Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"You can't have it for free",aibu?

360 replies

imacccu · 02/12/2022 15:00

So I'm at Manchester for the Christmas markets.
Spent £20 on a Greek sharing box to eat for lunch.
I ask for two forks and she tells me they've ran out and to get them from the Brazilian stand opposite.
So off I go and say "can I have two of the plastic forks please as the Greek stand have ran out"

She says "no I'm not allowed as you didn't buy food here,you can't expect them for free"
I said okay il buy a drink
She said no only food
The cheapest thing was £10
So I sad no
Aibu to think she could of gave me a plastic fork
Is this what the worlds came too?
She had a huge and I mean huge tub of cutlery

So we had to eat with our hands which was near impossible as it was coated in sauces etc

OP posts:
VanGoghsDog · 03/12/2022 09:49

ReedRite · 03/12/2022 01:30

If anybody needed 10p for something and asked, I’d give it to them.

It’s 10p.

Wouldn’t you? To help someone out?

Ever heard of paying it forward?

I'd give a person 10p, or even £10.

A business? No.

And if I were a business, I'd not go around giving away 10p here and there.

VanGoghsDog · 03/12/2022 09:45

OP did actually offer to pay for £3 for a drink, which would cover the cost of the fork many many times over.

Someone doesn't understand how profit works .....

Cheesuswithallama · 03/12/2022 09:36

"i don't understand how other business in other situations are run, but you are all wrong anyway. And angry"

😂

ReedRite · 03/12/2022 09:16

RishisProudMum · 03/12/2022 02:01

You may want to refresh yourself in analogies. It’s a question that was directly prompted by your silly statement. That the answer isn’t to your liking doesn’t change the facts.

What you do in your small (non catering) business has nothing to do with how they run theirs.

And I’d suggest you look into a mirror. Your attitude, which proclaims that anyone who doesn’t run their business as you see fit (despite the fact that you know nothing about them or said business) is somehow lacking in decency and kindness strikes me as cold, self-centred and lacking in psychological insight.

The fact that you are compelled to insult anyone who disagrees with you strikes me as extremely dim. Which isn’t an attractive trait.

Obviously I’ve really hit a nerve judging by the angry tone of your replies. We’re clearly not going to agree. You think it’s good to be tight and I don’t. Different strokes for different folks, I guess 🤷‍♀️

imacccu · 03/12/2022 09:04

We had been to las iguanas for bottomless brunch so our "dinner" was just when we fancied it ..hence grabbing something so late from the markets

OP posts:
poefaced · 03/12/2022 07:40

Do you not think it a wee bit cheeky and rather awkward to be effectively saying "I see that you are selling food, which is what I now need, but I shall instead give my business to your competitor

From the customer’s perspective, it’s just a fork, but is cheeky from the stall holders perspective.

I was at an event where there were 4 food stalls, all providing the same kind of hot food for free. (i.e. paid for by the event organisers but us attendees got it for free).

I chose the stall with the shortest queue food and got my food with a paper plate and plastic cutlery but they had run out of takeaway boxes (I wanted to take it away). They asked me to ask another stall for a box.

I asked another stall and they said sorry, they only had enough for their own customers.

I was a bit miffed, because it was a free event and the stalls had already been pre-paid for their services.

But then I realised, it was extremely busy and they had to prioritise the customers who had chosen their stall.

BadNomad · 03/12/2022 04:53

Was it today you ate lunch with your hands, in the dark, at 20:30?

Tsort · 03/12/2022 02:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Why is it a silly question?

Maverickess · 03/12/2022 02:03

ReedRite · 03/12/2022 01:30

If anybody needed 10p for something and asked, I’d give it to them.

It’s 10p.

Wouldn’t you? To help someone out?

Ever heard of paying it forward?

Yup, I'd give someone 10p if they needed it and asked, probably the next person too, probably the next 10 or 20.
But I'd have to draw the line somewhere because even if I was 'only' giving away 10p at a time, in a situation where I was continually faced with requests, it'd start costing me what I can't afford pretty quickly.
And no matter with which person I drew the line, whether I'd given away 10p or 10 grand - that person would feel aggrieved that I wouldn't help them to the tune of 'only' 10p. They wouldn't know or care about the people I'd previously helped to be nice, only that I was 'mean' by not helping them.

That said it's a good business tactic to destroy the reputation of a competitor - send everyone over to the opposition for a fork because you've run out, knowing they'll either say no or they will soon get fed up and then people are put off them by them saying no and are not likely to use them in future, and there you are (with replenished forks at the ready) to serve who may have been their customers!

Also with the mutual fork covering agreement - maybe they had this agreement and the Greeks didn't fulfill their obligations yesterday when the Brazilian's ran out of cutlery and the Brazilian's are now returning the favour? 🤔

RishisProudMum · 03/12/2022 02:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You may want to refresh yourself in analogies. It’s a question that was directly prompted by your silly statement. That the answer isn’t to your liking doesn’t change the facts.

What you do in your small (non catering) business has nothing to do with how they run theirs.

And I’d suggest you look into a mirror. Your attitude, which proclaims that anyone who doesn’t run their business as you see fit (despite the fact that you know nothing about them or said business) is somehow lacking in decency and kindness strikes me as cold, self-centred and lacking in psychological insight.

The fact that you are compelled to insult anyone who disagrees with you strikes me as extremely dim. Which isn’t an attractive trait.

ReedRite · 03/12/2022 01:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

RishisProudMum · 03/12/2022 01:41

ReedRite · 03/12/2022 01:30

If anybody needed 10p for something and asked, I’d give it to them.

It’s 10p.

Wouldn’t you? To help someone out?

Ever heard of paying it forward?

So, no? You don’t often just give 10p to caterers who haven’t provided you with a service? As that was the question.

Well, neither does anyone else. Passers by don’t just pop in and gives small business owners a bit of cash for nothing in return. So there is no reason to expect the reverse other than entitlement.

They are businesses and are not there to help people out, fulfil needs for which they are not recompensed or pay it forward. They are there to turn a profit.

ReedRite · 03/12/2022 01:30

RishisProudMum · 02/12/2022 23:35

A commercial enterprise that exists to make money (in an industry with notoriously tight margins) is ‘mean’ for not giving stuff away?

Do you often just give 10p to caterers who haven’t provided you with a service? Just not to be ‘mean’? If not, does that make you an arsehole?

If anybody needed 10p for something and asked, I’d give it to them.

It’s 10p.

Wouldn’t you? To help someone out?

Ever heard of paying it forward?

NumberTheory · 03/12/2022 00:54

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 23:02

We have been told by market traders here that there is limited space for forks so it makes sense that there are going to be times when forks run out for the Greeks.

It also makes sense that the Brazillian stall opposite also runs the risk of running out of forks.

So it would be reasonable to assume that they would have a 2 way agreement for this scenario.

If they don't have a 2 way agreement both the Greeks and Brazillians are BU for not having one

If they do have an agreement Brazillians are BU for not honouring it given that they had a large tub of forks remaining.

The latter is the most likely as the Greeks sent them over to get forks. I don't see why they would do this if they didn't have an agreement.

Either way the Brazillians are BU.

Your logic fails at the start.

An agreement is not the obvious solution to the issue. Such an agreement would only be mutually beneficial if both traders were equally competent at meeting demand for cutlery. If one of them is not as good at this business task (or deliberately stiffs the other) such an agreement would penalise the more talented trader. So it is not reasonable to assume they would have one.

Also, the Greek stall has an obvious incentive to lie to their customer and tell her she can get cutlery elsewhere as they would not want her going on about the lack of cutlery in front of other potential customers. Sending her to another stall penalises their competition and removes a potential disincentive for other customers (she might return if she can’t cadge any from elsewhere, but less likely to do that at that point as most people just give up - and, indeed, OP spent her time in an exchange with the Brazilian stall, not having a go at the Greek stall for selling her food without cutlery).

Frenulumetta · 03/12/2022 00:38

If she had any business sense at all she would have sold you some cutlery for less than £10 and if the other place had any business sense at all they would go buy more or not run out in the first place. But no they were not unreasonable to refuse you free cutlery they pay for that they cannot subsidise other businesses its hard enough in the catering trade as it is.

ReedRite · 03/12/2022 00:26

MrsMorrisey · 03/12/2022 00:04

Yes but people remember when someone has been generous or not and that does affect future business.

If she had given me the fork, next time I'd buy my meal from them.

Well yes, that’s generally the way it works. There seems to be a lot of posters on here, though, who run small businesses that don’t need any repeat business to thrive.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/12/2022 00:14

The first person to look up the price miswrote it as 0.019p, instead of £0.019. Posters then added a few more zeros for good measure.

Ah, OK, then - but it looked to me (I may be wrong) that it was the same person consistently having reduced the prices of forks a hundred-fold!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/12/2022 00:11

The market traders here have said the Brazilian stall would have not have had that many forks to do that (despite the OP pointing out they did)

We don't know how many customers the Brazilian stall gets, so although they had 'loads', they may just have got the number that they anticipated needing for an expected number of meals sold over a certain time period.

It's a bit like somebody seeing your healthy-looking bank account on pay day and declaring that the drinks are all on you, but not factoring in all of your unavoidable bills that money has to cover throughout the month.

MrsMorrisey · 03/12/2022 00:04

Yes but people remember when someone has been generous or not and that does affect future business.

If she had given me the fork, next time I'd buy my meal from them.

DPotter · 02/12/2022 23:44

ReedRite
I’m surprised you don’t bring a few extra carriers, DPotter, even if you’re not prepared to give them out. Just thinking for your own purposes, like if one splits, or somebody buying a £100 item asks for one extra or something. You wouldn’t say no to a 45p carrier and risk losing a £100 sale, presumably?

I'm a sole trader, a potter. I'm already carrying 4 plastic storage boxes of pots (each weighing in the region of 15kg), a box of lights, batteries, chargers & table coverings, a box of display stands & clamps, a bag of bags, a bag of bubble wrap, a box for price tags, card payment mc, scissors, pens, tape, business cards, a bag for food for the day, a water bottle, plus a flask, sometimes 2, for coffee (my margins this Christmas season don't run to buying food and drink from other stallholders, be they Brazilian, Greek, or any other nationality). Half the time I am also providing my own table and chair.

Over the last 12 years I have honed the stuff I carry to the bare minimum. This evening I had 8 trips up and down 2 flights of stairs to pack up my stuff from a Christmas craft fair. It's events like this that save me on gym membership! In order to make a £100 sale I need the pot and the means to take a card payment. Touching large quantities of wood, I have never had a bag split on me. It's more important to have my chargers so my phone and card machine work. Do I have the wherewithal to carry additional bags, or anything else non-essential - NO. I know an extra bag or 2 wouldn't take much room, however there are things I would prefer to take as extras so where would the extras stop? I already fill a large hatch back with all my kit.

Like many, if not all aspects of life, my business is a balancing act - it's finely honed, regularly reviewed and (again touching large quantities of wood) rarely lets me down. I'm focused on my customers (potential and actual) - other stallholders will have to look after theirs.

BadLad · 02/12/2022 23:43

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/12/2022 21:28

The Brazilian stall missed a trick. They should have accepted your offer to buy a drink and throw in a fork. If they did that every time a Greek food customer needed a fork, they would be making a nice little profit.

But people are saying about how vital goodwill is to the Brazilian stall. Once word gets out that 'they refuse to give you a fork unless you buy a drink' - with no mention of the fact that it's for use with food sold by somebody else and that they are reluctantly responding to a cheeky request, rather than proactively trying to cash in, that could massively backfire on them.

0.00019p

Where is this figure coming from repeatedly? The forks work out to about 2p each; if they were that price, you would get 100 for 2p! They're cheap, but not that cheap!

The first person to look up the price miswrote it as 0.019p, instead of £0.019. Posters then added a few more zeros for good measure.

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 23:37

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/12/2022 23:07

This would annoy me too OP. It's a fork

Do you not think it a wee bit cheeky and rather awkward to be effectively saying "I see that you are selling food, which is what I now need, but I shall instead give my business to your competitor, whom I believe to offer a superior product and/or better price, and none to you; but as they are unable to provide a fork, I shall nevertheless expect you to cheerfully hand one over to me, a competitor's customer" ?

I know OP offered to buy a drink after the stall said No, but only as a reaction to their declension - there was no automatic assumption that she should clearly be a customer in order to receive items provided to customers.

Aside from that, as we've said, it was quite possibly dozens and dozens of forks that the Brazilian stall was expected to hand over free of charge when they could have been serving their own actual customers. If 2p will never amount to anything significant, regardless of volume, will you pay one into my bank account every hour for the next 30 years?

The OP did not want a free fork, just did not want to buy another meal that was expensive and would go to waste.

If the Brazillian stall had an overage of forks then they could have easily sold a fork to the OP for a significant markup. Easily 50p for a 2p fork. If they didn't facilitate a clear win win situation here then the Brazillian stall was BU.

The market traders here have said the Brazilian stall would have not have had that many forks to do that (despite the OP pointing out they did) in which case they should have an agreement with the Greek stall to cover each other when either runs out of forks, particularly since the Greek stall sent the OP to the Braziliian stall. I don't know why they'd do that if they had no agreement. If the Brazilian stall did not honor this agreement the Brazillian stall is BU.

If they do not have an agreement and have a limited amount of forks the Brazillian stall has the same risk of not being able to supply cutlery as the Greek stall. Therefore the Brazilian stall is again BU.

RishisProudMum · 02/12/2022 23:35

ReedRite · 02/12/2022 16:46

Because being so tight you won't give someone the steam off your piss makes you an arsehole?

How much is a plastic knife and fork to a caterer who buys them in bulk? 10p?

Mean.

A commercial enterprise that exists to make money (in an industry with notoriously tight margins) is ‘mean’ for not giving stuff away?

Do you often just give 10p to caterers who haven’t provided you with a service? Just not to be ‘mean’? If not, does that make you an arsehole?

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 23:09

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/12/2022 23:07

This would annoy me too OP. It's a fork

Do you not think it a wee bit cheeky and rather awkward to be effectively saying "I see that you are selling food, which is what I now need, but I shall instead give my business to your competitor, whom I believe to offer a superior product and/or better price, and none to you; but as they are unable to provide a fork, I shall nevertheless expect you to cheerfully hand one over to me, a competitor's customer" ?

I know OP offered to buy a drink after the stall said No, but only as a reaction to their declension - there was no automatic assumption that she should clearly be a customer in order to receive items provided to customers.

Aside from that, as we've said, it was quite possibly dozens and dozens of forks that the Brazilian stall was expected to hand over free of charge when they could have been serving their own actual customers. If 2p will never amount to anything significant, regardless of volume, will you pay one into my bank account every hour for the next 30 years?

It's also quite possible that the Greeks covered the Brazillians dozens and dozens of times when the Brazillians ran out of forks, and the Brazillians decided not to repay the favour.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/12/2022 23:07

This would annoy me too OP. It's a fork

Do you not think it a wee bit cheeky and rather awkward to be effectively saying "I see that you are selling food, which is what I now need, but I shall instead give my business to your competitor, whom I believe to offer a superior product and/or better price, and none to you; but as they are unable to provide a fork, I shall nevertheless expect you to cheerfully hand one over to me, a competitor's customer" ?

I know OP offered to buy a drink after the stall said No, but only as a reaction to their declension - there was no automatic assumption that she should clearly be a customer in order to receive items provided to customers.

Aside from that, as we've said, it was quite possibly dozens and dozens of forks that the Brazilian stall was expected to hand over free of charge when they could have been serving their own actual customers. If 2p will never amount to anything significant, regardless of volume, will you pay one into my bank account every hour for the next 30 years?