Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being unreasonable to ask her to sell theatre tickets?

167 replies

Strawberryjam45 · 02/12/2022 07:06

My neice stayed with my for 3 months while she found her feet in a new (and very expensive city). The deal was that she would help out with my two LOs around work. My birthday is on Xmas eve and I asked her whether it was ok to babysit then as I wanted to go to the theatre. She said ok and I booked. Just for context we never do anything on Xmas eve/we are not culturally Christian so it didn't strike me as this was in anyway unreasonable.

Fast-forward 3 months and my neice has now moved out and found her own place. I went to lunch with her and asked if she was still good for babysitting on that day. She looked at me blankly before saying in a very casual manner that she had forgotten and was actually going to spend that day at home in her home city as she had a few days off. First I heard of it and her tone wasn't apologetic.

I mentioned this to her mum (my sister) and said that while I understand my niece's plans have changed would it be possible for her to try and sell the non-refundable/exchangeable tickets as I'd only bought them as she'd agreed to babysit and there wasn't any other feasible childcare options which weren't a faff. The tickets were £200 by the way and I just don't want the hassle of trying to shift them.

Her mum said that she thought I was being unreasonable as her daughter had felt "pressurized" to say yes as she was living with me (news to me as she made herself at home while living with us (borrowing personal items without asking etc, not feeling the need to buy groceries etc, which was fine but hardly the behavior of someone who feels obliged by their circumstances) and is very good at saying "no" in general. She also said she thought it was unreasonable for me to ask her to babysit on Xmas eve (even though we never celebrate Xmas eve as a family and it was my bday). She said she would buy the tickets from me as otherwise I would "go on about it forever".

Am I right to feel annoyed at my sister? Although she's offered to pay for the tickets, her tone was very off and like I had been v unreasonable. My neice is not a child by the way, she is well into her mid-20s.

OP posts:
InsomniacVampire · 02/12/2022 08:57

I think people are beign a bit harsh on you OP- you helped the niece out massively and she checked out as soon as she found her own feet. Which she would not be have been able to do without your help.

Id be annoyed too and would not be reaching out to help her ever again.

Feef83 · 02/12/2022 08:55

The niece is no doubt back to her hometown because her flat mates are all going back to their respective families.

op - the more i think about this, the most i think you sound quite profoundly unpleasant

Feef83 · 02/12/2022 08:53

I would never ask someone in their 20s just moved to a big city to commit to babysitting on Xmas eve * 3 months* before the event itself!

Weirdwonders · 02/12/2022 08:53

Also how are you expecting her to get where she needs to go on Christmas Day? Is she spending it with you or will she have to travel somewhere after you get home? Have you offered to pay her to be there across Christmas Eve and Christmas Day? It’s all very well saying it’s not celebrated in your family but I suspect that’s not the case.

HelpMeCope85 · 02/12/2022 08:51

You’re being VU here OP. Very entitled. Your sister shouldn’t have to pay. Get a babysitter or sell the tickets yourself.

Feef83 · 02/12/2022 08:51

So you say Xmas isn’t important in your family

and yet…

you niece has booked a few days off over Xmas and is going back to her family

and

your sister thinks She also said she thought it was unreasonable for me to ask her to babysit on Xmas eve

MGMidget · 02/12/2022 08:50

PS, the niece probably did feel a bit pressurised too but said yes with no intention of following through to placate you whilst she was living with you. Obviously Christmas Eve is a big occasion for many so it is quitte a big ask but if she didnt do much else then expecting a big favour in return for your big favour was not unreasonable in the circumstances.

MyAutocorrectWishesMeDeaj · 02/12/2022 08:50

YABVU. Get another babysitter. You literally have weeks.

PingPongMerrilyWithPie · 02/12/2022 08:47

They're on your card, sort them out yourself.

Your sister has been kind to offer, however much you don't appreciate it, and personally I think it would be churlish to take her up on the offer.

You're this girl's aunty. We're all human, she is only young and not in a world where everything is pre-planned around childcare. Put it down to an innocent mistake and move on from it. You just look vindictive and unkind trying to make the tickets her problem.

Tulipomania · 02/12/2022 08:47

OP, you have 2 choices here:

  1. Find another babysitter
  2. sell the tickets yourself

You've still got 3 weeks to sort it out.

poefaced · 02/12/2022 08:45

borrowing personal items without asking etc, not feeling the need to buy groceries etc

At 25, she should know better. Don’t have her to stay again.

luxxlisbon · 02/12/2022 08:43

Your niece likely did feel pressured. How is she supposed to go to her family for Christmas if she’s babysitting for you in a different city on Christmas Eve?

Its annoying when childcare falls through but ultimately you just need to make other arrangements or don’t go. I’m not sure why you think it’s your niece’s responsibility to sell the tickets.

rookiemere · 02/12/2022 08:39

If you can't or won't get another babysitter, you're probably better placed to sell the tickets. You're in an older age group so people more likely to have the spare cash and inclination to go, and you presumably live locally so should know people in the area.

If you were to put them on Facebook marketplace right now you should get at least half face value for them, but as others have said check with the theatre as you may well be able to change the date you go.

devildeepbluesea · 02/12/2022 08:39

Sorry posted too soon.

asking her to babysit on Christmas Eve whilst she’s staying with you (and providing free childcare) is cheeky in itself. Presumably she’s a young girl who may well have friends to see and parties to go on on Christmas Eve.

I don’t blame her at all for saying no now that she doesn’t live with you.

And as for getting her to sell the tickets / getting the money off your sister - that’s quite the level of entitlement.

Just get another sitter or sell the things yourself.

Weirdwonders · 02/12/2022 08:38

It might have been a reasonable request if she was still living with you but it’s three months ago and she’s since moved out. Of course she’ll have said yes at the time, she probably didn’t feel like she could say otherwise.

MGMidget · 02/12/2022 08:38

It is probably going to be easier for you to get a refund than for your niece ir sister to find a buyer for the tickets. I think your niece and sister could have shown a bit more gratitude for 3 months accommodation and hosting in an expensive city as it doesnt sound like she did a lot/created extra work for you so I can see why you feel she should have honoured the commitment to babysit as a return favour. However, she isnt that type of person and neither is her mother. I would probably distance myself a little from them and not put yourself out in future.

devildeepbluesea · 02/12/2022 08:36

I think asking your niece to babysit on Christmas Eve, whatever your culture, whilst she’s essentially a

Feef83 · 02/12/2022 08:34

I’m most baffled about going to the theatre on Xmas eve and leaving your children with a babysitter!

Feef83 · 02/12/2022 08:34

I mentioned this to her mum (my sister)

why did you not chat with your niece?

Sunshineandflipflops · 02/12/2022 08:31

I can understand you being annoyed at being let down but this isn't anything to do with your sister as your neice is an adult.

In your situation, I would either try and get another babysitter (made more difficult by it being Xmas eve) or, assuming you have a partner and you were going to go with them, they stay home and you take a friend instead.

caringcarer · 02/12/2022 08:26

You have plenty of time to arrange another babysitter or to sell tickets on. You are being mean to drag your sister into it. Just accept your niece forgot she agreed 3 months ago. People change their plans.

CatSpeakForDummies · 02/12/2022 08:26

I can see that she felt babysitting while she lived there was part of her "contract," and once she'd moved out it wouldn't occur to her to keep doing it.

You have weeks, to either find someone to babysit or to leave DH at home and take a friend. I can't believe you object to this "faff" more than taking £200 off your sister.

MaryMollyPolly · 02/12/2022 08:22

you must have realised at the time of asking, that young people usually have their own special plans for the Christmas holidays

The niece did have plans -to babysit.

LAMPS1 · 02/12/2022 08:21

Passing your problem on to an innocent third party is very unreasonable.
Why involve her at all ? Sounds as if you wanted to punish her by making it her problem as the mother of the niece who you feel let you down.
It’s sad your theatre plans are scuppered but really, you must have realised at the time of asking, that young people usually have their own special plans for the Christmas holidays whether they are of the Christian faith or not ( just as you did).
Try to sell the tickets yourself or pay a baby sitter if you can find one at this stage. Don’t accept your sister’s plan to buy the tickets. Sort this unfortunate mix-up between you and your niece yourself and apologise to your sister for bringing her into it all.

rookiemere · 02/12/2022 08:18

With tickets that expensive, I'd have checked with her a few times along the way to make sure she had remembered and was still on board.

We have young adult nephew who used to come up for the occasional weekend to look after teen DS so we could go away. Although I'd ask him months in advance, I'd need to double check with him much nearer the date as he'd have forgotten.

Shame that you can't just get another babysitter.