Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asked to borrow some money from DP over Xmas period

281 replies

Ajaal · 02/12/2022 10:52

Hi, me and DP have been together for 8 years. We have a 1 year old child and I work part time and care for our child, him full time.
We both pay into the joint account, him obviously more than me but I contribute what I can. After paying the joint account, my phone bill, my car tax monthly payments I am currently only left with about £150 per month to live on which has to pay for my fuel and daily living expenses. This month I have nearly run out because of Christmas and buying people presents. I asked him if I would be able to borrow some money and then pay it back to him after pay day, so that I would be able to go out to my works Christmas dinner. He had a less that happy reaction to me asking for some money.
Am I being unreasonable? He seems to think I am living a life of some sort of luxury ..... which couldn't be further from truth

OP posts:
AccioChocolate · 02/12/2022 11:37

Marriage isn't for everyone. Some women can't get past the historical ties to what was basically women passed from father to husband as a maid, sex doll, and childcare provider

I am completely sympathetic to that view.

However you have chosen to be the maid and childcare provider without even the protection that women who were married were provided. He is not being your provider. He has all the benedits an of a traditional relationship where you are a 50s housewife but he has none of the obligation to provide

That's crazy.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 02/12/2022 11:36

Also consider if you really want to be staying in a relationship with someone who doesnt want to share, and wont even lend you (rather than give) the money for one meal

Mirrorcell · 02/12/2022 11:35

Woman - sacrifice career. Clean house. Limited free time. Cook. Child rearing. Skint. What are the pros?

man - advance career. More money. Savings. Cooked for. Cleaned after. No financial disadvantage. What are the cons?

emilydickinsonscat · 02/12/2022 11:35

Your situation is crazy!

Are you housemates who had a ONS and that resulted in a child?
Which you decided to keep against his wishes?

Because thats what your financial set-up reads like.

Families are completely different - everyone working together and supporting each other as a team a unit.
This is why people often get married before having children, I know you can be financial abused within marriage, but at least the intention is you operate as a unit.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 02/12/2022 11:34

As PP have said

You should have equal spending money
If he doesnt ask if he can go out for a meal then neither should you
The savings as his, not yours, unless you're married or named on the account
He is benefiting from you sacrificing your career to save on childcare costs. You are subsiding the family much more than him.
If you don't have equal access to money you need to go back to work full time, making sure he pays his proportionate share of childcare costs, to build up your savings pot
Make sure all spends on children (days out, clothes and everything) come out of the joint account
Dont have any more children with him until this has sorted

ThatEdgyFeeling · 02/12/2022 11:34

Ajaal · 02/12/2022 11:16

@LaLuz7 Nope I don't have access to it. I am aware that I sound absolutely mad to everyone on here.... I get it, I do! Sadly it's not always that clear cut. There are many reasons as why someone not feel able to leave somebody. I just wanted to see what peoples reactions would be because sometimes he makes me feel like I'm being selfish, bad with money etc, not caring about saving for the future etc etc

He would say that, wouldn't he?🙄

IncompleteSenten · 02/12/2022 11:33

You are being mugged off

You need to tell him that you are going to go back to work full time because you are absolutely sick of his attitude about money and you want financial security and independence.

And that of course this means he will be doing 50% of all things domestic and child related as well as paying half of childcare fees.

When he complains about that, suggest he outsource his share of responsibilities to you for a grand a month.

honeylulu · 02/12/2022 11:32

Sigh. If marriage isn't for you, get a civil partnership fgs. Otherwise you're literally enslaving yourself to the bloke while he sits on HIS pile of cash. If he gets fed up and dumps you, you won't see any of it I bet.

There's nothing cool/ modern/liberated about that!!!

beachcitygirl · 02/12/2022 11:31

More red flags than a communist parade.

011899988I9991197253 · 02/12/2022 11:30

He gets all the benefits of having a wife and you get none of the benefits of having a husband.

This is such a great way of putting it, @Dacadactyl

beachcitygirl · 02/12/2022 11:30

Ajaal · 02/12/2022 11:06

Just to add we are not married because neither of us has the desire to be married. Marriage isn't for everyone - I know it's the norm, but I've never desired a marriage or a wedding from ever since I was younger

Then you're a bloody mug. Marriage protects women who go part time. You don't need the party or fancy ceremony but you (evidently ) need the protection of the law.

Marriage is a contract & it makes sure NOONE is left worse off should relationship end.

Proudofitbabe · 02/12/2022 11:30

Unless he's actually also skint, he should GIVE you the money and wish you a great night out. Anything else is being a total tightwad. Why do people tolerate this, it's such an awful quality in a partner/father.

Bananarama21 · 02/12/2022 11:29

Hes financially abusive and by not being married you are not protected by law including savings and if the house is in his name regardless if you share a child.

NoSquirrels · 02/12/2022 11:29

Work out how much you would get paid for working FT, and how much childcare would then cost.

Then ask to sit down and go through household finances with him.

If you would be left with more money every month once you’d paid a share of the childcare and living costs in proportion to your income, then you can start the discussion about how you should get more money each month/contribute less to overall living costs because you are doing childcare and housework.

NerrSnerr · 02/12/2022 11:29

Of course marriage isn't for him, why would it be when it works out well for him this way doesn't it?

You need to get back to working full time, make him pay his share and protect yourself.

beachcitygirl · 02/12/2022 11:28

isthewashingdryyet · 02/12/2022 10:57

Not another woman bringing up a child as her contribution to the family, and not getting equal access to family money. This must be the fifth post about this, this week

All money in one pot, equal personal spends. You have a shared child, and are sacrificing your future financially

I am so worried this is so common

I literally couldn't agree with this poster more!

Young women doing this!

Give your heads a bloody wobble.

All FAMILY money into one pot. Set amount in different account for bills & food etc

Then what's left split EQUALLY in half.

You are working part time to bring up his child/children.

🛑 STOP being taking for a bloody mug .

SurpriseSparDay · 02/12/2022 11:28

JFC …

How are you ‘together’ - given the financial circumstances you describe.

And you’re deluding yourself about your own and your child’s security going forward. This is no partnership.

Bookworm20 · 02/12/2022 11:27

You are not being selfish OP. He is.

You have reduced your working hours (and therefore pay) to look after your child (HIS child) and also do all the house stuff.

Yet his life has carried on absolutely as normal. No sacrifice for him anywhere in sight.

Money should be shared equally given that you are doing all the house stuff and childcare. Why should that leave you worse off financially? I bet if you suggested switching roles he'd think you were mad.

And you have no access to the savings. That is because they are his savings. So he gets to carry on his career, save loads of money, and this leaves you, the mother of his child, worse off.

So, who do you think is the selfish one here?

Tell him finances need to be shared. Or get yourself back to work FT and he can cough up half the childcare (although I suspect if you suggested that, he would say you'd have to pay it all because YOU want to return to work).

And he shouldn't be lending you some money to go on your xmas work thing. He should be giving it to you. I bet you he is going on his work xmas thing without a second thought.

peaceandove · 02/12/2022 11:27

Why, why, why do women willingly put themselves in such a vulnerable position? Why on Earth have a child with someone when you clearly don't agree on how finances should be split.

Twenty years ago when I had DD1, we agreed I would work part time, but all our money went into a shared account, my name was on the mortgage and on our savings account.

I would never have had a child with DH if he wasn't happy with this.

DenholmElliot11 · 02/12/2022 11:26

He should have offered to pay for the meal for you for a treat. Just out of curiousity when was the last time he brought you a bunch of flowers?

liarliarshortsonfire · 02/12/2022 11:26

I'd be telling him that you're going back to work full time as you can't afford part time and he's going to have to pay his % of childcare and 50% of all childcare, housework etc

Catflapping · 02/12/2022 11:26

Why do have a joint bank account if not to share money? With my DP all our wages go into our joint account and all our bills come out of it. DP earns 3x my wages. We have spending pots for different things and more long term spending and that comes out the joint account too. Whatever’s left it for us to spend as we see fit, we don’t ask about clothes and small treats,lunches and what not. If one of us wants to buy something big we’ll have a discussion about it, still not asking permission, but just a check that we think our finances are ok for it, e.g. DP bought a £500 BBQ on sale last month.
It sounds awful to have to ask for money, and doesn’t feel like a good base for a long lasting happy relationship either. I would have an open discussion about how this is making you feel. If you can’t have a comfortable discussion about money then I can’t really see you can be in a happy relationship. I would feel trapped.

TrixJax · 02/12/2022 11:26

After paying the joint account, my phone bill, my car tax monthly payments I am currently only left with about £150 per month to live on which has to pay for my fuel and daily living expenses

I would consider all the above should come out of the joint account. They are all household costs which the family benefits from. Your phone is needed for nursery or childminder to contact you, car and fuel needed for family shop, ferrying DC around, commuting to work. These are all essential spends for your household.
So you both need to pay the same proportion of your salary into joint account eg 70% and pay everything out of that except PERSONAL spend like clothes for you, hair, nails, gifts, nights out. I would not class family car and petrol as a personal spend.

MulderSmoulder · 02/12/2022 11:26

011899988I9991197253 · 02/12/2022 11:18

Marriage is a legal contract that provides financial security for you, and your child.

You are 100% entitled to opt-out of entering into that contract, but you can’t then moan that it’s all unfair where you’re the one who has created and enabled this unfair set-up.

This man has no legal or financial connection to you. He doesn’t need to give you money.

Exactly. It’s unbelievable how many women buy into the idea that marriage is this fairytale nonsense, that they don’t need a bit of paper to prove commitment or love.

Then they have a baby, drop work & end up financially dependent on someone with no legal protection.

Could there be a connection between the men who don’t believe in marriage and the ones who don’t want to held fully responsible for the costs of procreating?

Yesnoormaybe · 02/12/2022 11:26

Surely you must have known that he was a nasty selfish bastard before you decided to have a baby. Did you discuss how finances would work when you Would be working part time. As pps have said you need to work full time and he can pay half the child care. Then you need to ltb.