Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think Kanye West's racism is going to lead to an increase in violence against Jews?

254 replies

smokedsalm0n · 02/12/2022 11:03

Firstly, I am Jewish, no connection to Israel, I'm not Israeli (not that I need to qualify my post with that) and have lived in the UK all my life.

So, after his recent rantings about loving Hitler, Nazis and the holocaust (torontosun.com/entertainment/celebrity/i-like-hitler-kanye-west-doubles-down-on-hate-speech-on-alex-jones-infowars-show)

I'm feeling very scared and scared for my kids, especially reading recent threads like this:

www.mumsnet.com/talk/secondary/4662884-kanye-wests-harmful-views-tackling-antisemitism-at-school

Kanye is very influential and popular with the younger generation and my Jewish children are already getting more racist comments said to their faces without any fear of retribution. I am genuinely scared for their physical safety. Jews shouldn't have to live in fear, its 2022 ffs not the 1930s!

OP posts:
AnElegantChaos · 02/12/2022 16:45

Testingprof · 02/12/2022 16:26

I wish people wouldn’t compare racism and anti semitism in this way. Yes I can imagine a teacher doing the same about racism, because it happens all the time.
Racism in my experience is far more acceptable socially than antisemitism. You only have to look at threads where an op has experienced racism and they are repeatedly told maybe that isn’t the issue or any other excuse. I’ve yet to see that on a thread about anti semitism, I’m not saying it’s never happened.

You only have to look at threads where an op has experienced racism and they are repeatedly told maybe that isn’t the issue or any other excuse. I’ve yet to see that on a thread about anti semitism

Check out the Baddie thread then from last week because that is exactly how Jews were treated on that thread! And how they've been getting treated increasingly over the last few years. Antisemitism is racism. 6 million were killed because of their non-Aryan race.

There's currently a thread on Lady Hussey's behaviour where I've made the same point, except in relation to anti-black racism and how it's repeatedly minimised by white people who like to tell black people that they are exaggerating and imagining things. A quick look at the very online left on Twitter will show you how Jews are treated with exactly the same kind of language and accusations; that there's no issue, they're making it up. The 'It's a Scam' crowd in particular.

Squeezita · 02/12/2022 16:43

EgonsShell · 02/12/2022 16:29

@PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog Yes, this. There was another thread quite recently where many posters proudly declared their antiracist credentials, yet for them Jews were fair game to be mocked and disbelieved. Their racism was a lot more veiled than the more explicit rightwing variety or extreme cases like Kanye.

they’re not anti racists then

LondonWolf · 02/12/2022 16:41

I think he's trying to ruin Kim Kardashian by association. I think a big punishment for Kim for leaving him is a big part of this.

TheVanguardSix · 02/12/2022 16:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

It’s called hate speech.

CPL593H · 02/12/2022 16:36

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 02/12/2022 16:18

Antisemites and racists are not always one and the same. One encounter I had was with someone who would describe themselves as anti racist, but still made a remark about 'fucking jews in Isreal' in my hearing.

I think sometimes people who would consider themselves anti racist have no problem making anti semitic remarks (the word "consider" is deliberate) but Nick Fuentes is a white supremacist. KW is very much included in the people he hates, if he could see it.

Echobelly · 02/12/2022 16:34

@Desdem - I agree, KW isn't the threat so much as the extremists infrastructure that will make use of his views.

@Testingprof - you may not have seen it here, but Jews do get a lot of 'You're too sensitive', 'You just see antisemitism everywhere'. Tbh, some of my co-religionists are oversensitive but I always ask people to try to understand why that might be.

EgonsShell · 02/12/2022 16:29

@PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog Yes, this. There was another thread quite recently where many posters proudly declared their antiracist credentials, yet for them Jews were fair game to be mocked and disbelieved. Their racism was a lot more veiled than the more explicit rightwing variety or extreme cases like Kanye.

Testingprof · 02/12/2022 16:26

Choconut · 02/12/2022 13:51

Everyone knows Kanye has Bipolar disorder and it often seems probably a god complex. He thinks he has the answer and is the answer to all the worlds problems. He needs to step away and get himself well - but he probably doesn't feel like there's anything wrong with him, he probably thinks he's invincible and even if the whole world disagrees with him, then they're the ones that are wrong. What do you do with someone that ill? IMO he shouldn't be allowed on tv for his own sake as well as others, he's not going to listen to anyone advising him as he probably thinks he's god, and people want him on their show as he's very famous and who knows what craziness he'll come out with next (or what he can be goaded into saying) - it's exploitation in itself IMO.

HIs influence means he's a worry, but reading the other MN thread that the OP linked to was more horrifying IMO. A teacher who didn't know if it was worth tackling anti semitism because that just might make it worse. WHAT? Could you imagine a teacher saying that about racism in a school? Before it was an issue with the labour party I had no idea anti semitism was such an problem in this country but it's really worrying that teachers think it's not worth tackling for whatever reason.

I wish people wouldn’t compare racism and anti semitism in this way. Yes I can imagine a teacher doing the same about racism, because it happens all the time.
Racism in my experience is far more acceptable socially than antisemitism. You only have to look at threads where an op has experienced racism and they are repeatedly told maybe that isn’t the issue or any other excuse. I’ve yet to see that on a thread about anti semitism, I’m not saying it’s never happened.

Squeezita · 02/12/2022 16:22

@PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog that’s disgusting but that person is not an anti-racist. You have to be an equal opportunities anti-racist, not some are more equal than others.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 02/12/2022 16:22

Kanye West is very troubled, and I think almost everyone recognises that he spouts nonsense. However it is worrying to think where the hatred he is expressing really comes from, what voices he has been listening to that feed his resentment and anger. And who else is listening to those voices.

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 02/12/2022 16:18

CPL593H · 02/12/2022 15:51

Quite, I hold KW responsible for the hate speech and using his platform to spread it, but where I think whatever MH crisis he is experiencing is a real factor is not being able to see that Nick Fuentes and the rest of the loathsome lot are using him.

Antisemites and racists are not always one and the same. One encounter I had was with someone who would describe themselves as anti racist, but still made a remark about 'fucking jews in Isreal' in my hearing.

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 02/12/2022 16:16

@smokedsalm0n as a fellow Jew, I don't think this one incident will cause anymore of a rise than what we have seen already. We live in Manchester and are more cultural than religious. DH looks much more obviously jewish than I do, strong ME genes. He has had an increasing amount of abuse on the streets in the last 5 - 10 years. I am afraid the ship has sailed and I worry for our DC's future. DD has just started school, at a C of E school, because we were so worried about security at the Jewish schools. DH and I are very Sad to have to make that choice.

Marblessolveeverything · 02/12/2022 16:02

His ranting is horrific and is sickening. Some of the messages recently sent to David Biddal on his recent documentary were eye opening to me. The fact today children in the UK have to practice drills is absolutely heart-breaking.

I am in Ireland - we have a tiny Jewish population, and I believe there is generally a respect, interest and curiosity of Jewish traditions and history.

I would be interested to know, and this is in no way an excuse - doesn't Kanye have well documented mental health issues - is his illness leading to this disgusting rants?

I don't think hate speech should ever be facilitated under "freedom of speech".

CPL593H · 02/12/2022 15:51

ancientgran · 02/12/2022 14:35

Wouldn't a lot of racist bigots be anti KW as a black man as much as they are antisemitic? I sort of assumed the sort of person who is racist is well racist.

Quite, I hold KW responsible for the hate speech and using his platform to spread it, but where I think whatever MH crisis he is experiencing is a real factor is not being able to see that Nick Fuentes and the rest of the loathsome lot are using him.

Desdem · 02/12/2022 15:50

BigMandsTattooPortfolio · 02/12/2022 14:49

It was only recently that the far right Roger Stone endorsed the idea of West as Trump’s Vice President in ‘24.

It’s one of the world’s oldest and ugliest prejudices, for nigh on 3000 years the Jewish People have been persecuted under many empires. Terrifying how anti-Semitism has escalated to the extent it has. As pp mentioned, it’s on the extreme Left as well as the far Right.

Roger Stone is a frightening individual. I can imagine hard right backers pursuing this ticket.

West being Black will have its advantages. His musical legacy is kind of irrelevant now. He still has a huge platform, draws the headlines and is probably open to the possibility of a big platform - a political one - to reach more ears.

I agree, OP. He's dangerous. Perhaps not him per se, but the right wing machinery that is growing around him to drive the most aggressive right-wing agenda.

iklboo · 02/12/2022 15:43

I take it he knows fuck all about Hitler's Aryan Race beliefs and the Reich's treatment of Black people.

pointythings · 02/12/2022 15:42

He is an appalling man. He is also very mentally unwell. But I don't think he is as influential with the younger generation as people think - his views probably chime with the QAnon subset in the US and their followers and that is concerning, but the average young person (and I have a household of them) think he is a mentally unwell racist who should not be listened to by anyone.

hamstersarse · 02/12/2022 15:25

Julienne4467 · 02/12/2022 15:19

I watched the whole 3 hour stream, unlike anyone on here, and no, I would not be worried.

God well done. I imagine it’s a challenge to do 3 hours of Ye and Alex Jones 🤐

Julienne4467 · 02/12/2022 15:19

I watched the whole 3 hour stream, unlike anyone on here, and no, I would not be worried.

Echobelly · 02/12/2022 15:15

Some people are saying racists will be put off by messages coming from someone of colour, but remember most aren't overt racists, some of them see this as a opportunity (ironically) to say 'See I'm not a racist, I agree with this black person - he's got a point'. Although they like this view on the erroneous front that they think 'woke' people's worldview means that they can never criticise women/ black people/LGBTQ people, which is of course not the case at all!

TooBigForMyBoots · 02/12/2022 15:09

YANBU @smokedsalm0n. The rise and acceptance of antisemitism recently is frightening. WTF has happened to our society?Sad

LoveFoolMe · 02/12/2022 15:06

@CountZacular
Without sounding like ‘whataboutary’, I also feel like there’s been a huge rise in misogyny and homophobia too and I wonder why, at time when we’re supposed to be more aware of combating hate is society becoming abhorrent in general?

Whenever there’s an economic downturn, I think people tend to look for scapegoats to vent their frustrations on. Sadly I suspect we’ll see further prejudice, conspiracy theories and hate crime until the global economy recovers.

PlinkPlonkFizz · 02/12/2022 15:01

StaunchMomma · 02/12/2022 14:38

It's really quite frightening to watch him descend into madness in front of our very eyes but yes, also terrifying to watch him stoke the flames of antisemitism to an audience that is already predisposed to believing misinformation on a grand scale.

I agree that his words will likely lead to attacks on Jewish communities.

I wish more people of influence would speak out against it and try to balance his non-sensical rants with reasoning & empathy.

I also hope Kim will stop her children from spending any time with Papa for the foreseeable!!

I agree with you. This is a man in a frightening mental health crisis, not a free-speech pioneer of unsayable things.

BigMandsTattooPortfolio · 02/12/2022 14:49

It was only recently that the far right Roger Stone endorsed the idea of West as Trump’s Vice President in ‘24.

It’s one of the world’s oldest and ugliest prejudices, for nigh on 3000 years the Jewish People have been persecuted under many empires. Terrifying how anti-Semitism has escalated to the extent it has. As pp mentioned, it’s on the extreme Left as well as the far Right.

Isitsixoclockalready · 02/12/2022 14:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

So is anything then. What is your opinion on what he said?