/12/2022 20:17

@NalaNana Ah that's fair enough, it's just the immediacy of the comment against mine that got me on edge.

I totally agree they are both miscarriages and it is silly to say a CP isn't. Where is the line where it becomes a miscarriage then? But I do think it is useful to have a term for those really early losses as I needed early intervention and that may not have happened if they made me wait until it was more established. So it was useful for GPs to understand what was going on

Apparently the line is when it can be seen on ultrasound rather than just detected in your blood or urine. But it's a pretty arbitrary line either way.

startfresh · 02/12/2022 20:25

When I had this after a MMC, I went straight to the EPAU who dealt with my first one. They did a blood test, confirmed hCG was too low but counted it as a MC even without their test being positive and told me to call them next pregnancy test positive. I got additional scans from them for that one.

NalaNana · 02/12/2022 20:23

@LaForza101 I don't really have an issue with the term chemical pregnancy, I just find it dismissive when others say that it isn't a form of miscarriage because it feels like they are attempting to degrade or invalidate it which can be hurtful 😔 a lot of the advice I've seen is to mirror the language of the person suffering the loss, so as not to invalidate their experience.

LaForza101 · 02/12/2022 20:17

@NalaNana Ah that's fair enough, it's just the immediacy of the comment against mine that got me on edge.

I totally agree they are both miscarriages and it is silly to say a CP isn't. Where is the line where it becomes a miscarriage then? But I do think it is useful to have a term for those really early losses as I needed early intervention and that may not have happened if they made me wait until it was more established. So it was useful for GPs to understand what was going on

mam0918 · 02/12/2022 20:13

jamoncrumpets · 02/12/2022 16:45

Nobody is denying the way the NHS handles miscarriages needs a big injection of cash and training. My 12 week one was an absolute car crash. But a chemical pregnancy has little to no risk for the mother, and is too early to be seen even by EPU.

I know somebody who treats her chemical pregnancy and her 9 week loss exactly the same, but I personally found them very very different.

I know people who lost a pregnancy at 12 weeks and shrugged it off as 'not a baby' but that doesnt mean everyone else who feels it shouldn't.

OP has reached the infertility threshold, infertility can be devistating and to FINALLY see a line just to have it ripped away is heartbreaking.

OP needs medical investigations and is entitled to them, she has every right to go to the doctor and doctors arent only reserved for things that have 'risk to life'.

NalaNana · 02/12/2022 20:01

@LaForza101 I was referring to comments like "a loss this early on it counts as a chemical pregnancy rather than a miscarriage" earlier on in the thread that only serves to be unhelpful.

LaForza101 · 02/12/2022 19:32

@NalaNana I only referred to my last two losses as chemical pregnancies to differentiate that they were earlier than my MMC which was recorded in my medical records as I needed medical management at the hospital. So the OP knows it was a similar level of dismissal from my GP

I'm well aware they are miscarriages/losses thank you

NalaNana · 02/12/2022 19:15

A loss is a loss and any feelings of sadness are completely valid. I thought it was quite well known that it's unhelpful and insensitive to tell a woman who miscarries 'at least it was early'. The amount of posters stumbling over themselves to refer to this as a chemical rather than a miscarriage, when a chemical is a form of miscarriage, is bizarre.

I hope you get the medical support you deserve OP which obviously includes documenting this loss.

LaForza101 · 02/12/2022 19:03

I was in a similar position earlier this year having had a MMC and then two chemical pregnancies. First doctor said the last two didn't count as I hadn't taken a test at the GP and it wasn't on record. Very upsetting as it felt like I wasn't believed.

I got a second opinion at the same surgery and they said the other GP was being very unreasonable expecting me to come in for a test every time my period was late so there was a 'record'. It wasn't policy and they were talking nonsense basically and I was referred for testing straight away.

Feel free to try again but in the absolute worst case that it happens again (wishing you all the luck that this won't be the case) try a different GP.

So sorry this has happened to you too

Minimochi · 02/12/2022 18:49

I'm sorry for your loss. :( I also don't think you did anything wrong by going to the GP. After a year of ttc, they should refer you to a fertility specialist. The mere fact that you can get pregnant doesn't mean that you don't need any help.

I had 2 early miscarriages (both ectopic), then referral to the fertility clinic in Bristol. We had DS after they cleared my tubes. I've since had another 4 early mcs ...two of those ectopic (followed by removal of my left tube), the third and fourth as part of IVF when the embryo implanted but simply didn't develop further...
I've been seen by the EPU (back when we still lived in the UK) every single time and they had me on their high priority list. They were usually really lovely, even if there was nothing anyone could have done. When we moved abroad, my gynaecologist was a little easy-going to begin with. I don't think she quite believed me when I said I'd need help when ttc #2. But it's now 4 mcs later and she's very much on the ball. I get an appointment immediately after a positive test. They are really good at squeezing me in and supporting me with the stuff needed for my IVF treatment.

babyjellyfish · 02/12/2022 18:21

YANBU, OP.

A chemical pregnancy is a miscarriage, just a very early one. You were still pregnant, and the pregnancy still ended. Of course the physical and emotional impact of losing a pregnancy at 5 weeks is not the same as losing one at 8 weeks, or 10 weeks, or 12 weeks, just as the physical and emotional impact of having a miscarriage at 12 weeks is not the same as having a stillbirth. But in all cases they are pregnancies which don’t result in the birth of a living baby.

In your position I would want this in your medical records so that if you have a third loss you can pursue recurrent miscarriage testing.

I probably wouldn't go back to the GP now, but if you do have another loss you should go back to him and say you've now had three losses and you want to be referred. And if he won't refer you, go to another GP and explain that you've had three losses but one was early and your GP refused to note it.

Iggi999 · 02/12/2022 18:20

Emotionally pregnancy is not a linear thing, with people feeling a little more pregnant with every day that passes. There is an almighty jump from "not pregnant" to "pregnant" the first time you see that positive line on a test. Their whole life lies before you. For this reason people miscarrying at 8 weeks don't feel one week's worth of greater hurt than those miscarrying at 7 weeks.
The physical symptoms will vary with time, but I don't think for most women it's the physical side that causes the most lasting problems.

LemonBounce · 02/12/2022 18:08

So sorry you are going through this.
Can't believe you doctor, people like that should not be in that role. You are obviously right about the tests being very unlikely to give a false positive.
Can you ask to change doctors? You need a supportive doctor during this process.
You'd be well within your rights to complain.

SarahAndQuack · 02/12/2022 18:06

I'm so sorry, OP. Just adding to the other people saying it's normal not to have 'evidence,' and also (unfortunately) normal for GPs not to be terribly sympathetic. The first time I miscarried my GP made me feel like a total idiot for bothering him by coming in. But all the other medics I've seen through the recurrent miscarriage service subsequently have been excellent and much more sensitive, so I really do recommend pushing for some intervention, even if your GP is being a bit of a pain.

user1469032438 · 02/12/2022 18:01

@theydontspeakforus you didn't don't worry :)

theydontspeakforus · 02/12/2022 17:57

@Digitalash I didn't mean anyone here was making a competition - I'm really sorry if that's how my post came across, and I'm very sorry for your loss.