Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"You can't have it for free",aibu?

360 replies

imacccu · 02/12/2022 15:00

So I'm at Manchester for the Christmas markets.
Spent £20 on a Greek sharing box to eat for lunch.
I ask for two forks and she tells me they've ran out and to get them from the Brazilian stand opposite.
So off I go and say "can I have two of the plastic forks please as the Greek stand have ran out"

She says "no I'm not allowed as you didn't buy food here,you can't expect them for free"
I said okay il buy a drink
She said no only food
The cheapest thing was £10
So I sad no
Aibu to think she could of gave me a plastic fork
Is this what the worlds came too?
She had a huge and I mean huge tub of cutlery

So we had to eat with our hands which was near impossible as it was coated in sauces etc

OP posts:
gobbynorthernbird · 04/12/2022 10:11

@HotChoxs are you local to Manchester and have you been to the Xmas markets?

slashlover · 04/12/2022 10:05

Take it up with the market traders who said they have limited space for cutlery. People can't have it both ways.

But maybe they prioritised cutlery over something else? Maybe they don't need as much equipment as the other stall, we don't know. They have no obligation to set up an agreement with another staff when they might not need help or they may never see the other stall again.

HotChoxs · 04/12/2022 10:00

slashlover · 04/12/2022 09:36

Well actually we do, the Greek stand had run out of forks While the Brazilian one still had loads left.
Obviously they weren't selling much or making any profit so should have sold a drink. Unless they were being petty and unreasonable. Which they were.

Why obviously? Maybe they bulk bought enough cutlery to last a while so they didn't run out or have to shut up shop to make a cash and carry run? Maybe the Greek stall brought 100 forks and ran out and maybe the Brazilian stall brought 500 forks and still have 300 left.

Take it up with the market traders who said they have limited space for cutlery. People can't have it both ways.

If they had that many forks it's a poor decision not to use one to sell a drink with one. Don't have to be a market trader to see that if the profit margins for a drink are that poor they'll be out of business quickly.

HotChoxs · 04/12/2022 09:54

NumberTheory · 04/12/2022 03:35

So you are admitting that your assertion that they are unreasonable not to have an agreement is false?

And now you are asserting that a specialist food cart is unreasonable not to automatically become a cutlery retailer - even though you have no idea about the long or short term market for it, the opportunity cost, Christmas Market rules over what they can sell, or what the public attitude might be to them opportunistically selling disposable cutlery for a significant mark up?

Not at all. If you read back you'll see the market traders said that the stalls will have limited space for cutlery.

On this basis a specialist food stall should either have an agreement with another for adverse circumstances or if they're not selling anything adapt to survive.

Clearly nobody wants to use this food stall because of their poor attitude and they're likely to go out of business.

slashlover · 04/12/2022 09:36

Well actually we do, the Greek stand had run out of forks While the Brazilian one still had loads left.
Obviously they weren't selling much or making any profit so should have sold a drink. Unless they were being petty and unreasonable. Which they were.

Why obviously? Maybe they bulk bought enough cutlery to last a while so they didn't run out or have to shut up shop to make a cash and carry run? Maybe the Greek stall brought 100 forks and ran out and maybe the Brazilian stall brought 500 forks and still have 300 left.

gettingolderandgrumpier · 04/12/2022 09:35

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/12/2022 12:39

I was also going to say that, if any half-decent person would give anybody 10p without thinking twice, can I come to yours with 500 mates who are all 10p short - and then back again tomorrow and the next day?!

I’m impressed you have 500 mates !

NumberTheory · 04/12/2022 03:35

HotChoxs · 04/12/2022 02:45

They wouldn't need one in this situation.

If the Greek stall was sending loads of customers over to the Brazil stall asking for forks, then they could have just made a nice profit couldn't they.

If they weren't then the Greek stall wasn't frequently running out of forks and there's no reason for the Brazil stall not to cover the Greek stall in an adverse event.

Both are quite obvious win/win business decisions.

So you are admitting that your assertion that they are unreasonable not to have an agreement is false?

And now you are asserting that a specialist food cart is unreasonable not to automatically become a cutlery retailer - even though you have no idea about the long or short term market for it, the opportunity cost, Christmas Market rules over what they can sell, or what the public attitude might be to them opportunistically selling disposable cutlery for a significant mark up?

HotChoxs · 04/12/2022 02:55

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/12/2022 00:11

The market traders here have said the Brazilian stall would have not have had that many forks to do that (despite the OP pointing out they did)

We don't know how many customers the Brazilian stall gets, so although they had 'loads', they may just have got the number that they anticipated needing for an expected number of meals sold over a certain time period.

It's a bit like somebody seeing your healthy-looking bank account on pay day and declaring that the drinks are all on you, but not factoring in all of your unavoidable bills that money has to cover throughout the month.

Well actually we do, the Greek stand had run out of forks While the Brazilian one still had loads left.

Obviously they weren't selling much or making any profit so should have sold a drink. Unless they were being petty and unreasonable. Which they were.

HotChoxs · 04/12/2022 02:45

NumberTheory · 04/12/2022 02:36

What exactly do you think the agreement is that the two stalls would have in this situation?

They wouldn't need one in this situation.

If the Greek stall was sending loads of customers over to the Brazil stall asking for forks, then they could have just made a nice profit couldn't they.

If they weren't then the Greek stall wasn't frequently running out of forks and there's no reason for the Brazil stall not to cover the Greek stall in an adverse event.

Both are quite obvious win/win business decisions.

NumberTheory · 04/12/2022 02:36

HotChoxs · 04/12/2022 00:37

Incorrect, since if one is unable to meet demand from cutlery, the other could easily profit from selling cutlery at a markup.

The more I think about it the more it's clear that the Brazillian stall is in the wrong.

What exactly do you think the agreement is that the two stalls would have in this situation?

HotChoxs · 04/12/2022 00:37

NumberTheory · 03/12/2022 00:54

Your logic fails at the start.

An agreement is not the obvious solution to the issue. Such an agreement would only be mutually beneficial if both traders were equally competent at meeting demand for cutlery. If one of them is not as good at this business task (or deliberately stiffs the other) such an agreement would penalise the more talented trader. So it is not reasonable to assume they would have one.

Also, the Greek stall has an obvious incentive to lie to their customer and tell her she can get cutlery elsewhere as they would not want her going on about the lack of cutlery in front of other potential customers. Sending her to another stall penalises their competition and removes a potential disincentive for other customers (she might return if she can’t cadge any from elsewhere, but less likely to do that at that point as most people just give up - and, indeed, OP spent her time in an exchange with the Brazilian stall, not having a go at the Greek stall for selling her food without cutlery).

Incorrect, since if one is unable to meet demand from cutlery, the other could easily profit from selling cutlery at a markup.

The more I think about it the more it's clear that the Brazillian stall is in the wrong.

onlythreenow · 04/12/2022 00:34

It's their cutlery, they can give it away or not. However, I imagine you won't be buying anything from them in future, and neither will some of the people you have told this story to. A business should never undervalue its reputation, something the Brazillian stall has failed to grasp.

suzanneinfo · 04/12/2022 00:11

Am assuming Manchester has a shop that sells forks 😝 More going on here. Absolutely they should do a deal with a fellow trader and sort it longer term. Appalling that you are already paying a premium and they aren't delivering a means to eat it.

Bleachmycloths · 03/12/2022 19:18

No, she couldn’t “of gave” you a fork but she could “have given”
I don’t care what a snotty cow I am or what outraged replies I get. But FFS, 2 grammatical mistakes in two words 🙄

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/12/2022 18:54

The Greek stall were being ridiculous. They knew they had run out of cutlery

On the other hand, if it had been plates that they'd run out of, I would completely understand Grin

somuchshoppingsolittletime · 03/12/2022 18:50

The Greek stall were being ridiculous. They knew they had run out of cutlery - they should have asked a favour to buy some in bulk from another stall so they could continue trading. It was very unreasonable of them to tell you to ask a competitor for free stuff, when they had taken a sale away from them.

Bekstar · 03/12/2022 18:39

Those who should have given culterly where the ones who sold them. If they were out they should have gone over themselves and requested extra from nearby stall. Of course they don't owe you the cutelry.

T1Dmama · 03/12/2022 18:38

The stall you bought from should’ve ordered enough forks!..
why should the other supply forks to people who shopped elsewhere.. then they’d run out..

gobbynorthernbird · 03/12/2022 18:33

ReedRite · 03/12/2022 00:26

Well yes, that’s generally the way it works. There seems to be a lot of posters on here, though, who run small businesses that don’t need any repeat business to thrive.

They don't need (or really get) repeat business. They aren't permanent premises with regular customers, they're temporary stalls visited by tourists/out of towners.

wentworthinmate · 03/12/2022 18:27

I'd be mightily PO and have told the Greek stall exactly what I thought and asked for a refund. They should have told you they had no forks.

threatmatrix · 03/12/2022 17:50

imacccu · 02/12/2022 15:00

So I'm at Manchester for the Christmas markets.
Spent £20 on a Greek sharing box to eat for lunch.
I ask for two forks and she tells me they've ran out and to get them from the Brazilian stand opposite.
So off I go and say "can I have two of the plastic forks please as the Greek stand have ran out"

She says "no I'm not allowed as you didn't buy food here,you can't expect them for free"
I said okay il buy a drink
She said no only food
The cheapest thing was £10
So I sad no
Aibu to think she could of gave me a plastic fork
Is this what the worlds came too?
She had a huge and I mean huge tub of cutlery

So we had to eat with our hands which was near impossible as it was coated in sauces etc

Are you for real? I can see you never have had and never will have a business .

Lamaitresse · 03/12/2022 17:44

YABU for using a plastic fork in the first place.
Take your own cutlery with you next time, then wash it at home.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/12/2022 12:39

I was also going to say that, if any half-decent person would give anybody 10p without thinking twice, can I come to yours with 500 mates who are all 10p short - and then back again tomorrow and the next day?!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/12/2022 12:36

That said it's a good business tactic to destroy the reputation of a competitor - send everyone over to the opposition for a fork because you've run out,

It doesn't do an awful lot for your own reputation to sell people food that obviously needs cutlery and only then tell them that you don't have any, though.

One reason I prefer Aldi or Lidl over Asda or Morrisons is because the former always have boxes that you can take or otherwise will sell you a decent re-usable bag for a fair price if you need one. Asda only ever have those 30p plastic 'bags for life' (that are now so thin, they're barely any stronger or more durable than the old 'single-use' bags - and our local Asda frequently run out of them anyway); and Morrisons will either charge you 60p for a similar bag (granted, a bit thicker than the Asda ones) or offer you one of the rubbish paper ones.

I know others will disagree, but to me, in this one aspect at least, I consider the German stores good businesses in recognising the customers' need and being willing and able to help you to take your goods away in a practical way; whilst the others (in this respect) are shockingly-bad businesses that don't even care about helping customers to get their purchases home, once they have their money. It's certainly put me off going to them or buying nearly as much if I've forgotten my own bags or have underestimated how many I would need.

RishisProudMum · 03/12/2022 12:22

ReedRite · 03/12/2022 09:16

Obviously I’ve really hit a nerve judging by the angry tone of your replies. We’re clearly not going to agree. You think it’s good to be tight and I don’t. Different strokes for different folks, I guess 🤷‍♀️

My response was in the tone befitting of your (now deleted) insulting comment. Your multiple odd posts on this thread would indicate that the person for whom this has ‘hit a nerve’ is you. I wonder why.

You think it’s good to be entitled and blinkered and I don’t. Different strokes for different folks, I guess. 🤷🏽‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread