Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I can hear my neighbour sobbing...

263 replies

FooFighter99 · 01/12/2022 16:30

And I feel terrible, but I can't do anything - can I?

She's a young (23ish?) new mum who lives with her partner. Baby was born in October. Her family are all in a different town about 1hr away (I think)

And I'm pretty sure I've heard them arguing a few times since they moved in

I'm WFH today and sat in the living room and I can hear her sobbing through the wall Sad Sad Sad

It would be totally inappropriate to knock and ask if she's ok, because then she'll know we can hear them (only when the tv is off though). But I do worry about her and have told DH and DSD(22) that if I hear them arguing and it gets heated I'll be going round and dragging him out by his ear!

It could be PND, or something else (I do hope baby is ok)

WWYD???

OP posts:
EnfysPreseli · 02/12/2022 13:10

I don't think it's intrusive to knock on the door and say that you're working from home and wondered if she fancied coming round for a coffee. No need to mention that you've heard her cry, but empathise a bit about how life is with a new baby. If she wants to talk, let her talk. If she doesn't that's fine. At least she knows that there's somewhere she can turn if she does need some support.

Isthisfareal · 02/12/2022 13:05

We had a baby earlier this year and have had some horrendous arguments - as you do when you’re knackered and taking it out on each other. I personally wouldn’t go round while she’s crying. Sometimes you need a good cry, and as others have said, it’s her personal space where she should be allowed to cry and not have a neighbour knock on the door or draw attention to the fact you can hear her. Yes we all hear things from time to time but give the girl a bit of privacy. However, sometime next week, pop over and say hello. How are you? How’s the baby? If I can sit with the baby while you catch up on sleep/have some lunch/a shower you just tell me. She won’t (as my lovely neighbours have offered many times!) but it’s so nice to have the offer of support. I also think she’ll speak to her mum or a close friend first rather than confide in you… unless you’re really good friends. And that is totally fine. Just by asking if she’s ok might prompt her to reach out to someone close if she’s not ok.

dontbringthatbirdinhere · 02/12/2022 13:02

I'd also pop round and have a cuppa. Perhaps you could say you remember how hard the first few months of having a newborn were for you and wonder if she fancies some company and a chat?

Wishiwasatailor · 02/12/2022 12:56

could you just knock and ask if she wanted to go for a dog walk together. No need to mention that you heard her crying or even ask if she’s ok. If she wants to share anything it’s likely it will happen.

moofolk · 02/12/2022 12:46

Knock on.

"Hiya I'm WFH and so bored, do you fancy a brew?"

PaintDiagram · 02/12/2022 12:46

What a sad state of affairs that we’re becoming a society that neighbours are strangers.

Mum called our next door neighbour an angel and I called her Auntie. Apparently she’d never hear us thru the wall (I know now that my dad was emotionally and financially abusing mum/gave nil support). She popped over with a knitted blanket when I was born to break the ice and the rest was history.

Don’t push your way in and demand to put on the kettle but offering some baked goods/left over cake is the human touch that we all need as humans. Maybe she needs reassurance from a mum that she’s doing the right thing, maybe she could do with having a chat with another human who’s not a new born baby, maybe she’ll look at you like she’s got three heads but in the future she might just need someone.

tammie49 · 02/12/2022 12:41

I'd go round. She'll appreciate it so much I'm sure. It's the hardest thing having a new born and it can be so isolating. You might be able to help her out with getting the confidence to go to some groups. Good support networks at that time are worth their weight in gold.

2bazookas · 02/12/2022 12:38

There's a new baby and a mum alone sobbing loud enough to hear through the wall. Noise travels two ways; so she can hear your noises through the wall too; TV, laughter, music, your phone ringing. She surely KNOWS she can be heard crying and is past caring. Just desperate, at the end of her tether, not coping.

That's a red flag for PND and PND can be very dangerous for both.

Get round there, you know she needs help. You can just say "Sounds like you 're on your own and need some company " .

neverbeenskiing · 02/12/2022 12:37

I was diagnosed with postnatal depression and PTSD after my second baby. I cried a lot. Uncontrollably, probably louder than I realised, and for sustained periods of time. I would have hated it if a neighbour had turned up because they'd heard me sobbing. I would have been mortified, but felt I had to seem appreciative and pleased to see them and so I probably would have forced myself to accept their offer of a cuppa and a chat. I probably would have told them I was feeling much better and how helpful they were. Privately, I would have been desperate for them to go.

Your neighbour isn't me, and she might just be having a bad day. She might feel completely differently. The point is you don't know, but if you just turn up then it puts her on the spot and you won't really know whether or not its been helpful as most people (well, most women, let's be honest) are conditioned to be 'polite' and grateful even when they're in crisis.

Scandiscrepancy · 02/12/2022 12:29

I know everyone is saying you shouldn’t go over and talk to your neighbour but I disagree. I had PND and I just felt so lonely and bored at home all day with my baby. I would have loved it if my neighbour with grown up kids (and all the experience that comes with that) had been present in my life at that time.

Notmrsfitz · 02/12/2022 12:27

The house next door to me is a rented one and quite often the tenants leave and new ones arrive - I’ve heard lots through our (paper thin walls) and thankfully my neighbour was able to intervene many years ago when dreadful things were happening in my house.

I always have tried to be friendly and buy the various families selection boxes at Xmas and Easter eggs at Easter but some of the families I choose not to be involved with on that level, whilst their arguments are awful it soon blows over and I accept it’s just the anger of youth.

one time my youngest son was home and he heard the previous neighbour on the phone trying to get some piroton for her child from friends as she couldn’t leave the house and he actually went to the shop, got her some and took it to her - without her even asking him. (He’s a very thoughtful ds)

I think I’d be inclined to just nip round and say - you’re working from home today and are a bit lonely does she fancy a quick cup of coffee and a biscuit?

QuimReaper · 02/12/2022 12:20

I haven't RTFT but just wanted to say, if at all avoidable, please don't turn up unannounced! I've had people do that when I've been perfectly happy and on top of the world (to deliver congratulatory gifts no less), but completely and utterly wiped out, and been mortified to open the door to what I assumed would be the postman, but was in fact a friend, looking like a total scruff with unbrushed hair wearing leggings and a T shirt. And that was during Covid, when they couldn't even be invited in to observe the chaos in the kitchen. I imagine your poor neighbour might be in at least as un-guest-ready a state if you jump her on her doorstep.

If at all possible, drop her a line and ask if it's OK to pop by in an hour or so, give her a chance to smarten herself up if she needs.

xogossipgirlxo · 02/12/2022 12:19

YouTarzan · 01/12/2022 20:59

Can you imagine the stress of wanting to cry but feeling like you can’t cos your neighbour will be round?

... and puts the kettle on😆

Throwawayaccount1 · 02/12/2022 12:17

"hi I ordered some donuts/muffins, and they accidentally sent me double, I thought you might like some. They got me through my kid being tiny!"

CamelFlarge · 02/12/2022 12:08

I'd err on the side of inviting her to yours rather than just turning up. A note through the door inviting her to join you on your coffee break would be enough.

Lisa411980 · 02/12/2022 12:07

Maybe break the ice if you don't speak to her often maybe buy a tiny gift for baby for Christmas and take a card around strike up a conversation about the baby and maybe offer her if she ever just wants 5 minutes then she's more than welcome to pop around for a brew.

mezlou84 · 02/12/2022 11:37

I would invite her round for coffee a few times a week. It's hard not being close to family and being a new mam. Bake some buns or something and say I've just made some buns if you want to come round for coffee and buns x

Mulhollandmagoo · 02/12/2022 00:38

Honestly l, when I was in the thick of it with a newborn, and really struggling, I'd have loved.someone to check on me! Just nip.round, double check she's ok, offer her a brew and if she accepts great, of not just tell her to let you know if she needs you for anything, maybe?

Heretobeanon · 02/12/2022 00:15

This would have been me a few months ago. I have an amazingly supportive DH, but you still end up having silly arguments because you're both knackered.

The sobbing was just because it was so hard looking after a newborn, just the two of us with zero help from extended family. It would often follow an argument because I would get sad that we were griping at each other about trivial things due to us both being so tired.

I totally get why you are concerned about the possibility of DV, but she could just be overwhelmed.

DuplicateUserName · 01/12/2022 22:55

Duttercup · 01/12/2022 22:34

Think of a time that you have sobbed like that and how much despair someone has to feel to get like that - wouldn't you want someone to just show some support
**
No, I really wouldn't. I would be troubled at not being able to cry inside my own house without feeling self-conscious.

Despair?

I cried because I forgot to buy eggs when my DS1 was 2 months old.

Sleep deprivation does that to even the strongest of people so I wouldn't automatically assume despair.

Duttercup · 01/12/2022 22:34

Think of a time that you have sobbed like that and how much despair someone has to feel to get like that - wouldn't you want someone to just show some support
**
No, I really wouldn't. I would be troubled at not being able to cry inside my own house without feeling self-conscious.

GG1986 · 01/12/2022 22:25

If you are friendly with her, i would knock on her door with some cakes or biscuits and ask her if she is ok as you thought you could hear her crying the other day, i wouldn't mention the arguing though. Ask her if she needs anything and leave it be.

kateandme · 01/12/2022 22:20

But equally someone's been doing a good old cry sesh.theyve got a new born.so if betrying to go round anyway to support.
Could you cook a pie or something.say you had way too much and would they like it.and you've been meaning to come see how she's getting on anyway.

DuplicateUserName · 01/12/2022 22:19

Snnowflake · 01/12/2022 18:18

I would've been mortified if I thought my neighbours could hear me and doubly so if they let me know about it!

I'm surprised at this - surely the difficulties of early days with a new baby are recognised now as is pnd. No need to be mortified.

You're surprised I'd be mortified if the family next door told me they could hear me crying? Really? Confused

Lots of difficulties are recognised but that doesn't mean everyone's comfortable with near strangers wanting to talk to them about it.

kateandme · 01/12/2022 22:17

Oh and contrary to mnet law.couples can argue and shout without it being abuse.disagreements aren't all whispers and rational lines.