Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if you get the teacher an Xmas gift..

110 replies

twohomesneeded · 01/12/2022 21:31

... that you don't forget the TA?

It doesn't have to be another gift, just a card from your child (or you) saying how much their support is appreciated.

Being a TA can sometimes be a thankless (and occasionally challenging) task and this one small thing could just make your child's TA smile and count themselves lucky to have great kids and parents at their school.

OP posts:
summers2016 · 03/12/2022 13:14

Totally agree Pumperthepumper.

Pumperthepumper · 03/12/2022 13:06

I really think we need to stop saintifying people who work in schools. It’s a job - TA aren’t in it for the love of it, they’re in it to make money and get school holidays. If you want to support them, forget this ‘a smile goes a long way!’ nonsense and start campaigning for more money into education.

Stompythedinosaur · 03/12/2022 12:49

I agree with the op!

crussont · 03/12/2022 12:09

Managinggenzoclock · 02/12/2022 08:55

We have a class rep and money collected is always divided between the teacher, ta and other staff who contribute to the class (e.g 1:1 LSA)

Sounds a bloody nightmare. I'd hate that.

crussont · 03/12/2022 12:08

JanglyBeads · 01/12/2022 23:41

So the (I'm guessing primary) teacher gets a gift, but the much lower paid TA will be gushingly grateful for a small card, right.....

They should both be grateful for anything they are given!

crussont · 03/12/2022 12:07

girlmom21 · 01/12/2022 22:08

Well it depends how much interaction the child has with the TA and their relationship, surely?

Working in the same room as someone who's being given a gift doesn't entitle you to a gift.

Yes this. There's enough social pressure to get the teacher a gift without having to get one for the TA too.

crussont · 03/12/2022 12:06

twohomesneeded · 01/12/2022 21:31

... that you don't forget the TA?

It doesn't have to be another gift, just a card from your child (or you) saying how much their support is appreciated.

Being a TA can sometimes be a thankless (and occasionally challenging) task and this one small thing could just make your child's TA smile and count themselves lucky to have great kids and parents at their school.

No ffs stop making it a competition

NorthStarRising · 03/12/2022 12:06

I love a card telling me I’ve done a good job, or saying I’ve made a difference.
I have some I’ve kept for decades.

Unicorn2022 · 03/12/2022 11:59

I always used to get the teacher and TA the same gifts through primary school. They don't have TAs in our secondary schools and my children refuse to take gifts in for their teachers nowadays.

clpsmum · 03/12/2022 11:44

I think people should or shouldn't buy presents for whoever they want to and not just because they think they should

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 03/12/2022 11:36

The I would hope you are getting the TA who works with your son a gift or card, beside, as he clearly receives and benefits from a TA being allocated time to work specifically with him.

My DD would no doubt benefit from one in one attention as well - all children will do better with an adult next to them helping them focus, helping correct mistakes or misunderstandings as they occur. For example, she finds inference a bit hard and would likely improve this skill faster if she had a TA with her to ask the right leading questions during reading exercises that test this skill. However, she doesn't get any, and nor do most of the class, because support is targeted to those pupils who have the greatest need of it. This is what I mean.

BesidetheseasideXxx · 03/12/2022 10:48

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 01/12/2022 23:21

If they are working with a group of children, as opposed to a 1:1, then yes , those children would be lower ability in whatever aspect of work they were engaging in and in need of TA assistance. Otherwise they wouldn't need TA assistance!

God good, are we really claiming children don't have differing abilities now? I bet no-one is objecting if their child is referred to as higher ability in maths, for example.

The reporting on attainment is literally based on expected ability in regards to age related expectations.

My dad can't tell me the the names of the TAs in her class. One is working 1:1 with a child who is working 3 years below his age related expectations and the other is working with a group of children who are lower in academic performance than the rest of the class - is that sufficiently round the houses for you?

My child (6) has support from a TA because he struggles to pay attention and often zones out when the teacher is talking, so really benefits from the TA checking in on him to make sure he understands what he's supposed to be doing. There's no concerns about his reading ability or maths. So lower ability children isn't really the correct phrase to use, TA's support in all sorts of ways.

twohomesneeded · 03/12/2022 09:58

No you don't NEED to buy a present, a card saying thank you would be very much appreciated though I'm sure, or even an email, or even just a 'thank you for all your help' said at pick up when you see them.

I think a few posters have focused on the gift giving and expense here. Perhaps I should've been more explicit in my post but I though the way I worded it was clear - IF you are getting a gift for the teacher to show appreciation don't forget to show appreciation to the TA too. It absolutely does not NEED to be a present. A card is great, an email costs nothing but either would mean a lot.

TAs are not there to support the teacher (who is more than able to teach the class), they are there to support your child. Maybe ask your child who helps them read, who sorts them out when they graze their knee, who comforts them if they get upset in school when thinking about sad things, who helps them find their lost stuff etc.

As for those saying that it's just TAs doing their job, maybe you've never experienced someone showing appreciation to you? That feeling puts a smile on a face and lifts spirits. TAs aren't in it for the money, there's not exactly career progression for them in this role; they do it to support children.

OP posts:
ByeByeMr · 02/12/2022 20:32

I am a midday supervisor. A child today told me they loved me and that I'm the best teacher in the world. I'll take that over a present.

Carbon12 · 02/12/2022 20:11

I found the perfect thread to ask this question.

My daughter has two main key workers at nursery.

But there are two additional carers in the same room who help out if one of her key workers is busy/absent.

I was going to get gift cards for her keyworkers but do I also get something for the other two? Does it have to be the same value?

cansu · 02/12/2022 20:07

I think people should do whatever they want. I am a teacher and do not expect or encourage any gifts. I used to buy for people at my dad's school but it was so expensive I eventually moved to gifts for staff room to share. I intend this year to buy a load of chocolates and biscuits and send them in for staff to share.

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 02/12/2022 20:06

I regularly take out a higher attaining group who have already grasped the main concept being taught and do something additional with them to extend them.

If this was happening in my DD's school I'd be ecstatic. It's not though.

extrapineappleonmypizza · 02/12/2022 20:06

Just buy a packet of biscuits for the staff room, attach a card saying it's for All Staff and don't stress it!

jtaeapa · 02/12/2022 20:01

When my kids were small, it was almost impossible to find out who the TA was!

GetTheGoodLookingGuy · 02/12/2022 19:56

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 01/12/2022 23:21

If they are working with a group of children, as opposed to a 1:1, then yes , those children would be lower ability in whatever aspect of work they were engaging in and in need of TA assistance. Otherwise they wouldn't need TA assistance!

God good, are we really claiming children don't have differing abilities now? I bet no-one is objecting if their child is referred to as higher ability in maths, for example.

The reporting on attainment is literally based on expected ability in regards to age related expectations.

My dad can't tell me the the names of the TAs in her class. One is working 1:1 with a child who is working 3 years below his age related expectations and the other is working with a group of children who are lower in academic performance than the rest of the class - is that sufficiently round the houses for you?

I'm a TA, and I can't say that there's been a single day at my job when I have only worked with "lower ability" children. I regularly take out a higher attaining group who have already grasped the main concept being taught and do something additional with them to extend them. Several times recently the teacher and I have each had half of the class to do different inputs in maths when everyone's at a different stage and needs a different thing. I read with every child at least once a fortnight. I teach my own phonics group, twice a day, who are very much "middle ability" as they're the top phonics group. I have just gone round the classroom in my head and I have had a personal interaction with every child in my class today - checking their writing with them, chatting with them at lunchtime, doing first aid, colouring with them in golden time, correcting behaviour, etc. Sometimes (and with some child) I spend more time with them than the teacher does.

I don't need presents (although I do appreciate them), but I am very much involved in the education of every single child in my class. No, I don't have to plan (although I do talk through the plans with the teacher and give opinions/suggestions) and I'm not held responsible for data and children's progress, but in many aspects I am a (far lower paid) second teacher in that class.

(My favourite ever thing I've recieved at Christmas from a child was a card in which he had written "Merry Christmas, Miss GoodLookingGuy, and please don't eat any nuts because you're the best TA ever" [I'm allergic].)

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 02/12/2022 18:19

I always get the teacher and the ta (one assigned to each class) the same gift each, every year. I don't buy for the 1.2.1 additional TA as I know she is specifically 1.2.1 for one child all day and doesn't work with the other kids.

In eldest class, they have a job share two teachers plus a TA so three identical gifts.

I spend less per gift as I like to get them all something the same value (usually a coffee voucher or something consumable).

earsup · 02/12/2022 18:15

NC12345665 · 02/12/2022 17:14

Yes, everything is a competition to show off these days.

probably....well i wouldnt want a load of bath bombs....dont have a bath...!!...or chocolates...but could regift to others....save spending and buying gifts....not that i do that...!!

thingumybob · 02/12/2022 17:59

I was a 1:1 TA for 6 yrs following the year group from Yr 1 to Yr 6. I knew the children really well. Even though I was a 1:1 it was me that supervised break times, supported at lunchtimes, dealt with fall outs, noticed and reported cp issues, spotted children with unidentified SEN and got their teachers to get them assessed and supported, found ways to support children who needed help in class, did first aid, looked after them when they were ill, challenged the brightest children with new ideas etc. etc. etc. All for not much more than minimum wage.

I can gaurentee that if your child's class has a TA, your child will have benefited from that in some way even if they don't really realise it. By the time we were in Yr 6 the children were old enough to decide for themselves to show appreciation and I got lots of lovely cards and gifts. To be honest a homemade card is wonderful. It's not about having a gift, it's about being appreciated.

I see a lot of those children around still and even though they are well into secondary school now they still call out my name and say hello if they see me and I get big smiles from them which is lovely. It does show that I mattered to them even though technically I was a 1:1 TA to another child.

It's really sad to see some of the attitudes here towards TAs.

Ted27 · 02/12/2022 17:49

I was a bit 'ouch' at the low ability remark

Yes of course children have different abilities
I suppose I am sensitive to it as my son had a lot of TA support but is not in fact 'low ability' . He was very behind in primary because of his early life experiences ( he is adopted). By secondary he had caught up but it took years of input from teachers and fabulous TAs.

Rainbowcat99 · 02/12/2022 17:41

To be honest @Potterie I often jump on "what should I buy teachers..." threads to say don't buy anything, I don't want parents spending what they can't afford on me. So if you don't get anything for anyone then absolutely fair enough.
The really dismissive attitudes to TAs on this thread are so sad though. Most of them do an amazing job and make a huge difference to your children, just that they tend to stay in the background.

Swipe left for the next trending thread