Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"You can't have it for free",aibu?

360 replies

imacccu · 02/12/2022 15:00

So I'm at Manchester for the Christmas markets.
Spent £20 on a Greek sharing box to eat for lunch.
I ask for two forks and she tells me they've ran out and to get them from the Brazilian stand opposite.
So off I go and say "can I have two of the plastic forks please as the Greek stand have ran out"

She says "no I'm not allowed as you didn't buy food here,you can't expect them for free"
I said okay il buy a drink
She said no only food
The cheapest thing was £10
So I sad no
Aibu to think she could of gave me a plastic fork
Is this what the worlds came too?
She had a huge and I mean huge tub of cutlery

So we had to eat with our hands which was near impossible as it was coated in sauces etc

OP posts:
Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 02/12/2022 23:05

It was lunch time -the greek food stand owner was a dick for being understocked with cutlery but I get the opposite stall owners reason for saying no - she cannot be expected to supply free cutlery to all the greek food stands customers for the rest of the Day especially when they are not buying anything off her.

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 23:02

NumberTheory · 02/12/2022 22:49

OP is asking if it’s reasonable of her to expect a stall she has had nothing to do with to provide her with cutlery when the stall she bought from ran out. And in the absence of clear contractual obligation by the Brazilian stall to her, yes, it’s unreasonable. She should direct her ire to the stall she actually had a contract with who failed her.

The Greek stall can feel aggrieved if the Brazilian stall reneged on a proper agreement to provide cutlery for the Greek stall’s customers, though that seems vanishingly unlikely given the details OP has provided. But even if that were the case, it’s still the Greek stall who have chosen a “fork supplier” who didn’t deliver, and it’s the Greek stall OP had a contract with.

We have been told by market traders here that there is limited space for forks so it makes sense that there are going to be times when forks run out for the Greeks.

It also makes sense that the Brazillian stall opposite also runs the risk of running out of forks.

So it would be reasonable to assume that they would have a 2 way agreement for this scenario.

If they don't have a 2 way agreement both the Greeks and Brazillians are BU for not having one

If they do have an agreement Brazillians are BU for not honouring it given that they had a large tub of forks remaining.

The latter is the most likely as the Greeks sent them over to get forks. I don't see why they would do this if they didn't have an agreement.

Either way the Brazillians are BU.

NumberTheory · 02/12/2022 22:49

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 22:28

But regardless, the primary fault is with the Greek stall who
a) Did not bring the equipment their customers needed and
b) Deceived the OP by giving her the false impression a cooperative relationship with the other stall existed and that she could expect to get what she needed there. And so they got her to stop hassling them for something they ought to provide and transferred her ire onto the other stall.

Except you've now argued that there is a lot can be hypothesised about. So maybe the Greeks had an agreement with the Brazillians to cover each other when they ran out of forks and the Brazillians didn't honour it.

Maybe this is all on the Brazillians.

OP is asking if it’s reasonable of her to expect a stall she has had nothing to do with to provide her with cutlery when the stall she bought from ran out. And in the absence of clear contractual obligation by the Brazilian stall to her, yes, it’s unreasonable. She should direct her ire to the stall she actually had a contract with who failed her.

The Greek stall can feel aggrieved if the Brazilian stall reneged on a proper agreement to provide cutlery for the Greek stall’s customers, though that seems vanishingly unlikely given the details OP has provided. But even if that were the case, it’s still the Greek stall who have chosen a “fork supplier” who didn’t deliver, and it’s the Greek stall OP had a contract with.

poefaced · 02/12/2022 22:48

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 22:39

Actually this is the theory that now makes most sense on this thread.

The Greeks and the Brazillians had an agreement to cover each other when they ran out of forks. The Brazillian serving was new that day and didn't know this.

This can be deduced by
a) Space for forks is limited and margins are so tight in this business to the extent that it would make business sense to cover each other when either ran out of forks
b) You can sell the forks on at a significant markup when this happens
c) The OP said she had a huge and I mean huge tub of cutlery

So the Greeks were NBU as they had the agreement in place, but the Braziilians were BU for not informing their new employee about the agreement.

I think that theory is very unlikely.

MrsMorrisey · 02/12/2022 22:44

This would annoy me too OP. It's a fork 🤦‍♀️

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 22:39

Actually this is the theory that now makes most sense on this thread.

The Greeks and the Brazillians had an agreement to cover each other when they ran out of forks. The Brazillian serving was new that day and didn't know this.

This can be deduced by
a) Space for forks is limited and margins are so tight in this business to the extent that it would make business sense to cover each other when either ran out of forks
b) You can sell the forks on at a significant markup when this happens
c) The OP said she had a huge and I mean huge tub of cutlery

So the Greeks were NBU as they had the agreement in place, but the Braziilians were BU for not informing their new employee about the agreement.

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 22:28

But regardless, the primary fault is with the Greek stall who
a) Did not bring the equipment their customers needed and
b) Deceived the OP by giving her the false impression a cooperative relationship with the other stall existed and that she could expect to get what she needed there. And so they got her to stop hassling them for something they ought to provide and transferred her ire onto the other stall.

Except you've now argued that there is a lot can be hypothesised about. So maybe the Greeks had an agreement with the Brazillians to cover each other when they ran out of forks and the Brazillians didn't honour it.

Maybe this is all on the Brazillians.

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 22:26

NumberTheory · 02/12/2022 21:45

They aren’t going to know for sure, in advance, which Greek stall customer they gave a fork to was the one that was one free fork giveaway too many.

We have no idea if OP was the first customer to ever approach them, or if the Greek stall has been sending customers over for years and after realising they’ve been spending hundreds a year on forks for some other owner’s business, the Brazilian stall finally brought in a policy to protect their interests.

But regardless, the primary fault is with the Greek stall who

a) Did not bring the equipment their customers needed and
b) Deceived the OP by giving her the false impression a cooperative relationship with the other stall existed and that she could expect to get what she needed there. And so they got her to stop hassling them for something they ought to provide and transferred her ire onto the other stall.

This makes no sense whatsoever

If they Greeks were sending people over for forks for several years they could have made quite a decent profit out of forks. Would have been their highest margin by a long way.

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 22:17

Actually what's really surprising is that the Brazillians and Greeks didn't have an agreement if someone ran out of forks to help each other out, given the apparent risk involved in the limited amount of forks they can bring with them. Why would they not make this agreement?

ReedRite · 02/12/2022 22:15

I’m surprised you don’t bring a few extra carriers, DPotter, even if you’re not prepared to give them out. Just thinking for your own purposes, like if one splits, or somebody buying a £100 item asks for one extra or something. You wouldn’t say no to a 45p carrier and risk losing a £100 sale, presumably?

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 22:12

DPotter · 02/12/2022 22:05

Which begs the question what happens if one of your 45p bag splits. Do you refuse to sell a £100 item to a customer?

That would be up to the customer

So basically you're at the mercy of a limited amount of 45p bags as to whether your business is viable or not.

Just as a food stall is at the mercy of a limited amount of 2p forks as to whether their business is viable or not.

Which essentially means that the Greeks may have been in a position whereby something went wrong with the forks that day and from what I'm hearing margins are so tight in this business they could have gone under if they told the customers there were no forks left.

So why are they being criticised for being put in a position where they have a limited amount of something and can't afford to lose custom if something goes wrong?

DPotter · 02/12/2022 22:05

Which begs the question what happens if one of your 45p bag splits. Do you refuse to sell a £100 item to a customer?

That would be up to the customer

DPotter · 02/12/2022 22:03

I see so I'm leaning towards just plain rude then

I didn't perceive the conversation as reported by the OP to be rude. Unsatisfying for the OP yes, rude to her no.

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 22:03

Cheesuswithallama · 02/12/2022 22:01

In this case, yes, I got there.

Mainly because I think that you are either entitled with no understanding of pricing (which doesn't require more than basic math skills and common sense when someone said "it's all in the price together") and logistic such as "I can only carry as much", or you are now simply on a wind up.

Well the Greeks seem to understand it don't they? They didn't even have to include a fork with their sale 😅

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 22:02

DPotter · 02/12/2022 22:00

Seeing as you wouldn't sell for a 2p discount on a £3 item I assume that a 2500% markup on a 2p item would be something you would keenly negotiate as a business person who see an opportunity to make money

It isn't just about the 'discount' to one customer. It's about being able to provide a bag / fork / spoon to my future customers. I'm not going to compromise on the quality of service I provide to full paying customers. I don't discount as if you do, you run the risk of having to discount for a whole swathe of people, not just the first person to ask. I've seen traders fall foul of this and it gets ugly pretty quickly if you refuse a discount to someone whose friend has been in receipt of one, when discounts are not on general offer. As I say margins are tight and I don't price to include a % for a discount.

Well thanks for clarifying once again that you bring a limited amount of bags with you.

Which begs the question what happens if one of your 45p bag splits. Do you refuse to sell a £100 item to a customer?

Cheesuswithallama · 02/12/2022 22:01

In this case, yes, I got there.

Mainly because I think that you are either entitled with no understanding of pricing (which doesn't require more than basic math skills and common sense when someone said "it's all in the price together") and logistic such as "I can only carry as much", or you are now simply on a wind up.

DPotter · 02/12/2022 22:00

Seeing as you wouldn't sell for a 2p discount on a £3 item I assume that a 2500% markup on a 2p item would be something you would keenly negotiate as a business person who see an opportunity to make money

It isn't just about the 'discount' to one customer. It's about being able to provide a bag / fork / spoon to my future customers. I'm not going to compromise on the quality of service I provide to full paying customers. I don't discount as if you do, you run the risk of having to discount for a whole swathe of people, not just the first person to ask. I've seen traders fall foul of this and it gets ugly pretty quickly if you refuse a discount to someone whose friend has been in receipt of one, when discounts are not on general offer. As I say margins are tight and I don't price to include a % for a discount.

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 21:59

I see so I'm leaning towards just plain rude then.

Cheesuswithallama · 02/12/2022 21:58

You are being a twat Chox now

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 21:54

DPotter · 02/12/2022 21:50

So if they offered to buy a £34 item would you refuse to give them a 45p bag?

Yes, especially if it was at the beginning of the day. I may have 3 large pots as part of my stock needing large bags so would only bring 3 large bags with me so I need to reserve the large bags for the larger items. Stallholders have to carry every single piece of stock and display equipment with them and the only storage we have is behind the stall. We don't have the luxury of a store cupboard like a shop, where extra packaging can be stored just in case.

I see, so you don't bring enough spare 45p bags with you that if someone wanted one with a £34 item you would not sell the item.

Thanks for clarifying.

I guess then, the Greeks must have dropped a couple of forks or something and being market traders with these kind of margins, continued to sell the food. Perfectly understandable given this is the attitude towards customers right?

DPotter · 02/12/2022 21:50

So if they offered to buy a £34 item would you refuse to give them a 45p bag?

Yes, especially if it was at the beginning of the day. I may have 3 large pots as part of my stock needing large bags so would only bring 3 large bags with me so I need to reserve the large bags for the larger items. Stallholders have to carry every single piece of stock and display equipment with them and the only storage we have is behind the stall. We don't have the luxury of a store cupboard like a shop, where extra packaging can be stored just in case.

Cheesuswithallama · 02/12/2022 21:49

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 21:37

Oh I see the Brazilians wouldn't have know that from what the OP said, but the OP would have totally understood the Brazillians had a limited number of forks from what they said? I guess perfect communication only works one way in this case.

And nobody is expecting them to give out free stuff. Once again you are constructing a strawman argument. They were either rude, incapable of making enough profit on a £3 item to give a 2p discount, or like the Greeks they didn't have enough forks with them. Which is it?

Really just stop it.

Business don't own random people free stuff nor do they owe them some explanations of their finances and stocking because that is what would happen.
"My apologies, but we cannot as we don't have too many ourselves"
"I can see loads behind you"
"Yes, that's for our service today"
"But you got loads. Just give me some"
And so on.
(Sounds exaggerated? Had very similar discussions about goods and inventory)

They also don't have to give forks with drinks. It is simple as that.

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 21:49

DPotter · 02/12/2022 21:45

Hotchocs

They were either rude, incapable of making enough profit on a £3 item to give a 2p discount

Just so you know Hotchocs - I never discount

Oh ok lets put it another way
They were either rude, incapable of making enough profit on a £3.02 item from explicitly including the cost of the fork in the price of the drink, incapable of negotiating the sale of a fork on at a 2500% markup, or like the Greeks didn't bring enough forks with them.

Seeing as you wouldn't sell for a 2p discount on a £3 item I assume that a 2500% markup on a 2p item would be something you would keenly negotiate as a business person who see an opportunity to make money.

So which is it?

NumberTheory · 02/12/2022 21:45

ReedRite · 02/12/2022 21:13

If they genuinely couldn’t give away a single fork for fear of running out early for their own customers, they could have spent 10 seconds explaining that nicely to OP.

They aren’t going to know for sure, in advance, which Greek stall customer they gave a fork to was the one that was one free fork giveaway too many.

We have no idea if OP was the first customer to ever approach them, or if the Greek stall has been sending customers over for years and after realising they’ve been spending hundreds a year on forks for some other owner’s business, the Brazilian stall finally brought in a policy to protect their interests.

But regardless, the primary fault is with the Greek stall who

a) Did not bring the equipment their customers needed and
b) Deceived the OP by giving her the false impression a cooperative relationship with the other stall existed and that she could expect to get what she needed there. And so they got her to stop hassling them for something they ought to provide and transferred her ire onto the other stall.

DPotter · 02/12/2022 21:45

Hotchocs

They were either rude, incapable of making enough profit on a £3 item to give a 2p discount

Just so you know Hotchocs - I never discount