Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I white Irish?

243 replies

SmallNuts · 01/12/2022 21:12

Parents are from Ireland, have the accent, moved when they were late twenties.

i was born in England. Have an Irish passport. Live in England.

can I consider myself white Irish?

it’s for diversity monitoring.

OP posts:
MoreSleepPleasee · 01/12/2022 23:30

For the statistics for the charity I work for we enter ethnicity and nationality so would tick 'white Irish' then 'British'.

Pinkapron · 01/12/2022 23:29

Your nationality is British, and your ethnic origin is Irish. But you are automatically also classed as an Irish citizen as you have an Irish born parent.

ohlordhelpme · 01/12/2022 23:27

TattoedLady · 01/12/2022 23:00

"have the accent" 🤣

Were you fed flat 7up or Lucozade as a kid?
Do you know what red lemonade is?
Do you support Ireland, say in rugby?
Do you follow the Gaa?
Do you know how to have the craic?
Do you know where the press is, or the hot press for that matter?
Did you ever forget to put the immersion on?
When you're getting the messages, do you know what a half pan is?
Did you ever get the shift?
Do you know what a Guard is?
Did you ever put the dinner in the ding?
Floury spuds?

Answer yes = Irish

Did you ever get the shift 😂

ohlordhelpme · 01/12/2022 23:25

Same as you (Irish parents, had brother there, moved here, had me here). I consider myself Irish. A lot of people don't, but that's how I feel.

GraceandMolly · 01/12/2022 23:20

@legalseagull You're British though if you were born here aren't you?

If a child is born in a barn, does it make them a pig?

I would say - yes you can consider yourself white Irish.

TattoedLady · 01/12/2022 23:20

OutFortheBirds · 01/12/2022 23:05

@TattoedLady 🤣🤣🤣
See also

  • what is a scallion?
  • When should you REALLY light a bonfire?
  • What are the best crisps?
  • What are Zig and Zag?
  • who were Ann and Barry?

@OutFortheBirds

Stage One, Book 1

Mammy is in the kitchen.
Ann and Barry are in the kitchen too. They like helping Mammy.

Daddy is outside. He is cleaning his car.

Callipygion · 01/12/2022 23:19

Nationality - British
Ethnicity - Irish

TheHateIsNotGood · 01/12/2022 23:13

It's all based on climate, rivers, mountains and hemisphere and distance from the sun after all. And evolution.

Rivers, seas and Mountains create geographical boundaries that tend to demarcate human boundaries such as nation, religion, culture.

The position of a geographical place in relation to the Equator and the Sun affects skin pigmentation, eg darker skin tones nearer to the Sun and lighter further towards the Poles.

Hemisphere is relative because more land mass, population and economic activity is found north of the Equator.

As more and more people move Ooop North (of the Equator) over time (centuries) humanity will evolve and adapt to their natural climactic environments.

Skin-tones will darken in the North for a few hundred years as all the races mix but unless the Earth moves its Axis, eventually the skin tones will lighten. Now personally I care not at all what skin colour anyone has.

But give such matters a thought, Darwinist though they might be. It's already writ that most Religions have no thought-space for natural evolution so I'll just leave it there.

Creameggs223 · 01/12/2022 23:09

If you are born and raised in England then why would you say white Irish? Have you lived in Ireland? If so fair enough but if not then I'd say white British.

OutFortheBirds · 01/12/2022 23:05

@TattoedLady 🤣🤣🤣
See also

  • what is a scallion?
  • When should you REALLY light a bonfire?
  • What are the best crisps?
  • What are Zig and Zag?
  • who were Ann and Barry?
DorritLittle · 01/12/2022 23:05

I'd consider you British. What do you want to be?

TrixJax · 01/12/2022 23:04

TattoedLady · 01/12/2022 23:00

"have the accent" 🤣

Were you fed flat 7up or Lucozade as a kid?
Do you know what red lemonade is?
Do you support Ireland, say in rugby?
Do you follow the Gaa?
Do you know how to have the craic?
Do you know where the press is, or the hot press for that matter?
Did you ever forget to put the immersion on?
When you're getting the messages, do you know what a half pan is?
Did you ever get the shift?
Do you know what a Guard is?
Did you ever put the dinner in the ding?
Floury spuds?

Answer yes = Irish

Some of these are Scottish too!

XanaduKira · 01/12/2022 23:03

British / English / Irish / Northern Irish - it's your choice Op so pick whichever you identify with best.

TattoedLady · 01/12/2022 23:00

"have the accent" 🤣

Were you fed flat 7up or Lucozade as a kid?
Do you know what red lemonade is?
Do you support Ireland, say in rugby?
Do you follow the Gaa?
Do you know how to have the craic?
Do you know where the press is, or the hot press for that matter?
Did you ever forget to put the immersion on?
When you're getting the messages, do you know what a half pan is?
Did you ever get the shift?
Do you know what a Guard is?
Did you ever put the dinner in the ding?
Floury spuds?

Answer yes = Irish

Pigriver · 01/12/2022 22:59

This is my dh. Both parents Irish (Cavan and Tyrone) moved here separately in their teens, met and married. All children born and raised here. Dh doesn't have an accent but has an Irish passport and identifies as British much to the annoyance of his dad. Upbringing very Irish, all their friends were Irish, raised Catholic (culturally rather than overly religiously) learned Irish dancing and accordion as kids down the Irish centre etc.
I was born here. Our kids have British passports but only because I said if he wanted them to have Irish ones he'd have to do it.
We go to Ireland twice a year to visit his dad who has moved back over.

LookingGlassMilk · 01/12/2022 22:58

I hate these arguments. I was born in England to Irish parents and we all moved back to Ireland when I was 16.

So I was brought up in England and have an English accent, but I basically have no connection with England at all. I've never had a British passport, I've never lived there as an adult. All my family are in Ireland.

But because I was born in England and have the accent I'll never be accepted as Irish. But I'm not really English either, it's just a place I lived in when I was a child.

Definitelyrandom · 01/12/2022 22:57

I’m entitled to an Irish passport and grew up in a Manchester Irish culture - and in an environment where I remember my parents saying “so and so doesn’t like Irish/Catholics”. It does bug me that forms don’t allow you to tick mixed Irish/British heritage/identity. I tick the British one as it’s strictly closer but it doesn’t feel quite right.

Doodadoo · 01/12/2022 22:56

IceandIndigo · 01/12/2022 22:55

A Black person born in the UK to parents from the Caribbean would have the choice whether to identify as Black British or Black Caribbean on a diversity monitoring form. The point is that no one else gets to tell you how you should identify.

I dare you to repeat that on one of the gender/trans threads 😂

Doodadoo · 01/12/2022 22:55

SmallNuts · 01/12/2022 22:23

It’s for diversity monitoring.

if you aren’t white British you are guaranteed an interview (if you meet the criteria).

It wouldn't be hard to outshine the Brits. Minority or not.

IceandIndigo · 01/12/2022 22:55

Calmdown14 · 01/12/2022 22:22

So a white person born to Irish parents is definitely still Irish but a black person born to Carribbean parents is definitely British? Many of these answers are the opposite of the other threads today.

I'm part English but my kids are born and raised in Scotland. I'd expect they will tick Scottish as their option in the future. Going back further gives too many options!

There are usually Black British options on these forms as well aren't there?

A Black person born in the UK to parents from the Caribbean would have the choice whether to identify as Black British or Black Caribbean on a diversity monitoring form. The point is that no one else gets to tell you how you should identify.

LonginesPrime · 01/12/2022 22:53

It’s for diversity monitoring.

if you aren’t white British you are guaranteed an interview (if you meet the criteria).

Before I saw this part, OP, I was going to say that you should list both nationalities if it asks for them, but that you can just choose the ethnicity you feel best describes you personally without needing anyone else's permission or blessing.

But now it appears that the purpose of the question is to ensure people who aren't white British get a fair shot in the selection process, it seems disingenuous to effectively conceal the fact you're white British (as well as being Irish) by only stating the Irish part.

You have the privilege of being able to flit between nationalities and cultural identities depending on what's most beneficial to you at any given moment, and this guaranteed interview scheme sounds like it's designed precisely to level the playing field for those non-white British people who don't benefit from the luxury of being able to slip in and out of being white British whenever it suits them.

Appleandoranges · 01/12/2022 22:45

Nationality is what your passport is so it's normally very straightforward. Ethnicity is not always straightforward. If you have Irish/European heritage (and are white) you can choose to be or pass as white British, which you can't if you have dark skin. That does not necessarily mean you won't face discrimination e.g. Jews! /Eastern Europeans. If you have brown/black skin you will never identify as white British. But skin colour isn't always a great indicator of heritage and ethnicity and that's something people don't realise. You can be white with one black/Asian parent. OR have brown skin with one white British parent. Or be white and not feel British. And have brown skin and feel very British.

IceandIndigo · 01/12/2022 22:44

If this is for diversity monitoring purposes I suspect it won’t make one bit of difference whether you put White British or White Irish. All the ‘White’ sub-categories will be combined in any analysis anyway. But the point of the question is that it’s about how you identify, there isn’t really a wrong answer If you identify as Irish rather than British, by all means put that.

Whalesong · 01/12/2022 22:43

FetlocksBlowingInTheWind · 01/12/2022 22:39

How about, one European parent, one English, born in UK.
White British?

I've often wondered but that's what I always put.

With one English parent I'd probably put that too. But with one Irish, one other European, British from birth, we always put "white Irish/white other" where possible. Never, ever "white British" as that's not ethnically true in their case. They DO always put their nationality down as British when asked about that on forms in the UK (if the form allows we of course also put down their other two).

TiptoeThroughTheToadstools · 01/12/2022 22:42

Squeezita · 01/12/2022 21:16

But where are you REALLY from, OP?

Jokes. Yes, you’re White Irish.

😂😂😂