Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

do i have this right about smear tests?

128 replies

tefley · 01/12/2022 19:41

So, last time I had a smear test, I got a letter saying I was negative for HPV and therefore no further tests were done on the sample like looking at the cells.

I haven't had any sexual contact since my last test, therefore there's no way my HPV status can have changed. So am I correct in saying there's no point in me having a another smear test unless I did have sexual contact?

I'm confused because I tried to explain this to a nurse and the receptionist at my GP clinic, but they were both insistent I come in, and I've been getting multiple texts and letters about it.

My situation is a bit more complicated than most- I have vagnismus which makes these kinds of things genuinely excrutiating. I'm trying to work through it, and I'm worried an unpleasant experience will set me back. The appointment is tomorrow and have been prescribed valium to try to stop the muscle spasms, but it just seems like a lot to go through when (if I've got it right), the sample won't even be tested?

OP posts:
FictionalCharacter · 01/12/2022 21:26

You don’t have to go for a smear at all so they are wrong to “insist”. It’s offered and you can take up the offer if you want. They shouldn’t bully women into it the way they do, like it’s some kind of civic duty. Cervical cancer isn’t a common cancer anyway, look at the stats https://www.cancerresearchuk.org/health-professional/cancer-statistics/statistics-by-cancer-type/cervical-cancer
The HPV swab test isn’t yet available on the NHS. Hopefully they will make it available in the future.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 01/12/2022 21:25

I had my last one done in the colposcopy chair @jessieminto and like you say it makes a huge difference. Mine was done privately and I've never had the option on the NHS despite crying in pain.

The consultant who did the last one said that due to the position of my cervix it would be nearly impossible to do the smear on a bed in a GP surgery. It's a shame no one ever told me that before.

poshme · 01/12/2022 21:24

@Tiredandweary1987 you say that only having one sexual partner meaning you can't get HPV is a misconception- how else do you get it please?

If a virgin has only ever had sex with another virgin how do they get HPV? My understanding was that it is sexually transmitted.

jessieminto · 01/12/2022 21:15

My smears have been really painful due to disability. I was referred to my hospital to have them done with the proper gynea chair and dr. They have gas & air on standby but so far I've not needed it. Being in the correct position has helped immensely.

jtaeapa · 01/12/2022 21:14

OP the smear can also detect random things like a polyp on your cervix. The nurse would actually see it in that case.

Mummyratbag · 01/12/2022 21:12

Does anyone know if you can have cell changes whilst HPV is dormant? As in you have HPV, you test negative on the day of smear, so no further examination of cells, but you have it in your body? Could you have changes that are not investigated or is someone with cell changes always going to test positive?? I have not had HPV as far as I know, but I just wondered (another who has difficult smears due to tilted uterus).

DonutWorry · 01/12/2022 21:00

I used to find smears really painful so put them off for a long time. The last one I had was actually surprisingly easy and was shocked that I tested positive for HPV! it must have been dormant for a reeeeeally long time. It's 100% worth doing and I will never miss another one again. Good luck x

notanothertakeaway · 01/12/2022 21:00

Like you, I find smear tests horrendous. My reaction is so bad / extreme that I've been asked if I've previously been sexually assaulted

But it is quick. And stops hurting as soon as it's over. And PP are right that the HOV virus can lay dormant

So, I'm glad you have decided to go. Well done

Diazepam does help me. The other things that help are (1) tell them you're scared, don't try to be brave, (2) remember you can tell them to stop any time (3) get them to do a countdown 10 9 8 etc so you are prepared for them to start

Flowersintheattic57 · 01/12/2022 20:57

Is the smear test still worth doing if the nurse practitioner always complains while manoeuvring the speculum like a periscope that your cervix ‘is pointing the wrong way’, makes it very unpleasant and painful and then afterwards you get a letter that the result is ‘inconclusive’, please return for another round.
After decades of this shenanigans and reading up that HPV can survive for about 15 years before it naturally disappears, I took a home test for the full range of HPV, and it came back negative. I’m not sexually active and haven’t been since the nineties and have never had a positive test.

Elliania · 01/12/2022 20:54

I just want to say bravo OP for being so receptive to the information as to why smears are so important & also for being able to steel her nerves and get it done. You got this OP and I hope it's not as bad as you think it will be. Maybe have a chat to the nurse beforehand as well so they can be extra gentle and as quick as possible?

WetBandits · 01/12/2022 20:51

Thank you for posting this OP! I’m glad you’ve found it useful and I’m sure others have too. FWIW we have absolutely tiny speculums in our clinic if we need them. I used one on a lady the other day which was about the size of my index finger as she was post-menopausal and very dry and sore, still managed to fully visualise her cervix.

WetBandits · 01/12/2022 20:49

>99% of cervical cancer is caused by HPV.

Jenhen89 · 01/12/2022 20:49

tefley · 01/12/2022 20:34

Presumably that's still a false negative result though?

If you have HPV, but that test is not able to provide a positive result because it is dormant?

No because it’s negative in the sense that it won’t cause any changes to your cervical cells. False negative would mean that it’s incorrect and is actually positive, and could thereby be causing changes to your cells.

StaceySolomonSwash · 01/12/2022 20:48

Much better to go for your smear. I've got an appointment next week to have polyps investigated that were picked up during a routine smear. Not looking forward to it but I'd rather that than not being checked.

MariosMagicMushrooms · 01/12/2022 20:45

NugsNotDrugs · 01/12/2022 20:43

There are some (rare) cases of cervical cancer that are not caused by hpv.
I was sent for a biopsy (scary two week cancer pathway) despite testing negative for hpv.
over and done with in one hospital appointment. The lump turned out to be a harmless bruise but it was worth checking.

Yes but the smear test only tests for HPV to start with. It’s only if someone tests positive that the cells are then screened for cancer. Those rare cases which aren’t caused by HPV will now be missed.

The3Ls · 01/12/2022 20:43

www.england.nhs.uk/2021/02/nhs-gives-women-hpv-home-testing-kits-to-cut-cancer-deaths/ available in some parts of NHS for around a year. £25 from superdrug to avoid (for you) a potentially traumatic experience you have to take valium for. Much better alternative

NugsNotDrugs · 01/12/2022 20:43

There are some (rare) cases of cervical cancer that are not caused by hpv.
I was sent for a biopsy (scary two week cancer pathway) despite testing negative for hpv.
over and done with in one hospital appointment. The lump turned out to be a harmless bruise but it was worth checking.

DoraDee · 01/12/2022 20:41

I raised a similar question to my GP and was told that the smear test is a chance for a health professional to also see any obvious changes or causes for concern as some changes can happen without HPV being present. If you really struggle to have a smear test, even with medication, you can request to have it somewhere where gas and air are available.

VestaTilley · 01/12/2022 20:39

YABU, the weird cells can develop at any time. Get your smear.

Zanatdy · 01/12/2022 20:36

I was wondering the same so I’m glad you posted this as I know to keep going now

SquirrelRed · 01/12/2022 20:35

Sleeepdeprived · 01/12/2022 20:30

I didn’t realise the smear test only looked at HPV status. Does that mean you only get cervical cancer if you’re HPV positive? Or is it only the test that tests for HPV status and doesn’t pick up cervical cancers that started unrelated to HPV?

Over 99% of cervical cancers are caused by HPV

tefley · 01/12/2022 20:34

Jenhen89 · 01/12/2022 20:32

It’s not a false negative, it’s just lying dormant.

Presumably that's still a false negative result though?

If you have HPV, but that test is not able to provide a positive result because it is dormant?

OP posts:
Jenhen89 · 01/12/2022 20:32

tefley · 01/12/2022 19:48

Ok this is interesting, I knew HPV itself could lie dormant, but not that this would mean you'd get a false negative.

It’s not a false negative, it’s just lying dormant.

Sleeepdeprived · 01/12/2022 20:30

I didn’t realise the smear test only looked at HPV status. Does that mean you only get cervical cancer if you’re HPV positive? Or is it only the test that tests for HPV status and doesn’t pick up cervical cancers that started unrelated to HPV?

Purplelion · 01/12/2022 20:28

I had a clear smear test 3 years ago. 2 months ago I tested positive for HPV despite being in a monogamous relationship (I am now single but not sleeping with anyone) the nurse explained how it can lie dormant. I had severe dyskaryosis and CIN 3 cells. I had a lletz procedure 2 weeks ago and have a follow up smear in 6 months to check for HPV again, I would always advise people to go for their smear tests, without it I wouldn’t have even consider testing myself for HPV

Swipe left for the next trending thread