Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is racist?

180 replies

Toospicey · 01/12/2022 18:38

This FB post is doing the rounds amongst my friends.

Is it just me?

To think this is racist?
To think this is racist?
To think this is racist?
To think this is racist?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Amybelle88 · 01/12/2022 23:30

DogInATent · 01/12/2022 18:58

Starts out ok, but definitely ends up crossing the line.

This.

At first I thought absolutely not, last page verges into dodgy territory.

ginggung · 01/12/2022 22:53

These attempted dog or kid napping stories seem all too common for my liking, yet never reported on the news or current affairs. Filled with drama and typically involving a person of colour. I'm not convinced tbh. Last picture did allude racism. However if this was a true scenario then who knows what a person would say.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 01/12/2022 22:51

Someone on FB has just shared a post about two child abduction attempts in Carlisle. Doesn’t mention race in the post but the comments section is FULL of people saying “must be the hilltop lot” (referring to a hotel that is housing Afghan and Syrian refugees).

Racist pricks

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 01/12/2022 22:47

AlwaysGinPlease · 01/12/2022 22:39

I absolutely loathe racism but this is not it. But that " it's racist" attitude is what allowed those large gangs of Asian pedophiles to get away with it for so long.

No. Just no. That was the authorities and social services being completely and totally incompetent at their jobs and were happy to victim blame the girls who came from poor backgrounss. Not everyday people who don’t think POC should be tarred with the same brush

Conkersareback · 01/12/2022 22:46

@Coughybreak she describes other girls "as getting tarted up", she's not a nice person IMO. Girls/women can dress as they wish.

Yes women lie, men lie... not all of them, but saying "I don't like women being called liars, is ridiculous"!

NashvilleQueen · 01/12/2022 22:45

Isn't it all bullshit anyway? I've seen endless variations of these sort of things on FB. I

stockpilingallthecheese · 01/12/2022 22:42

More offended by her spelling Confused

Coughybreak · 01/12/2022 22:40

Conkersareback · 01/12/2022 22:25

@Coughybreak maybe you should not just side with women because they're called liars, maybe you should read the facts and decide, women lie!

It's like you saying, inside with everyone that says Asian men are predators, that's racist!

maybe you should not just side with women because they're called liars, maybe you should read the facts and decide, women lie

I was with you up till the last two words!

There are no independent statements or verified facts available. I have read the woman's statement, which is all we have of the facts, and seen what look like some discrepancies. But overall, the main facts look credible to me. Weighing up the (very limited and partial) evidence, I am not convinced she is lying. And I'm not going to say I think she is, just to go along with the majority.

On the question of racism, what I read is a furious woman yelling her rage that this man got away with it, and in the process hitting out unfairly at others. Not good. But not in the same league as taking a child.

I've tried not to let my opinion be affected by the mockery of this uneducated woman's bad grammar and writing style. I mean, that makes me think less of the people mocking her, not of her.

Anyway, I'm done now. Sending my love to all children and parents affected by incidents like this.

AlwaysGinPlease · 01/12/2022 22:39

I absolutely loathe racism but this is not it. But that " it's racist" attitude is what allowed those large gangs of Asian pedophiles to get away with it for so long.

declutteringmymind · 01/12/2022 22:32

I was ok with it until the last paragraph 'these people' where she has applied the deeds of this one person to an entire nationality.

She makes some valid points re: difficulties in checks, and if any man was following a child and grabbing her, no cultural allowances should be made.

However it is definitely xenophobic and has a nasty undercurrent to it.

Rinatinabina · 01/12/2022 22:31

I wouldn’t have a problem with someone saying “asian man, at this time at this location”. It seems to be saying that there are loads of chinese men trying to abduct children. I’m a bit hmmm about that.

GCAcademic · 01/12/2022 22:31

Coughybreak · 01/12/2022 21:19

How did you find out they were untrue? I wouldn't know what research I could do to establish the facts in each case.

A case that hasn't gone to court would be very unlikely to be covered by the mainstream media. If police issued a warning the press would probably report that. But I can't see the police telling everyone who asks if a woman complained that a man tried to lead her child away. So I don't know how you or I would get that information.

As an academic, do you have access to better sources of information than the general public?

If you don't have direct evidence that they were invented, it seems strange that you automatically dismiss women's accounts of a distressing experience.

In some of the cases, the police stated that they had no reports of the claimed incident. The posts were also removed.

ClangingBell · 01/12/2022 22:31

If people have read that whole post to the end and come to the conclusion it’s not racist, I have a strong suspicion that hold some pretty racist opinions themselves.

Conkersareback · 01/12/2022 22:27

VestaTilley · 01/12/2022 22:26

What’s racist about it?

Provided it’s true and not fake news, he tried to abduct a child and is basically getting away with it. And if he’s Chinese then he is Asian.

YABU. Or do you think we shouldn’t mention crimes with a person of colour as the perpetrator?

Did you read all the pages? Do you think it's not fake news?

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 01/12/2022 22:27

VestaTilley · 01/12/2022 22:26

What’s racist about it?

Provided it’s true and not fake news, he tried to abduct a child and is basically getting away with it. And if he’s Chinese then he is Asian.

YABU. Or do you think we shouldn’t mention crimes with a person of colour as the perpetrator?

Because it was one man who allegedly did this and she’s ‘warning people of the Asians that are going round doing this’.

In what world is that NOT racist?!

VestaTilley · 01/12/2022 22:26

What’s racist about it?

Provided it’s true and not fake news, he tried to abduct a child and is basically getting away with it. And if he’s Chinese then he is Asian.

YABU. Or do you think we shouldn’t mention crimes with a person of colour as the perpetrator?

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 01/12/2022 22:25

Also racist - describing how the 9yo shouldn’t have to deal with “some Asian man” grabbing her - would a white man have been better?

Re the trauma - I imagine if something like this did happen it would be scary AF but what I don’t think would help would be to have your mum screaming like a banshee and following the man around before melodramatically throwing you into a travel agents.

Conkersareback · 01/12/2022 22:25

@Coughybreak maybe you should not just side with women because they're called liars, maybe you should read the facts and decide, women lie!

It's like you saying, inside with everyone that says Asian men are predators, that's racist!

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 01/12/2022 22:23

SleepyAnkylosaurus · 01/12/2022 22:17

Racist and I’m not convinced it happened either.

So many things don’t add up. Not least the police turning up and making an arrest within minutes and the whole world seemingly stopping. And not to touch her arm because of DNA? Doesn’t sound right. The fact the actual ‘attempted kidnap’ is glosses over and not really described in great detail speaks volumes. And catching a plane in 2 hours one minute then suddenly the next day.

Oh well hopefully the mum has got the attention she clearly craves

Coughybreak · 01/12/2022 22:22

Conkersareback · 01/12/2022 21:44

*I presume they went to Heathrow the day before because they had a cheap flight leaving at some ungodly hour of night. The policeman may have shared information, perhaps unofficially, because he was annoyed that the offender wasn't going to be charged. And the fellow could have hung around long enough to be arrested because he had mental health problems; in my case, after I ran away, the man followed me back to the place he'd taken me from.

I can't see the police or a solicitor thinking the Chinese embassy would give them information about someone's asylum claim, though! The mother may have misunderstood something. But on the other hand, who knows what she was told?*

And you only see discrepancies? Grin

Well, as I've detailed above, the stuff about China sounds odd, but the other three points have a plausible explanation.

I openly admit my instinct is to side with women when they are called liars for complaining about a man's unacceptable behaviour.

SleepyAnkylosaurus · 01/12/2022 22:17

Racist and I’m not convinced it happened either.

redbigbananafeet · 01/12/2022 22:16

CourtneeLove no I've not seen any documentaries about m Chinese grooming gangs. Can you direct me to them?

Isitsixoclockalready · 01/12/2022 22:11

Lumping Asian people in as one homogeneous group is definitely dodgy.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 01/12/2022 22:07

Am I seeing something different to what other people are seeing?!

It has all the trappings of massively overt racism!!

This woman’s DD was allegedly grabbed by an Asian man.

Shes gone on to say she wants people to know ‘what these Asian people are doing’x

That is, in its most basic form, claiming that a whole race behaves poorly simply because ONE person in that race behaved poorly.

She wouldn’t be saying “all these white men” if a white man had grabbed her DD.

My 5yo would know that’s racism FFS.

Unless you’re inherently very, very stupid - or just racist yourself - how could you possibly not see how that’s racism!!

WildImaginings · 01/12/2022 22:02

@Conkersareback exactly.