Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"You can't have it for free",aibu?

360 replies

imacccu · 02/12/2022 15:00

So I'm at Manchester for the Christmas markets.
Spent £20 on a Greek sharing box to eat for lunch.
I ask for two forks and she tells me they've ran out and to get them from the Brazilian stand opposite.
So off I go and say "can I have two of the plastic forks please as the Greek stand have ran out"

She says "no I'm not allowed as you didn't buy food here,you can't expect them for free"
I said okay il buy a drink
She said no only food
The cheapest thing was £10
So I sad no
Aibu to think she could of gave me a plastic fork
Is this what the worlds came too?
She had a huge and I mean huge tub of cutlery

So we had to eat with our hands which was near impossible as it was coated in sauces etc

OP posts:
HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 21:45

DPotter · 02/12/2022 21:43

Hotchocs
What if someone had then offered to buy an item 100x the price of the carrier bag then. £34. Would you have told them they had to buy an £100 item which fits in a carrier bag instead?

I factor in the cost of bags into the prices of my work, so little pots have 34p factored in, and larger items have 45p factored in. So if someone bought a pot for £100 it would be large and have a 45p bag linked to it. If another stallholder had sent a customer over to ask for a bag I still would have said no, because they hadn't bought anything from me and I carry a limited number of bags according to the stock I have with me, ie 100 pots of various sizes, I have 100 bags of various sizes. Sadly Christmas fairs, craft fairs are not run on a collective basis, we each have to pay our own way. there is a degree of co-operation, but favours have to be requested and paid for, in cash or kind!

Ps I would be mightily miffed if another stallholder sent over a customer to ask for a bag. Usually People ask because they have bought several smaller items, each with their own bag and they realise it would be easier to carry them all in one bag. If another stallholder had suggested to a customer to ask me for a bag as they had run out, I would be having words with that stallholder.

I see.
So if they offered to buy a £34 item would you refuse to give them a 45p bag?

DPotter · 02/12/2022 21:43

Hotchocs
What if someone had then offered to buy an item 100x the price of the carrier bag then. £34. Would you have told them they had to buy an £100 item which fits in a carrier bag instead?

I factor in the cost of bags into the prices of my work, so little pots have 34p factored in, and larger items have 45p factored in. So if someone bought a pot for £100 it would be large and have a 45p bag linked to it. If another stallholder had sent a customer over to ask for a bag I still would have said no, because they hadn't bought anything from me and I carry a limited number of bags according to the stock I have with me, ie 100 pots of various sizes, I have 100 bags of various sizes. Sadly Christmas fairs, craft fairs are not run on a collective basis, we each have to pay our own way. there is a degree of co-operation, but favours have to be requested and paid for, in cash or kind!

Ps I would be mightily miffed if another stallholder sent over a customer to ask for a bag. Usually People ask because they have bought several smaller items, each with their own bag and they realise it would be easier to carry them all in one bag. If another stallholder had suggested to a customer to ask me for a bag as they had run out, I would be having words with that stallholder.

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 21:37

Cheesuswithallama · 02/12/2022 21:31

Op didn't say she told them greeks told her to go over as well. Just an fyi

Stop trying to make small businesses feel bad for not giving free things to randoms when they are not in positions to do so

Oh I see the Brazilians wouldn't have know that from what the OP said, but the OP would have totally understood the Brazillians had a limited number of forks from what they said? I guess perfect communication only works one way in this case.

And nobody is expecting them to give out free stuff. Once again you are constructing a strawman argument. They were either rude, incapable of making enough profit on a £3 item to give a 2p discount, or like the Greeks they didn't have enough forks with them. Which is it?

DPotter · 02/12/2022 21:32

You wouldn't believe what the buying public will ask ! Whole different thread....

Re plastic bags

charging is based on the size / turnover of the seller I believe. I buy in twisted handle paper bags - I could make them myself, but I'm a potter not a bag maker!

Cheesuswithallama · 02/12/2022 21:31

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 21:29

What if someone had then offered to buy an item 100x the price of the carrier bag then. £34. Would you have told them they had to buy an £100 item which fits in a carrier bag instead?

Also had they explained another stallholder sent them over wouldn't you have said they shouldn't have sent you over instead of talking about how you don't give out free stuff as if the OP is some kind of chancer?

Op didn't say she told them greeks told her to go over as well. Just an fyi

Stop trying to make small businesses feel bad for not giving free things to randoms when they are not in positions to do so

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 21:29

DPotter · 02/12/2022 21:26

I run a small craft business, I sell at Christmas markets and I can pretty much guarantee that at every market I go to I'll be asked have I a got a carrier bag by someone who hasn't bought anything from me. I use twisted handle bags which cost 34p for a medium sized one. I know 34p doesn't sound much but in this economic climate we find ourselves the 34p's mount up and margins are tight. I usually decline to provide.

The food stallholder who sold you the food should have approached the other stall themselves and made an arrangement, not placed you, and probably others, in the embarrassing position of asking and being refused.

What if someone had then offered to buy an item 100x the price of the carrier bag then. £34. Would you have told them they had to buy an £100 item which fits in a carrier bag instead?

Also had they explained another stallholder sent them over wouldn't you have said they shouldn't have sent you over instead of talking about how you don't give out free stuff as if the OP is some kind of chancer?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/12/2022 21:28

The Brazilian stall missed a trick. They should have accepted your offer to buy a drink and throw in a fork. If they did that every time a Greek food customer needed a fork, they would be making a nice little profit.

But people are saying about how vital goodwill is to the Brazilian stall. Once word gets out that 'they refuse to give you a fork unless you buy a drink' - with no mention of the fact that it's for use with food sold by somebody else and that they are reluctantly responding to a cheeky request, rather than proactively trying to cash in, that could massively backfire on them.

0.00019p

Where is this figure coming from repeatedly? The forks work out to about 2p each; if they were that price, you would get 100 for 2p! They're cheap, but not that cheap!

poefaced · 02/12/2022 21:27

DPotter · 02/12/2022 21:26

I run a small craft business, I sell at Christmas markets and I can pretty much guarantee that at every market I go to I'll be asked have I a got a carrier bag by someone who hasn't bought anything from me. I use twisted handle bags which cost 34p for a medium sized one. I know 34p doesn't sound much but in this economic climate we find ourselves the 34p's mount up and margins are tight. I usually decline to provide.

The food stallholder who sold you the food should have approached the other stall themselves and made an arrangement, not placed you, and probably others, in the embarrassing position of asking and being refused.

Good! Can’t believe they have the nerve to ask.

Don’t you have to legally charge for plastic bags now anyway?

DPotter · 02/12/2022 21:26

I run a small craft business, I sell at Christmas markets and I can pretty much guarantee that at every market I go to I'll be asked have I a got a carrier bag by someone who hasn't bought anything from me. I use twisted handle bags which cost 34p for a medium sized one. I know 34p doesn't sound much but in this economic climate we find ourselves the 34p's mount up and margins are tight. I usually decline to provide.

The food stallholder who sold you the food should have approached the other stall themselves and made an arrangement, not placed you, and probably others, in the embarrassing position of asking and being refused.

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 21:23

HoppingPavlova · 02/12/2022 21:22

Nope. It’s up to the Greek stall to go over to the Brazilian and say ‘can I have a handful of your forks please as I’ve run out and I’ll bring a handful back over tomorrow at set up and make sure I’m not short again’. You should be miffed at the Greek stall, not the Brazilian.

I'm miffed at the attitudes of both. Don't see why it has to be one or the other. It's not a competition for worst market stall.

Cheesuswithallama · 02/12/2022 21:23

ReedRite · 02/12/2022 21:20

It sounded to me like they were trying to bilk the OP out of £10, rather than explaining nicely.

Tbf with that rents on stalls, who wouldn't 😂

HoppingPavlova · 02/12/2022 21:22

Nope. It’s up to the Greek stall to go over to the Brazilian and say ‘can I have a handful of your forks please as I’ve run out and I’ll bring a handful back over tomorrow at set up and make sure I’m not short again’. You should be miffed at the Greek stall, not the Brazilian.

Cheesuswithallama · 02/12/2022 21:22

ReedRite · 02/12/2022 21:15

I’m not sure the staff in Costa and Starbucks will be that focused on the cost per unit of each sundry, but someone in the management chain will be. Just probably not the people on the ground.

I am not dosagreeing that was actually my argument to why chains are more willing to give things before on the thread

ReedRite · 02/12/2022 21:20

poefaced · 02/12/2022 21:16

They did explain, not very nicely, but maybe OP is an unreliable narrator. It doesn’t seem like a Christmas market stall would talk like to customers.

It sounded to me like they were trying to bilk the OP out of £10, rather than explaining nicely.

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 21:20

poefaced · 02/12/2022 21:16

They did explain, not very nicely, but maybe OP is an unreliable narrator. It doesn’t seem like a Christmas market stall would talk like to customers.

Would it seem like a Christmas stall would serve some food when they've run out of forks and another stall can't help out?

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 21:18

ReedRite · 02/12/2022 21:13

If they genuinely couldn’t give away a single fork for fear of running out early for their own customers, they could have spent 10 seconds explaining that nicely to OP.

I'm not sure how the OP wouldn't accept no, when they accepted it and offered to buy something instead. It's not like anyone would of taken on board that the stall is as back as the Greeks and doesn't bring some extra forks with them so can't give a fork away when someone purchases an item.

The OP was perfectly reasonable.

poefaced · 02/12/2022 21:16

ReedRite · 02/12/2022 21:13

If they genuinely couldn’t give away a single fork for fear of running out early for their own customers, they could have spent 10 seconds explaining that nicely to OP.

They did explain, not very nicely, but maybe OP is an unreliable narrator. It doesn’t seem like a Christmas market stall would talk like to customers.

ReedRite · 02/12/2022 21:15

Cheesuswithallama · 02/12/2022 21:04

Of course they are. They have better contracts thanks to buying power. What costs indie a pound, costs costa most likely 50p...
If you buy regularly 30million straws, you will of course get them waaaay cheaper than if you buy 3 thousand.

I’m not sure the staff in Costa and Starbucks will be that focused on the cost per unit of each sundry, but someone in the management chain will be. Just probably not the people on the ground.

Emotionalsupportviper · 02/12/2022 21:14

thelobsterquadrille · 02/12/2022 17:54

Exactly.

I'm not sure why the Brazilian stall is being slated - it's the Greek stall that's displaying shit business decisions!

I agree.

The Brazilian stall might have got a lot more customers if the Greek one had been upfront about having no cutlery - that might be what is peeing them off. Not only that they being expected to provide free forks, but they are being cheated of trade.

ReedRite · 02/12/2022 21:13

rwalker · 02/12/2022 21:05

it not stinginess when they give there forks away and run out for there own customers what do they do there quite right to refuse

doesn’t sound like OP just accept no when they said it they were obviously that pissed off they wouldn’t even sell her one

If they genuinely couldn’t give away a single fork for fear of running out early for their own customers, they could have spent 10 seconds explaining that nicely to OP.

Cheesuswithallama · 02/12/2022 21:13

ReedRite · 02/12/2022 21:10

That’s so interesting, thank-you. I’m not surprised in many ways.

I didn’t articulate it, but I was kind of wondering if in less wealthy areas the food places will have tighter margins and therefore be less able to be generous.

Yes, staff in the chains will be less invested in profit margins perhaps.

Our independents in my local area are very friendly and helpful and wouldn’t dream of refusing to give a plastic fork, but I guess they are completely dependent on building up a loyal local clientele. And when a cup of coffee and a slice of cake doesn’t leave you much change out of £8, I guess they can afford to be generous with the odd cup or fork! And not to do so would really not be giving out the right vibe.

People are also way less cheeky in actual business with premises and tables.

Takeaways and stalls bring out the worst in people for some reason. That's why they also have to be usually tough.

ReedRite · 02/12/2022 21:10

poefaced · 02/12/2022 21:00

www.thelondoneconomic.com/news/environment/poor-people-really-are-more-charitable-than-the-rich-according-to-new-research-93441/

Here it is! I suppose chains are more likely to give things like napkins/water than indie restaurants.

That’s so interesting, thank-you. I’m not surprised in many ways.

I didn’t articulate it, but I was kind of wondering if in less wealthy areas the food places will have tighter margins and therefore be less able to be generous.

Yes, staff in the chains will be less invested in profit margins perhaps.

Our independents in my local area are very friendly and helpful and wouldn’t dream of refusing to give a plastic fork, but I guess they are completely dependent on building up a loyal local clientele. And when a cup of coffee and a slice of cake doesn’t leave you much change out of £8, I guess they can afford to be generous with the odd cup or fork! And not to do so would really not be giving out the right vibe.

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 21:09

rwalker · 02/12/2022 21:05

it not stinginess when they give there forks away and run out for there own customers what do they do there quite right to refuse

doesn’t sound like OP just accept no when they said it they were obviously that pissed off they wouldn’t even sell her one

We've been over it. If that's the excuse then there was no need for them to be rude to the OP who had already explained the situation.

Either they're rude, incompetent, or both.

rwalker · 02/12/2022 21:05

ReedRite · 02/12/2022 20:48

We’ve covered this up thread 👆It’s not the same, though in my experience the chains are usually happy to give out the odd cup/napkin/straw etc, if you ask politely. As are many local independents.

I’ve never come across such abject stinginess as exhibited on this thread, but perhaps it’s a regional thing/area specific. I’m in quite an affluent area, maybe that’s playing a part.

it not stinginess when they give there forks away and run out for there own customers what do they do there quite right to refuse

doesn’t sound like OP just accept no when they said it they were obviously that pissed off they wouldn’t even sell her one

Cheesuswithallama · 02/12/2022 21:04

poefaced · 02/12/2022 21:00

www.thelondoneconomic.com/news/environment/poor-people-really-are-more-charitable-than-the-rich-according-to-new-research-93441/

Here it is! I suppose chains are more likely to give things like napkins/water than indie restaurants.

Of course they are. They have better contracts thanks to buying power. What costs indie a pound, costs costa most likely 50p...
If you buy regularly 30million straws, you will of course get them waaaay cheaper than if you buy 3 thousand.