Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I white Irish?

243 replies

SmallNuts · 01/12/2022 21:12

Parents are from Ireland, have the accent, moved when they were late twenties.

i was born in England. Have an Irish passport. Live in England.

can I consider myself white Irish?

it’s for diversity monitoring.

OP posts:
Dotjones · 02/12/2022 09:20

This is where the whole question of nationality falls down. If the OP is legitimately "Irish" despite being born in England and living there, then by extension a first generation immigrant to Britain cannot be British, using the same logic.

I don't have the answer, just wondering what the rules are. It seems to be the case that you can just decide for yourself what nationality you are - which would be fine, except of course that's not how it works either - I can't just decide to be French because I've probably got some Norman blood in me.

Personally I'd say the OP should just put "British" as their nationality, after all the island of Ireland is part of the British Isles (the term includes the UK, Ireland and Isle of Man).

girlmom21 · 02/12/2022 09:12

@SmallNuts what did you put on last years census?

TerraNostra · 02/12/2022 09:04

Calmdown14 · 01/12/2022 22:26

I fill these out in Scotland regularly and you get white Scottish, white Welsh, white Irish or white British. Not white English as an option.

The categories don't make a lot of sense. They could just ask country of birth and country/ies of origin

That's very interesting. I am Scottish but live in England and when I fill them in there is usually white British, white Irish and white other. No white Scottish option.

I always thought it was looking for an ethnicity- based answer, but (come to think of it) it confuses nationality and ethnicity otherwise surely the only option for all white people would be Caucasian?

I must ask my husband what he puts, he was born and brought up in the U.K. but his father is from a Scandinavian country.

TheOrigRights · 02/12/2022 08:01

In answer to your question OP, you can say you are white Irish or white British.

TheOrigRights · 02/12/2022 08:00

British is either Yes or No. It's not your ethnicity.
White is subjective

I am British. My father was Indian (Mother British).
I am white, two of my 4 siblings are brown.

When asked my ethnicity I select Mixed white and asian.
When asked my nationality I say British.

On your form, me and 2 of my siblings (the white ones) could tick White British. The other 2 should not tick White. What would they choose? I guess they have been subjected to more racism than us white ones.

Surely they should be asking for what ethnicity you identify as, and a different question asks about their nationality and right to work in the UK?

AhNowTed · 02/12/2022 07:52

You're absolutely white Irish.

You just happened to be born in Britain.

MistletoeandBaileys · 02/12/2022 07:49

You can of course identify as white Irish. That is your heritage. I’m Irish myself.

I’ve always felt they need to revamp how to do those forms. The language can feel really archaic on them. my husband isn’t Irish although he has citizenship and gets to pick the box “White Other”. We get a good laugh out of it!

Rollin · 02/12/2022 07:48

I would say its handy having 2 passports! Particularly if they’re a few years apart in renewal as you always have one in date…

Rollin · 02/12/2022 07:47

I would say yes but it’s up to you to decide.
I’m also dual National but born in Ireland, but I would say Northern Irish, Irish or British depending on the circumstances and I use whichever passport is handiest at the time. Generally the Irish one unless it’s something to do with U.K. officialdom.

LemonTT · 02/12/2022 07:42

Questionnaire’s about asking about your ethnic or minority status are used to identify whether certain groups experience poor service or outcomes. They are usually used by employers in recruitment and public service providers.

Irish people experienced discrimination and poor outcomes in Britain for many generations and can still do. Generally this is worse for the first generation or migrant population. For example housing, health and schooling in migrant hubs is often poor quality.

Bigots are often not above just looking at someone’s name and concluding their background. A lot of bigots don’t like Irish people any more than Eastern Europeans or people of colour.

There has been lots of data to demonstrate discrimination against Irish people in Britain.

inisfree · 02/12/2022 07:40

Listen Op, more importantly do you believe that Flat 7up is a cure for all ills. If the answer is yes then you are white Irish Wink

DelphiniumBlue · 02/12/2022 07:35

You are whatever you think you are. It is your choice to decide how you identify. As I explained to the teacher who questioned me about my heritage as he didn't agree with the box I'd completed on the school's monitoring form.

MollyRover · 02/12/2022 07:32

Are there tick boxes for Black Nigerian and Black Ghanaian? Or is it just Black African?

Endlesssummer2022 · 02/12/2022 07:30

Appleandoranges · 01/12/2022 22:21

The thing is this shows that if you are white you get the choice of ticking white British or white Irish. But if you are black or Asian, the only thing you can tick is black British or British Asian. In a mixed family, you could easily have siblings one who can tick white British and the other who would have to tick black British, but they would have the same heritage. I also find it strange that in US, Hispanics aren't counted as white when they are actually white/ just more tanned/more olive than Northern Europeans. Ethnicity rarely makes sense.

So all Hispanics are white? So Zoe Zaldana, TessaThompson, Roxie Perez, Rosario Dawson, Gina Torres and Cardi B are all white people now then?

I’ll think you’ll fine Hispanic/Latinos/Latina’s come in a range of colours from Christina Aguilira and Cameron Diaz to Colman Domingo who’s darker than many black people.

MollyRover · 02/12/2022 07:27

@BacklogBritain because it should be Caucasian, surely? Seems more segregated than diverse to me.

BacklogBritain · 02/12/2022 07:19

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

MollyRover · 02/12/2022 07:15

I can't believe White Irish is indicated as a tickbox

xJ0y · 02/12/2022 07:12

@notsosoftanymore only if she wants to be and applies

xJ0y · 02/12/2022 07:10

When i was in the uk, I just ticked white. I didnt see the purpose of the other box but I guess it's for the purpose of statistics, not to give anybody an identity crisis!

notsosoftanymore · 02/12/2022 02:28

A bit of a p.s., I said 1801 because that was the date of the Act of Union, basically the Brits doing what Putin is doing in an age when they could. Of course, Britain had dabbled in England from the 13th century onwards and especially in the 16th and 17th centuries.

notsosoftanymore · 02/12/2022 02:23

As this page makes clear, if you have an Irish parent but were born outside of Ireland, you are automatically an Irish citizen.

^www.citizensinformation.ie/en/moving_country/irish_citizenship/irish_citizenship_through_birth_or_descent.html^
3. Born outside Ireland to an Irish parent
If you were born outside of Ireland, you are automatically an Irish citizen by birth if either one of your parents was born in Ireland and was entitled to Irish citizenship.

However, as the page also makes clear, the constitution was changed in 2004 and citizenship is now more complicated. Britain's dabbling in Ireland from 1801 onwards meant that famine and mismanagement caused famine and mass emigration and citizenship was offered to anyone with a Irish parent because economic conditions basically meant that people were forced to emigrate and lost Irish citizenship for their children. Huge numbers of people in the US and Australia/New Zealand have Irish heritage because of emigration.

OP you are white Irish.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 02/12/2022 01:58

Yes obvs.

I'm English.my parents are English. I have a Scottish great grandmother but I'm not Scottish bc I don't know the culture.

You're Irish-English. You feel English but your close heritage is Irish.

SmallNuts · 02/12/2022 01:37

BadNomad · 02/12/2022 00:59

Have you called yourself Irish every other time you've had to answer this question? This won't be the first time you've had to answer it. It's on everything. If you normally pick "white British" then you would be wrong to pick "white Irish" this time for the purpose of getting an advantage over others.

“It’s on everything”. Like what? I’ve not changed anything medically for many decades…. How else would it be measured?

OP posts:
SmallNuts · 02/12/2022 01:36

BadNomad · 02/12/2022 00:59

Have you called yourself Irish every other time you've had to answer this question? This won't be the first time you've had to answer it. It's on everything. If you normally pick "white British" then you would be wrong to pick "white Irish" this time for the purpose of getting an advantage over others.

I’m not using it for my advantage. I’m already guaranteed via my disability.

It’s something I’ve come across before. And for medical reasons I answer white Irish. My whole family appear to have lived in Ireland and are “white” skin….

i wouldn’t consider Irish a minority population, but really they are. Note how I say they. Am I really different than a uk first born child of polish persons or an Asian person? My name is somewhat English so unless I told people, they wouldn’t know.

I didn’t want to touch on the sore topic of those in the north considering themselves British.

OP posts:
BadNomad · 02/12/2022 01:04

Does Spain allow children born there to claim Spanish nationality? If that was the case, wouldn't one of the Beckham lads be Spanish?

The OP was neither born in Ireland nor raised there. Now, if she'd been born in England to Irish parents then raised in Ireland, she would be seen as Irish. Which is what you are getting at with the Beckham kid.