Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to empty the bank to buy a car?

58 replies

Shannny · 02/12/2022 08:22

We have around £8k in our bank. By the end of the month this will go down to about £6k - then we’ll get paid and it will go back upto £9k before dwindling down again with mortgage, bills and groceries etc.

Generally we add around £500 a month to the “max balance” but sometimes we lose that and we’ll be same as month before or less.

Anyway, we both desperately need new cars. Both of our cars are over 10 years old and are starting to fail and cost a lot in repairs. We’ve only had them for around 4 years.

I’m starting to think it’s false economy buying these old cars. One of them has cost us more in repairs than we actually bought it for. We’re talking thousands.

So we need to replace at least one of them. Looking at Ford Kuga. DH says the max we can spend is £7k and it has to come out of bank. No credit. This will wipe out our bank account (that we’ve spent years building up) for another old car.

I think we should get one on zero interest credit and spend around £10k. This will get us a much newer car with less miles.

YABU - DH is right, use the money you have in bank even though it will wipe you out and leave you with no safety net

YANBU - get in on credit so you get a decent car for once.

OP posts:
hennybeans · 02/12/2022 10:29

I would echo other posters about Japanese brands being the most reliable. I've driven Toyotas for 25 years- only need regular servicing, new tyres, and wipers. They just keep going and going.

DH usually goes for Fords or VWs. He is always at the garage getting something replaced. I finally convinced him to get a Honda. Happy days.

I would get a Japanese make on 0 percent finance if you can.

Hellsmovie · 02/12/2022 10:22

Cant not cang

Hellsmovie · 02/12/2022 10:22

Surely a 10 year old car cang cost that much to maintain?

I've got a 18yr old car that cost me £550 last 2 Mot's passed with 2 advisories

VisitingThem · 02/12/2022 10:22

I think you are right OP, I was brought up never to buy anything on credit but with cars they just cost so much when they are older in terms of maintenance and parts etc. Our current car was only 3 years old when we got it and its been a revelation tbh.

Lcb123 · 02/12/2022 10:21

I’d get a decent second hand car on credit. It’s precarious to not have those savings. Can you trial have one shared car? Might be cheaper even if you get some taxis. We have one shared car, means a bit of organising but works for us, and saves a lot of money.

Snowpaw · 02/12/2022 10:21

You could get finance on just some of the cost of it; I bought an excellent used car. It's been ticking over just fine with minimal repair costs since about 2017. I put half down in cash and got finance for the other half. That way I didnt have a huge debt hanging over me but I didnt wipe out all my savings.

I think as long as you get a used car from an approved, reputable dealer then they are a really good deal. I would never buy a brand new car - absolute waste of money given the speed with which they depreciate.

Piffpaffpoff · 02/12/2022 10:20

At the moment, with decent interest rates for savings, 0% finance is the more financially efficient route to take I think.

In your situation, I'd do 0% on the car and then take a big chunk of the money in savings and lock it into a savings account for a year or two to get the best interest rate, leaving you with a reasonable float for emergencies.

SilentHedges · 02/12/2022 10:18

My last car was 21 years old, that's what I class as old. It was still going fine and not costing money, I just wanted something more comfortable for longer commutes.

I've just upgraded to a newer car, which is 8 years old. When I hear a 10ish year old car, described as old and expensive to repair, it tells me you're driving the wrong type/make of cars.

I've always driven Hondas, I have friends that drive old Honda's with zero expensive repairs. Failing that, look at other Japanese brands, they make incredibly reliable cars.

xogossipgirlxo · 02/12/2022 10:15

I would go crazy knowing I spent all my savings. Your idea is better.

user1471447863 · 02/12/2022 10:10

0% interest is sensible - especially since you have the cash siting there earning interest but available to pay off the loan should the need arise.
There's not going to be too much difference (other than availability) in reliability/age/condition between a 7k and a 10k kuga though.

OnlyFannys · 02/12/2022 09:56

Shannny · 02/12/2022 09:28

Leonberger (st Bernard sized)

Can we....can we see the dog? 👀

Skadoo · 02/12/2022 09:50

Hyundai and Kia are the same brand, sometimes it is the exact car with a different look to it, (Kia Venga and Hyundai i20 are the same car) weird difference being that Kia offer a 7 year warranty and Hyundai a 5. I always wonder why some car manufacturers still only offer a 3 year warranty. Way to stand by your brand.

Dh has a Kia sportage. Great car. I would do what you have suggested and put the car on a 0% with a view to how long it will take you to pay that back and then you keep the savings.

The one thing I will suggest doing is get an independent mechanic to look over the car. The easiest way to do this is AA which I think cost us just under £200 for the vehicle and all the other checks that you can do. This meant that recently when I bought a 2 year old car with a full service history I could reject it based on a fault picked up by us on the test drive, backed up by the AA report and then a failure by the dealership to be able to fix said fault. I got a full refund. Just because a garage has serviced it does not mean a car does not have faults.

WonderfulCounsellors · 02/12/2022 09:47

Just saddle the dog up like a horse

Pearls1234 · 02/12/2022 09:43

I’m with you on this.

I bought my last car when it was 5 years old and over the years I spent thousands more on repairs than I spent on it in the first place. I accept that I should have moved on sooner but it had sentimental value. 😞
It was scrapped at 13 after a repair quote for about 5 times the value of the car. It had a good run, but these repairs were getting more frequent and more expensive.

After all that I wanted peace of mind so I opted for a new car on a good finance deal, with a decent manufacturer warranty. If anything malfunctions in the next few years, it’s covered. Always check what is and isn’t included and the terms of warranty period/mileage, but overall the warranty was a big selling point and they tend to be longer with new cars.
Plus no MOT for three years, which was always an expensive time with my old car.
On a purely indulgent note, it was my first brand new car and I loved being able to choose it. It’s orange!

As long as you can comfortably afford the payments and you’re confident your financial position is not likely to change (obviously anything can happen, but YKWIM), I’d say go for it. Keep your emergency fund for just that.

CottonSock · 02/12/2022 09:43

I would seriously consider going down to one newer car. Even if it means occasional taxis, it's still cheaper.

KirstenBlest · 02/12/2022 09:42

I thougt it would be something like a St Bernard or Great Dane.

I'm another one who has an old car. Usually bought from someone I know and trust. Not had a bad un yet. I'd forgotten that new car prices had gone up a lot since I last looked.

It's not a good time to buy a used car right now. You'd probably be better off looking at a new one. An estate car might be an option.

Jellycatspyjamas · 02/12/2022 09:41

If you’re looking at a Sportage size car I’d highly recommend the Hyundai Tucson, super reliable and cheap to run. I bought a year old one 6 years ago and have never had a days bother with it.

In general I’d go for a newer car on finance than buying an older one outright, I can budget for repayments but not for random repairs especially when I rely on the car for school runs etc the inconvenience of having it off the road is worth paying more for the car.

Dacadactyl · 02/12/2022 09:39

Sorry ignore me! I've just seen it's interest free credit.

Dacadactyl · 02/12/2022 09:38

I can see both sides of this so I'm not voting.

Do either of you have any relatives or friends from whom you can borrow some money (interest free ideally, or at a lower interest rate than a bank) so as not to need credit? Apologies if you've already thought of this and it's not viable. It's just that it's how we get our cars.

Shannny · 02/12/2022 09:37

How about a Kia Sportage? I just need a big car that don’t break the bank. We do love Kuga but not sure if it’s the best way to go finance wise

OP posts:
FuckabethFuckor · 02/12/2022 09:35

Sorry, a ten-grand Kuga or whatever

FuckabethFuckor · 02/12/2022 09:35

A seven/eight-grand Kuga (or whatever) isn’t necessarily going to be the last word in reliability either, and you might end up doing many of the same repairs again that you’ve already done on your current cars.

Personally, I’d keep the older ones going. I run older cars, and I have a sort of monthly slush fund and do preventative maintenance out of that.

AdoraBell · 02/12/2022 09:34

I would do the zero interest credit, as long as you can manage the payments.

MaggieFS · 02/12/2022 09:30

Bet that wasn't the answer expected about the dog. Definitely a big one! (And beautiful).

As long as you manage it sensibly which it sounds like you will, I'd do as you suggest,

Shannny · 02/12/2022 09:28

KirstenBlest · 02/12/2022 09:06

How big is the dog?

Leonberger (st Bernard sized)

OP posts: