Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I can hear my neighbour sobbing...

263 replies

FooFighter99 · 01/12/2022 16:30

And I feel terrible, but I can't do anything - can I?

She's a young (23ish?) new mum who lives with her partner. Baby was born in October. Her family are all in a different town about 1hr away (I think)

And I'm pretty sure I've heard them arguing a few times since they moved in

I'm WFH today and sat in the living room and I can hear her sobbing through the wall Sad Sad Sad

It would be totally inappropriate to knock and ask if she's ok, because then she'll know we can hear them (only when the tv is off though). But I do worry about her and have told DH and DSD(22) that if I hear them arguing and it gets heated I'll be going round and dragging him out by his ear!

It could be PND, or something else (I do hope baby is ok)

WWYD???

OP posts:
CarefreeMe · 01/12/2022 19:44

*wall

CarefreeMe · 01/12/2022 19:44

You don't need to let on that you didn't hear. I think you should tell her, and let her know that you're there for her.

Please don’t do this.

Telling someone you can hear them crying through the way is so nasty.

Isahlo · 01/12/2022 19:44

Could you pick up something like a book advent calendar and take it for baby? Or similar or a cheaply advent calendar for them and say, people don’t get you advent calendars when your the mum or something

AcrossthePond55 · 01/12/2022 19:42

Could you go round to 'borrow' an egg, sugar, a pair of pliers? If she has a tear-stained face maybe just say "You ok, <name>?" with no mention of hearing anything and let her take it from there. She can either say "Sure, I'm fine" or use it for an opening to ask for help or just talk and release some tension.

L0bstersLass · 01/12/2022 19:38

FooFighter99 · 01/12/2022 17:03

It's all gone quiet now and their car is gone

I'll just have to watch and listen and hopefully get a chance to ask her if she's ok without letting on that I heard her crying

You don't need to let on that you didn't hear. I think you should tell her, and let her know that you're there for her.

Suzi888 · 01/12/2022 19:36

I would be mortified if someone knocked my door mid cry (though, thinking about it I probably wouldn’t answer!).
Yes the walls may be thin, but she might have thought it was a quiet cry.

Duttercup · 01/12/2022 19:33

Completely against the grain but I would be absolutely mortified if someone came round because I was crying in the privacy of my own home.

Hidingawaytoday · 01/12/2022 19:32

One of the nicest things anyone did for me after DD was born, was my neighbour (also on mat leave) who messaged me on DH's first day back at work saying her DH had seen him leave for the office that morning and did I fancy grabbing a coffee. She remembered the first day she'd been alone on mat leave and wanted to make sure I had company if I needed it.

So, I don't think you should mention the crying/arguing but do think you could pop round with some mince pies/invite her out for a coffee, one mum to another, just so she knows you're there.

5128gap · 01/12/2022 19:31

I'd go. Making sure she and the baby are OK trumps any social embarrassment it might cause. I'd rather be thought of as interfering and intrusive than think of a young woman in prolonged distress for what could be one of many serious reasons.Just knock, say you can hear her crying and does she need help.

Saxiee · 01/12/2022 19:29

But I do worry about her and have told DH and DSD(22) that if I hear them arguing and it gets heated I'll be going round and dragging him out by his ear!

Why assume it's his fault?

I've had plenty of arguments with men in my time that I instigated.

But, no, I wouldn't knock. Because I wouldn't want someone to come and check and me if I were crying in my own house. I'd be annoyed and feel like I can't even cry in peace without someone getting involved.

Layersoftaytoes · 01/12/2022 19:28

soundsofthesixties · 01/12/2022 16:49

I went round when I heard my young neighbour sobbing. She was just overwhelmed at the time with 2 young babies and had a row with her partner. She was really happy that I had knocked, had a good long chat and she felt much better. Mind you I'm the same age as her Nan, so perhaps that helped.

This!! ❤️ I think sometimes people just need that reassurance. I myself wouldn’t find it intrusive. I’d find it warming whilst feeling at- very low point. As humans we spend our lives walking past one another, mindin our business never smiling at strangers, it’s all very cold interactions. To have someone overhear me upset and check im ok, would really help

sweetbambi · 01/12/2022 19:27

I would try find some kind of an excuse to pop over and check on her. I did when I noticed my next door neighbour had been keeping herself to herself and was not texting like she usually would for any Christmas wishes. I went to see her and she was doing so badly and through helping her through a tough time. I gained a friend and she now knows I am just a text away. you sound so kind and I am sure she would appreciate someone reaching out.

Layersoftaytoes · 01/12/2022 19:25

PickyEaters · 01/12/2022 19:06

Hmm, I would be careful in this situation. Call me heartless but let's suppose:
(a) She is sobbing because she has serious depression or other problems. (Realistically what can OP do about this? A cup of tea isn't going to help; whe probably needs therapy and/or psychiatric medication.)
(b) She is highly strung and/or has emotional incontinence. (The cup of tea might console her but this will be a never-ending obligation.)
(c) Abusive relationship. (Again, realistically what is OP going to do about it? Offer this woman and her child a place to live? Beat up the husband?)…

I would be wary of getting involved.

All of those things can absolutely be helped by showing support?
a) if she’s depressed - this could be the first step to getting a GP appointment/therapy. Sometimes all it takes is to realise people will listen and will help. It’s a nudge in the right direction.
b) if this is the case and it gets too much, the OP can take a step back. She’s an adult.
c) what ridiculous suggestions? The person who posted this could direct her to charities and support groups who can help? Lend her some emotional support for 5 bloody minutes? To use the excuse “she’s being abused? So, what does she want me to do about it? Beat up her husband?” Is a truly bizarre, uncaring way to look at a situation like that. I hope you don’t work in a sector that requires you to provide off-the-cuff help.

Nevermind91 · 01/12/2022 19:25

I would be going round and casually asking if they need anything, as you are popping to the corner shop. Or even pretending you've run out of tea bags, something like that.
No one could possibly be offended by that, and it would put your mind at rest and offer perhaps a timely reminder to your neighbour that there is a friendly face next door.
Hope all's well...

WibblyWobblyTimeyWimeyStuff · 01/12/2022 19:24

FooFighter99 · 01/12/2022 16:38

Yes @WibblyWobblyTimeyWimeyStuff I don't think she'd appreciate me knocking on when she's mid-sob and full of snot but I will try and speak to her next time I see her and ask if she's ok - we do have a good relationship as far as being neighbours go, our dogs love playing with each other and run in and out of our houses when we stand outside chatting (it's hilarious) and I've told her we're always happy to help if she's ever stuck for anything

I think I'll keep my ears open and see how it develops

Sounds fab! Smile

EarringsandLipstick · 01/12/2022 19:23

It’s not nosiness to ask if a distressed new mother is OK

It is if she's in her own house & has an expectation of privacy!

EarringsandLipstick · 01/12/2022 19:22

MarrymeKeanu · 01/12/2022 18:33

I wouldn’t hesitate. I’d be knocking and gently telling her “When our Tv is off we can sometimes hear and I’ve just heard you crying and as one mum to another I just want to check you’re ok. Would you like to grab baby and come in to my house for a cup of tea?”

God this is awful. Nosey & patronising in one.

She's in her home. In private. She should be able to cry if she wishes, the idea of a neighbour deciding what is wrong with her is all kinds of wrong.

The other suggestions of checking in & arranging a coffee another time are good. OP you sound v kind.

ICanHideButICantRun · 01/12/2022 19:21

So her partner wasn't in? What time would he normally be home?

If she's off work tomorrow and he's out at work, I would definitely go round then and ask if she wanted the baby minding while she had a bath or some time to herself. I really feel for her - it should be such a lovely time being that age with a partner and a new baby, but there are so many things that can make it feel like the end of the world.

Layersoftaytoes · 01/12/2022 19:20

I think if you hear that again, absolutely go round and lend an ear/a shoulder/a hug. Postpartum is so tough, especially if family are far away AND struggling with a boyfriend. She might even just appreciate someone else holding the baby for a second as I imagine dad is back at work now.

i have 2 young kid and I feel like if someone overheard me crying I’d like to think/hope they’d come see if I was ok. I wouldn’t feel intruded. I’d feel grateful someone was there to pick me up when I needed it most ❤️

EastLondonObserver · 01/12/2022 19:11

Don’t go round. Making someone feel they have no privacy and their private business can be heard through the wall may well do more harm than good.

CarefreeMe · 01/12/2022 19:10

Please don’t go round!

As someone who had PND my home was my safe space where I could cry and get away from the judgement of the rest of the world.

Even now I will sometimes come home and have cry and it’s good to get it out of my system but feeling like I couldn’t cry in my own home and that I had to put on a front would be absolutely awful!!

By all means get chatting to her when you see her and become friendly with her but do not go round, even if she’s not crying.

PickyEaters · 01/12/2022 19:06

Hmm, I would be careful in this situation. Call me heartless but let's suppose:
(a) She is sobbing because she has serious depression or other problems. (Realistically what can OP do about this? A cup of tea isn't going to help; whe probably needs therapy and/or psychiatric medication.)
(b) She is highly strung and/or has emotional incontinence. (The cup of tea might console her but this will be a never-ending obligation.)
(c) Abusive relationship. (Again, realistically what is OP going to do about it? Offer this woman and her child a place to live? Beat up the husband?)…

I would be wary of getting involved.

Prescottdanni123 · 01/12/2022 19:06

Absolutely nothing wrong with popping around to see if she is ok or inviting her over the next time you see her. She might enjoy a bit of friendly support and sympathy.

Is this the first time that you have heard her crying? If not, it might just be that she is having a bad day. Or maybe she has received some bad news unrelated to the baby that has upset her. I wouldn't automatically jump on the PND bus.

How bad are the arguments you've heard her have with her partner? Horrible blazing rows? Couples argue sometimes, it might be nothing to worry about. I don't know exactly what it is you've heard between them so I don't know whether you should jump on the abusive partner bus either.

If you chat to her a bit over the next few days/weeks she might open up a bit more.

thelionthewitchtheaudacityofTHISbitch · 01/12/2022 19:06

pattihews · 01/12/2022 17:21

19 years ago I used to see a really sad-looking young woman walking in the lanes around my house with a young baby. I'd wave and say hello if we passed and wonder about her but did nothing. Then one day she seemed particularly tearful and unkempt and without thinking about it I asked her to come in and have a cup of tea. She ended up having a bath and washing her hair while I sat with the baby. She said it was the first break she'd had in weeks. She came round every few days for a couple of months until things improved.

She and her daughter send me a Christmas present every year. They moved away, but the daughter is at university an hour away from me and they've visited recently.

How lovely! Sorry I cant work out how to send flowers now. But sending you a bunch. You were very kind (in the proper sense of the word).

oakleaffy · 01/12/2022 18:57

SpinningFloppa · 01/12/2022 16:40

Can’t believe how many are telling you to go round, if a neighbour did this to me I would think nosey git, she’s in her own home is private she is obviously unaware you can hear, how embarrassing it would be to have a neighbour show up and ask what’s wrong! Bloody nosey

Glad I don’t live in your area- It’s not nosiness to ask if a distressed new mother is OK