Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I can hear my neighbour sobbing...

263 replies

FooFighter99 · 01/12/2022 16:30

And I feel terrible, but I can't do anything - can I?

She's a young (23ish?) new mum who lives with her partner. Baby was born in October. Her family are all in a different town about 1hr away (I think)

And I'm pretty sure I've heard them arguing a few times since they moved in

I'm WFH today and sat in the living room and I can hear her sobbing through the wall Sad Sad Sad

It would be totally inappropriate to knock and ask if she's ok, because then she'll know we can hear them (only when the tv is off though). But I do worry about her and have told DH and DSD(22) that if I hear them arguing and it gets heated I'll be going round and dragging him out by his ear!

It could be PND, or something else (I do hope baby is ok)

WWYD???

OP posts:
Ringmaster27 · 01/12/2022 17:32

Personally, I’d knock up something quick and easy -flapjack or something, knock round and say you made way too much and thought she might like some. Make general chit-chat, ask after the baby, and let her know you’re there to chat and have a cuppa if she ever fancies it because you remember what it’s like to be drowning in everything “baby” when they are so little.
I’d have massively appreciated it if one of my neighbours did that. I remember one day, having an awful day with 16 month old DD1, 3 week old DS, ExH had deployed to Iraq for 6 months the week befor and I was totally overwhelmed. My health Visitor showed up for an appointment I’d totally forgotten about, and as soon as she walked in I just sobbed and got it all off my chest. Never appreciated a cup of tea more than the one she made me that day 🙌🏻

Dissuadepersuade · 01/12/2022 17:31

I would take around a box of chocolates, just say you're not keen on them and thought she might like them..if it's someone like me and you eveb hint at knowing she's upset that'll make her bottle up even more.

At least it gives you the chance to make conversatid

MadameMackenzie · 01/12/2022 17:30

OP I’ve been in precisely your neighbour’s situation and would’ve loved it if my neighbour came to see if I was ok when I was spending days doing nothing but sobbing my heart out. I was so bad that my Mum had to take baby for 4 days once when my DH died. (It was an abusive marriage but I was still devastated). I had NOBODY and nobody seemed to care. My mum was great and took the baby but no emotional support whatsoever. None of my friends cared. I was so lonely. So with that in mind, I vote for knocking this evening and asking if there’s been a parcel delivered. Just to make sure she’s ok now

MsCactus · 01/12/2022 17:28

FooFighter99 · 01/12/2022 16:30

And I feel terrible, but I can't do anything - can I?

She's a young (23ish?) new mum who lives with her partner. Baby was born in October. Her family are all in a different town about 1hr away (I think)

And I'm pretty sure I've heard them arguing a few times since they moved in

I'm WFH today and sat in the living room and I can hear her sobbing through the wall Sad Sad Sad

It would be totally inappropriate to knock and ask if she's ok, because then she'll know we can hear them (only when the tv is off though). But I do worry about her and have told DH and DSD(22) that if I hear them arguing and it gets heated I'll be going round and dragging him out by his ear!

It could be PND, or something else (I do hope baby is ok)

WWYD???

I was once drunk arguing with my bf (now husband) when I was about 20, sobbing and shouting about nothing really.

A man knocked on the door to 'check if I was ok' and I'll be honest I was totally mortified. The last thing I'd want to know is that a neighbour is listening to me crying in my home.

Everyone argues - but that intrusion into my personal space would make me feel awful. I'd feel like I could never cry in my own home again without you coming over.

JMO tho, others might feel differently

Teaandtoast35 · 01/12/2022 17:26

I cry a lot at the moment OP as I have lost children recently. I get upset if someone comes round or hears me, even close family sometimes because I feel so low and it just makes me feel worse to have someone there. I feel like I have to feel better for them. I’d not go round now but go over, introduce yourself, take some cake, make a friend of her and tell her it’s so difficult to have a new baby etc and let her know you’re there.

MarmiteMama17 · 01/12/2022 17:25

I used to be this girl, please go and check on her

Cantstandbullshit · 01/12/2022 17:23

BumbleNova · 01/12/2022 16:33

I’d go round and offer her a cup of tea.

she sounds like she could do with a friendly face. Having a new baby is bloody hard without a horrible partner in the mix.

And you automatically conclude that her partner is horrible? You got all that insight from the opening post?

AuntyPeanut · 01/12/2022 17:23

@pattihews you're an angel!

geraniumsandsunshine · 01/12/2022 17:22

jtaeapa · 01/12/2022 16:49

Hmmm I think I would not interfere.

a cup of tea is not going to fix anything.

I disagree. Talking can be a great help and knowing that someone cares can lift you.

Fleurdaisy · 01/12/2022 17:22

Put a card through the door ? You could have a little present for the baby ( 1st Christmas) would she like to come round for coffee?

geraniumsandsunshine · 01/12/2022 17:21

@FooFighter99 have you got children? If so, you can go round and say you know how hard it is and you'd love to have her round for a piece of cake and a cuppa and that you are happy to walk the baby round the block

pattihews · 01/12/2022 17:21

19 years ago I used to see a really sad-looking young woman walking in the lanes around my house with a young baby. I'd wave and say hello if we passed and wonder about her but did nothing. Then one day she seemed particularly tearful and unkempt and without thinking about it I asked her to come in and have a cup of tea. She ended up having a bath and washing her hair while I sat with the baby. She said it was the first break she'd had in weeks. She came round every few days for a couple of months until things improved.

She and her daughter send me a Christmas present every year. They moved away, but the daughter is at university an hour away from me and they've visited recently.

cookiecreammmpie · 01/12/2022 17:15

It's a hard one because as much as I hate the thought of someone distressed and needing help, if it was me that was upset, I'd feel embarrassed that someone had heard me crying in when I thought was the privacy of my own home. The other day I was crying over the recent death of a family member and I would have hated to explain that to a neighbour. If you feel you need to go round then do but be prepared in case you don't get the reaction you expect.

DuplicateUserName · 01/12/2022 17:14

FooFighter99 · 01/12/2022 17:07

If I thought her and/or baby were in danger and could hear them actively arguing then I wouldn't hesitate to call the police and go round, and DH and DSD would both be right behind me

But hearing her crying through the wall (seemingly alone) isn't the same, and knocking on the door at that moment didn't necessarily feel like the right thing to do

But you won't be dragging anyone anywhere by their ear, so it's best to formulate a proper plan and let your DH and DSD know what it is.

HamBone · 01/12/2022 17:12

Why don't you make them something food-wise and drop it round later or tomorrow? Ask how she and the baby are, is there anything you can do as you know she must be exhausted, etc. Just knowing she can text you if she wants to would be lovely, given she doesn't have any family close by.

notanothertakeaway · 01/12/2022 17:10

PizzaPizza56 · 01/12/2022 17:06

Please dont knock and ask what's wrong, just ask her how she's getting on when you see her out and about. I cried a lot when my baby was really young and some neighbours came round to see if I was OK one afternoon. Now I'm out of the newborn fog I can see they were being kind but at the time it massively added to my feelings of failing and not being able to cope and I was terrified they were going to report me to social services for being a terrible parent.

I agree with this @PizzaPizza56

She should be able to cry in peace in her own home

But it would be kind to check in on her another time soon

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 01/12/2022 17:10

The strife and distress are damaging to the poor baby. I'd go around without hesitation. Don't say you heard her crying, just make some excuse about wanting to bring her some cake, or whatever, and check things out.

BrightSaturn · 01/12/2022 17:08

PizzaPizza56 · 01/12/2022 17:06

Please dont knock and ask what's wrong, just ask her how she's getting on when you see her out and about. I cried a lot when my baby was really young and some neighbours came round to see if I was OK one afternoon. Now I'm out of the newborn fog I can see they were being kind but at the time it massively added to my feelings of failing and not being able to cope and I was terrified they were going to report me to social services for being a terrible parent.

we posted basically the same thing at the same time! I completely agree with everything you’ve said.

sometimes we just cry because it’s hard!

FooFighter99 · 01/12/2022 17:07

Pjsandhotchoc · 01/12/2022 17:02

Agreed. If you don’t want to go round there when you think she’s home alone and sobbing (I wouldn’t either btw), you’re not going to barge in mid-row and pull the bloke from his house are you?
Discuss with DH and DSD what you’ve heard. Sounds weird but might be helpful to keep a basic log. Not “10:55 heard the kettle go one” kind of thing but maybe just note down dates if you hear any raised voices for example. And if any of your ever you hear what sounds like a physical fight, or property being damaged, call 999.

If I thought her and/or baby were in danger and could hear them actively arguing then I wouldn't hesitate to call the police and go round, and DH and DSD would both be right behind me

But hearing her crying through the wall (seemingly alone) isn't the same, and knocking on the door at that moment didn't necessarily feel like the right thing to do

OP posts:
Wrongsideofpennines · 01/12/2022 17:07

Find an excuse to go round. You bought too many packets of biscuits/too much milk/friend gave me a bottle of wine but I'm teetotal etc. Then ask to go in a see the baby and then offer to chat and generally be a good neighbour. Tell her your know what it's like with a newborn and if you can ever help by fetching shopping, watching him while she showers etc that you'd be glad to.

PizzaPizza56 · 01/12/2022 17:06

Please dont knock and ask what's wrong, just ask her how she's getting on when you see her out and about. I cried a lot when my baby was really young and some neighbours came round to see if I was OK one afternoon. Now I'm out of the newborn fog I can see they were being kind but at the time it massively added to my feelings of failing and not being able to cope and I was terrified they were going to report me to social services for being a terrible parent.

BrightSaturn · 01/12/2022 17:06

I’m a mum of a new baby and I sometimes cry in my house because I feel overwhelmed and it’s hard with lack of sleep. I would be mortified if my neighbour came and knocked because they heard me crying. I call my family or friends for support.

a general chat when you see her would be better, invite her over for a tea if she wants to but don’t ask her what’s wrong or imply at all that you heard her crying. That’s my opinion anyway :)

Soothsayer1 · 01/12/2022 17:06

I would try to befriend her, not mention that you've heard her sobbing, but be a kindly and steady person that she can trust

Montague22 · 01/12/2022 17:06

It’s awkward but I would go round today. Take a ready meal/cake as an excuse. Invite her for a walk or offer to watch the baby for an hour if she wants to nip out. Just break the ice somehow and then do it again.
I am always super protective with my babies but I used to leave my first with the elderly couple next door for an hour (not saying you are old), but I didn’t actually leave him with anyone else for months. I used the time for my own Dr appts or to wash my hair!

MrsThimbles · 01/12/2022 17:06

FooFighter99 · 01/12/2022 16:48

Because it isn't a black and white situation is it?

For all I know she's watching a sad film and having a bit of a cry (and me going round would be beyond embarrassing)

Or her partner has given her a smack (in which case my going round would only make things worse)

Or, and heaven forbid, something has happened to baby (cos you just never know, cot death happens to 1 in 3000)

Forgive me for voicing my concern on an anonymous public forum - if you don't like it, scroll away

Your reasons for justifying not going round are ridiculous.

she’s crying because she’s watching a sad film? You can laugh about you going round.

She’s a victim of domestic violence? All the more reason to go round even if you have to wait till her abuser goes out.

Her child has passed away? You won’t know till you go round and see why she’s crying and she might just need a hand to hold till family arrive.

And you didn’t voice concern. You started a nonsense thread and decided almost immediately not to take on board the suggestions from the majority that you could go round and see if she’s ok. And your ridiculous reasons for not going round have only highlighted just how ridiculous your post was in the first place.