Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I can hear my neighbour sobbing...

263 replies

FooFighter99 · 01/12/2022 16:30

And I feel terrible, but I can't do anything - can I?

She's a young (23ish?) new mum who lives with her partner. Baby was born in October. Her family are all in a different town about 1hr away (I think)

And I'm pretty sure I've heard them arguing a few times since they moved in

I'm WFH today and sat in the living room and I can hear her sobbing through the wall Sad Sad Sad

It would be totally inappropriate to knock and ask if she's ok, because then she'll know we can hear them (only when the tv is off though). But I do worry about her and have told DH and DSD(22) that if I hear them arguing and it gets heated I'll be going round and dragging him out by his ear!

It could be PND, or something else (I do hope baby is ok)

WWYD???

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SnozPoz · 05/12/2022 20:23

pretty certain if you can hear them they can hear you, so it won't be earth shattering for her to realise you have heard her crying. I would find the right moment to have a conversation with her, asking if she's alright and letting her know you're there if ever she wants to come round for a tea and a chat

Brackensmomma · 04/12/2022 20:24

@Joyfuljolly not really I can hear my neighbours sneeze I can hear them crying. And they can hear me.
Depends on how old the houses are. Are old houses have very little if anything in the way of sound proofing.

The walls in my last flat were so thin I could hear my upstairs neighbours fart in the bath.. it was that bad.
So I don't think this young mum would have to be crying very loud at all.

If she was screaming then yes but just crying no.

Madamum18 · 04/12/2022 15:32

Personally in that scenario I would knock on the door, make up a vague excuse about was a parcel of mine by any chance left with them as it hasnt arrived but also no card or something similar, and then looking at her say "oh are you ok? Can I do anything? Would you like a cuppa?" or whatever.....if she is sobbing then the fact that she has been crying would be obvious on her face.

NannaKaren · 03/12/2022 14:55

Go round.
if it was my Dd I’d want someone to go round…
might be nothing, might be baby blues, post natal depression, or just tiredness - go round - she can always say no thank you but you would feel awful if anything bad happened to the baby or her or indeed the partner - just knock xxx

MrsThimbles · 03/12/2022 13:34

SpinningFloppa · 03/12/2022 13:20

so you think she’s crying for attention 🙄

Yes. But not in the way your thinking.

SpinningFloppa · 03/12/2022 13:20

Joyfuljolly · 03/12/2022 12:57

Hmmm, I think you need to be crying very loudly for your neighbours to hear you through the wall to be honest. Crying isn’t normally a loud activity unless proper wailing, so I’m wondering if she wanted you to hear,

so you think she’s crying for attention 🙄

Ibizamumof4 · 03/12/2022 13:10

Omg don’t do anything just leave her !I would be mortified I cried lots when baby new and argued it would of made me super paranoid a lot worse if I knew
y neighbour had been listening. Do not knock around unless you hear something incredibly concerning

Joyfuljolly · 03/12/2022 12:57

Hmmm, I think you need to be crying very loudly for your neighbours to hear you through the wall to be honest. Crying isn’t normally a loud activity unless proper wailing, so I’m wondering if she wanted you to hear,

MadameMackenzie · 03/12/2022 12:52

Fremdschämen · 03/12/2022 12:40

"As long as no identifying details are posted I don’t understand the “invasion of privacy” pearl clutching attitude from some who seem to enjoy reading about others and then complaining about it. If we could not write about others MN wouldn’t exist. Again, there’s no identifying details about this crying woman and she could be in any country."

OP has given an indication of the mum's age; the distance away she thinks her family live; the month in which the baby was born; that they share a party wall (so live in a semi or a terraced house); that she could hear the mum sobbing on a particular day, at a particular time; that the OP has a DP and a step daughter and the age of the step daughter. Also an indication of what she thinks the mum's partner might do for a living. That they appeared to have all gone out on a particular evening. That the two of them are already on speaking terms; that they both have dogs that have played together.

Enough there, I'd suggest, for the neighbour to potentially recognise herself, if she is a reader of MN, now, or in the future.

But not really enough for anyone else to definitively identify her which is the most important factor imho

Fremdschämen · 03/12/2022 12:40

"As long as no identifying details are posted I don’t understand the “invasion of privacy” pearl clutching attitude from some who seem to enjoy reading about others and then complaining about it. If we could not write about others MN wouldn’t exist. Again, there’s no identifying details about this crying woman and she could be in any country."

OP has given an indication of the mum's age; the distance away she thinks her family live; the month in which the baby was born; that they share a party wall (so live in a semi or a terraced house); that she could hear the mum sobbing on a particular day, at a particular time; that the OP has a DP and a step daughter and the age of the step daughter. Also an indication of what she thinks the mum's partner might do for a living. That they appeared to have all gone out on a particular evening. That the two of them are already on speaking terms; that they both have dogs that have played together.

Enough there, I'd suggest, for the neighbour to potentially recognise herself, if she is a reader of MN, now, or in the future.

Fremdschämen · 03/12/2022 12:28

*PTSD

Fremdschämen · 03/12/2022 11:46

Sandra1984 wrote:

"pearl clutching attitude"

I don't see why legitimate concern for potential invasion of an individual's privacy should be framed and dismissed as "pearl clutching".

This reminds me of a thread a few months ago where a poster started a thread about a Ukrainian woman and her child who were living with her and a perceived issue around the meaning of a child's painting, where the OP was actively inviting MN readers to analyse the painting for signs of PTDS. There was no indication that the woman staying with the OP had given consent for a copy of the painting to be reproduced on a public forum, was aware that it was being discussed or was happy for readers to pile in with public opinion on the content of the painting and her child's wellbeing.

Mummydrama · 03/12/2022 11:34

Im a newish mummy and my neighbours are brilliant. Always stop for a chat and see how me and baby are doing. I went through an episode of pulling my hair out (lack of sleep!) Crying, would up and take baby for a walk in middle of night! A neighbour brought round a care package of treats. Had a good chat as she has 2, swapped stories. Another with no kids offered her house as a tea and cake zone. They didnt prey but now i can ofload if need be and we help each other. So yes dont prey but let her know you have a friendly ear with NO judgements. These times are hard and when it gets to boiling point we could make silly decisions with no one to turn too. You could still take something else round for the baby. I still get lil gifts even now.

Sandra1984 · 03/12/2022 10:32

@Fremdschämen But whatever her situation, this is not a soap opera and although I'm sure you mean well, your "Please keep us all updated on what happens next." does come across somewhat as an intrusion on this individual's privacy.

The initial thread was already an invasion of privacy on an individual, fact is most threads on mumsnet are, MN thrives on stories about second parties who’ve no idea they’re being talked about. OP is concerned about her neighbour and rightfully so, we the posters are concerned too hence an update on the situation would be nice. As long as no identifying details are posted I don’t understand the “invasion of privacy” pearl clutching attitude from some who seem to enjoy reading about others and then complaining about it. If we could not write about others MN wouldn’t exist. Again, there’s no identifying details about this crying woman and she could be in any country.

FerryYaBerryLa · 03/12/2022 10:21

@Fremdschämen

I always think the same when people ask to be kept updated on the next instalment.

Fremdschämen · 03/12/2022 10:04

Brackensmomma wrote:

"...It's so sad that she's alone when she could really do with her family.
But a good friend would be a good substitute I'm sure.
Please keep us all updated on what happens next."

Let's not forget that the subject of this thread is (presumably) a real person who might conceivably be a reader of MN, if not now, at some point in the future and might recognise herself from the OP's descriptions here on MN or from snippets of posts in Google links.

She may or may not have an abusive or "horrible" partner. She may or may not be struggling with PND. She may of may not be in a situation that needs monitoring by concerned neighbours for past, current or future domestic abuse.

But whatever her situation, this is not a soap opera and although I'm sure you mean well, your "Please keep us all updated on what happens next." does come across somewhat as an intrusion on this individual's privacy.

Stewball01 · 03/12/2022 09:50

Go round.

Badunkadunk · 03/12/2022 09:16

And if I were you, next time you hear her crying and you know he’s not there, go round and ask her straight out if everything okay because you can hear that she’s upset.

FooFighter99 · 03/12/2022 09:13

Cantseethewindows · 02/12/2022 22:11

OP, can I just say how lovely you are? When we brought our second baby home in the middle of a winter COVID lockdown our downstairs neighbour started slamming her doors as soon as our eldest cried for longer than a minute or two. I was absolutely depressed from having a lockdown baby and she must have heard me crying and shouting I hated my life. Her reaction was to insult our children and begin a bullying campaign. Absolute bitch! Your neighbour is lucky to have you, irrespective of what you do now. You're so understanding and sympathetic.

Thank you @Cantseethewindows 🥰

I’m so sorry you had awful neighbours! I can’t understand that mentality at all. I’ve always been on great terms with my neighbours, from being a little girl, everyone in our street knew each other and looked out for one another (still do!). Even the smack head/schizophrenic guy DH and I lived next door to years ago would take parcels in for us 🤣 bless him

They haven’t been home so I’m assuming she stayed at her mums last night, I don’t actually know what her partner does for a living but I think it’s some sort of manual job (like builder or plumber maybe)

Like I’ve said, I’ll keep an eye out for her and try to stage a conversation and see where it leads. Don’t worry, I won’t be ignoring the situation

OP posts:
Badunkadunk · 03/12/2022 09:10

I’m not going to vote as that doesn't seem appropriate. But what I would do is reach out to her, maybe pop round with something for the little one? You don’t need to interfere or fish or ask if she is okay. What she needs to know is that there is someone nearby who she can go to when she wants to talk. So I’d just start off by being a nearby friendly face. It’s better to regret having tried to do the right thing and having it thrown back in your face than regret doing nothing at all.

Brackensmomma · 03/12/2022 08:49

@FooFighter99
You sound a lovely caring person I'm sure your neighbour would appreciate you dropping by. Especially after you've already given baby a present..
It's so sad that she's alone when she could really do with her family.
But a good friend would be a good substitute I'm sure.
Please keep us all updated on what happens next.

LornaaMb · 03/12/2022 08:14

I understand it’s awkward but there’s so much evidence about how talking to someone who is low can make all the difference. There’s lots of adverts out just now about it - the simple ‘how are you ‘ and checking if person says the usual‘I’m fine’. If she has PND the stigma surrounding this is higher from the person themselves and often families / society. People with PND are also at higher risk of poor outcomes.
I’m answering a bit late but I think a gentle hello and seeing how she is a good thing.

its true she may decline invite for coffee but then a rain check offer can be made. Good luck 🤞!

Innachu · 03/12/2022 07:49

Maybe offer to take her dog out, just say that you know how tough it must be with a new baby..
when we had a newborn every normal chat or a cup of tea (even out of the blue) would have been extremely welcome!
you always have your hands full and my teas whenever I managed to make one would all end up cold without anyone around to help

Plumnora · 03/12/2022 00:51

Please knock and ask if she’s ok. A long time ago I had a neighbour like this- it was very obvious she was in an abusive relationship but I didn’t realise he was hitting her. They had a young child.

I often thought about popping round to say hello and check she was ok but like you I thought it would be intrusive so I didn’t.

Then she tried to kill herself. Luckily she didn’t succeed but it was a wake up call for me. Never ignore your concerns. She may be absolutely fine but you may be helping more than you realise if you do reach out.

DixonD · 02/12/2022 23:43

SpinningFloppa · 01/12/2022 16:40

Can’t believe how many are telling you to go round, if a neighbour did this to me I would think nosey git, she’s in her own home is private she is obviously unaware you can hear, how embarrassing it would be to have a neighbour show up and ask what’s wrong! Bloody nosey

I, on a personal level, would agree with this. If I were in a bit of state for whatever reason, there’s no way I’d answer the door to a neighbour (or anyone).

Swipe left for the next trending thread